- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( )* !!%% + &'( ) * ! " # $ %&!%!! ##! %'#!(& $$ )$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %*&&(* $+ !*!&& ! $$!()!$ , &(&!& &-&& % $ +) * $$ ) )$ %*&&(* )# )$ $$ %*&&(* - 3 - ! %'& " # $ %&!%!! ##! %'#!(& $!+ % $$!()!$ $ &-&& $ $ % , &(&!& &-&& $ $ % $ , . , $ . , /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 4/9/ 3>: 0??/0@9 01/ ;=@/2 050=893 34/ A6257/83 082 0>012 ?099/2 =8 :&-&& <B 34/ /7</1 :; - 4 - :3:1 CC=2/83 @0=79 1=<680@ D 0205=1= ;:1 94:13 E34/ 1=<680@F ) ) 4=9 C@0=7 ?/3=3=:8 =9 ;=@/2 <B 34/ =8A61/2C@0=7083 C@0=7=85 C:7?/8903=:8 :; 9)& && &&&% 4/ 1=<680@ 0;3/1 C:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ /G=2/8C/ :8 1/C:12 51083/2 9!! &* &''% >=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; *H ;1:7 203/ :; ?/3=3=:83=@@1/0@=I03=:8 # 551=/G/2<B34/90=2:12/1 34=90??/0@=9;=@/2<B 34/C@0=70839;:1/8408C/7/83=8>4=C4=3=9C:83/82/2340334/ 1=<680@ /11/2 =8 30J=85 )&H 2=90<=@=3B 3: 34/ >4:@/ <:2B 34:654 099/99/2 34/ 907/ 09 )(H 3 =9 ;6134/1 9303/2 3403 34:6544/>09/018=859! &&&%?/17:834090C::@=/ 34/ 1=<680@ 409 30J/8 :8@B 9! &&&% ?/1 7:834 / 3::J 31/037/83;:1!&20B9082=8C611/2465/7/2=C0@/K?/89/9 / 96930=8/2 ;10C361/ =8A61=/9 082 34/1/;:1/ 1/L6/93/2 ;:1 /8408C/7/83 +) - 5 - 4=9 0??/0@ =9 ;=@/2 <B 34/ 0??/@@083 % 896108C/ :7?08B 050=893 34/ 0<:G/ 90=2 0>012 =8 >4=C4 =3 =9 70=8@B C:83/82/2 3403 :8 !&&)&& 34/ 1/9?:82/83C@0=7083 >09 ?1:C//2=85 =8 0 7:3:1CBC@/</01=851/5=93103=:8 :%&! % )*-08234/21=G/1:;0@:11B>=341/5=93103=:8 :%&!% !! ?01J/2 4=9 @:11B =8 34/ 7=22@/ :; 34/ 1:02 >=34:63 ;:@@:>=85 310;;=C 16@/9 4/ C@0=7083 2094/2 34/ @:11B 09 0 1/96@3 4/ 96930=8/2 ;10C361/ =8A61=/9 >4=C4 01/ 51=/G:69 =8 80361/ / 682/1>/83 9615/1B 082 2=9C4015/2 :8 !*&)&& >=34 ;:@@:>%6? 31/037/83 3 =9 C:83/83/2 3403 34/ 1=<680@ /11/2=8;093/8=8534/@=0<=@=3B:834/=8961/1:;34/@:11B>=34:63 ?1:?/10??1/C=03=:8:;/G=2/8C/:81/C:124/C:7?@0=83>09 @:25/2 <B 34/ ;034/1 :; 34/ 1=2/1 :; 7:3:1CBC@/ =8 >4=C4 4/ 9303/23403 34/0CC=2/83=9C069/226/3:34/8/5@=5/8C/:;4=9 9:80824/2094/23:0?01J/2@:11B6334/C4015/94//3=9 ;=@/2050=893<:3434/21=G/19:;7:3:1CBC@/082?01J/2G/4=C@/ 082 /11/2 =8 0>012=85 C:831=<63:1B 8/5@=5/8C/ /8C/ =3 =9 C:83/82/2 3403 (H :; C:831=<63:1B 8/5@=5/8C/ :6543 3: </ C:89=2/1/2:8</40@;:;34/1=2/1:;7:3:1CBC@/4/21=G/1:; 34/@:11B4098:G0@=221=G=85@=C/8C/09:834/203/:;0CC=2/83 4/ 2:C3:1 409 099/99/2 )-H 3:>0129 @=7< 2=90<=@=3B 4/8C/ - 6 - 34/1=<680@:65433:40G/30J/8!)12:;34/@=7<2=90<=@=3B=/ !)H3:34/>4:@/<:2B082/11/2=830J=8534/907/09)&H 469 1/L6/93/2;:17:2=;=C03=:8:;34/:12/1 * 27=33/2@B 34/ C@0=7083 >09 05/2 ) B/019 4=@/ ?1:C//2=85:807:3:1CBC@/ 4/2094/234/9303=:8/2@:11B082 34/@:11B>09?01J/2=834/7=22@/:;34/1:02>=34:63;:@@:>=85 310;;=C16@/909?/16@/!=G:;34/:02/56@03=:89 !-'- ;:194:13E34/6@/9 !-'-F 1/5012=85C:831=<63:1B8/5@=5/8C/ 1/02909;:@@:>9 ! ! ! !" #$ ! ! ! " " " % & ' ! " - 7 - " ! " ! ! # ( 9?/134/0<:G/90=26@/9 !-'- 34/21=G/1940@@ 8:3 ?01J 34/ G/4=C@/ :8 34/ 70=8 1:02 082 3469 34=9 C@0=7 ?/3=3=:8=9;=@/2:8@B050=89334/:>8/1082=8961/1:;34/@:11B 4:654 34/ C4015/ 94//3 =9 ;=@/2 050=893 34/ 1=2/1 :; 7:3:1CBC@/0820@9:21=G/1:;34/@:11B 34/@=0<=@=3B=9;=K/2:8 34/ 896108C/ :7?08B :; 34/ @:11B :>8/1 4/ 896108C/ :7?08B =8 34/=1 0??/0@ 409 C:83/83/2 3403 34/ 1=2/1 :; 34/ 7:3:1CBC@/ =9 8/5@=5/83082 34/ C:831=<63:1B 8/5@=5/8C/:6543 3:40G/;=K/26?:84=7 <6334/90=209?/C3>098:310=9/2<B 34/896108C/:7?08B</;:1/34/1=<680@0334//01@=/93?:=83 :;3=7/996C4 8:>34/BC088:310=9/34/90=2:<A/C3=:8=8 34/0??/0@082=3C088:3</C:89=2/1/2 ' @0=70831/9?:82/83>0905/2)B/0194:6544/ 9303/234034/>09/018=859! &&&%?/17:834 4/4098:3 ;=@/2 08B =8C:7/ ?1::; / 7/3 >=34 08 0CC=2/83 :8 !&&)&& 4/8C/ 09 ?/1 34/ 56=2/@=8/9 :; 34/ 018030J0 - 8 - 303/ /50@ /1G=C/9 634:1=3B 4=9 8:3=:80@ =8C:7/ =9 3: </ 30J/8099!) (&%?/17:834 - / 96930=8/2 ;10C361/9 :; 5102/ :?/8 3=<=0 082 9/57/830@ ;=<6@0:; 1=543 @/5 ;10C361/:; @/;3 7/2=C0@ 70@@/:@= ;10C361/:;1=543940;3C@0G=C@/0820@9:682/1>/839615/1B;:1 3>:3=7/94/C@0=7083/K07=8/2D:C3:1?@0C=85:834/ >:682 C/13=;=C03/ 2=9C4015/ 967701=/9 082 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=@=3B09)-H3:34/>4:@/<:2B63 34/1=<680@/11/2=8 C:89=2/1=85 34/ 907/ 09 )&H >=34:6308B<09=9 /8C/ 34=9 C:613;=829=31/09:80<@/3:7:2=;B34/2=90<=@=3B09!)12:;)-H =/ !)H CC:12=85@B 34/ @:99 :; ;6361/ /018=85 C0?0C=3B :; 34/C@0=7083>:6@2C:7/93: !) (&K!K!'K!)HM9) '* !&&% !& 4/ 07:6839 51083/2 682/1 7/2=C0@ /K?/89/9 082 1/7:G0@ :; =7?@0839 8//29 8: =83/1;/1/8C/ 09 34/1/ =9 8: 2=9?63/1/5012=8534/07:683 !! 4/0??/@@0837=5438:340G/>:1J/203@/093;:10 ?/1=:2 :; 341// 7:8349 26/ 3: 34/ =8A61B 96930=8/2 =8 34/ 0CC=2/83 34/1/;:1/ 9#! &%!) (&K) =93:</51083/2 - 9 - 682/1 34/ 4/02 @:99 :; =8C:7/ 261=85 @0=2 6? ?/1=:2 082 34/ 07:683 8//29 3: </ /8408C/2 3: 9)& &&&% 3:>0129 31089?:1303=:8 /K310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083 C4015/9 082 9& &&&%3:>0129?0=808296;;/1=85082@:99:;07/8=3=/9=9 3:<//8408C/23:9 &&&% ! 8 0@@ 34/ 3:30@ C:7?/8903=:8 C:7/9 3: 9( ( ')'%>=34=83/1/930334/103/:;*H?0;1:734/203/ :;?/3=3=:83=@@1/0@=I03=:8 !) 4/ 0>012 ?099/2 <B 34/ 1=<680@ =9 7:2=;=/2 09 682/1 ,-./ 012342/ !0=808296;;/1=85 & &&&% :99:;07/8=3=/9 &&&% ) /2=C0@/K?/89/9 #) #''% #1089?:1303=:8 /K310 8:61=947/83 082033/82083C4015/9 )& &&&% :99 :; =8C:7/ 261=85 @0=2 6? ?/1=:2 # ! &% *:99:;;6361//018=85C0?0C=3B ) '* !&&% (/7:G0@:;=7?@0839 )& &&&% :30@ ) CC:12=85@B 34/ C@0=70831/9?:82/83 =9 /83=3@/2 ;:1 0 3:30@ C:7?/8903=:8 :; 9' & ')'% 4/ C:7?/8903=:8 0>012/2 <B 34/ 1=<680@ =9 1/26C/2 ;1:7 9!! &* &''% 3: 9' & ')'>=34=83/1/930334/103/:;*H?/108867 - 10 - !# 834/1/96@334/;:@@:>=85:12/1=9?099/2 = 4/ 0??/0@ ;=@/2 <B 34/ C@0=70839 =8 $ :&!))'& =9 082 34/ 0??/0@ ;=@/2 <B 34/ 896108C/ :7?08B =8 $ :&!'-&=9 ( ! == 4/ 896108C/ C:7?08B =9 2=1/C3/2 3: 2/?:9=3 9' & ')'% >=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; *H ?0 >=34=8 :8/ 7:834 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; 34=9 :12/1 === 8 96C4 2/?:9=3 34/ C@0=7083 =9 ?/17=33/2 3: >=34210>34//83=1/07:6830@:85>=34=83/1/93 0CC16/2:8=3 =G 4/ 07:683 :; 9 &&&% 09 0 930363:1B 2/?:9=3 2/?:9=3/2 </;:1/ 34=9 :613 940@@ </ 31089;/11/23: /.) &%!! ( $ =93: !@: -