- 1 - ! "#$## # % &%'() &%(( * ! " #$ % & ' ' ! & ( $ ) '* Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !( ) $ ( !( * !+!(!( () " #$* & , & ()% * & ) & (!() * -+.(!( ' ' & && !)#%+#(%#/%)#% & (!()& ' & & $ $*& * & '* * 0*$** # 0*$**% 12 324545-627 82569 /::;<2= - 56 75>2 -+.(!( -? 2@ -@6 -A5:2 4/45-6 5=/7 5< 82?-72 - 3 - 415< -;74 <22B569 97/64 -? 8/5A ;6=27 2:45-6 ) -? 1/7/45C/ /9/75B ;7/B<1/ /6154/ (!() D?-7 <1-74 EFG 7295<4272= ?-7 412 -??26:2< 3;65<1/8A2 ;6=27 2:45-6< !)#% +#(%#/% )#% -? 1/7/45C/ C/C/ /6154/(!()#?-7<1-74EF%6-@326=569-6412?5A2-? 412 A2/762= ==545-6/A 265-7 5H5A $;=92 /6= $*& -;745=/7 ( 12 ?/:4< -? 412 :/<2 56 8752? /72 41/4 75>2 -+.(!(-?2@-@6-A5:24/45-65=/7:/>24-82 7295<4272= -64128/<5<-? 412 ?57<4 56?-7>/45-6 A-=92= 8C 41256?-7>/646H2<459/45-6@/<;6=274/B26/6=:1/792 <1224 :/>2 4- 82 ?5A2= /9/56<4 /::;<2= -< 4- . 24545-627 82569 /::;<2= - @/< /3372126=2= -6 !! (!(/6=<56:24126125<56I;=5:5/A:;<4-=C ) 2/7= 75 /6I/C /45A A2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 412 324545-627/::;<2= 75 $/>/=/7 1/1/8;==56 591 -;74-H276>264A2/=27?-772<3-6=264-4/42/6= - 4 - 75 /=A--7 /4C/6/7/C/6/:1/7C/ A2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 72<3-6=264-<(/6=)27;<2=412>/4275/A<-672:-7= 6 H52@ -? 412 75H/A :-642645-6< ;792= 8C 412 A2/762=:-;6<2A?-74123/7452<4123-56441/4@-;A=/75<2 ?-7>C:-6<5=27/45-65< *C /6<@27 4- 412 /8-H2 3-564 5< 56 412 E29/45H2F?-7412?-AA-@569 + 2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 412 324545-627 :-6426=2= 41/4 <56:2 412 56H2<459/45-6 5< /A72/=C :->3A242= /6= :1/792<12241/<8226?5A2==242645-6-?412324545-62756 :;<4-=C 5< 6-4 72J;572= 2 /A<- :-6426=< 41/4 <5>5A/7 /AA29/45-6<1/H28226>/=2/9/56<4/::;<2=-<+/6= .::;<2=- 5</A72/=C97/642=/645:53/4-7C8/5A /6= - 5 - /::;<2= -<+ /6= . /72 26A/792= -6 729;A/7 8/5A /< 327 412 -7=27 3/<<2= 8C :--7=56/42 26:1 -? 415< -;74 1272?-722H26-64123756:53A2-?3/754C415<324545-6275< 26454A2=4-8272A2/<2=-68/5A . 12 :-642645-6 -? 412 A2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 412 324545-627 5< -33-<2= 8C 412 A2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 72<3-6=264 -<( /6= ) :-6426=569 41/4 412 324545-627 /77/5962=/</::;<2=- 56412372<264:/<25<412>/56 /::;<2= 56 75>2 -!(!( -? $/6@/= -A5:2 4/45-6 7295<4272=?-7412-??26:2;6=27412 :4::;<2= - 5< :-/::;<2= 56 412 </5= :/<2 12 :1/792<1224 ?5A2=8C4126H2<459/4569 ??5:27=5<:A-<2<41/4412>-45H2 -?412/::;<2=-</6= ?-7:->>544569412-??26:25< 41/4'()K5==/33/@/<82569/<<5<42=8C412=2:2/<2= /5I56/41 56 37-<2:;4569 412 :/<2 /9/56<4 /::;<2= -< /6= /6=41272?-72/::;<2=-</6= 12725641-;914 54 ?54 4- ?565<1 15> -?? 6 3;7<;/6:2 -? 412 </>2 412<2 /::;<2=1/H2:-6<3572=4-924127/6=:/;<2=412=2/41-? 412=2:2/<2= - 6 - 2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 72<3-6=264 -<( /6= ) /A<-<;8>54<41/45675>2-!(!( 6-@326=569?-7 475/A82?-7241232:5/A-;74412H5:45>1/</A72/=C8226 2L/>562= 56 :152? 6 <3542 -? 4/B569 ! K /=I-;76>264< A2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 412 324545-627 82?-72 41275/A-;741/=6-4:7-<<2L/>562=412H5:45>?-7412 72/<-6< 82<4 B6-@ 4- 15> 2 /A<- <;8>54< 41/4 56 412 </5= :/<2 412 324545-627 @/< 26A/792= -6 8/5A <;8I2:44-:-6=545-6<6<3542-?41/4412372<264-??26:2 5< :->>5442= 412728C 412 324545-627 1/< H5-A/42= 412 :-6=545-6< 5>3-<2= 8C 412 -;74 @15A2 97/64569 8/5A /6= 126:2125<6-426454A2=?-797/64-?8/5A 6327;</A-?412>/4275/A<-672:-7=545<<226 41/4412324545-62782569/::;<2=- :-6<3572=@541412 -4127 /::;<2= ?-7 :->>5<<5-6 -? 412 -??26:2 56 J;2<45-6 @15:15<3;65<1/8A2254127@541=2/41-75>375<-6>264?-7 A5?2 ! < 327 412 :1/792<1224 ?5A2= 8C 412 6H2<459/4569 ??5:27412>-45H2?-7:/;<569=2/41-?412 - 7 - =2:2/<2=/5I56/415<41/4121/=/<<5<42=-625==/33/ @1-5<412>/56@5462<<:542=/<'()56412</5= :/<241/45<326=569/9/56<4412372<264/::;<2=45<6-4 56 =5<3;42 41/4 412 H5:45> 56 412 </5= :/<2 5< /A72/=C 2L/>562=56:152?8;41/<6-48226:7-<<2L/>56569<56:2 A-69 4 5< 412 :-642645-6 -? 412 A2/762= :-;6<2A ?-7 412 324545-62741/4412324545-6271272565</A<-/6/::;<2=56 75>2 -+((!( -? $/6/@/= -A5:2 4/45-6 5=/7 =5<475:4 ?-7 412 -??26:2 3;65<1/8A2 ;6=27 2:45-6 )( -? 6=5/626/A -=2 ? /AA412<2:-642645-6<4/B268C 412 A2/762=:-;6<2A?-7412324545-627/72:-6<5=272=545<<226 41/4 412 324545-627 5< 1/H569 :75>56/A /642:2=264< ?427 412324545-627@/<26A/792=-68/5A5675>2-!(!( 7295<4272=?-7:->>544569412-??26:2;6=2741237-H5<5-6< -? 412 :4 412 372<264 :/<2 5< 7295<4272= /9/56<4 15>6=27<;:1:57:;><4/6:2<12:-;A=6-48226A/792= -6 8/5A56 412372<264:/<24 5<4- 826-45:2=41/4 412 >-45H2?-7:->>5<<5-6-?412-??26:25<41/4412=2:2/<2= 5</<<5<4569-62-?41237-<2:;45-6@5462<<2<56412 - 8 - :/<2 /6= 41272?-72 12 @/<2A5>56/42= ?-7 <;33-74569 412 37-<2:;45-6 /6= 54< @5462<<2< ? /AA 412<2 ?/:4< /6= :57:;><4/6:2< /72 4/B26 564- :-6<5=27/45-6 /> -? 412 -3565-641/4545<6-4</?24-26A/792412324545-627-68/5A /4415<<4/92::-7=569AC/6<@27412/8-H23-56456412 /6=37-:22=4-3/<<412?-AA-@569 12:75>56/A324545-65< +) %##( $ 5<4-A-