Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58163 (KAR)
THE BRANCH MANAGER THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v. BHARATI AND ANR
MFA/200114/2024 · 2025-11-11
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58163 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58163 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! ""#"$%! ! &! #'#(##"
# #((
)%*
# #((
)%*
+
! ! " #
"
$
%% $
&& '(
' &
$
) $
&& '(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! * $
''')
'#
$+%!# #
'$'(
, #
(''% '$'(
, ,
! $
%'
! # $
& &
! #
"
&
$
)) $
&&
'
! " '* $
''''
#
$ +%!#
- 3 -
(''%
,
'$'(
-
-
. '"
/')$'') 01 234543346 78 9:4 ;1<3=;>4 >/?2=;8 /; 9:4 @3/<;6 /5 A<=;9<? /'$'') 01 50B46 78 9:4 >B=0?=;9 144C0;@ 4;:=;>4?4;9 /5 9:4 >/?24;1=90/; /9: 9:4 =224=B1 =34 234543346=@=0;199:4<6@?4;9=;6=D=366=946(''% 2=11460; /'$'(789:4 /9/34:0>B4>>064;91 B=0?1307<;=B/,0E=8=2<3=!5/31:/39F9:49307<;=BG#
' :49307<;=B=5943>/;106430;@9:44;90344H064;>4 /; 34>/36 =D=3646 = 1<? /5 1+'$ =B/;@ D09:
0;943419 =9 9:4 3=94 /5 I 243 =;;<? 53/? 9:4 6=94 /5 249090/; 90BB 9:4 6=94 /5 34=B0J=90/; @@304H46 78 9:4 1=06 <6@?4;9 =;6 =D=36 /')$'') 01 234543346 78
- 4 -
9:4 ;1<3=;>4 >/?2=;8 =;6 /'$'') 01 234543346789:4>B=0?=;9
% 4=3;46 >/<;14B 5/3 9:4 ;1<3=;>4 >/?2=;8 ?=0;B8>/;94;6469:=9K019:4D/<;6>439050>=94*' 01 9:4 />9/3 :4 />9/3 04 ' 011<4 601=70B098 >439050>=94 1 243 9:4 601=70B098 >439050>=94 ' =1141146 ''I601=70B0989/9:4<2243B0?7'01;/9=934=946 />9/3 /;106430;@ 9:4 1=?4 9:4 9307<;=B :=1 43346 0; 9=C0;@I601=70B0989/9:4D:/B47/682=3953/?9:=9)I /5 9:4 0;>/?4 01 =6646 =1 5<9<34 23/124>91 :4 9307<;=B ?0@:9;/9:=H4=6646)I9/D=3615<9<3423/124>91=1243 9:4 >09=90/; 0; 9:4 >=14 /5
!"#$%&$&&
' #( ## &$&&) =;6 9:<1 34A<419469/34=114119:4A<=;9<?=;69/346<>49:41=?4 / =B1/ 9:4 9307<;=B :=1 =D=3646 5<9<34 ?460>=B 4K24;141 D09:/<9=;87=101
) 4=3;46>/<;14B5/39:4>B=0?=;91<7?0919:=9=1 /;9:46=94/59:4=>>064;99:4>B=0?=;9D=1=@46'84=31
- 5 -
=;6 :4 D=1 4=3;0;@ = 1<? /5 1$ 78 6/0;@ =@30><B9<34D/3C/39:4934=9?4;99:4>B=0?=;9124;9=1<? /5 1%$ 9/D=361 ?460>=B 4K24;141 :/<@: 9:4 />9/3=11411469:4601=70B0989/'9/'I<99:49307<;=B :=1/;B89=C4;I9/9:4D:/B47/68:49307<;=B:=1;/9 =D=3646 =;8 =?/<;9 <;643 9:4 :4=6 93=;12/39=90/; 4K93= ;/<301:?4;9 =;6 =994;6=;9 >:=3@41 =;6 =B1/ <;643 /9:43 :4=61 <39:43 09 01 1<7?09946 9:=9 9:4 0;943419 :=1 9/ 74 4;:=;>46 9/ 'I 53/?
I /; 9:4 >/?24;1=90/; =?/<;9 :4345/34 B4=3;46 >/<;14B 5/3 9:4 >B=0?=;9 34A<4191 9/ 4;:=;>49:4>/?24;1=90/;
0;>49:4>B=0?=;9:=1;/923/6<>46=;80;>/?4 23//5 0; H04D /5 9:4 @<064B0;41 011<46 78 9:4 &=3;=9=C= 9=944@=B43H0>41<9:/30989:49307<;=B9:40;>/?4/59:4 >B=0?=;9 01 9/ 74 9=C4; =9 1%'$ 243 ?/;9: =1 9:4 =>>064;9 :=1 />><3346 0; 9:4 84=3 '( ; H04D /5 9:4 >09=90/; 342/3946 0;
*
342/39460;+&$#,-#((!$)I/59:4 0;>/?4019/74=66464;>49:40;>/?4>/;1064346789:4 9307<;=B=91$01>/334>9=;6;4461;/0;9435434;>4
- 6 -
:4 />9/3 =1141146 9:4 601=70B098 =9 ' L 'I =;6 9:4 9307<;=B :=1 9=C4; I 9/ 9:4 D:/B4 7/68 :4 1=?4 01 >/334>9=;69:49307<;=B:=1=D=3646=1<?/51')$ 9/D=361 ?460>=B 4K24;141 =;6 9:48 ;4461 ;/ 0;9435434;>4 :4 >B=0?=;9 D=1 :/1209=B0J46 5/3 10K 6=81 :4345/34 >/;106430;@ 9:4 ;=9<34 /5 0;E<3041 2430/6 /5 :/1209=B0J=90/;
9:01 /<3950;610934=1/;=7B49/=D=36=1<?/51$ 9/D=361 2=0; =;6 1<55430;@ 1'$ 9/D=361 B/11 /5 =?4;09041 1%$ 9/D=361 93=;12/39=90/; 4K93= ;/<301:?4;9=;6=994;6=;9>:=3@41<49/9:40;E<30419:4 >B=0?=;9?0@:9;/9:=H4=994;646=;8D/3C5/3=9B4=199:344 ?/;9:1:4345/349:01 /<3950;610934=1/;=7B49/=D=36= 1<? /5 1%+$ !1'$ , % ?/;9:1# 9/D=361 B/11 /5 0;>/?4 6<30;@ B=06 <2 2430/6 4;>4 9:4 9/9=B >/?24;1=90/;01<;643- #, -./0123-40.564 2745
/11/55<9<340;>/?4 1%'+%$ '
460>=B4K24;141 1')$ % =0;=;61<55430;@ 1$ ) /11/5=?4;09041 1'$
/11 /5 0;>/?4 6<30;@ B=06 <2 2430/6 1%+$
3=;12/39=90/; 4K93= ;/<301:?4;9 =;6=994;6=;9>:=3@41 1%$
5., 08
- 7 -
>>/360;@B89:45/BB/D0;@/3643-
"
!0# :4 =224=B 50B46 78 9:4 ;1<3=;>4 >/?2=;80; /')$'')01601?01146*
!00# :4 =224=B 50B46 78 9:4 >B=0?=;9 0;
/'$'')01=BB/D460;2=39*
!000# :4 >B=0?=;9 01 4;909B46 9/ 9/9=B >/?24;1=90/;/51+%+$=B/;@D09:0;943419=9 9:43=94/5I243=;;<?53/?9:46=94/5249090/; 90BB9:46=94/534=B0J=90/;*
!0H# :4 ;1<3=;>4 >/?2=;8 01 6034>946 9/ 642/109 9:4 4;:=;>46 >/?24;1=90/; /5 1()+$ =B/;@D09:0;943419D09:0;=2430/6/5/;4?/;9:*
!H# ; 1<>: 642/109 9:4 >B=0?=;9 01 243?099469/D09:63=D9:44;9034=?/<;9=B/;@D09: 0;943419=>>3<469:434/;
- 8 -
!H0# :4 =?/<;9 05 =;8 642/10946 78 9:4 ;1<3=;>4 >/?2=;8 1:=BB 74 93=;1?09946 9/ 9:4 9307<;=B5/39:D09:
0/ )(##"* '"
019/-B/- -