- 1 - !" #$% $ "" & ! "# $% ! "# & $% ! "# ' $% ! "# ( ! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) *+%%% *,'% & ) ! *,'% ' -" " , "- *,'% " " '. "- *,'% $ * " *,'% . '. * " *,'% , - 3 - * " *,'% ( )/ )' / &$* %&% . , )) ! ) %% ) ) +%, 0 )) $%%% ) ) &%% %% +++ ) ) ! ) )) ) ) " ) 0 1 - 4 - % $ 1 ! 234 456789 :;;5:< 34 :=3438> ?=7@ A25 BC9>@58A :89 956=5538 7+++78A25?3<57?=3863;:<3D3< C9>5 39:=:89:<47BC9>@58A:89956=5538 7$%%%78A25 ?3<57?=3863;:<5837=3D3< C9>5 39:= 25 4C3A 34 934@34459 47 :<47 A25 :;;5:< 25 ;<:38A3??4:=538456789:;;5:< & <:38A3??4 2:D5 ?3<59 A25 4C3A 38 : =5;=5458A:A3D5 6:;:63AEFE38D7G38>A25;=7D3437847?=95=C<5,7?7957? 3D3<=7659C=5+,%?7=427=AHA25795I! ' 25;<:38A3??46<:3@A2:AA254C3A;=7;5=A354:=5A25 ;CF<36 ;=7;5=A354 :89 A25E 455G 38BC86A378 :>:384A A25 95?589:8A4 A7 =54A=:38 A25@ ?=7@ 38A5=?5=38> 38 A25 ;5:65?C< ;744544378:8958B7E@58A7?A254C3A;=7;5=A354FEA25;CF<36 25=5 :=5 A2=55 ;=7;5=A354 9546=3F59 38 A25 46259C<5 8:@5<E E 7&% @5:4C=38> %' :6=54 & >C8A:4 E 7@5:4C=38>%&:6=54'>C8A:4:89A25A23=9;=7;5=AE 34 <:89 F5:=38> E 7 @5:4C=38> % :6=54 %, >C8A:4 :<< 43AC:A5938:<:9G5=3 D3<<:>5 39:=A:<CG - 5 - $ 5?589:8A4 7$A7+=5@:38595J;:=A5F5?7=5A25 A=3:<7C=A . 25 4C3A ;=7;5=AE F5:=38> E 7 4A:894 38 A25 8:@5 7? 95?589:8A4 7+ :89 % 25 4C3A ;=7;5=AE F5:=38> E 74A:89438A258:@57?95?589:8A4 7$A7,254C3A ;=7;5=AE F5:=38> E 7&% @5:4C=38> %' :6=54 & >C8A:4 4A:89438A258:@57?95?589:8A4 7':89 , 25 A=3:< 7C=A 934@34459 A25 4C3A 78 A25 ;=5@345 A2:AA25=53487;:;5=;CF<36:A378A:G58FEA25;<:38A3??4954;3A5 :87=95=;:445978:8:;;<36:A378C895==95=C<5,7?A25 795 8 :993A378 A7 A2:A A25 A=3:< 7C=A 2:4 6784395=59 A25 6:4578@5=3A:892:4934@34459A254C3A78A25;=5@345A2:A A25;<:38A3??4:=5C8:F<5A754A:F<342A2:AA254C3A;=7;5=A354:=5 A25;=7;5=A35438K2362A25;CF<362:D5=3>2A + 25 ?3=4A :;;5<<:A5 7C=A 2:4 :>=559 A25 ?38938> 7? A25A=3:<7C=A:892:4934@34459A25:;;5:< % 25?7<<7K38>4CF4A:8A3:<LC54A37847?<:K:=345?7= 6784395=:A3787?A234:;;5:< 3! 025A25=A25A=3:<7C=A:89A25?3=4A:;;5<<:A5 7C=AK5=5BC4A3?35938934@34438>A254C3A78 - 6 - A25;=5@345A2:AA25;:;5=;CF<36:A3783487A A:G58 ;C=4C:8A A7 :8 7=95= 78 :;;<36:A378 ?3<59C895==95=C<5,7?A25795M 33! 025A25=A25:;;5<<:8A454A:F<342A2:AA254C3A ;=7;5=A354 :=5 A25 7D5=8@58A ;=7;5=A354 @5:8A?7=;CF<36C45M 5:=859 67C845< ?7= A25 ;<:38A3??4:;;5<<:8A4 K7C<9 4CF@3A A2:A A25 ;<:38A3??4 :=5 38A5=54A59 38 ;=7456CA38> A25 ;=7655938> 78<E 38 =54;56A 7? AK7 A5@;<54 8:@5<E 2:>E:D:8A23 5D:<:E::89 :>:8:A2 5D:<:E:<76:A5938A25 4C3A;=7;5=A354 5:=859 67C845< ?7= A25 =54;78958A4 7' :89 K7C<94CF@3AA2:A:?7=5@58A37859AK7A5@;<54:=587A<76:A59 38 E 7&% K2362 34 =5>=:8A59 A7 =54;78958A4 7' :89 & 5:=859 67C845< ?7= A25 ;<:38A3??4:;;5<<:8A4 K7C<9 4CF@3A A2:A A25 :?7=5@58A37859 AK7 A5@;<54 :=5 <76:A59 38 E 7&%4:=5;<EA25<5:=85967C845<?7=A25=54;78958A4 7':89K7C<94CF@3AA2:AA2745A5@;<54@:EF5<76:A5938 E 74:89 ' 8A2:A5D58AA254CFB56A@:AA5=7?A25934;CA5>5A4 =59C659A7<5445=5JA58A47?87KA254C3A34?3<5938=54;56A 7? A2=55 ;=7;5=A354 8:@5<E E 74 :89 &% 25 <:89 - 7 - E 7@5:4C=54%:6=54%,>C8A:4E 7@5:4C=54%& :6=54'>C8A:4:89E 7&%@5:4C=54%':6=54&>C8A:4 5:=859 67C845< ?7= A25 :;;5<<:8A4 78 384A=C6A3784 K7C<9 4CF@3A A2:A A25 5JA58A 7? <:89 67D5=59 FE A25 A5@;<54 K7C<967D5=:;;=7J3@:A5<E2:<?:6=5 $ 895= A2545 63=6C@4A:8654 :<47 87A3638> A25 ?:6A A2:AA25=5K:487;CF<36:A3787?87A365:4=5LC3=59C895==95= C<5 , 7? A25 795 A25 ;<:38A3??4 :=5 ;5=@3AA59 A7 K3A29=:K A25 4C3A :89 ;5=@3AA59 A7 ?3<5 : ?=542 4C3A 38 =54;56A 7? AK7 A5@;<54=5?5==59A7:F7D5 . 234 7C=A 2:4 87A >3D58 :8E 7;38378 :4 A7 A25 <76:A378 7? A25 A5@;<54 =5?5==59 A7 :F7D5 K3A2 =5?5=5865 A7 4C=D5E8C@F5=254:@542:<<F59563959:?A5=4C=D5E38>A25 ;=7;5=AE38K2362A25:?7=5@58A37859A5@;<54:=5<76:A59 , 86:45A25;<:38A3??4?3<5:8:;;<36:A378F5?7=5?3<38> ?=5424C3A!F5?7=5A25BC=34936A378:<C=D5E7=?7=4C=D5E7?A25 ;=7;5=A354 A7 3958A3?E A25 4C=D5E 8C@F5= 38 K2362 A25 :?7=5@58A37859 AK7 A5@;<54 :=5 <76:A59 A25 67865=859 C=D5E7=42:<<4C=D5EA25;=7;5=AE:4678A5@;<:A59C895=<:K K3A29C587A365A7A25:9B:658A7K85=4:8942:<<?C=8342=5;7=A - 8 - A7 A25 ;<:38A3??4 K3A238 ?7C= @78A24 ?=7@ A25 9:A5 7? A25 :;;<36:A378?7=4C=D5E + 38654CF@34437834@:95A2:AA25;<:38A3??4K3<<F5 ?3<38>:?=5424C3A38=54;56A7?AK7A5@;<54=5?5==59A7:F7D5FE K3A29=:K38>A254C3A38 7+++78A25?3<57?=3863;:< 3D3< C9>5 39:= A25 4CF4A:8A3:< LC54A3784 7? <:K 97 87A 4C=D3D5?7=6784395=:A378 % 25;<:38A3??4I4C3A38 7+++78A25?3<57? =3863;:< 3D3< C9>5 39:= 34 A=5:A59 :4 K3A29=:K8 K3A2 : <3F5=AEA7?3<5:?=5424C3A38=54;56A7?AK7A5@;<54=5?5==59A7 :F7D5 86:45?=5424C3A34?3<5938=54;56A7?AK7A5@;<54 =5?5==59 A7 :F7D5 4:@5 42:<< F5 9563959 38 :667=9:865 K3A2 <:K 03A2A25457F45=D:A3784A25:?7=5@58A37859:;;5:< 34934;74597? '( )$ * % 34A 7< 7',