- 1 - !"!# $%" % &% ' ! " # $ % ! &&'% # # # ( ) ! & ' ! "*+ $ Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! & ) & & ! $ & , ! ! % ! # - $ ! % # ! & !! ''.' & ! & # & ' ' #, ! && ! & ! /0 ! 1 "! 1 $ 234356567839:;<6=>57*35237?8397@'<:93>' AB85<> 7@ ;<8C 68 + 7 7@ <;<>C<; D6;;<A3 5<;BE 2<;E66>596:56C<923497CB:3C*+5234356567839 >27?>52<5236>687::B4<56787@><6C'<:93>'AB85<> 7@523;<8C56>>B*=6553C52<57B57@523><6C'<:93> ' AB85<> 7@ 523 ;<8C 439=6>>678 2<> *338 <::79C3C 57 26= *+ 523 34<95=385 7@ 683> <8C 37;7A+ 57 =683 - 3 - *<><;597:E68<83F53857@'<:93>'%AB85<7@;<8C23 4356567839 2<> <44;63C @79 :78D39>678 7@ 523 <A96:B;5B9<; ;<8C@79523385693'<:93>'AB85<>7@<A96:B;5B9<;;<8C @79 68CB>596<; 4B947>3 57 93>478C385 7% 34B5+ 7==6>>678397?3D39523><=32<>*33893G3:53C*+ 523@7;;7?68A93<>78 AA963D3C*+523><=3523493>385?965435656786>@6;3C 23 :<>3 7@ 523 4356567839 6> 52<5 23 6> 523 7?839<8C687::B4<56787@<:93>AB85<>7@;<8C<8C 52393D38B3C7:B=385>"$93@;3:5>523><=37?3D39 ?26;352334<95=3857@683><8C37;7A+497:3>>3C26> <44;6:<5678@79A9<857@;6:38:357=6832<>439=6553C26= 57=68378;+68<:93>%AB85<7@;<8C3>B*=65>52<5 523><6C439=6>>6786>A6D385<E68A6857:78>6C39<5678523 ;7:<56787@523*<><;597:E7826>;<8C3>B*=65>52<565 C73> 875 =3<8 52<5 23 6> 875 68 7::B4<5678 7@ <:93> AB85<>7@;<8C3<;>7>B*=65>52<534B5+7==6>>67839 6> 93HB693C 57 *3 AB6C3C *+ 523 497D6>678> 7@ 3:5678 . - 4 - <98<5<E< <8C 3D38B3 :5 %.) ?26;3 A9<8568A 79 93G3:568A 523 <44;6:<5678 <8C :<8875 C3:6C3 523 3F5385 B8C395237::B4<56787@5234356567839*<>3C78523<93<68 ?26:2236>439=6553C57:<99+7B5=6868A<:56D65+ 8523 ><6C A97B8C 65 6> 49<+3C 52<5 523 6=4BA83C 79C39 *3 >35 <>6C3<8C<;;7?523?96543565678<>49<+3C@79 3<983C CC65678<; 7D398=385 CD7:<53 GB>56@63>5236=4BA83C79C3938C79>3=385<8C49<+3C@79 C6>=6>><;7@523?96543565678 3:5678.7@523<98<5<E<<8C3D38B3:5 %.)93<C><>B8C39 !" " #" " " #" " !" ! # - 5 - # # $ %& # ' ( ) * ) +* ', +* , " ! - . # # / %0 1 # " # 2 # ) % . 2 - # ) " " 3 & " - 6 - # 4 ! . 2 & 5" 674 ! 5 8 679 & # " ) : . & 5 - 5 $ %& # " # ) - " 0;; " " 3 & " # 4 ! . 2 & 5" 67 4 ! 5 679 # <# / 1 # = & 5 3 & " # - 7 - 2 . . 2 # # " ) :$ & # " " # # $ & # " 2 # ) " # # # 2 ) :/ 1 # # " " # - 8 - 2 . # " " <# . # ) #" 2 <# # 1 # # ) )# ! " # # = " # " # $ & # " # = # )# ! ! " # # # 1 # # ) 2 - 9 - # # # 4 ! 2 . & . 2 = 5" 6:> 4 ! = < " 676 <# # 8 # # # ) # 4 ! . 2 & 5" 67 4 ! 5 679$ & # " ! 4 " !" " ) ?>)5 4 ! = 5" 67 4 ! 5 ; 670@ - 10 - :: 4 ! = 5" 67 4 ! 5 ; 670" - ) " # . ) :, %0)5 A # 2 ) 0" 9 " 0;;> # " " 0% 4 ! = # 5 5" 0;/ " " " 2 B " 2 " 5" # " - 11 - # - - " C ) #@ <# <# 5 " " " " # " " " # @ # @ # # " # # !" " # # @ # " " ! " # $ # C " @ ) @ - 12 - # 2 D 3 " E# * " <# 1@ # ?)5 4 ! . 2 & 5" 67@ # # ") E " 8 B 2 * * @ # C # 3 & 4 ! = # 5" 67?@ # # 0)55 ' # # 9 " 0;;> ! # - 13 - 0)555 5 # ) 0)5 ! #/ %9 7 / %7)5 1 ! 4 " 4 4 .! 3 " # " 4 ! = # 5 5" 6>" " " # / %: A # " " 2 " <# " - 14 - - 8 # ) 0 >9/ %> . # #" " ( & # <# " ( # ;6 4 ! = 5" 67 4 ! 5 ; 670" #" " " ( & # <# " ( 9%/ / %6 A # # - " ) # - # 4 ! 2 5" 0; 4 ! 5 > 0;0" ! 2 # - 15 - B " # # ! %; 1 # 4 ! & 0;?)0;0 <B 8 E8 0 F2 0;?" 00);G) 0;? # 2 <# # 2 5 " # # # " / * " HH /, 2B>?2387::B4<857@<;<8C?6>23>57C6D395 523 ><=3 @97= <A96:B;5B9<; 57 878<A96:B;5B9<; 4B947>3> 93>478C385 7% 6> *7B8C 57 :78>6C39 26> 93HB3>5 68 - 16 - <::79C<8:3?652;<?36>93HB693C57D396@+?235239523 439>78<44;+68A@79>B:2:78D39>6786><87::B4<857@523 ;<8C 79 875 <8C ?235239 523 ;<8C 6> >B653C @79 523 :78D39>678 <> 49<+3C @79 <8C 23 :<8875 93G3:5 523 ><6C <44;6:<567878523A97B8C52<5=6868A;3<>36>A9<853C@79 78;+<:93>%AB85<?2393<>52343565678392<>93HB3>53C @79:78D39>6787@523;<8C@79523385693<:93>AB85<> 2<5:<8875*3523:965396<36>93HB693C57D396@+68523 68>5<85 :<>3 ?235239 523 4356567839 6> 68 7::B4<5678 7@ <:93> AB85<> 7@ ;<8C <8C :<8 65 *3 :78D3953C @79 68CB>596<;4B947>3> ) 56>47>>6*;352<552334<95=3857@683><8C 37;7A+ =6A25 875 2<D3 A9<853C =6868A ;3<>3 @79 523 3F5385 7@ 78;+ <:93> % AB85< 7@ ;<8C @79 D<967B> 75239 93<>78> 6=6;<9;+ 523 4356567839 =<+ :<99+7B5 =6868A <:56D65+78;+78<47956787@523;<8C?26:2232<>49<+3C @79:78D39>678<8C7852375239479567823=<+68>5<;;523 93HB693C =<:26839+ 79 :93<53 >4<:3 @79 >579<A3 7@ 523 - 17 - =<5396<; 3F59<:53C 79 @79 75239 4B947>3> 93;<53C 57 523 68CB>59+ ( >93>478C385 7%2<>93G3:53C52393HB3>57@ 523435656783978;+@7952393<>7852<5523936>C6@@3938:368 523 ;<8C <93< >27?8 68 523 =6868A ;3<>3 <8C 523 ;<8C >7BA25 57 *3 :78D3953C *+ 523 4356567839 523 ><=3 6> ;6<*;357*3>35<>6C3 38:3523@7;;7?68A "6$ 23 6=4BA83C 38C79>3=38579C39 C<53C '%' 6>>B3C *+ 523 93>478C385 7%34B5+ 7==6>>67839 6C<9 D6C3 883FB93 57 523 ?965 43565678 6> 2393*+ >35<>6C3 "66$ 3>478C385 7%6>C693:53C57:78>6C39523 <44;6:<5678 7@ 523 4356567839 68 <::79C<8:3 ?652 523 497D6>678> 7@ 3:5678 . 7@ 523 <98<5<E< <8C 3D38B3 :5 %.) - 18 - E33468A 68 D63? 523 <@793=3856783C 7*>39D<5678><8C4<>><4497496<5379C39>68 <::79C<8:3?652;<? ?65268 52356=3 @9<=3 493>:96*3C B8C39 3:5678 . 7@ 523 <98<5<E< <8C 3D38B3 :5 %.) <@539 93:36457@<:3956@63C:74+7@526>79C39 "666$ 23?965435656786>C6>47>3C7@<::79C68A;+ () &%' " # 6>5 7%; 7