- 1 - ! ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '!( ) ! " # $ % & ' $ ( ) && $ $ # $# * $# * #+## Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , # ) $# #$ $ * ! " ) & # % # #,"-%# # " % ,- .( $ $ $# $ $ # ## # # & # / # &0 # 1& #% 234 566758 34 9387: 5;53<4= =27 >?:7? :5=7: ,-65447:>< >3< 6683@5=3><>.( AB =27 $5?<5=5C5 5C9 ?3AD<58 $585AD?5;3 3E343>< $585AD?5;3 - 3 - ?379 95@=4 >9 =27 @547 5?7 =25= =27 5667885<= 27?73< F B7: 25<: D4453<3 77?5< G54 566>3<=7: 54 D=5G5883 >9 5?;54 AB =27 $5?<5=5C5 =5=7 >5?: >9 DH597<;58D?D>< (746><:7<=> 27?73< F B7:5 5I77:5 &525< 9387: 56683@5=3>< >.( A79>?7=273E343><585C9?3AD<58$585AD?5;3=>:7@85?7 =27 >?:7? 65447: AB =27 ?746><:7<= > E3:7 >?:7? >$ (,F( :5=7: , 54 <D88 5<: E>3: 5<: => 47= 543:7 =27 45I7 D= =27 453: 56683@5=3><G549387:G3=25:785B>9-:5B427254<>= 9387: =27 :785B 56683@5=3>< 58><; G3=2 6683@5=3>< >.( D= 427 254 9387: 5<>=27? 56683@5=3>< 477C3<; 5< 3<JD<@=3>< >?:7? 27< >=27? 43:7 >AJ7@=7: =27 45I7 =27 ?3AD<58 E3:7 >?:7? :5=7: ( (>A47?E7:=25=93?4==27:785B56683@5=3><34=> A7:7@3:7:279387:56683@5=3><>.(>< ,*( 5<: 427 254 => 9387 =27 :785B 56683@5=3>< 58><; G3=2 =27 5A>E7 56683@5=3>< AD= 427 9387: =27 :785B 56683@5=3>< > >< *( 27 254 => @25887<;7 =27 >?:7? - 4 - :5=7: ( G3=23< * :5B4 27 9387: > 9>? 3<=7?3I?78379>94=5BD<:7?7@=3><,"%>9=275C9 @= G3=2>D= :785B 56683@5=3>< < =27 :785B 56683@5=3>< 427 4=5=7: =25= 427 34 65?:5<5423< 85:B 5;7: ( B75?4 4D997?3<;9?>I>8:5;7538I7<=45<:427@>D8:<>=5??5<;7 I><7B9>?9383<;=2756683@5=3><G3=23<=3I7:D7=>93<5<@358 @><4=?53<=4 54 4D@2 =27?7 34 :785B >9 - :5B4 5<: ?7HD74=7: =27 >D?= => @><:><7 =27 45I7 27 ?3AD<58 @><43:7?3<; =27 >AJ7@=3><4 >9 >=27? 43:7 588>G7: =27 56683@5=3><5<:@><:><7:=27:785B>9-:5B4><@>4=>9 4F><,- , ;;?37E7: AB =27 453: >?:7? ?746><:7<= >, =27?73< 254 6?797??7: =234 566758 7 4=5=7: =25= 3< =27 I>I7<=5C9993@7?5:;3?9>?G5?:7:=2756683@5=3><5<: 5993:5E3= >9 =27 5667885<= ?7;5?:3<; 234 D=5G58834236 >< * ,=2756683@5<=?746><:7<=> 27?73<9387:=27 56683@5=3>< A79>?7 ?746><:7<= > >< , , 3=4789 4 427 254 C<>G87:;7 >9 =27 566>3<=I7<= >?:7? >< , ,42742>D8:25E79387:5<56683@5=3><G3=23<* - 5 - :5B4274=5=7:=25=427@5<<>=5??5<;7=279D<:4AD= 427 G54 47883<; =27 E58D5A87 6?>67?=374 5==5@27: => =27 5?;54 9?5D:D87<=8B 54 67? K 5<: =2D4 3= @5<<>= A7 453: =25= 427 254 <> 93<5<@358 ?74>D?@74 5<: 427 254 <>= 9387: 5<B I7:3@58 @7?=393@5=7 => 42>G 27? :3475474 7 9D?=27? 4=5=7: =25= ?746><:7<= > 4>8: 5G5B =27 6?>67?=374 9>? G23@2 ?3;2= >9 D=5G5883 G54 @><93?I7: 3< >.- AB =27 5C9 ?3AD<58 5<: =2D4 427 34 :34HD583937: 9?>I @853I3<; =27 ?3;2= >9 D=5G5883 5<: 27? @853I 9>? D=5G5883 G54 ?7J7@=7: >< . ( 5<: 27 G54566>3<=7:>< (27?734<>4D993@37<=@5D47 9>? =27 ?3AD<58 => 588>G =27 56683@5=3>< 5<: =2D4 ?7HD74=7: =27 >D?= => 47= 543:7 =27 >?:7? :5=7: ,- ( 75?:=275?;DI7<=4>9A>=243:7 :I3==7:8B ?746><:7<= > 9387: 56683@5=3>< >.( >< ,*( 5<: 9387: :785B 56683@5=3>< >< *(27I53<@><=7<=3><>9=275667885<=27?73<34 =25= ?746><:7<= > G54 ><8B ( B75?4 427 G54 <>= - 6 - >8: 5;7: 427 G54 <>= 65?:5<5423< 85:B 5<: 427 ?746><:7:=>=27>AJ7@=3><4><, ,3=47895<:427 G5447883<;=276?>67?=B3<=27<5I7>9D=5G588342365<: =2D43=@5<<>=A7453:=25=427254<>93<5<@3584>D?@74 27?734 <> 4D993@37<=?754>< 9>?@><:><3<; =27:785B > :>DA= 427 254 => 9387 5< 56683@5=3>< 9>? @><:><3<; =27 :785B 58><; G3=2 6683@5=3>< >.( AD= 427 @25887<;7: =27 566>3<=I7<= >?:7? 3< 95E>D? >9 =27 5667885<= 27?73< 3< =27 453: 56683@5=3>< >.( 27?79>?7 =27 :785B 56683@5=3>< @5<<>= A7 :34I3447: >< =7@2<3@583=374 * 67?D458>956683@5=3><>.(42>G4=25= =27?7G546?7E3>D483=3;5=3><A7=G77<A>=2=2765?=374< 95@= B7:5 5I77:5 &525< 9387: >.- 9>? :7@85?5=3>< 5<: 3<JD<@=3>< 5;53<4= ?746><:7<= > =27 4D3= G54 :7@?77: 3< 27? 95E>D? 5<: :797<:5<= > G54 :3?7@=7: => :7@85?7 27? 54 D=5G5883 5<: 27 G54 584> ?74=?53<7: 9?>I 3<=7?97?3<; G3=2 =27 675@79D8 6>447443>< 5<:7<J>BI7<=>959953?4>9=274D3=5?;545<:4D3=85<:4 - 7 - ;;?37E7: AB =27 453: >?:7? ?746><:7<= >F$5?<5=5C5 =5=7>5?:>95C927?73<6?797??7: > , AD= 3= G54 :34I3447: ;53<4= =27 45I7 3= 254 6?797??7: "3E38% >- ( 5<: 3= G54 :34I3447: 54 G3=2:?5G< 27?759=7? 3= 254 9387: 7E37G 7=3=3>< 3< > ( 5<: =27 45I7 G54 584> :34I3447: ;53<3=2549378:47@><: "3E38%>(-( (5<:3= G54 584> :34I3447: >,(- --, G54 :346>47: >9 ><- (5<:=2795=27?>9=2756683@5<=?746><:7<= > 27?73<G54><7>9=2765?=B3<=27453: 5<:27 :37: >< ( --* 4 4D@2 427 G54 <>= 5G5?7 >9 =27 G?3=67=3=3>< 9=7?:34I34458>9=2747@><: ?746><:7<= >9387:47@><:?7E37G67=3=3><3< >( * 5<:3=G54584>:34I3447:2795=27?>9=275667885<=>, 9387: > ,- 9>? :7@85?5=3>< 5<: 3<JD<@=3>< 5<: ?746><:7<= > 4=5=7: =25= =27?7 34 <> E5@5<@B >9 D=5G5883 54 427 G54 58?75:B :7@85?7: 54 D=5G5883 3< >.- 5<: 3= G54 @><93?I7: AB =27 D6?7I7 >D?==27?79>?7=275C9?3AD<58>9$585AD?5;3588>G7: - 8 - =27:785B 56683@5=3><>< @>4= >94F => 7<4D?7 =27 5A>E7 95@=4 AB ;3E3<; ?754><5A87 >66>?=D<3=B => A>=2 43:74234>D?=93<:4<>?754><=>3<=7?97?7G3=2=27453: >?:7? . <=27?74D8==2756675834:7E>3:>9I7?3=45<: 34 *+, '&!! ( % 34=> 8>