Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58197 (KAR)
THE CHIEF ENGINEER ELECTRICITY v. M/S SAMALA MAREAPPA AND SONS AND ANR
MFA/202893/2023 · 2025-09-19
T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58197 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58197 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
# $%&
$&
##
'(
)
!"
#
#
! $
%
&! %
" ! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
'
('
%)
*!!!"
$
+ %!,! &!&, &
")
--* %
,
%&! '
%&! ! &
'
%&! '
*!*&! )
&
%&! ! -!,&! ! '
(
( . '
. '
- 3 -
&
(. '
/0 122033145 /16 78309 5/0 2:06045 122013 ;490: 0<58=4 ") < =7 5/0 :>85:158=4 149 =4<838158=4 <5 --**+,-./08?2;@484@5/0=:90:91509 *!*&! ) 216609>A5/0301:409:84<8213865:8<5';9@0
131>;:1@8 84:>85:158=42238<158=4= =7&! /0122033145/19 2:070::095/0618912238<158=4;490:0<58=4","=75/0 B<5:019C85/0<58=4=75/08?85158=4<5600D84@ <=49=4158=4 =7 9031A =7 ?=:0 5/14 ,!! 91A6 84 78384@ 5/0 12238<158=4 5= 605 16890 5/0 1:>85:13 1C1:9 91509 -!,&! ! & /0618912238<158=4C16:0E0<509165/0301:4095:813 =;:5 7=;49 5/15 5/0 9031A C16 >0A=49 5/0 20:8=9 5/15 <=;39>0<=49=4098450:?6=75/02:=F86=5=0<58=4"," =75/0B<5@@:80F09>A5/06189=:90:
5/0122033145 /16 2:070::09 5/0 2:06045 122013 <=4504984@ 5/15 5/0:0 C164=9031A8478384@5/012238<158=4;490:0<58=4",=7 5/0 B <5 16 5/0 61?0 /19 >004 78309 C85/84 5/0
- 4 -
6582;3150920:8=9=75/:00?=45/67:=?5/09150=7:0<0825 =7 5/0 1C1:9 /0 2:06045 122013 /16 >004 78309 1750: 1 9031A=7 ""!91A6/0122033145/166=;@/55=0G23184 5/0 9031A >A <=4504984@ 5/15 :062=49045 = 84 C/=60 71F=;: 5/0 1:>85:13 1C1:9 86 :0490:09 /19 2:070::09 14 0G0<;58=4 205858=4 84 &! ! >;5 5/0 61?0 C16 986?86609 /0:07=:0
5/01220331459894=551D014A650265=8?2;@4 5/0 =:90: :0E0<584@ 5/0 122033145H6 12238<158=4 ;490:
0<58=4",=75/0B<5=C0F0:
5/0:062=49045/19 7830917:06/0G0<;58=4205858=45C=91A62:8=:7=:0G28:A=7 5/020:8=9=7 &A01:67:=?5/09150=75/01:>85:131C1:9 586136=<=45049095/15845/0?014C/830
5/0:062=49045 /19 846585;509 7:06/ 1:>85:158=4 2:=<00984@6 C/8</ /16 >004651A092;:6;1455==:90:6216609845/0C:85205858=4 = ! "%&!&&2:070::09>A5/0
" /0122033145136=<=4504965/155/01:>85:131C1:986 84 4;3385A 16 85 /16 >004 :0490:09 >A 6=30 1:>85:15=: 149 5/0:0 C16 4= <=46046;6 7=: 14 :>85:158=4 :8>;413 5= >0 <=46585;509 >A 1 6=30 1:>85:15=: <<=:984@ 5= 5/0
- 5 -
122033145
5/0 :062=49045 C16 :0I;8:09 5= 7830 14 12238<158=4 ;490: 0<58=4 =7 5/0 B <5 ;5
85 ;483150:133A <=46585;509 5/0 :>85:158=4 :8>;413
C/8</ 86 4=5 84 <=47=:?85A C85/ 5/0 B <5 149 C=;39 /1F0 4= 84/0:045E;:8698<58=45=?1D0141:>85:131C1:9
, 55/02:06045651@05/86=;:586<=4<0:409C85/5/0 38?8509 I;0658=4 C/05/0: 5/0 9031A =7 ""! 91A6 86 :0I;8:095=>0<=49=409
64=5091>=F0
5/0=43A0G2314158=42:=F8909>A5/0 122033145 86 5/15 85 /19 4=5 2:070::09 5/0 122013 1@18465 986?86613 =7 5/0 12238<158=4 ;490: 0<58=4 ", =7 5/0 B <51685>0380F095/155/0:062=49045/191>149=409856 <318? 149 5/0 1:>85:13 1C1:9 86 84 856 71F=;: /0 12238<158=4 78309 ;490: 0<58=4 =7 5/0 8?85158=4 <5 6515065/155/0122033145C166;>60I;0453A19F86095=7830 5/02:06045122013
- 6 -
* 586?150:8135=4=505/1584
5/0 ;2:0?0 =;:5 /19 0G2:066091F80C5/155/09031A8478384@14122013;490: 0<58=4")=7B<5<=;394=5>0<=49=409>0A=495/0 20:8=9=7"!91A6166582;31509842:=F86=5=0<58=4",=7 5/0B<5/06189F80CC166;>60I;0453A=F0::;309 >A5/0;2:0?0=;:58413150:90<868=484
! " !
# $% &'
& (
) ) & (
#*
+ , #
=C0F0:
5/0 ;2:0?0 =;:5 /19 136= ?190 =>60:F158=4 5= 5/0 0770<5 5/15 @8F04 5/0 30@863158F0 845045
5/0 0G2:0668=4 J6;778<8045 <1;60H C=;39 4=5 >0 031658< 04=;@/ 5= 1<<=??=9150 14 84=:984150 9031A 84 78384@ 5/0 122013 4;49;3A
38>0:13122:=1</864=5C1::145090<=46890:
85 122=6850 5= 605 =;5 5/0 7=33=C84@ 0G5:1<5 7:=? 5/0 6189 90<868=4(
- 7 -
! " # #
$ %& "#"
" "
" ' # '# (! #'
" ' ) # *+ &#! , + ! #
# - ! .&)! ##
/
0# # #
1
/
0# # #
"" ! 234 ' "#
'## # + * +# +" #
- ! # #, # "## ' #+ !&# + ' # * '##
"&' # ' &" " " #
0 " * #
" - ! "
" ! '&" 5 #) * #' # !! '
&"'
"
"'
# '# 3 * # ' " ' 3 (! #' '#, !! ' &"' *. ' #'# - *+
"
" & "
"
" " +""
" &# '# 3 * # '
$ '# (! #''#"" #+
" *. '
"# ' "" +"'
" - ""#
"&' #' &" 6! #"# '# -'###)
+ # #)
" &# '# 3 * #'
- 8 -
$ - ""# "&' # ' &" 6 '# # # '# (! # ' "
"' #&) + # "&" ##)&# *. ' # '# -
" &
$ &"#.! 7 &
8&#. *1.! 7 & 8&#. *3 94 "&# '# - '# 8&#. *( #5 !"'3
""2 9,93
", 8 !#) # ' # &# '# * ! #+ ! &
"
"&" '#" %& #' " $
: #! # # ' # "" # * #) '
" "&&" # * * &"
" ! $ : #! # ' ## * ! # # +* &#) # &"
; #"&" *+
: #!
# '#" %& #'
""
"&*" %& #+'&* "#) # $ <#) '" " #'
" *+ +
# &" # & ! #
# ' " !& # : #! # # 9 # '
" *+
: #! #
"#9&
"
"& ##) " "#
" * #)
"< " * '<
# : #! # #
: #! # # &# & * "
#
$ ##&#* "
##
$ "* "& # * #) ' *+ '
" # "&&"
##
$ ' !#)
"&'
"& #*
# ! # #
"& # &-
$ * # # + $ + &" )" # *
$ #* * &"
# * #) " # #
- 9 -
" # * " # !+
## "
=
" #* " #" '
*&# ''&
$ "
"# *
! ,!#"&*," '# '# $ '#'
"# * ! # ) #
'"&* !"
# ' # !&" * ! #
"# * ! $
'" " # '
" !#"
!# # &#
"&*," '#
'# !" +
"
7
7 & # ! # +
"
' ' #) #
"
"&&" * '! #
" "& #)
#.&"' * " " #) *. ' )" # '
" #" )
"
"' + * # ' ' )" #
$ &"
' # !# # *+= +
#) &# "&*," '# '# '#,,9
" * * "!"" # )&###
+ # '
"#)# ##) ""& ' #)
#
"#"&&"# #"= + #)
#7
7 & $ *
"##)"#'#"# #'
"##"&*," '#3 '# '
&*," '#3&" " ">
"&'' ""#
" #
"&&"
#+
" * # !# *+ '?@
$ " !# *+ '6 & ! #
'
"
# # +
$ "#" ) #)
" '
'# # # '#" 9,9 8&#. * $ # #'+ ' 993
" ! ' * ' #)" &# 8&#.
*( #5 !"'3"
! -!&! ! ##'
"
"## + +"
$
) #" # ' ,,3 *+
# * # '
"
"&&"
""!"" #3,,3
$
- 10 -
" * '! #
"
" # ' #) #+&
$ &" !# # *+ '* ' ! # #3,,3
$
" ! '& # * #
" ! # +
" *+ ,3,9 $ "&*" %& #' #)"* 5 #& & " #
$ ,3, 9"## "
"&*" %& #' #)"
&)
$ ""& '&#
* # #
6
) 45/02:06045<160C01:0;41>305=1<<0255/155/0 122033145 /16 605 =;5 14A <:098>30 0G2314158=4 7=: 5/0 84=:984150 9031A =7 ""! 91A6 <<=:984@3A
5/86 =;:5 :0E0<565/0<=450458=45/155/0122033145C162:0F04509>A 6;778<8045 <1;60 7:=? 78384@ 5/0 2:06045 122013 C85/84 5/0 6582;3150920:8=935/=;@/5/06189122013/164=5>004 50:?09161<=??0:<813122013
5/0;490:3A84@9862;5084 :0620<5=7C/8</5/01:>85:131C1:9
86:0490:09
6I;1:03A 71336 C85/84 5/0 6<=20 =7 <=??0:<813 9862;50 /86 86 >0<1;60 85 86 1 <=??0:<813 <=45:1<5 1C1:909 >A 5/0 122033145 2;:6;145 5= 50490: 84F8509 7=: 1 2:=E0<5 =7 =465:;<58=4 =7 ! % 3840 7=: 1 986514<0 =7 ,, D83=?050:6 7:=? 0@@841>;98/13; 38?856 5= ! 6;> 65158=4 0331:A =;5/ 7=: 0F1<;158=4 =7 2=C0: 7:=? - 11 -
84902049045 2=C0: 23145 =7 %6 =4 5=513 5;:4D0A >1686/061?086:030F145165/012201320:8=97=:78384@ 5/0 122013 84 :0620<5=7 1 <=??0:<8139862;50 86 *!91A6 1495/0:07=:0
5/09031A8478384@5/02:06045122013C=;39 >0"!91A6?=:05/145/09031A=7 ""!91A616<318?09 >A5/0122033145
/0 12238<158=4 7=: <=49=4158=4 =7 9031A 86 1<<=:984@3A:0E0<509=460I;0453A
5/012201386:0E0<509 16C033
- 0 <31:87A 5/15 5/86 =:90: C=;39 4=5 2:0<3;90 5/0 122033145 7:=? :18684@ 133 =>E0<58=46 5/15 85 86 =5/0:C860 045853095=841<<=:914<0C85/31C
5=:068655/00G0<;58=4 2:=<00984@6
12 '%( &
12 '( &
865=( 3=(- (