- 1 - !"# $ %"&$ %"& &! $$ '$($) * ! "" # "" !$ Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "" # % "" !% "" # # "" !! "" # & '" # ( $ " # $ " # - 3 - ! " )! "" # $$ "" # % " " # " % "" # $ " !! "" # - 4 - ) " "" # " ) "" # * #+ " $ "" # , " "" " ## " # & '" !- ## *- # # '(- % ( - 5 - # *)* $**! " # # " " # # ." # ." # # &" ' ." # ( /01,223,40150436789/3,22344,:9124,0:90551;:63< 3=90>: >5 =/,443:?0:? 9/3 @;6?A3:9 ,:6 63=<33 6,936 $**! 2,1136 78 9/3 3:0>< 0B04 #;6?3 ,:6 # ;66370/,4 0: >*)* C/3<378 9/3 1;09 50436789/324,0:905515><2,<9090>:,:6132,<,932>113110>: 0:<3123=9>51;091=/36;432<>23<9801601A01136 /32,<9031,<3<353<<369>,123<9/30<<,:D0:? 735><39/3<0,4>;<9 - 6 - ! ><73993<;:63<19,:60:?9/3?3:3,4>?8>59/3 5,A048 >5 9/3 24,0:90551 ,:6 6353:6,:91 01 3E9<,=936 /3<3;:63< /3 2<>2>109;1 78 :,A3 /0B,22, > /,:6,22, 34,?0 ,:6 /01 C053 78 :,A3 /,B,:9<,AA, C3<3 6036 43,B0:? 73/0:6 9/30< =/046<3: 78 :,A3 ",1,AA, 3:D,22, 04,AA, /,::,AA, ",1,:,?>;6,/,:D<,AA,,<B,90,:6 ,/,63B0,19/30< 43?,4 /30<1 /3 13=>:6 1>: 78 :,A3 3:D,22, 6036 - 7 - 43,B0:? 73/0:6 /01 C053 78 :,A3 ,/,63B0 ,:6 , 1>: 78 :,A3 /,:9,?>;6, ,1 6353:6,:9 >1 ,:6 ,:6 50B3 6,;?/93<1/35059/1>:78:,A3",1,:,?>;6,60360:9/3 83,< ** 43,B0:? 73/0:6 /01 43?,4 /30<1 ,1 6353:6,:9 >1%9>* :36,;?/93<78:,A3 ,/,63B0,41>6036>: !* *% 43,B0:? 73/0:6 /3< 43?,4 /30<1 ,1 24,0:9055 >1 9> $ 593< 9/3 63,9/ >5 2<>2>109;1 78 :,A3 /0B,22, 0: 9/3 83,< ) 9/3 24,0:90551 ,:6 6353:6,:91 /,B3 1;==33636 9> 9/3 1;09 1=/36;43 2<>23<9031 9/<>;?/ ,B,90,<,1,353:6,:9>19>*73/0:69/37,=D>5 24,0:9055>19>!,:6A>9/3<>524,0:9055>1 9>$>: *)* /,6 =<3,936 9/3 7>?;1 ,DD; "099, ,9<, 0: 5,B>;<>56353:6,:9>! :9/37,101>51,06,DD;"099, ,9<, 6353:6,:9 >! >: *% /,1 ?0B3: B,<60 9> <3B3:;3,;9/><090319>3:93</3<:,A378634390:?:,A31 >5 24,0:9055 >1 9> ! 9/3 A>9/3< >5 24,0:9055 >1 9> $ ,:66353:6,:9> 9>*0:9/3<3B3:;3<3=><61,1 23< > *%F /3 1,06 A;9,90>: 3:9<8 01 :>9 70:60:? ;2>: 9/3 1/,<3 >5 9/3 24,0:90551 /3 6353:6,:91 - 8 - 78 =>44;60:? C09/ 9/3 <3B3:;3 ,;9/><09031 /,B3 =<3,936 7>?;1 6>=;A3:9 ,:6 0443?,448 6343936 9/30< :,A31 0: 9/3 <3B3:;3 <3=><61 /3<35><3 9/3 24,0:90551 /,B3 50436 9/3 1;095><2,<9090>:,:6132,<,932>113110>:>59/30<1/,<30: 9/31;091=/36;432<>23<98 % 593< 13<B0=3 >5 1;AA>:1 6353:6,:9 > /,1 ,223,<36 9/<>;?/ /3< =>;:134 :12093 >5 ?<,:90:? 1;550=03:9>22><9;:090311/3606:>95043C<0993:19,93A3:9 353:6,:9 > /,1 ,223,<36 9/<>;?/ /3< =>;:134 ,:6 50436 9/3 C<0993: 19,93A3:9 :12093 >5 13<B0=3 >5 1;AA>:1 9/3 >9/3< 6353:6,:91 606 :>9 ,223,< /3:=3 9/38C3<324,=363E2,<93 : 9/3 7,101 >5 243,60:?1 >5 9/3 2,<9031 9/3 <0,4>;<9/,15<,A369/35>44>C0:?011;31 ! " # # - 9 - # $ % $ #% % % & ' " ( )* + $ /3<0,4>;<9 /,1 ,:1C3<3611;3>0:9/3 ,550<A,90B311;3>1,:6!0::3?,90B3,66090>:,411;3 > 0: 9/3 ,550<A,90B3 ,:6 11;3 > ,1 23< 9/3 50:,4 @;6?A3:9/3,66090>:,4011;301 <34,9369>C/39/3<9/3 6353:6,:9>2<>B319/,99/31;09>59/324,0:90551017,6 5>< :>:F@>0:63< >5 :3=311,<8 2,<9031 /3 24,0:90551 /,B3 :>9 0A243,636 9/3 6,;?/93<1 >5 63=3,136 3:D,22, 78 :,A31 /,<,6, ,EA0 >;<,AA, ;<;63B0 ,:6 ,9:,AA,/3<0,4>;<9,593<=>:1063<0:?9/33B063:=3 >5 9/3 2,<9031 /,1 =>A3 9> 9/3 =>:=4;10>: 9/,9 9/38 ,<3 :3=311,<8,:62<>23<2,<90319>9/31;090:=30:9/31;09 - 10 - 5><2,<9090>:9/36,;?/93<1>563=3,1363:D,22,,<3,41> 3:9094365><9/30<1/,<30:9/31;091=/36;432<>23<90319/3 <0,4 >;<9 /,1 ,:1C3<36 ,66090>:,4 011;3 > 0: 9/3 ,550<A,90B3,:6601A011369/31;09 ) 3,<:36 =>;:134 5>< 9/3 ,22344,:9124,0:90551 1;7A09936 9/,9 9/3 <0,4 >;<9 C>;46 /,B3 23<A09936 9/3 24,0:90551 9> 0A243,6 9/3 :3=311,<8 2,<9031 0: 9/3 1;09 0:193,6 >5 601A0110:? 9/3 1;09 ,:6 9/3<35><3 43,<:36 =>;:1345><9/3,22344,:911;7A099369/,9059/01,223,401 <3A099367,=D9>9/3<0,4>;<99/324,0:90551C0440A243,6 9/36,;?/93<1>563=3,1363:D,22,,12,<90319>9/31;09 5 9/3 =>F1/,<3<1 ,<3 :3=311,<8 2,<9031 9/3 <0,4 >;<9 1/>;463E3<=0139/32>C3<;:63< <63< ;43*>59> 60<3=9 9/3 2,<9031 9> 0A243,6 9/3A ,1 2,<9031 0: 9/3 1;09 0:193,6>5601A0110:?9/31;095><:>:F@>0:63<>5:3=311,<8 2,<9031 : B03C >5 9/3 ,7>B3 C09/>;9 3E2<3110:? ,:8 >20:0>:>:9/3A3<091>59/3=,13C32,119/35>44>C0:? - 11 - 0 /3,223,401,44>C36,:6<3A,:6369>9/3 <0,4>;<95><5<31/=>:1063<,90>: 00 /3@;6?A3:9,:663=<336,936$**! 2,1136789/33:0><0B04#;6?3,:6# ;66370/,40: >)*01139,1063 000 /3 24,0:90551 ,<3 60<3=936 9> 0A243,6 9/3 6,;?/93<1>563=3,1363:D,22,78:,A31 /,<,6, ,EA0 >;<,AA, ;<;63B0 ,:6 ,9:,AA, ,1 2,<9031 9> 9/3 1;09 ,593< 011;0:?:>90=39>,449/32,<9031 0B /3<0,4>;<90160<3=9369>6012>13>59/3 1;09 0: ,==><6,:=3 C09/ 9/3 4,C C09/>;9 730:? 0:54;3:=36 78 ,:8 >713<B,90>: A,63 0: 9/3 @;6?A3:9 ,:6 63=<33 6,936 $**! +( '$) & +( ' &! ) & 019>4>%*