- 1 - !! "" # "$% ! &! "'# #% (" )* ! ! ! " # $ ! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - % & ! ' % - 3 - " " $ ((% ! % & ! ' (($'! ! ) - 4 - ! ) ! " $ % % & ' - 5 - ! " ' ! $ ! % - 6 - * + , " - - ( - ."$''& ! + , - ."$''& - ."$''& " ! - ."%"' * + ! , - 7 - - $ - - - - - # - - '(& #( #( - /0 1! " + 1! , 2345 46 7382 9234:25 ;<=:>29 ?<4 872 @468 A28686<:24> 3> @299 3> 872 9234:25 55686<:39 <B24:C2:8 5B<;382@7<42A42>2:8>87242>A<:52:8> 22D6:E 3 @468 <? C3:53C=> 5642;86:E 872 42>A<:52:8 3=87<46862> 8< 3::<=:;2 872 42>=98> <? 872 @468 A28686<:24> @7< 3AA23425 ?<4 F3C6:386<:> 73B6:E >8=56255=46:E8723;352C6;G234'('&872A42>2:8@468 A28686<:6>?6925 234:25 ;<=:>29 ?<4 872 @468 A28686<:24> 46 7382 >=HC68> 8738 872 A28686<:24> @242 E43:825 35C6>>6<: 8< >8=5G 87264 ;<=4>2 6: 92;846;63: 4352 38 - 8 - 46 35E=4= 3C396:E2>7@34 :5=>84639 436:6:E :>868=82 =4C38D39 72 A28686<:24> ;<CA92825 87264 25=;386<: 3:5 ?6:399G 3AA9625 ?<4 @4686:E 2F3C6:386<:> 72 42>A<:52:8 3=87<46862>6>>=25739986;D28>3:5872A28686<:24>3AA23425?<4 8722F3C6:386<:><@2B2487242>A<:52:83=87<46862>?369258< 3::<=:;287242>=98> <423><:>@738><2B24@2423>>6E:25?<4 :<:(52;934386<: <? 42>=98> 234:25 ;<=:>29 >=HC68> 8738 872 42>A<:52:8> ;3::<8 @6877<95 872 42>=98> @687<=8 >=??6;62:8 ;3=>23:587242?<4235642;86<:C3GH26>>=25?<452;934386<: <?42>=98> <:2 874<=E7 872 ;<:82:8> <? 872 >8382C2:8 <? <HI2;86<:>?6925 " 234:25 55686<:39 <B24:C2:8 5B<;382 >=HC68> 8738 46 35E=4=3C396:E2>7@34:5=>84639436:6:E:>868=82 =4C38D39 735 :<8 3AA9625 ?<4 3??696386<: ?<4 872 G234> '('& HG A3G6:E A42>;46H25 ?22 72 >365 6:>868=82 @3> 6:>A2;825 A=4>=3:8 8< 872 5642;86<:> <? 876> <=48 6: <'"$ '& HG 3 (C2CH24 :>A2;86<: <CC68822 72 <CC68822 ?<=:5 >246<=> 93A>2> 6: 4=::6:E 872 6:>868=82 3:5 6CA3486:E 8436:6:E 8< 872 >8=52:8> 234:25 55686<:39 - 9 - <B24:C2:8 5B<;382 ?=48724 >8382> 8738 872 @468 A28686<:24> @242 A24C68825 8< @4682 2F3C6:386<:> 6: ;<CA963:;2 <? 872 6:8246C <4524> <? 876> <=48 6: <'"$ '& 3:5 87242?<42 872G ;3::<8 >22D ?<4 3::<=:;2C2:8 <? 42>=98> 3:5 87=>872@468A28686<:6>:<8C36:836:3H92 $ 5C688259G 3 A4<;25=42 6> A42>;46H25 ?<4 E2886:E 872 ;3:565382> 35C68825 8< A46B382 :5=>84639 436:6:E :>868=82>>A24872:<4C>?6F25872;3:565382>34242J=6425 8<H2399<8825HG87242>A<:52:8>8<3A3486;=9346:>868=82738 3A348739986;D28>@699<:9GH26>>=25<:>386>?3;8<4GA4<<?H26:E A4<5=;258738872;3:565382>73B2A=8=A42J=64253882:53:;2 8 6> :<8 872 ;3>2 <? 872 42>A<:52:8> 8738 872G 6>>=25 7399 86;D28>@687<=8B246?6;386<:<?8723882:53:;2<?872A28686<:24> 72426: : 3 J=24G A<>25 HG 876> <=48 9234:25 55686<:39 <B24:C2:85B<;38242>A<:5258738872A28686<:24>3AA23425 ?<4 A43;86;39 2F3C6:386<: H2?<42 @4686:E 872<4286;39 2F3C6:386<: < C3824639 6> <: 42;<45 8< >7<@ 8738 872 A28686<:24>?369256:872A43;86;392F3C6:386<: 242 6> 3 ;3>2 @7242 % >8=52:8> 342 @3686:E ?<4 8726442>=98>8<H252;93425>6:;2'& <C3824639@738><2B24 - 10 - 6> A4<5=;25 HG 872 42>A<:52:8> 8< >7<@ 8738 872 ;3:565382> @242 E<8 35C68825 HG 46 35E=4= 3C396:E2>7@34 :5=>84639 436:6:E :>868=82 =4C38D39 @687<=8 399<8C2:8 HG 872 42>A<:52:8> 72 ;<:82:8> <? 872 7399 86;D28> 38 ::2F=42( 42B239> 8738 87<>2 7399 86;D28> @242 6>>=25 HG 872 <:84<9924 8382 <345 <? F3C6:386<:> 9>< 87242 6> 3 :<82 8738 872 8436:22 >7<=95 B246?G 872 ;<442;8:2>> <? 399 872 528369> 96D2 3C2-387240>:3C2436:6:EA246<54352 3C2<?872 28;86>39><C2:86<:2587386?3:GC6>83D26>?<=:5872>3C2 >7<=95 H2 6:?<4C25 8< 872 3=87<468G 6CC2563829G H2?<42 84352 82>8 3:5 ;<442;86<: <? C34D> ;345 ;3::<8 H25<:2 3?824@345> 76>6:5225C3D2>68;92348738H3>6:E<:872C38246393B3693H92 H2?<42 872 42>A<:52:8> >365 7399 86;D28> @242 A42A3425 3:5 6>>=257=>686>;9234873887235C6>>6<:<?872A28686<:24>6: 872 A3486;=934 :5=>84639 436:6:E :>868=82 6> @6876: 872 D:<@925E2 <? 872 42>A<:52:8> ? 872 42>A<:52:8> 735 42399G ?298 8738 35C6>>6<: <? >=;7 ;3:565382> @3> 6CA4<A24 872G @<=9573B283D2:>82A>6CC2563829G><3>8<>3B2872?=8=42<? 87<>2>8=52:8>=8:<876:E<?8738><483AA234>8<73B2H22: 5<:299872>2?3;8>3:5;64;=C>83:;2>;92349G42B239>8738872 42>A<:52:8>@<D2=A383B24GH293825>83E2726:3;86<:<: - 11 - A348 <? 872 42>A<:52:8> ;3::<8 73CA24 872 ?=8=42 <? 872 A28686<:24> 7242?<42 876> <=48 6> <? 872 B62@ 8738 872 42>A<:52:8>34242J=64258<H25642;8258<52;934287242>=98> <?872A28686<:24>6CC2563829G % 7=>872@468A28686<:6>399<@25@687872?<99<@6:E +6, 72 <CC6>>6<:24 2A348C2:8 <? CA9<GC2:8 3:5436:6:E2:E39=4=6>5642;8258<83D2>82A> ?<4 3::<=:;2C2:8 <? 42>=98> <? 872 A28686<:24> 6CC2563829G +66, ::<=:;2C2:8 <? 42>=98> >7399 H2 5<:2 3> 2FA25686<=>9G 3> A<>>6H92 H=8 :<8 93824 873: 26E78@22D>?4<C8725382<?42;26A8<?;<AG<? 876><4524 #+, ("- #% * '" 6>8 < 9 <$