Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58199 (KAR)
RAJU @ RAJASHEKHAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200261/2023 · 2025-08-04
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58199 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58199 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
#%%
&'
&(%)*
&)) +
!"#$# % &
'
(
&'(
!"#$#
(
! #$) % &
'
( )*+&' ( ( ( $)$!$) $+$!$)
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#"!$# ( (( )$*))) )+* $"))+ $+ $"(
(( ,
-
$# & -
'
# ./ 011/22034 5/637 4./ 0889:/; 63 <#"!$#<34./=62/<=4./2/0>3/;>6386102/::6<3:
9;7/ 6?0@019>0&/>/630=4/> >/=/>>/; 4< 0: A>602 <9>4B =<> 4./ :0C/ <= 8<3D/36/38/' 6: 6E19736374./ ?9;7E/34 <= 8<3D6846<3 03; <>;/> <= :/34/38/ ;04/; $)$!$) 8<3D684637.6E=<>4./<==/38/:1936:.052/93;/>/846<3: )$*))) )+* $"))03; $+<=4./3;603/302 <;/ &=<> :.<>4 -4./ -' 03; :/34/38637 4< 93;/>7< :6E12/6E1>6:<3E/34=<>01/>6<;<=)@/0>:03;10@0=63/ <= : $$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 )$* <= 4< 93;/>7< :6E12/ 6E1>6:<3E/34 =<> # @/0>
- 3 -
03; 10@ 0 =63/ <= :#$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/>/846<3))<=4<93;/>7<:6E12/6E1>6:<3E/34 =<> # @/0> 03; 10@ 0 =63/ <= :#$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 ) ) 4< 93;/>7< :6E12/ 6E1>6:<3E/34 =<> " E<34.: 03; 10@ 0 =63/ <= :#$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 +* <= 4< 93;/>7<:6E12/6E1>6:<3E/34=<>"E<34.:03;10@0=63/ <=:#$$$=<>4./<==/38/1936:.052/93;/>/846<3 $" <=03;4<10@=63/<=:#$$$/08.=<>4./<==/38/:
1936:.052/93;/>/846<3:))03; $+<=F64.;/=0924 :/34/38/=<>/08.<=4./<==/38/:
./80:/<=4./1><:/8946<3635>6/=6:4.04<3 $ $$#0405<94##$1E4./0889:/;/34/>/;4./ <==68/<=4.//0;0:4/><=<D/>3E/34>6E0>@8.<<2 08.@0262207/03;0::0924/;.6EF64..03;:C68C/;.6E <3 4./ 8./:4 03; 4./ 1>6D04/ 10>4: / 02:< 4>6/; 4< :4>0379204/4./3/8CF64.03634/346<34<809:/.6:;/04. ./ 63?9>/; F0: 02:< 1>/D/34/; =><E ;6:8.0>7637 4./ <==68602 ;946/: 0: 4./ /0; 0:4/> <= 4./ <D/>3E/34
- 4 -
8.<<2/.0:4<>34./>/8<>;:03;8<EE644/;E6:8.6/= 059:/; 4./ 63?9>/; 63=<>E034 63 =624.@ 2037907/ F64. 03 634/346<34<63:92403;4<1><D<C/5>/08.1/08/8>6E63022@ 6346E6;04/;4<809:/;/04.<=4.//0;0:4/>03;4./>/5@ 8<EE644/;4./<==/38/3>/8/614<=4./=6>:463=<>E046<3 4./(F0:>/76:4/>/; ) =4/> 63D/:467046<3 8.0>7/:.//4 80E/ 4< 5/ =62/;./2/0>3/;076:4>04/4<<C8<736G038/<=4./05<D/ :06; <==/38/: 03; 8<EE644/; 4./ E044/> 4< 4./ /::6<3: <9>4./>602<9>4:9EE<3/;4./0889:/;889:/; .0: 011/0>/; 5/=<>/ 4./ >602 <9>4 12/0;/; 3<4 79624@ 03;8206E/;4<5/4>6/;<1><D/64:80:/4./1><:/8946<3 /H0E63/; 363/ F643/::/: 0: ,:# 4< 03; 7<4 E0>C/;
4./;<89E/34:04 H:#4<#$./0889:/;.0:;/36/; 0224./638>6E6304637E04/>602:0D062052/<3>/8<>;594.0: 3<48.<:/34<2/0;03@/D6;/38/63.6:;/=/38/ + =4/>40C637634<8<3:6;/>046<30224./E04/>602: <3>/8<>;4./>602<9>480E/4<4./8<3829:6<34.044./ 1><:/8946<3 6: :988/::=92 63 1><D637 4./ 79624 <= 4./
- 5 -
0889:/; =<> 4./ <==/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3: )$* )) ) ) +* $" )) 03; $+ <= 4./ 3;603 /302 <;/ 03; 088<>;6372@ 8<3D684/; 03; :/34/38/; .6E 0:
:404/; 05<D/
/637 077>6/D/; 5@ 4./ :0E/ 0889:/; 6: 5/=<>/4.6:<9>4
/0>; >6 .6D0303; 044030:./446 2/0>3/;
8<93:/2 =<> 4./ 011/22034 03; >6 0E0;0> .0.059;;63 2/0>3/;
67. <9>4 <D/>3E/34 2/0;/> =<> 4./ >/:1<3;/34 />9:/; 4./ E04/>602: 63829;637 4./ >602 <9>4>/8<>;:
" 3 D6/F <= 4./ >6D02 8<34/346<3: 9>7/; 5@ 2/0>3/;8<93:/2=<>5<4.4./10>46/:4./1<6344.04F<92; 0>6:/=<>E@8<3:6;/>046<36:
- 6 -
* @03:F/>4<4./05<D/1<6346:
=<>4./=<22<F637
!
46: 4./ 8<34/346<3 <= 4./1><:/8946<3 4.040:
<3 4./ ;04/ <= 4./ 6386;/34 0889:/; .0D/ 8>6E63022@ 4>/:10::/; 634< 4./ <D/>3E/34 8.<<2 0::0924/; 4./ /0;0:4/>F64.03634/346<34<809:/.6:;/04.03;4>6/; 4<:4>0379204/.6:3/8C46:4./=9>4./>8<34/346<3<=4./ 1><:/8946<3 4.044./ 0889:/; .0: 4<>34./<==68602>/8<>;:
03; 1>/D/34/; 4./ /0; 0:4/> F.62/ ;6:8.0>7637 .6:
<==68602 ;946/: 059:/; .6E 63 =624.@ 2037907/ F64. 03 634/346<3 4< 63:924 03; 4< 1><D<C/ 5>/08. <= 1/08/ 03;
8>6E63022@ 6346E6;04/; 4./>/5@ 8<EE644/; 4./ 0=<>/:06; <==/38/:
,#6:4./63?9>/;63=<>E034/.0:;/1<:/; 05<944./6386;/3403;:404/;4.044./0889:/;80E/4<.6: <==68/ 059:/; .6E 63 =624.@ 2037907/ 03; 0::0924/; F64. .03;: 03; C68C/; F64. 2/7: 03; 809:/; 4./ 63?9>6/: /
- 7 -
02:< ;/1<:/: >/70>;637 4./ 084: <= 4./ 0889:/; 63 8<EE644637<4./><==/38/:34.04>/70>;./2<;7/;=6>:4 63=<>E046<30:1/> H# #$ ,:)+*03;!0>/:06;4<5//@/F643/:: 4<4./6386;/34,:03;!.0D/3<4:911<>4/;4./80:/ <= 4./1><:/8946<3 ,:) 03; + /D/3 4.<97. :911<>4/;
4./ 80:/ <= 4./ 1><:/8946<3 .0D/ :404/; 4.04 4./@ .0D/ ./0>; I90>>/2 594 4./@ .0D/ 3<4 ://3 4./ 0889:/; 0::0924637,# ## , 6: 4./ <84<> F.< /H0E63/; 4./ 63?9>/;
,# 03; 6::9/; ,<93; />46=6804/ 0: 1/> H* : 1/> H* 4./ 63?9>/; .0: 80E/4< .6E 4./.6:4<>@ <= 0::0924 5@ 4./ 0889:/; 3 /H0E63046<3 4./>/ F0: 4/3;/>3/::
<D/> 4./ 8./:4 2/=4 4.67. 03; :8><49E <F/D/> , .0: 3<4 :06; 4.04 63?9>6/: :9==/>/; 5@ 4./ ,# 0>/ :9==686/34 4< 809:/ .6: ;/04. ," 6: 4./ F643/:: 4< 4./ :1<4E0.0G0>04 H),6:4./3D/:46704637==68/> D/34.<97.4./,#.0:=922@:911<>4/;4./80:/<=4./ 1><:/8946<3 3<4.637 .0: 5//3 /26864/; =><E ,# 4<
- 8 -
8<34/3;4.044./63?9>6/::9==/>/;5@,#03;4./0::0924 E0;/5@0889:/;F/>/:9==686/344<809:/.6:;/04.<>F64. 03634/346<34<809:/.6:;/04.;E644/;2@4./0889:/; .0:3<49:/;03@F/01<3:F.62/8<EE6446374./<==/38/:
/ 0::0924/; F64. .03;: 03; C68C/; F64. 4./ 2/7: 32@ :6E12/63?9>6/:F/>/809:/;4<,# # <3:6;/>6370224./:/=084:03;86>89E:4038/:<= 4./80:/0E<=4./<1636<34.044./1><:/8946<3.0:3<4 1><D/;4./79624<=4./0889:/;=<>4./<==/38/1936:.052/ 93;/>/846<3)$*<=3;603/302<;/ #) 4 6: 4./ 8<34/346<3 <= 4./ 1><:/8946<3 4.04 0889:/; .0: 4<>3 4./ 195268 ;<89E/34: 03; 809:/;
E6:8.6/=
943<4.637.0:5//31><;98/;5/=<>/4./<9>4 63 4.04 >/70>; ./>/=<>/ 4./ 1><:/8946<3 .0: 02:< 3<4 1><D/; 4./ <==/38/ 93;/> /846<3 +* <= 3;603 /302 <;/ <F/D/> =><E 4./ E04/>602: <3 >/8<>; 4./ 1><:/8946<3 6: :988/::=92 63 1><D637 4./ 79624 <= 4./ 0889:/; =<> 4./ <==/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3: ))
- 9 -
) ))) $"03; $+<=4./3;603/302<;//38/ ./6:26052/=<>4./8<3D6846<3=<>4./0=<>/:06;<==/38/:
#+ .0D/7<3/4.><97.4./6E1973/;?9;7E/34<= 8<3D6846<303;<>;/><=:/34/38/10::/;5@4./>602<9>4 ./ >602 <9>4 .0: 1><8//;/; 4< 8<3D684 0889:/; =<> 4./ <==/38/93;/>/846<3:)$*03;+*<=3;60/302<;/ /D/3 4.<97.
4./>/ 0>/ 3< :9==686/34 E04/>602: 4< 044>084 4./:/ 1><D6:6<3: <= 20F ./>/=<>/ 0E <= 4./ <1636<3 4.04 4./ 6E1973/; ?9;7E/34 <= 8<3D6846<3 03; <>;/> <= :/34/38/10::/;5@4./>602<9>48022:=<>634/>=/>/38/5@ 4.6:<9>4 # 4 4.6: ?93849>/ 2/0>3/; 8<93:/2 =<> 4./ 011/22034 :95E64: 4.04 4./ 6386;/34 .0; <889>>/; <3 $ $$# 63 0 =64 <= 037/> ./>/ F0: 3< 634/346<3 4< 809:/ 4./ ;/04. <= ,# ./>/=<>/ ./ :95E64: 4.04 5@ 8<3:6;/>637 4./ =084: 03; 86>89E:4038/: <= 4./ 80:/ E0H6E9E2/36/38@E0@5/:.<F363=0D<9><=4./0889:/;
5@ 6E1<:637 <32@ =63/ 63:4/0;<= :95:40346D/ :/34/38/ =63; 8<3:6;/>052/ =<>8/ 63 4./ :95E6::6<3 E0;/ 5@ 4./
- 10 -
2/0>3/;8<93:/2634.04>/70>;0:4./E04/>602:<3>/8<>; :.<F4.0464F0:0:9;;/3<9459>:4<=037/><34./:19> <=E<D/E/34 #" 3 D6/F <= 4./ 05<D/ 03:F/> 4./ 1<634 =<> 8<3:6;/>046<3 A B 03; 1><8//;/; 4<10::4./=<22<F637
&6' ./ >6E6302 11/02 6:
&66' ./ 6E1973/; ?9;7E/34 <= 8<3D6846<3 03; <>;/> <= :/34/38/ ;04/; $)$!$)10::/;63<#"!$#5@4./ 2/0>3/; >6386102 /::6<3: 9;7/ 6?0@019>0 F64. >/70>; 4< <==/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3:)$*03;+*<=3;603/302<;/6: ./>/5@ :/4 0:6;/ : 0 >/:924 0889:/; 6: 08I9644/;<=4./:/<==/38/:
- 11 -
&666' ./ ?9;7E/34 <= 8<3D6846<3 ;04/; $)$!$)10::/;63<#"!$#10::/; 5@ 4./ 2/0>3/; >6386102 /::6<3: 9;7/ 6?0@019>0 F64. >/70>; 4< <==/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/>/846<3:))))) + $+03; $"<= 6:./>/5@8<3=6>E/;
&6D' <F/D/> 4./ <>;/> <= :/34/38/ 6: E<;6=6/;0:./>/93;/> &D' ./ 0889:/; 6: 26052/ 4< 10@ =63/ <= :)$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 )) 10@ =63/ <= :)$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/1936:.052/93;/>/846<3))10@=63/ <= :)$$$ =<> 4./<==/38/1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 ) + 10@ =63/ <= :#$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 $+ 03; :)$$$ =<> 4./ <==/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/> /846<3 $"<=3;/=09244<10@=63/4./ 0889:/; 6: :/34/38/; 4< 93;/>7< :6E12/
- 12 -
6E1>6:<3E/34 =<> # ;0@: 4< /08. <= 4./ <==/38/:
/76:4>@ 4< :/3; 508C 4./ >602 <9>4 /8<>;: 02<37 F64.8<1@<=4.6:?9;7E/34=<>63=<>E046<303;=<>3//;=92 0846<3
,* &##) $
6:4<#2<$