- 1 - ! "!#$ %#!&!&"## '!( ! " # $% % ! & " # $% & ! ' ( ' ' ' Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ' )%* +,-+.//0 %-1-2-+-3 ,//-4,56-77- 89:51.4 ;9+ <=. 7.<,<,95.+1 -5/ +,-44,>-+3:5 -=:>-+ ;9+ <=. +.1795/.5<=-?.-77.-+./,57.+195 =.8-7<,95./!+,< .<,<,95,1;,4./1..>,56-!+,<9; .+<,9+-+,<9@:-1=<=.9+/.+/-<./AABA7-11./C0<=. +.1795/.5<,5977.-4A"?,/.55.D:+.",5 19;-+-1/.4.<,56<=.5-E.9;7.<,<,95.+9;+9E<=. 19; 09F9; ,5/=-5:+-5/;:+<=.+9+/.+<9.5<.+<=.5-E. 9;7.<,<,95.+9,5<=. 9;<=.1-,/1:+?.05:EC.+<9-5 .D<.5<9;A8+.B:5<-1 B =.1=9+<;-8<1-+.<=.1. <,11-,/<=-<C-1./95-89E74-,5<<=-<-77.-+1<9=-?. C..5 E-/. <9 <=. +,?-<. .8+.<-+0 9; .?.5:. ,5,1<.+ ,5 A"<=.11,1<-5<9EE,11,95.+<+.-<./<=.89E74-,5<-1 -5 -77.-4 95. :5/.+ .8<,95 B($& 9; <=. -+5-<->- -5/ .?.5:. 8< E->,56 7.<,<,95.+1 -5/ -1 - 7-+<0 <9 <=. - 3 - -77.-4-49562,<=9<=.+1-5/7-11./<=.9+/.+95AABA ;9+ 89++.8<,95 9; 94:E5 9G ,5 +.17.8< 9; 4-5/ ,5 09F<9-5.D<.5<9;8+.B:5<-166+,.?./C0 <=.9+/.+9;<=.11,1<-5<9EE,11,95.+<=.7.<,<,95.+1-4956 2,<= 9<=.+1 ;,4./ .?,1,95 .<,<,95 C.;9+. <=. .7:<0 9EE,11,95.+ =. .7:<0 9EE,11,95.+ ?,/. 9+/.+ /-<./ (AA /,1E,11./ <=. .?,1,95 .<,<,95 95<.5/,56 <=-< <=.9+/.+9;11,1<-5<9EE,11,95.+,12,<=9:<3:+,1/,8<,95<=. 7.<,<,95.+1-+.C.;9+.<=,19:+< 9:51.4 ;9+ <=. +.17.8<,?. 7-+<,.1 :+6./ 1.?.+-4 895<.5<,951.-+/<=.-+6:E.5<1-5/7.+:1./<=.!+,<7-7.+1 2,<=8-+. =.9+/.+7-11./C0<=.11,1<-5<9EE,11,95.+,1 ;:+5,1=./-49562,<=<=.!+,< .<,<,95-5/<=.1-E.,1E-+>./ -155.D:+."7.+:1-49;<=.7+.-EC4.,5<=.9+/.+84.-+40 /.7,8<1 <=-< <->,56 59<. 9; <=. 89E74-,5< E-/. <9 <=. +,?-<. .8+.<-+0 .?.5:. ,5,1<.+ ,5 A" <=. 11,1<-5< 9EE,11,95.+ +.6,1<.+./ <=. -77.-4 =,1 ,1 :51:1<-,5-C4. ,5 4-2=.+.-195,1-77-+.5<=.-77.-4:5/.+ .8<,95B($& 9; <=. 8< ,1 E-,5<-,5-C4. 9540 -1 -6-,51< <=. E:<-<,95 .5<+0 - 4 - E-/.C0<=.-=1,4/-+.58.<+.-<,56<=.89E74-,5<E-/.<9 <=. +,?-<. .8+.<-+0 9; .?.5:. ,5,1<.+ -5/ +.6,1<.+,56 <=. 1-E.-1-5-77.-4-5/7-11,56<=.9+/.+<=.+.95,1:5<.5-C4. =.9+/.+7-11./C0<=.11,1<-5<9EE,11,95.+,14,-C4.<9C. 1.<"-1,/.889+/,5640,<,11.<"-1,/. ( =. !+,< 9; .+<,9+-+, ,1 9+/.+./ =. 9+/.+ /-<./ AABA 7-11./ C0 <=. 11,1<-5< 9EE,11,95.+ ,5 9 77.-4A" ?,/. 55.D:+." ,1 @:-1=./ 951.@:.5<40<=.9+/.+7-11./C0<=..7:<09EE,11,95.+,1 -419 @:-1=./ -5/-E:1 ,1 9+/.+./ /,+.8<,56 <=. -:<=9+,<0 8958.+5./<9+.1<9+.<=.5-E.9;7.<,<,95.+9,5<=..89+/ 9;+,6=<1 .1:4<-5<40<=.!+,< .<,<,95,1 %.8-:1.9;/,1791-49;!+,< .<,<,957.5/,56,5<.+498:<9+0 -774,8-<,95 ,; -50 -+. /,1791./ 9; -5/ ,5<.+,E /,+.8<,95 ,; -50 1<-5/1/,18=-+6./ !)* '&"##( & ,1<9 49