- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( )* %% &'( ) * ! " # $%% & ' % ! %" ! "( % % "'' # $ )'* % )& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %)) '+($'&)% % % % ) % ) % %) " % ! '( , " %% % - " % '( '+ )" ) * %..%% ! ! ! " # $%% & ' % ! %" ! "( % % "'' # $ )'* % )& %)) '+($'&)% % % % ) % ) % %) - 3 - " % ! '( , " %%%- " %' '+ % ) ) " %!/ %/ 0%" $ ' 1234561237891:5;<=><56;?41;?:><56561 2@@12A; 61;1 5B< 2@@12A; 231 =?A14 >C 561 DA2?92:5; 272?:;5 561 D<99<: E84791:5 2:4 2B234 42514 '( @2;;14 >C 561 44?5?<:2A ?;53?D5 2:4 1;;?<:; "8471 2:4 %19>13 %- ?E2C2@832 F=<3 ;6<35 G3?>8:2A,H ?: % <;' 2:4 '( <= '+ ;11I?:7 1:62:D191:5 <= D<9@1:;25?<: 61 2@@1AA2:5 ?: %) <' B2; DA2?92:5 ?: % <'( '+ 2:45612@@1AA2:5?:%)<'( B2;DA2?92:5?: %<' '+ (61=2D5;<=561D2;12315625561DA2?92:5;915 B?5623<24532==?D2DD?41:5<:'4815<32;62:4 :17A?71:543?J?:7>C56143?J13<= <<4;8989J16?DA1 - 4 - >123?:7317?;5325?<:< '' 31;8A5?:7?:?:E83?1; 5< 561 DA2?92:5; )<3 B6?D6 561C B131 5312514 2; ?:@25?1:5 ?: 561 6<;@?52A =<3 ;1J132A 42C; 2:4 ;8==1314 4?;2>?A?5C 1:D1 561 2@@1AA2:5; 6131?: 624 =?A14 561?3 31;@1D5?J1 DA2?9 @15?5?<:; >1=<31 561 3?>8:2A DA2?9?:7 D<9@1:;25?<: <= ;'+ 2:4 ;' 61 3?>8:2A D<:;?413?:7 561 1:5?31 92513?2A; 2J2?A2>A1 <: 31D<34 624 2B23414 2 ;89 <= ;+ ''' ?: % <'( '+ 2:4 2 ;89 <= ; ?: % <' '+B?56?:5131;525K@132::89=3<95614251 <=@15?5?<:;5?AA312A?L25?<:2:44?31D51431;@<:41:5<' <B:13 <= 561 J16?DA1 5< @2C 561 D<9@1:;25?<: 5< 561 DA2?92:5; 2:4 1M<:132514 31;@<:41:5 < :;832:D1 <9@2:C=3<9?5;A?2>?A?5C 773?1J14>C561;2?4E84791:5<=5613?>8:2A 561 ?:E8314DA2?92:5 ?: % <'( '+ 62; @31=13314 561 2@@12A ?: %) <' 2:4 561 ?:E8314 DA2?92:5?:%<' '+62;@31=133145612@@12A?: %)<'( - 5 - :%)<' / 5 ?; D<:51:414 >C 561 A123:14 D<8:;1A =<3 561 DA2?92:55625561D<9@1:;25?<:2B23414>C5613?>8:2A?; <: 561 A<B13 ;?41 61:D1 561 ?9@87:14 E84791:5 2:4 2B234?;A?2>A15<>19<4?=?14>C1:62:D?:7D<9@1:;25?<: 5 ?; ;52514 5625 561 2@@1AA2:5 62; ;8;52?:14 =32D5831 <= ;8@13?<3329<8;<=6?@><:1<:3?765;?41:;8@@<35<= 6?; DA2?9 61 1M29?:14 561 <D5<3 2; !( B6< 2=513 DA?:?D2A1M29?:25?<:41@<;1456255612@@1AA2:5?;;8==13?:7 ' 5< K 4?;2>?A?5C 5< 561 3?765 A<B13 A?9> B6?D6 62; <>J?<8;AC 3148D14 561 123:?:7 D2@2D?5C <= 561 2@@1AA2:5 85 561 3?>8:2A 4?;>1A?1J14 561 1J?41:D1 <= !( 2:4 4<D891:5; M' 2:4 '+ @3<48D14 >C 561 DA2?92:5 2:4 :<5 2B23414 2:C D<9@1:;25?<: =<3 A<;; <= =85831 123:?:7 D2@2D?5C <: 561 73<8:4 5625 61 1M29?:14 561 !( 2=513 56311C123;<=2DD?41:55?;2A;<D<:51:4145625912731 29<8:5; 231 732:514 =<3 @2?: 2:4 ;8==13?:7; 2:4 A<;; <= ?:D<91 483?:7 A2?4 8@ @13?<4 ; @13 M' N M532D5 <= 3?J?:7 ?D1:;1 561 43?J13 <= 561 <==1:4?:7 J16?DA1 B2; - 6 - @<;;1;;?:7 A?D1:;1 5< 43?J1 A?765 9<5<3 J16?DA1 ('(5<'('2:4?5?;;8>9?551456252;@13 G, 17?;513 M532D5 25 M 561 8:A241: B1?765 <= 561 J16?DA1?;''I7; 2:42;;8D6?5?;2?765%<5<316?DA1 2;41=?:148:413561@3<J?;?<:;<= 561%<5<316?DA1D5 :J?1B<=561;291 ?5D2::<5>1;2?4562556143?J13B2; :<5 @<;;1;;?:7 J2A?4 2:4 1==1D5?J1 43?J?:7 A?D1:;1 2; 61A4 >C5613?>8:2A1:D1 A123:14D<8:;1A=<3561DA2?92:5 D<:51:414 561 :;832:D1 <9@2:C ?; A?2>A1 5< @2C 561 D<9@1:;25?<: @138;2A<=M''!<8:4135?=?D251 ;6<B; 5625561DA2?92:562;;8;52?:1473?1J<8;?:E83?1;!(N <D5<3 62; 2;;1;;14 ' 5< K <= @1392:1:5 @6C;?D2A 4?;2>?A?5C 61 2DD?41:5 62; <DD83314 <: ' 2:4 561 DA2?92:5 2@@3<2D614 561 !( <: '' =<3 <>52?:?:7?;2>?A?5C135?=?D251613?>8:2A<>;13J145625 56131?;?:<34?:25141A2C?:2;;1;;?:74?;2>?A?5C2:44?4:<5 2B234 2:C D<9@1:;25?<: =<3 A<;; <= =85831 123:?:7 D2@2D?5C B6?D6 :114; ?:513=131:D1 >C 56?; <835 - 7 - 49?5514AC <: @138;2A <= 561 92513?2A; <: 31D<34 561 DA2?92:5 62; ;8==1314 4?;2>?A?5C 5< ;<91 1M51:5 1:D1 D<:;?413?:7 561 :25831 <= ?:E83?1; 2:4 @13?<4 <= 6<;@?52A?L25?<: 56?;<835=?:4;?5312;<:2>A15<2;;1;;561 4?;2>?A?5C25K + 61DA2?92:5;52514562561B2;2714(C123; B<3I?:72;3?J132:4123:?:7; @139<:56 >85 61 62; :<5 =?A14 2:C ?:D<91 @3<<= ; 61 915 B?56 561 2DD?41:5 <: ' 2; @13 561 D6235 ?;;814 >C 561 23:252I2 5251 172A 13J?D1; 856<3?5C 56?; <835 4119; ?5 2@@3<@3?251 5< 312;;1;; 561 ?:D<91 <= 561 DA2?92:5 25 ; + @13 9<:56 2:4 2@@3<@3?251 98A5?@A?132@@A?D2>A15<6?;27173<8@?;G',DD<34?:7AC 561DA2?92:5?;1:5?5A14=<3A<;;<==85831123:?:72;8:413/ ; + M'M'MKO;+( )835613 561 3?>8:2A 62; 3?765AC 732:514 ; ''' 5<B234; 914?D2A 1M@1:;1; B6?D6 :114; :< ?:513=131:D1 2; 56131 ?; :< 4?;@851 317234?:7 561 ;291 - 8 - 6?; <835 =?:4; ?5 312;<:2>A1 5< 2B234 2: 29<8:5 <= ;( =<3 @2?: 2:4 ;8==13?:7* ; 5<B234; 532:;@<3525?<: 1M532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5 D62371; 2:4; =<3A<;;<=291:?5?1; 1 9?765 :<5 62J1 2551:414 2:C B<3I 25A12;5 =<32@13?<4<=563119<:56; 61:D1 A<;;<=?:D<91483?:7 A2?48@@13?<4D<91;5<; $ +M(& ' 61 D<9@1:;25?<: 2B23414 >C 561 3?>8:2A ?; 9<4?=?142;8:413/ +,-. /01231. /01231. ' <;; <= =85831 123:?:7 D2@2D?5C +( 2?:2:4;8==13?:7 ( (<;;<=291:?5?1; %14?D2A1M@1:;1; ''' 32:;@<3525?<: 1M532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5 D62371; <;;<=123:?:7483?:7561 A2?48@@13?<4=<39<:56; 2,4 "5" ) '' DD<34?:7AC 561 DA2?92:52@@1AA2:5 ?; 1:5?5A14 =<3 2 5<52A D<9@1:;25?<: <= ; ' 2; 272?:;5 - 9 - ;+ ''' 2B23414 >C 561 3?>8:2A 6131 B?AA >1 1:62:D191:5<=;' ( + :%)<'( / ' 5?;;52514>C561DA2?92:55625255615?91<= 2DD?41:5 ;61 B2; 2714 2><85 ( C123; 2:4 123:?:7 ;' @13 9<:56 >C B<3I?:7 2; 2 D<<A?1 85 ;61 =2?A14 5< =?A1 2:C ?:D<91 @3<<= )835613 2; @13 !<8:4 135?=?D251 ;61 62; ;8;52?:14 <:1 ;?9@A1 ?:E83C >;13J?:7 561;1 2;@1D5; <= 561 925513 561 3?>8:2A 62; 3?765AC2B23414561D<9@1:;25?<:8:4132AA6124; ?:5<52A 25; B?56?:5131;5255613251<=K1:D1 56?; <835=?:4;:<312;<:5<?:513=131B?56561;2?4<34132:4 6131>CD<:=?395612B234@2;;14>C5613?>8:2A '( :56131;8A5 561=<AA<B?:7<3413?;@2;;14/ i) 61 2@@12A ?: %) <' ?; 2:4 561 2@@12A ?: %) <'( ?;6131>C - 10 - ii) 1;@<:41:5 < ?: %) <' ?; 4?31D514 5< 41@<;?5 561 1:62:D14 D<9@1:;25?<: <= ; ' 2A<:7 B?56 ?:5131;5 25 561 3251 <= K @13 2::89 B?56?: <:19<:56=3<95614251<=<3413 iii) 1;@<:41:5 N :;832:D1 <9@2:C ?: %) <'( ?; 4?31D514 5< 41@<;?5 ; 2B23414 >C 561 3?>8:2A B?56 ?:5131;5 25 561 3251 <= K B?56?: <:1 9<:56 =3<95614251<=<3413 ?=?5?;:<541@<;?514 iv) : ;8D6 41@<;?5 561 2@@1AA2:5; ?: ><56 561 2@@12A;231@139?55145<B?56432B5611:5?31 29<8:52A<:7B?56?:5131;52DD3814<:?5 .-) &% ( $ % ?;5</'A</