- 1 - !"# $ %& $ %& "&'" $$ (') * !"!#$% & ' # (!"!%# Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ' !")#%! * + ++%+ #$#+ % ' ' (!"!#$% & ' + *, ' %)#$%$%! #% + + #)*# + ' + $#$%%$% ' "#%$%$ + + + ' #)#!$$ + - + . + + ' / / ' - 3 - & / 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 #)*# => =<=: '501;652 ;< #"" 05:5183><5: :5>5::59 <= 32 ?<05 ;<- 032 @558 >1659@A<05;631B38<@518C3CC:15D59@A<05E79CB58<389 3F3:993<59$#$%%$%432259@A<05991<1=836581=: 1D1679C5389 363@7:3C118 '="#%$%$ % +3;<2 C1D18C :125 <= <05 >1618C => <05 344536 @:15>6A2<3<593:5<03<=8%!$%$#3<3@=7<#!4B F058<05;631B38<36=8CF1<0=<05:2F324:=;55918C183 ;=:41= D501;65 @53:18C = * $)" >:=B 5B@03D1 <=05887:D1663C5F058<052319D501;65F32853: 0=F ==B F1<018 <05 61B1<2 => 78323C1 <=F8 3< <03< <1B5 <05 9:1D5: => :3;<=: @53:18C = ** "$) 3<<3;059 F1<0 :3165: @53:18C = % "#% F32 4:=;55918C 30539 => <05 2319 ;=:41= D501;65 389 <05 9:1D5:=><052319<:3;<=:F329:1D18C012D501;65F1<001C0 2455918:32038985C61C58<B3885:3<<03<<1B5366=>3 279958F1<0=7<38A1891;3<=:<059:1D5:<7:859<05<:3;<=: - 4 - <=F3:92 :1C0< 32 3 :5276< <05 <:3165: 3<<3;059 F1<0 <05 <:3;<=: 932059 <= <05 ;=:41= 975 <= F01;0 <05 ;631B38< F0=F3218B3<5=><05;=:41=272<31859C:15D=7218E7:152 389F320=241<361G59 * 05;631B38<>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8#HH =><05;<255I18C;=B45823<1=8<F324653959<03<205 2458< 07C5 3B=78< <=F3:92 B591;36 5J458252 ;=8D5A38;5;03:C525<;<F32>7:<05:4653959<03<<05 3;;1958< =;;7::59 47:56A =8 3;;=78< => <05 :320 389 85C61C58<9:1D18C=><05=>>58918CD501;65@A1<29:1D5: 8 25:D1;5 => 8=<1;5 :524=8958< =2# <= * 03D5 34453:59 <0:=7C0 <051: ;=78256 524=8958< =2# 389 % 03D5 8=< >1659 <051: 2<3<5B58< => =@E5;<1=82 0=F5D5: :524=8958< =* >1659 1<2 F:1<<58 2<3<5B58< 958A18C<053D5:B58<2B39518<05;631B45<1<1=8<F32 ;=8<58959<03<<059:1D5:=><05=>>58918CD501;65F328=< 0=6918C3D36193895>>5;<1D59:1D18C61;58;532=8<0593<5 => <05 3;;1958< 389 <05:5@A <05:5 12 D1=63<1=8 => 4=61;A ;=891<1=8 - 5 - ! 8<05@3212=><054653918C2=><0543:<152<05 631B2:1@7836>:3B59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055D1958;505;631B38<01B256>F325J3B185932 # 389 :3D1 01D3:3A3 F32 5J3B1859 32 % 389 C=< 5J01@1<59 9=;7B58<2 83B56A J# <= J# 524=8958< =* 5J3B1859 1<2 =>>1;5: 32 # 389 C=< 5J01@1<599=;7B58<83B56AJ#05631B2:1@7836@A <051B47C859E79CB58<18<5:36130569<03<<053;;1958< <==I463;5=83;;=78<=>:32038985C61C58<9:1D18C=><05 =>>58918C D501;65 @A 1<2 9:1D5: 32 3 :5276< => F01;0 <05 ;631B38<272<3185918E7:15205:1@7836>7:<05:0569<03< <05;631B38<1258<1<659<=3;=B45823<1=8=>2%$"!$$ 36=8C F1<0 18<5:52< 3< <05 :3<5 => HK 43 389 91:5;<59 :524=8958< =* <= 954=21< <05 ;=B45823<1=8 3B=78< 36=8C F1<0 18<5:52< 518C 3CC:15D59 <05 4:5258< 344536 032@558>1659 H 53:859;=78256>=:<05;631B38<032:31259<05 >=66=F18C;=8<58<1=82 - 6 - 3 +1:2<6A 975 <= <05 3;;1958< <05 ;631B38< 032 27>>5:59C:15D=7218E7:152050325J3B1859<059=;<=:32 % 05 9=;<=: 032 32252259 <05 F0=65 @=9A 9123@161<A 3< %#K 05 :1@7836 032 32252259 <05 9123@161<A 3< )K F01;012=8<056=F5:2195 @ 5;=896A 975 <= <05 3;;1958< <05 ;631B38< 032 272<31859C:15D=7218E7:152D583><5:912;03:C5>:=B<05 0=241<36205128=<1834=21<1=8<=912;03:C505::5C763: F=:I 05 032 <= 27>>5: 9123@161<A 389 78034418522 <0:=7C0=7< 05: 61>5 05 ;=B45823<1=8 3F3:959 @A <05 :1@7836 7895: <05 0539 ?4318 389 27>>5:18C- ?6=22 => 3B581<152-389?=<05:18;1958<365J458252-3:5362==8<05 6=F5: 2195 58;5 05 2=7C0< >=: 58038;5B58< => ;=B45823<1=8@A366=F18C<05344536 ) 8<05=<05:0389<05653:859;=78256>=:<05 827:38;5 =B438A 032 :31259 >=66=F18C ;=78<5: ;=8<58<1=82 3+1:2<6A<0=7C0<05;631B38<;631B2<03<205F32 53:818C2#!$$$ 45:B=8<02050328=<4:=97;5938A - 7 - 9=;7B58<<=52<3@612005:18;=B505:5>=:5<05:1@7836 032:1C0<6A32252259<0518;=B5=><05;631B38<8=<1=8366A 3<2#*%!$ @ 5;=896A 5D58 <0=7C0 9=;<=: 032 954=259 <03< ;631B38<03227>>5:59%#K9123@161<A<=<05F0=65@=9A05 0328=<3225225961B@9123@161<A=82195:18C<05B591;36 :5;=:92 389 5D1958;5 => 9=;<=: <05 :1@7836 032 :1C0<6A 32252259<05F0=65@=9A9123@161<A3<)K ; 01:96A;=82195:18C<0518E7:15227>>5:59@A<05 ;631B38< 389 B591;36 :5;=:92 <05 :1@7836 032 3F3:959 E72< 389 :532=83@65 ;=B45823<1=8 389 2=7C0< >=: 912B12236=><05344536 " 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05E79CB58<3893F3:9=><05:1@7836 < 12 8=< 18 91247<5 <03< <05 ;631B38< 032 272<3185918E7:15218<05:=39<:3>>1;3;;1958<=;;7::59=8 %!$%$# 3< 3@=7< #! 975 <= :320 389 85C61C58< 9:1D18C => 9:1D5: => <05 =>>58918C D501;65 15 :3;<=: - 8 - @53:18C = ** "$) 3<<3;059 F1<0 :3165: @53:18C = % "#% #$ 75 <= <05 3;;1958<<05;631B38<032 27>>5:59 <05>=66=F18C18E7:A ## 05;631B38<0325J3B1859:3D101D3:3A3 32 % 8012 5D1958;5 05032954=259<03< ;631B38< 03227>>5:59%#K9123@161<A<=<05F0=65@=9A50328=< 32252259 61B@ 9123@161<A =82195:18C <05 5D1958;5 => 9=;<=: 9123@161<A ;5:<1>1;3<5 389 B591;36 :5;=:92 <05 :1@7836032:1C0<6A32252259<05F0=65@=9A9123@161<A3< )K056=22=>>7<7:518;=B53F3:959@A<05:1@783612 E72< 389 :532=83@65 75 <= <05 3;;1958< <05 ;631B38< 03227>>5:59<0518E7:15205032<=27>>5:<0129123@161<A <0:=7C0=7< 05: 61>5 =82195:18C <05 5D1958;5 => 9=;<=: F=789 ;5:<1>1;3<5 J! 389 B591;36 :5;=:92 F5 3:5 => <05 =4181=8 <03< <05 ;=B45823<1=8 3F3:959 @A <05 :1@7836>=:?431838927>>5:18C-032<=@558038;59>:=B - 9 - 2#$$$$ <=2!$$$$ ?6=22=>18;=B597:18C631974 45:1=9-12<=@5C:38<59>=:<0:55B=8<02152*)!$ #*%!$J* +7:<05: ?6=22 => 3B581<152- 12 <= @5 58038;59 >:=B2#$$$$ <=2$$$$ #% 05 ;=B45823<1=8 3F3:959 @A <05 :1@7836 =8 =<05:0539212E72<389:532=83@65 #* 072 <05 ;631B38< 12 58<1<659 <= <05 >=66=F18C ;=B45823<1=8 +,-./012.3.4-5 42-5-.1-04/ /06054-4 7819- 5273.0: (/) /06054-4 78192/ 351 (/) 31838927>>5:18C #$$$$ !$$$$ <<58938<;03:C52>==9 389;=8D5A38;5;03:C52 !$$$ !$$$ =22=>>7<7:518;=B5 #!!"$$ #!!"$$ 591;365J45891<7:5 #))$$ #))$$ =22=>18;=B597:18C <:53<B58< #$$$$ #$$$$ =22=>3B581<152 #$$$$ $$$$ =22=>18;=B597:18C 63197445:1=9 &&& *)!$ 10: #;#< #;# < - 10 - # 8<05:5276<<05>=66=F18C=:95:12432259 3 0534453612 @ 05 E79CB58< => <05 631B2 :1@7836 12 B=91>159 ; 05 ;631B38< 12 58<1<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=B45823<1=8=>/#;# <323C3182< 2%$"!$$ 3F3:959@A<05:1@7836 9 05 827:38;5 =B438A 12 91:5;<59 <= 954=21< <05 ;=B45823<1=8 3B=78< 36=8C F1<018<5:52<HK43>:=B<0593<5=>>1618C => <05 ;631B 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361G3<1=8 F1<018 3 45:1=9 => 21J F55I2 >:=B <05 93<5 => :5;514< => ;=4A => <012 E79CB58< 5 05 344=:<1=8B58< 954=21< 389 :565325 => 3B=78< 20366 @5 B395 18 <5:B2 => <05 3F3:9=><05:1@7836 - 11 - > 8 D15F => <05 =:95: 93<59 %)#$%$%! 432259 @A <012 =7:< <05 ;631B38< 12 8=< 58<1<659 >=: 18<5:52< =8 <05 58038;59 ;=B45823<1=8>=:<059563A5945:1=9=>%!$ 93A218>1618C<05344536 4< ($ ) & 4< ("&'") & ' 12<=#6=#