- 1 - ! "# ###$% "# # &#!! $ ! " ! #! ! # $ % Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! $ # ! ! ! & &' " $ " # ! " $ ! ( ! ! - 3 - % "" $ ) #! ! ! ! * + ,' --#% -- " --#% #% * # -" " *- +-#' - 4 - - +.' $ - - (& - -$- $ %%(%! % %( % $$ - $ / $0 / "" + / ""' 12 345672 89 :8352;<5 <25=5=83 9=>2? .@ 512 <25=5=8327=AA545=3B5145512?=72:5=8389512>24732?=3B>2 6?B2 =3 $ 8 %%(%! % 14A 385 .223 :8;<>=2? C=5112<74@27=3512C7=5<25=5=83=A4A63?27 D !"#$"#% &#% "'%() * + )),) &) - . ) /012 34 15 ) ) 6 7 - 5 - 8 9 7 3 7 * "'%:) : , ;& . < * - . ) /01 2 3 4 1 5 ) 7 2= 7 ) 77 7 7 * 7 >= 2= 77 7 7 ? @ 87?27 ?452? %( % 512 >24732? =3B>2 6?B245<4748951287?278.A27E2?4A63?27 @; * 7 +7 AB "7 C. . 7* 7 ) 7 +7 &AB "7 "+7 &ADB "7 )7 +7 &AB "7 . * 7 ) * 7 . 7E +;<14A=AA6<<>=2?' - 6 - 9527 14E=3B ?2:>472? 5145 512 <72>=;=347@ 385=9=:45=83 14A >4<A2? 512 >24732? =3B>2 6?B2 14A ?=72:52? 512 72A<83?235 F 5452 235=5@ 58 :83A=?27 512 72<72A23545=83A45332G672A43?=34::87?43:2C=51 >4C 4A 2G<2?=5=86A>@ 4A <8AA=.>2 .65 385 >4527 5143 A=G ;8351A978;512?4528972:2=<589:8<@8951287?27 # 1=A867583%#%( % #385=3B51234567289 512 :8352;<5 <78:22?=3BA C1272=3 512 >43? >8A27A 472 A22H=3B 987 :8;<>=43:2 C=51 512 ?=72:5=83 89 512 87?27 89 512 >24732? =3B>2 6?B2 43? 9675127 8.A27E=3B 5145 512 >43? >8A27A 472 =35272A52? =3 B255=3B 512 724A834.>2 :8;<23A45=83 43? 512 A:8<2 89 <78:22?=3BA =3 :=E=> :8352;<5 C86>? 2G523? 58 23A67=3B 5145 ?=72:5=83 =A :8;<>=2?C=5192>5=54<<78<7=4525145512<78:22?=3BA.2 7292772?58;2?=45=8343?5127249527585128H?4>451 3 <67A643:2 89 512 87?27 89 51=A 8675 ?452? %#%( % # 512 ;45527 14A .223 7292722? 987 ;2?=45=83 987A255>=3B512=AA6212.2329=:=47@4B722?58<4@512 - 7 - 4;8635 89 A %%%% <27 4:72 C1=:1 472 512 >43?A 65=>=I2? .@ 512 2<475;235 12 A4=? A255>2;235 72<875 ?452?# % #4>A89=3?A<>4:2=351272:87?A ! 863527 499=?4E=5 =A 9=>2? .@ 512 .2329=:=47@ F G2:65=E2 3B=3227 =387 77=B45=83 43? 7863? $4527 2E2>8<;235 =?47 A545=3B 5145 512 .2329=:=47@ 14A 4B722? =3 512 ;2?=45=83 <78:22?=3BA 58 <4@ 4 :8;<23A45=83 89 A %%%% <27 4:72 987 512 >43?A 65=>=I2?43?45<474#14AA5452?4A63?27 @ ) 4 0 " 47 $ 7 A"4$B) 2 ) F 7) 7 4 7 / ) "4$ C F 7 + #),#)&#)) - . )/02 )4 5 ) < 9 4 /7 # F 7 7 F " CGHC% 77 . "77) 7 '7 . 7 1% - 8 - + # ' 7; ; 7 ;))#% 0 + ,# ' 7 ; 7 ))#% 0 + &# ' 7 ; 7 ),)#% 0 + &# ' 7 ; 7 ))#% 0 ; + # ' 7, D; 7 ))#% 0 + # ' 7 D; 7 )D)#% 0 D + # * C F 7 7/ '7 C < % , + &# + '7 67 % / 7 70 7 . 7 F " CGHC% 77 .E - 9 - & 5 =A 9675127 A5452? 5145 ?67=3B 512 ;24A672;235 89 512 >43? 6A2? 987 :83A576:5=83 89 <27:8>45=83 543H 512 >43?A @ 8A C272 385 65=>=I2? 987 512 :83A576:5=83 89 <27:8>45=83 543H .@=38777=B45=832<475;23543?4AA6:1512A4>2?22?A 4723852G2:652?=372A<2:589512A4=?>43?AC1=:1472385 65=>=I2? 1=A 4>=B3A C=51 512 <74@27 8+' 89 512 C7=5 <25=5=83 43? <474 89 512 87?27 <4AA2? .@ 512 >24732? =3B>2 6?B2A5452? 251454A=5;4@4A=5:86>?.2A223978;512 :863527499=?4E=5=5=AA5452?514545> 858!512>43? >8A27A43?512.2329=:=47@14E24B722?58512<7=:289512 >43? 65=>=I2? .@ 512 .2329=:=47@ 3A8947 4A > 8& =3 72A<2:589@ 8 % =5=AA5452?5145512A4>2?22?A14>> .22G2:652?4AA8834AAH25:1=A9=34>=I2?372A<2:5 58@ 8 ( =5=AA<2:=9=:4>>@A5452?5145512A4>2?22? 14A385.2232G2:652?4A512>43?8C32774=A2?8.J2:5=83 3 >=B15 89 512 :863527 499=?4E=5 A<2:=9=:4>>@ A545=3B 5145 51272 =A 43 2G2:65=83 89 A4>2 ?22? =3 72A<2:5 89 512 >43? - 10 - 65=>=I2? =2 @ 8A ( % % A=56452? 45 4>4A43B= E=>>4B2 54>6H 6;34.4? ?=A57=:5 =?47 43? <4@;235 14A .223 ;4?2 58 512 >43? >8A27A 51786B1:12K62C1=:1=A385?=A<652?.@512:8;<>4=3435A 43? 4>A8 14E=3B ;4?2 :>247 5145 @ 8A A=56452?45 4>4A43B=E=>>4B214A385.22365=>=I2?43? 512 A4>2 ?22?A :43385 .2 2G2:652? 43? 4>A8 B=E23 43 63?2754H=3B5145=372A<2:589@ 8 % A4>2?22?A14>> .2 2G2:652? 4A A883 4A AH25:1 =A 9=34>=I2? C2 9=3? 5145 51272 =A :8;<>=43:2 89 512 87?27 <4AA2? .@ 512 >24732? =3B>2 6?B2 4A C2>> 4A 512 87?27 <4AA2? .@ 51=A 867583%#%( % # 3 >=B15 89 512 A4;2 512 :8352;<5 <78:22?=3BA 472 1272.@ '( )###$%* '( )#* $" =A5 8> 8!