- 1 - !!" !#" $ %"&"%% %'" ()*+, -) ""+. / !"" # "$ ! " """ " "%" & ! " # $ " "" % " '& ( )%"* " " " " " ""+ " % " " " " " "'&' ) , -" " " " " +% ) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " "" % " ( " . " ! # . "$ "/0 0123245 062624507 80259 6/0 :;;<30= 23 2>?<95259 6/0 @<=9>056 4A ;4512;6245 :5= 47=07 4A 305605;0 =:60= ?:330= 25 4 ) 45 6/0 A2B0 4A 6/0 B0:750= ==26245:B 212B <=90 :5= % :B:8<7:92 CA47 3/476 D6/0 "72:B 4<76EF ;4512;6259 /2> A47 6/0 4AA05;0 ?<523/:8B0 <5=07 0;6245 ) 4A 5=2:5 05:B 4=0 , CA47 3/476 D6/0 EF :5= 305605;25964<5=079432>?B02>?72345>056A47,>456/3 :5=64?:GA2504A3 H:5=64?:GA2504A3 A476/04AA05;0?<523/:8B0<5=07 0;6245&4A6/04647 0/2;B03;6'CA473/476D6/0;6EF I26/=0A:<B6 305605;03 I/2;/ I:3 ;45A27>0= 25 6/0 @<=9>056 =:60= '&'?:330=2572>25:B??0:B4 ) ,456/0 A2B04A6/0B0:750===26245:B23672;6:5= 0332453<=90 - 3 - :B:8<7:92 CA47 3/476 D6/0 %2736 ??0BB:60 4<76EF 8G =23>2332596/0:??0:B 6236/0;4560562454A6/0?7430;<62456/:66/0 :;;<30=802596/072=074A>4647;G;B080:7259094 ))/:=72==056/03:>045B:5=:B:8<7:92>:25 74:=25:7:3/:5=509B29056>:55076405=:5907/<>:5 B2A0:5==:3/0=2664450 <9<B:8:2:3:703<B64AI/2;/ 3/03<36:250=A:6:B25@<7203:5==20=256/0/43?26:B105 6/4<9//0;:<30=6/074:=67:AA2;:;;2=0566/0?062624507 /:354625A47>0=6/23A:;6646/050:7036?4B2;036:6245:5= 6/0708G ;4>>2660= 6/0 4AA05;0 ?<523/:8B0 <5=07 0;6245 &' )4A:5= 0;6245&4A;6 "/0 B0:750= :92367:60 644J ;4952K:5;0 4A 6/0 4AA05;03 :5= 3<>>450= 6/0 :;;<30= "/0 :;;<30= :??0:70=80A4706/0"72:B4<76:5=?B0:=0=5469<2B6G:5= ;B:2>0=64806720="/0?7430;<62450L:>250=(364& :5=946>:7J0=L364'253<??4764A263;456056245 "/0 :;;<30= =0520= :BB 6/0 25;72>25:6259 >:6072:B3 - 4 - :1:2B:8B0 45 70;47= 8<6 /:3 546 B0= :5G 012=05;0 25 3<??476 4A /23 =0A05;0 "/0 "72:B 4<76 :A607 6:J259 2564 ;4532=07:6245 :BB 6/030 >:6072:B3 45 70;47= ;:>0 64 6/0 ;45;B<3245 6/:6 6/0 :;;<30= /:3 ;4>>2660= 6/0 4AA05;03 ?<523/:8B0 <5=07 0;62453 &' :5= ) 4A :5= 0;6245 & 4A ;6 :5= 23 B2:8B0 A47 ;4512;6245 4I0107 26 /:3 4?250= 6/:6 0;6245 &' >07903 I26/ 0;6245 )4A :5= 6/070A470 54 30?:7:60305605;0 I:32>?430= ) 0259:9972010=8G 6/0 @<=9>0564A ;4512;6245 :5= 47=07 4A 305605;0 ?:330= 8G 6/0 "72:B 4<76 6/0 :;;<30=?70A0770=72>25:B??0:B4 ) ,80A4706/0 %2736 ??0BB:60 4<76 "/0 %2736 ??0BB:60 4<76 45 70 :??70;2:6245 4A 6/0 >:6072:B3 45 70;47= ;:>0 64 6/0 ;45;B<3245 6/:6 6/0 :;;<30= /:3 ;4>>2660= 6/0 4AA05;0 :5=/023B2:8B0A47;4512;6245:5=305605;0"/<326/:3 ;45A27>0=6/02>?<950=@<=9>0564A;4512;6245:5=47=07 4A305605;0?:330=8G6/0"72:B4<760259:9972010=8G 6/03:>06/0?0626245072380A4706/234<76 - 5 - 0:7= 72 :3:1:B259 :32 B0:750= ;4<530B A47 6/0 ?062624507 :5= 72 4?:B 723/5: :=:1 B0:750= 29/ 4<76 41075>056 B0:=07 A47 6/0 703?45=056 07<30=6/0>:6072:B34570;47=25;B<=2596/0"72:B4<76 :5=??0BB:604<7670;47=3 , 5 120I 4A 6/0 721:B ;4560562453 <790= 8G 6/0 B0:750=;4<530BA47846/6/0?:762036/0?42566/:6I4<B= :7230A47>G;4532=07:624523 !"!# G :53I07 64 6/0 :8410 ?4256 23 A476/0A4BB4I259 "" & 6236/0;4560562454A6/0?7430;<62456/:66/0 :;;<30= I:3 72=259 >4647;G;B0 80:7259 094 )) 25 : 7:3/ :5= 509B29056 >:5507 34 :3 64 05=:5907 - 6 - 6/0B2A04A6/0?0=03672:53 0=:3/0=2664 <9<B:8:2:5= ;:<30=A:6:B25@<7203:3:703<B64AI/2;/3/0=20= "4 ?7410 263 ;456056245 6/0 ?7430;<6245 0L:>250=(6/0=:<9/6074A6/0=0;0:30=I/4I:3:5 0G0I265033 64 6/0 25;2=056 :3 3/0 :;;4>?:520= 6/0 =0;0:30=:66/062>04A25;2=056"/0A273625A47>:6245:3 ?07L ;:>0 6480 A2B0= 45 6/0 8:3234A 36:60>0564A (70;47=0=256/0/43?26:BI/056/025@<70=I:36:J05 64 6/0 /43?26:B 2>>0=2:60BG :A607 6/0 25;2=056 "/23 I265033 A<BBG 3<??4760= 6/0 ;:30 4A 6/0 ?7430;<6245 :5= 6/070 23 546/259 64 =2380B2010 /07 1073245 L 23 6/0 25M<036 >:/:K:7 L& 23 6/0 ?436>4760> 70?476 I/2;/ =23;B430 6/:6 6/0 =0;0:30= /:3 3<36:250= A4<7 0L6075:B 25@<7203 25;B<=259 A7:;6<70 64 7283 :5= =0:6/ I:3 =<0 64 3/4;J :3 : 703<B6 4A 25@<7G 64 126:B 479:5 20 87:25 :5= B2107 ' (3 :5= :70 6/0 >:/:K:7 I26503303 I/4 /:10 546 3<??4760= 6/0 ;:30 4A 6/0 ?7430;<6245 (3) - 7 - :5= :70 6/0 A47>:B I26503303 (3, :5= & :70 6/0 5103629:6259 AA2;073 "/0 A2736 25A47>:6245 25M<036 >:/:K:7 6/0 ?436>4760> 70?476 :B459 I26/ 6/0 47:B 012=05;04A(?74106/0;4560562454A6/0?7430;<6245 105 6/4<9/ 0G0I265033 I:3 ;7433 0L:>250= :6 B0596/ 546/259 /:3 8005 0B2;260= A74> /07 64 =2380B2010 /07 1073245 "/070A470 :> 4A 6/0 4?25245 6/:6 6/0 ?7430;<6245 23 3<;;033A<B 25 ?741259 6/0 9<2B6 4A 6/0 :;;<30=A476/04AA05;03?<523/:8B0<5=07 0;6245 )4A :5= 0;6245&4A;6 /:1094506/74<9/6/02>?<950=@<=9>0564A ;4512;6245?:330=8G6/0"72:B4<76:5=;45A27>0=8G6/0 %2736 ??0BB:60 4<76 I/2;/ /:3 6:J05 2564 ;4532=07:6245 6/0 >:6072:B3 45 70;47= :5= /:3 :77210= :6 6/0 729/6 ;45;B<3245=4546A25=:5G70:3456425607A070I26/6/0 3:>0 66/2336:90B0:750=;4<530BA476/0?062624507 ?7:G3 A47 3/4I259 B05205;G 25 A:14<7 4A 6/0 ?062624507 :3 - 8 - 6/0 25;2=056 /:= 4;;<770= 45 ) :5= G0:73 /:10:B70:=GB:?30=4532=072596/233<8>233245>:=08G 6/0B0:750=;4<530BA476/0?062624507:5=:B34256/0A:;63 :5= ;27;<>36:5;03 4A 6/0 ;:30 =00> 26 :??74?72:60 64 >4=2AG 6/0 47=07 4A 305605;0 ?:330= 8G 6/0 "72:B 4<76 ;;47=259BG :53I07 6/0 :8410 ?4256 ?:76BG 25 6/0 :AA27>:6210:5=?74;00=64?:336/0A4BB4I259 ! #2$ "/00123245062624523 #22$ "/0 2>?<950= @<=9>056 4A ;4512;6245 =:60= ?:330= 25 4 ) 8G 6/0 ==26245:B 212B <=90 :5= % :B:8<7:92 I/2;/ 23 ;45A27>0= 8G 6/0 ==26245:B 23672;6 :5= 0332453 <=90 :B:8<7:922572>25:B??0:B4 ) ,8G @<=9>056 =:60= '&' ;4512;6259 6/0 :;;<30= A47 6/0 4AA05;0 ?<523/:8B0 <5=07 0;6245 )4A:5= 0;6245&4A ;623/0708G - 9 - #222$ "/0 47=07 4A 305605;0 ?:330= 8G 6/0 "72:B 4<7623>4=2A20=:3<5=07 #:$ "/0 ?062624507 23 305605;0= 64 <5=0794 32>?B0 2>?72345>056 A47 : ?0724= 4A 450 >456/ :5= 64 ?:G : A2504A3 :5=25=0A:<B664 ?:G A250 64 <5=0794 32>?B0 2>?72345>056A47:?0724=4A&=:G3 A47 6/0 4AA05;0 ?<523/:8B0 <5=07 0;6245 )4A #8$ "/047=074A305605;0?:330=8G6/0 "72:B4<76A476/04AA05;0?<523/:8B0 <5=07 0;6245 & 4A ;6 23 /0708G;45A27>0= #;$ "/0 ?062624507 23 05626B0= A47 6/0 8050A26 4A 306 4AA :3 ?7412=0= <5=07 0;6245)4A7 - 10 - #=$ "/0 3<836:56210 305605;0 3/:BB 7<5 ;45;<77056BG 092367G 64 305= 8:;J 6/0 "72:B 4<76 :5= ??0BB:60 4<76 70;47=3 :B459 I26/ 6/0 ;4?G 4A 6/23 @<=9>056 A47 25A47>:6245:5=500=A<B:;6245 "0, )%%+ &! ( 2364 B4 "