Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58203 (KAR)

M/S VEERBHADRESHWAR TRADING CO v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WA/200210/2025 · 2025-08-22

H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$! "#$# !! %#& ! "#$ % & $ & & '###$ ( &) && ) "*" & '###$ Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + && , && $' ! "#$ " && , && - ! "#$ ) , && - ! "#$ ' $ $& $#( $ & ###!" % &$. &( . & &' - 3 - & "& & & (###$/(#(+ $ #/(#( & & & )0 & & & & )0 0 & #(#'(#(( ( )0 & & & 1 1 & $# 1 23456728234925:;<9=283>>234?9@A;4672>346?2= ( 234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 672 3>>288396 B;<85 C272D2968E:;962956736672;4524:738829@2F2A;4267?=;<46 ?=B?6742@3456;672;4524>3==25FE6728234925?9@82<5@2 B7242?9 672 8234925 ?9@82 <5@2 73= :;DD?6625 39 244;4 ?9 - 4 - =266?9@ 3=?52 992G<420 =; 38=; 6; 672 :;9=2H<296 ;4524 992G<4206;672B4?6>26?6?;9 + 72 :;<9=28 B;<85 38=; C272D2968E :;96295 6736 672 823=20:<D0=382 3@422D296 ?9 42=>2:6 ;A 672 >4;>246E 2G2:<625 FE 42=>;95296 9;" ?9 A3C;<4 ;A 42=>;95296 ;' 53625$+#/(#((3=>24 992G<42038=;=2603=?52F<6@?C29 8?F246E 6; 349363I3 95<=64?38 423= 2C28;>D296 ;345 6; ?9?6?362 A42=7 >4;:225?9@= 3@3?9=6 672 >26?6?;924 ?9 42=>2:6;A42=<D>6?;9;A8395?93::;4539:2B?6783B " 72 8234925 :;<9=28 A;4 672 3>>288396 B;<85 C272D2968E :;96295 6736 3A624 388;6D296 ;A 672 >4;>246E 3>>288396 ?9C2=625 7<@2 3D;<96 395 672 ;4524 >3==25 FE 672 8234925 ?9@82 <5@2 3AA2:6= 672 4?@76 ;A 672 3>>288396 395 729:2?642H<?42=?9624A2429:2 729 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 672 3>>288396 64?25 6; >24<=2 67?= ;<46 ;9 672 ?D><@925 ;4524 67?= ;<46 73C?9@9;6?:2583<=2C;A672;4524B7242?9672?96242=6;A 672 3>>288396 ?= >4;62:625 =636?9@ 6736 672 ;4524 B?88 9;6 F2 :;D2?9672B3E;A 388;66?9@672=3D28395?9A3C;<4;A 42=>;95296;'?A3A624A;88;B?9@6725<2>4;:2==?6?=A;<95 - 5 - 6736 >26?6?;924 73= C?;83625 672 624D= ;A 388;6D296 395 ?A 3 82@?6?D362;4524?=>3==2542=<D?9@6728395 ' 729672=3?583<=2CB3=F4;<@766;6729;6?:2 ;A 672 3>>288396J= :;<9=28 8234925 29?;4 :;<9=28 D352 672 =<FD?==?;9 6736 ?A 5?42:6?;9 ?= @?C29 6; :;D>8262 672 >4;:2== B?67?9A;<4B22I=3=>24672;4524;A6728234925?9@82<5@2 FE 5?=>;=?9@ 672 3>>238 2 A288 6736 =<:7 5?42:6?;9 :39 F2 @?C29 / 72 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 42=>;95296 B;<85 =<FD?6 6736 2:6?;9 +"0 ;A 672 349363I3 95<=64?38 423= 2C28;>D296 ;345 :6 :6 =>23I= 3F;<6 672 >;B24 6; 42=<D2 ;A >;==2==?;9 ;A >42D?=2= 2 B;<85 38=; :;9629567369;6?:273=6;F2@?C293953A624672?==<39:2;A 9;6?:2 ;98E 672 =3D2 73= 6; F2 >4;:2==25 29:2 67242 ?= 5?AA?:<86E?9:;9=?524?9@672=3D2B?67?9A;<4B22I= ! 72 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 42=>;95296 ;' B;<85 =<FD?6= 6736 672 =3?5 5?42:6?;9 D3E F2 @?C29 6; :;9=?524 672 =3D2B?67?9A;<4B22I=39538=;=<FD?6=6736672:;96296?;9= B7?:773C2F22943?=25D3EF2I2>6;>29 - 6 - * 23456723>>288396J=:;<9=283=B2883=672:;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 672 42=>2:6?C2 42=>;95296= 395 38=; 672 =<FD?==?;9 ;A 672 3>>288396J= :;<9=28 B?67 42@345 6; 672 >4;:2==B7?:7:39F25;92B?67?9A;<4B22I= $# 72 :;<9=28 3>>234?9@ A;4 42=>;95296 ;=( 6; B;<85=<FD?6=6736672=3D2:399;6F25;92B?67?9A;<4B22I= <6672:;<9=283>>234?9@A;442=>;95296;'B;<85=<FD?6= 6736 672E 342 4235E 6; 63I2 9;6?:2 ?9 ;4524 6; :;D>8E B?67 2:6?;9+"0(;A672 :6?DD25?3628E $$ 7242A;42 ?=5?42:6256;=24C26729;6?:2;9 42=>;95296 ;' 674;<@7 2D3?8 395 38=; 674;<@7 =>225 >;=6 A;467B?67;9;4F2A;42(!#!(#( 39542=>;95296;'6;A?82 ;FK2:6?;9 ?A 39E B?67?9 6B; B22I= A4;D 6736 5362 ?2 (!#!(#( 39542=>;95296;=(6; 6;:;9=?5243955?=>;=2 ;A672=3D2672423A624B?67?96B;B22I= $( 6 ?= 9;6?:25 6736 ?D><@925 ;4524 B3= >3==25 ;9 $ #/(#( 6?88536242=>;95296=73C29;6D35239E2AA;46=6; :;D>8E B?67 672 ;4524 29:2 67?= ;<46 63I?9@ 9;62 ;A 672 >2:<8?34 A3:6= 395 :?4:<D=639:2= ;A 67?= :3=2 5?42:6= 672 42=>;95296= 6; :;9=?524 672 =3D2 ?9 3 6?D2 F;95 D39924 - 7 - 9;6B?67=6395?9@67?46E53E=A;4A?8?9@;FK2:6?;93=:;962D>83625 <9524 2:6?;9 +"0( ;A 672 :6 6; A?82 ;FK2:6?;9= 6; 6729;6?:2 ?67672=2;F=24C36?;9=B4?63>>238?=5?=>;=25;A 88:;96296?;9=;A672>346?2=342I2>6;>29 '( %!& $ '( %#& $ ?=6;$8;$