Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 58181 (KAR)

JYOTHI v. ANIL KUMAR AND ANR

MFA/202585/2024 · 2025-09-22

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ % % "" &%' ( !"!#$ % && ' ' ( &)( #$" & !"!)*( "+,,,* # & # # $****( Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & - ' & ,*#!!,$!***** ' *(.*.#*#(*.*$.#*## %& & ' #/ ' *)*##*#! ( & ((' & & (*##*#) & ' ')##*## && ' 0 ' ' $ 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?< 366@2?A 6?14?=6>6?< B8 =B>56?34<2B? 43 4C4D969 2? <16 EF9A>6?< 4?9 4C4D9 94<69 (*##*#) 2? ' B)##*## :; <16 992<2B?47 6?2BD 2G27 F9A6 4?9 992<2B?47 294D # 4=<376492?A<B8276=742>56<2<2B?4D643F?96D/ - 3 - 14< B? **!#*## <16 =742>4?< C43 5DB=6692?A 4352772B?D296D47B?AC2<116D:DB<16DB?>B<BD=;=768DB> 12@56<<BFDF?4?4@1B352<47 <4:BF<((*4>C16? <16;D64=16974G4?;4=B?G6?<2B?14774<<14<<2>6D296DB8 <16>B<BD=;=7626D635B?96?<B(9DBG6123>B<BD=;=76 2? 12A1 35669 4?9 16 3F996?7; 4557269 :D64@3 16 =742>4?< :62?A 52772B? D296D 8677 B? DB49 4?9 3F3<42?69 AD26GBF32?EFD26316<BB@<D64<>6?<2?<161B352<474?9 82769 =742> 56<2<2B? 16 <D2:F?47 143 43363369 <16 =B>56?34<2B? 4?9 543369 4C4D9 16 =742>4?< 143 82769 <123455647366@2?A6?14?=6>6?<B8=B>56?34<2B? 64D9 764D?69 =BF?367 8BD <16 4556774?< =742>4?< 4?9 764D?69 =BF?367 8BD D635B?96?< B# ?3FD4?=6B>54?; ) 64D?69 =BF?367 8BD <16 4556774?< =742>4?< CBF79 =B?<6?9 <14< <16 4==296?< 143 <4@6? 574=6 2? <16 ;64D#*##4?94356D=14D<5D654D69:;<166A476DG2=63 F<1BD2<; 8BD 36<<76>6?< B8 9235F<63 2? B@. 49474<1 <16 ?B<2B?47 2?=B>6 8BD <16 ;64D #*## 23 ()!*. 4?9 <16 - 4 - D2:F?47 143 6DD69 2? <4@2?A ?B<2B?47 2?=B>6 4< 3(#***.169B=<BD &#C1B143233F699234:272<; =6D<282=4<6 H& 143 3<4<69 <14< <16 =742>4?< 23 14G2?A #*I 9234:272<; 4?9 6G6? <1BFA1 <16 <D2:F?47 143 =B?3296D69<169234:272<;4<#*I4<<2>6B8=47=F74<2?A7B33 B8 2?=B>6 143 D69F=69 <B I C2<1BF< 4332A?2?A 4?; D643B?16=742>4?<143:66?49>2<<692?<161B352<478BD * 94;3 4?9 <16D68BD6 <16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<769 <B =B?G6;4?=6 4<<6?94?< 8BB9 4?9 ?BFD231>6?< =14DA63 16<D2:F?471434C4D9697B33B82?=B>69FD2?A<167429F5 56D2B98BD<CB>B?<1316=742>4?<236?<2<769<B7B33B8 2?=B>69FD2?A742956D2B98BD<1D66>B?<134<3()!*. 56D >B?<1 16 =742>4?< 143 3F3<42?69 8D4=<FD6 B8 D2A1< 31BF796D EB2?< 4?9 8D4=<FD6 B8 ?6=@ B8 D2A1< 1F>BDBF3 B?3296D2?A <16 34>6 316 23 6?<2<769 <B 12A16D =B>56?34<2B? F?96D <16 1649 B8 542? 4?9 3F886D2?A 4?9 7B33 B8 4>6?2<263 2<1 <1636 16 5D4;3 <B 477BC <16 455647 - 5 - ! 64D?69 =BF?367 8BD D635B?96?< B# CBF79 =B?<6?9 <14< <16 D2:F?47 143 D2A1<7; <4@6? 9234:272<; 4?9 =B>56?34<2B? 4C4D969 F?96D 477 16493 4D6 EF3< 4?9 5DB56D $ 4G2?A 164D9 764D?69 =BF?3673 <123 BFD< 143 56DF369 2>5FA?69 EF9A>6?< 4?9 B<16D >4<6D2473 574=69 B?D6=BD9 16=742>4?<C434A69!;64D343B?<1694<6 B84==296?<26**!#*##164A6B8<16=742>4?<4?9 724:272<; B8 <16 ?3FD4?=6 B>54?; 4D6 ?B< 2? 9235F<6 3 56D =14D< 5D654D69 :; <16 6A47 6DG2=63 F<1BD2<; 8BD 36<<76>6?<B89235F<632?B@. 4947<1<16?B<2B?472?=B>6 8BD <16 ;64D #*## 23 3()!*. B?3296D2?A <16 34>6 <16 D2:F?47 143 6DD69 2? <4@2?A <16 ?B<2B?47 2?=B>6 4< 3(#***.16<D2:F?47143D2A1<7;4557269>F7<25726D($ =B?3296D2?A <16 4A6 B8 <16 =742>4?< 26 ! ;64D3 16 9B=<BD &#C1B1436H4>2?69<16=742>4?<143233F69 9234:272<; =6D<282=4<6 H& 3<4<2?A <14< <16 =742>4?< 23 14G2?A #*I 9234:272<; G6? <1BFA1 <16 D2:F?47 143 - 6 - =B?3296D699234:272<;4<#*I4<<2>6B8=47=F74<2?A7B33B8 2?=B>6 143 ?B< 4332A?69 4?; D643B? 4?9 <4@6? 9234:272<; 4< I B?3296D2?A <16 34>6 <16 9234:272<; 143 <B :6 <4@6?4<#*I ?G26CB8<164:BG6=742>4?<236?<2<769<B 7B33B82?=B>643F?96D/ 3()!*.H(#H($H#*IJ3!$$)**. " B?3296D2?A<CB>4EBD8D4=<FD6<16=742>4?<23 6?<2<769 8BD =B>56?34<2B? F?96D <16 16493 B8 542? 4?9 3F886D2?A 2? 3F> B8 3$****. 43 4A42?3< 3!****. 4?9 7B33 B8 4>6?2<263 2? 3F> B8 3!****. 43 4A42?3< 3#****.434C4D969:;<16D2:F?4716=742>4?<C43 49>2<<692?<161B352<478BD*94;34?9<16D68BD631623 6?<2<769<B=B?G6;4?=64<<6?94?<8BB94?9?BFD231>6?< =14DA63 2? 3F> B8 3***. 43 4A42?3< 3(****. 43 4C4D969:;<16D2:F?4716<D2:F?47143D2A1<7;4C4D969 =B>56?34<2B? 8BD >692=47 6H56?363 2? 3F> B8 3(*#"(.16<D2:F?471434C4D969=B>56?34<2B?8BD 7B33 B8 2?=B>6 9FD2?A <16 7429 F5 56D2B9 2? 3F> B8 3#)***. B?3296D2?A <CB 8D4=<FD63 3F3<42?69 :; <16 - 7 - =742>4?<4?9D63<49G2369316236?<2<769<B7B33B82?=B>6 9FD2?A <16 7429 F5 56D2B9 2? 3F> B8 3()#!*. H J 3))#!* ? G26C B8 <16 4:BG6 <16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<769 <B <B<47 =B>56?34<2B?43F?96D/ ) *+,- ./*0-+120 +3+4,*,56 172-841 ( B33B88F<FD62?=B>6 3!$$)**. # BC4D93542?4?93F886D2?A 3$****. 692=476H56?363 3(*#"(. ) B33B82?=B>69FD2?A7429F5 56D2B9 3))#!*. ! <<6?94?<B?G6;4?=6BB9 4?9?BFD231>6?<=14DA63 3***. $ B33B84>6?2<263 3!****. 1+) -9:9; , 16=742>4?<236?<2<769<B<B<47=B>56?34<2B?B8 3"),(. 43 4A42?3< 3#!$(. 4C4D969 :; <16 D2:F?47C2<12?<6D63<4<<16D4<6B8$I56D4??F> (* ?G26CB8<164:BG6<168B77BC2?A 2 1645564723 - 8 - 22 16 =742>4?< 23 6?<2<76 <B <B<47 =B>56?34<2B? B8 3"),(. 43 4A42?3< 3#!$(. 4C4D969 :; <16D2:F?47C2<12?<6D63<4<<16D4<6 B8 $I 56D 4??F> 8DB> <16 94<6 B8 56<2<2B?<277D6472K4<2B?/ 222 635B?96?< B# . ?3FD4?=6 =B>54?; 31477 965B32< <16 3429 4C4D94>BF?<C2<12?<6D63<C2<12?4 56D2B9B862A1<C66@38DB><12394; 84272?A C12=1 2< 23 724:76 <B 54; 2?<6D63< 4< <16 D4<6 B8 ,I 56D 4??F>/ 2G 16 BD96D B8 965B32< 4?9 D676436 543369 :; <16 <D2:F?47 D6>42? F?47<6D69 ,; & % %' $ & 23<B(7B#"