Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 58145 (KAR)
NABI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.RP/200055/2020 · 2025-06-25
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 58145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#!$
#$
%
&%'()*
%(( +
! " # $$
%
&
'
! " # %
&
( & ' $
) & $
*!(*! $ ) ) &
*! '
'
& *! !!(*!*! && ) $
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&&
'
+ )
$
# + )
$ %
,-./.0 -12,1/.-,//34,-.1,/56718,496. :;, <,:0:061,. -1/ =: .-:0 -:04 4,-.1,/ 0>;
67.: 62,.1=,1:4,-/,. * ,208061 <,:0:061,. 08 :;, -5578,/ ?;6 ;-8 8799,.,/ -1 6./,. 69 561205:061 01
6*! -1/ 8,1:,15,/-871/,. ! "
#$ %
"
& ' (
!!"
!)%
*
;, 2-40/0:3 69 :;, )7/>=,1: 69 561205:061 -1/ 6./,. 69 8,1:,15, ?-8 @7,8:061,/ A,96., :;, 90.8: -<<,44-:, 67.: 01
.0=01-4 <<,-4 6*! ?;,.,01 A3 )7/>=,1: /-:,/ !!(*!*! :;, )7/>=,1: 69561205:061 -1/ 6./,. 69
- 3 -
8,1:,15, 08 7<;,4/ A3 :;, 90.8: -<<,44-:,
67.: ?;04, /08=08801>:;,-<<,-469:;,<,:0:061,. &-5:8 01 :;, 17:8;,44 96. /08<68-4 69 :;, <.,8,1:
.,208061<,:0:061-.,-871/,. 56=<4-01:5-=,:6A,46/>,/A3.0 -;0A66A ?0:;'-/->,.-6405,:-:06161*!*! *-44,>01>:;-:61 *!*! *-:-A67:!!<=:;,56=<4-01-1:-1/;08?09, ,;A66AA0 -1/ :;,0. 5;04/.,1 674- -:,4 -1/
;-1/ -:,4 ?,.,80::01>019.61:69:;,0.;678,-1/?,.,56187=01>:,- :;,-5578,/5-=,:;,.,-1/:64/:;,56=<4-01-1::;-:;,08 01:,.,8:,/ 01 8,4401> ;08 8;-., 69 <.6<,.:3 :6 :;, ,B:,1: 69 61,-5.,-1/:64/:;,56=<4-01-1:?;,:;,.:;,808:,.69:;, 56=<4-01-1:0801:,.,8:,/01<7.5;-801>:;,8-=,
* ;,56=<4-01-1:.,<40,/:;-:;, 0816: -?-., 69 :;,?;,.,-A67:869;08808:,.-88;,;-8>61,:6,1>-47.7 :6,C,67:402,40;66/-1/-::;-:D715:7.,A,01>,1.05;,/A3 875; -1 -18?,. -5578,/ >6: ,1.05;,/ -1/ -A78,/ :;, 56=<4-01-1: 01 904:;3 4-1>7->, -1/ 01 :;08 857994, ;, ;-8 A,-:,1 :;, =0//4, 901>,. 69 :;, 56=<4-01-1:E8 4,9: ;-1/
- 4 -
.,874:01>015-7801>>.0,267801D7.31;,-.01>:;,;7,-1/ 5.3 69 :;, 56=<4-01-1: -33-/ -:,4 -A08-A -1/ 6:;,.8 5-=,:;,.,-1<-5090,/:;,@7-..,4
<61 .,5,0<: 69 :;, 56=<4-01: '-/->,.- 6405, .,>08:,.,/ :;, 5-8, 01
.0=, 6(*! * -1/ 2080:,/ :;, <4-5,690150/,1:561/75:,/8<6:=-;-F-.-1/.,56./,/:;, 8:-:,=,1:69:;,?0:1,88,8-1/-9:,.:;6.67>;012,8:0>-:061 904,/ :;, 5;-.>,8;,,: ;, -5578,/ 26471:-.043 -<<,-.,/ A,96.,:;,
67.:-1/;,?-8,14-.>,/61A-04
,-.1,/ :.0-4 ->08:.-:, :66C 56>10F-15, 69 :;, 699,15,8<7108;-A4,->-018::;,-5578,/71/,.,5:0618* !-1/*G69
-1/9.-=,/:;,5;-.>,5578,/<4,-/,/ 16:>704:3-1/:;,.,96.,:.0-4?-8;,4/
G .68,57:061 01 6./,. :6 ,8:-A408; 0:8 5-8, ,B-=01,/,4,2,1?0:1,88,8-8' :6' 56=<.0801>69 56=<4-01-1:01D7.,/ 8<6: =-;-F-. ?0:1,88,8 ,3,?0:1,88,8 :6 :;, 0150/,1: 65:6. ?;6 ,B-=01,/ :;, 56=<4-01-1: -1/ 0887,/ ?671/ 5,.:0905-:, -1/ 12,8:0>-:01> 9905,. .68,57:061-486<4-5,/61.,56./967./657=,1:-.3,20/,15,
- 5 -
-8B :6B56=<.0801>6956=<4-01:88<6:=-;-F-. &-1/?671/5,.:0905-:,9:,./7,:.0-44,-.1,/:.0-4)7/>, 561205:,/:;,-5578,/-1/8,1:,15,/-8.,9,..,/:687<.-
;, :.0-4 )7/>, /0/ 16: 56180/,. :;, >.-1: 69 <.6A-:061:;67>;7.>,/61A,;-4969:;,-5578,/
,01> ->>.0,2,/ A3 :;, 8-=, :;, -5578,/ 904,/ -1 -<<,-4 A,96., :;, 08:.05:
67.: 01
.0=01-4 <<,-4 6*! ( ,-.1,/ )7/>, 01 :;, 90.8: -<<,44-:,
67.: -9:,. 8,57.01>:;,.,56./8;,-./:;,-.>7=,1:869:;,<-.:0,801 :;,40>;:69:;,-<<,-4>.671/8-1/61.,-<<.,50-:06169:;, =-:,.0-4,20/,15,61.,56.//08=088,/:;,-<<,-461=,.0:8 ,01>97.:;,.->>.0,2,/A3:;,8-=,-5578,/08A,96.,:;08 67.:
! .0 -1-2,1/.- ,//3 4,-.1,/ 56718,4 96. :;, .,208061 <,:0:061,. .,0:,.-:01> :;, >.671/8 7.>,/ 01 :;, .,208061<,:0:0612,;,=,1:43561:,1/,/:;-:A6:;:;,567.:8 ;-2,16:<.6<,.43-<<.,50-:,/:;,=-:,.0-461.,56./-1/- :.020-4 0150/,1: ;-8 A,,1 A46?1 67: 69 <.6<6.:061 01 90401> -
- 6 -
9-48, 56=<4-01: ->-018: :;, <,:0:061,.
-1/ :;78 867>;: 96. -446?01>:;,.,208061<,:0:061
4:,.1-:02,43.0 -12,1/.-,//3?674/87A=0: :;-: 01 :;, ,2,1: :;08
67.: 7<;64/01> :;, 6./,. 69 561205:061-4,10,1:20,?=-3A,:-C,1;-201>.,>-./:6:;, 9-5::;-::;,-5578,/08-90.8::0=,699,1/,.-1/;-8A,,1 561205:,/614396.:;,699,15,71/,.,5:061*69
A3 ,1;-1501> :;, 901, -=671: .,-861-A43 -1/ 867>;: 96. -446?01>:;,.,208061<,:0:061
* ,. 561:.- =: .-:0 -:04 4,-.1,/ 0>;
67.: 62,.1=,1:4,-/,.87<<6.:8:;,0=<7>1,/)7/>=,1:;, ?674/97.:;,.561:,1/:;-:-5578,/0816:-8:.-1>,.:6:;, 56=<4-01-1:-1/?;,1:;,56=<4-01-1:.,<40,/:;-:;,/6,8 16:C16?-A67::;,?;,.,-A67:869;08808:,.-5578,/>6:
,1.->,/ -1/ 26471:-.043 5-78,/ >.0,2678 ;7.: A3 A0:01> :;, 4,9: ;-1/ =0//4, 901>,. 69 :;, 56=<4-01-1: ?;05; ;-8 A,,1 .0>;:43 -<<.,50-:,/ A3 A6:; :;,
67.:8 ;,.,96., 16 4,10,15,5-1A,8;6?1:6:;,.,208061<,:0:061,.-1/867>;: 96./08=088-469:;,.,208061<,:0:061
- 7 -
-201> ;,-./ :;, -.>7=,1:8 69 A6:; 80/,8 :;08 67.:<,.78,/:;,=-:,.0-461.,56./=,:057467843
1 875; <,.78-4 69 :;, =-:,.0-4 61 .,56./ 0: 08 5.38:-4 54,-. :;-: ?;,1 :;, 56=<4-01-1: -1/ ;08 9-=043 =,=A,.8?,.,80::01>019.61:69:;,0.;678,-1/56187=01> :;,:,-0:08:;,-5578,/?;626471:-.043-<<,-.,/:;,.,61 *!*! * -: -A67: !! <= -1/ ,1@70.,/ :;, 56=<4-01-1: :;-: ?;,:;,. :;, 808:,. 69 :;, 56=<4-01-1: 08 01:,.,8:,/ 01 <7.5;-801> 61, -5., 69 :;, <.6<,.:3 69 :;, -5578,/
;, 56=<4-01-1: .,<40,/ :6 :;, -5578,/ :;-: ;, /6,816:C16??;,.,-A67:869;08808:,.1:;-:.,>-./:;, @7-..,4 ;-8 A,>71 -1/ 01 :;, @7-..,4 -5578,/ 16: 6143 -A78,/:;,56=<4-01-1:01904:;34-1>7->,A7:-486A0::,1:;, 4,9: =0//4, 901>,. 69 :;, 56=<4-01-1: ==,/0-:,43 56=<4-01-1: .-08,/ ;7, -1/ 5.3 -1/ :;, 1,0>;A6.8 1-=,43 -33,/-:,4-1/-A08-A5-=,:;,.,-1/:;,3<-5090,/:;, @7-..,4;,.,0816468869:0=,0146/>01>:;,56=<4-01:-1/ ?671/5,.:0905-:,=-.C,/-:B/,<05:8:;,01D7.35-78,/
- 8 -
:6:;,4,9:=0//4,901>,.69:;,56=<4-01-1:?;05;8799050,1:43 56..6A6.-:,8:;,:,8:0=6136956=<4-01-1:-1/,3,?0:1,88,8
G -C01> 16:, 69 :;,8, -8<,5:8 69 :;, =-::,. -1/ -486 :;, 9-5: :;-: :;, 01D7.3 5-78,/ :6 :;, 56=<4-01-1:
5-116: A, 54-88090,/ -8 >.0,2678 01D7.3 -8 08 561:,=<4-:,/ 71/,. ,5:061 *! 69
4,-.1,/ :.0-4 )7/>, .0>;:43 -5@70::,/ :;, -5578,/ 96. :;, 699,15, <7108;-A4, 71/,. ,5:061*G69
A7:.,56./,/-16./,.69561205:061-1/ 8,1:,15,/:;,-5578,/-8.,9,..,/87<.-
: 08 <,.:01,1: :6 16:, :;-: :;, :-:, /0/ 16: 5;-44,1>, :;, -5@70::-4 69 :;, .,208061 <,:0:061,. 96. :;, 699,15, 71/,. ,5:061 *G 69
-1/ :;,.,96., 0: ;-8 A,56=,901-4
,-.1,/)7/>,01:;,90.8:-<<,44-:,
67.:61., -<<.,50-:06169:;,=-:,.0-4,20/,15,/0/16:901/-134,>-4 0190.=0:3 6. <,.2,.80:3 86 -8 :6 01:,.9,., ?0:; :;, 6./,. 69 561205:061-1/8,1:,15,
( 6:; :;,
67.:8 ;-2, 9-04,/ :6 16:, :;-: :;, -5578,/ 08 - 90.8: :0=, 699,1/,. 6 <.6<,. .,-8618 -.,
- 9 -
.,56./,/A3:;,4,-.1,/:.0-4 ->08:.-:,96.16:-996./01>:;, A,1,90:69:;,<.6A-:06169699,1/,.85:
*! -C01>16:,69:;,9-5::;-:71/,.:;,8:-:7:,96. :;,699,15,71/,.,5:061*69
:;,.,081656=<7486.3 <7108;=,1: <.,85.0A,/ :;08
67.: 08 69 :;, 56180/,.,/ 6<01061:;-:09:;,-5578,/08/0.,5:,/:6<-3,1;-15,/901, 69 8*!!! 69 ?;05; 8*!!!! 5-1 A, <-0/ -8 56=<,18-:061:6:;,' ,1/869D78:05,?674/A,=,:01 :;,9-5:8-1/50.57=8:-15,869:;,5-8,A38,::01>-80/,:;, 0=<.0861=,1:<,.06/
* 556./01>43 01 20,?
69 :;, 96.,>601> /085788061 :;,96446?01>6./,.08<-88,/
#0% .0=01-4 ,208061 <,:0:061 08 -446?,/ 01<-.:H
#00% ';04, =-01:-0101> :;, 6./,. 69 561205:061 96. :;, 699,15, <7108;-A4, 71/,. ,5:0618 * -1/ ! 69
:;, 6./,. 69 8,1:,15, 69 .0>6.678 0=<.0861=,1: 96. - <,.06/ 69 61, 3,-. 96. :;, <.62,/ 699,15,8
- 10 -
71/,.,5:0618*-1/!69
08;,.,A3 8,: -80/, A3 ,1;-1501> :;, 901, -=671: 01 - 87=698*!!! #000% 0=,08>.-1:,/:6<-3:;,,1;-15,/ 901,-=671::044!!*!*
#02% &-047., :6 <-3 :;, ,1;-15,/ 901, -=671: ?674/ -7:6=-:05-443 .,874: 01 .,8:6.-:061 69 :;, 8,1:,15, 69 0=<.0861=,1:
6./,.,/ A3 :;, :.0-4 ->08:.-:, 56190.=,/ A3 :;,90.8:-<<,44-:,
67.:
#2% 7:69901,-=671:.,562,.,/-87= 69 8*!!!! 08 6./,.,/ :6 A, <-0/ -8 56=<,18-:061:6:;,01D7.,/' 71/,./7, 0/,1:0905-:061 -4-15, -=671: 8;-44 A, -<<.6<.0-:,/ :6?-./8 :;, /,9.-301> ,B<,18,8 69:;,:-:,
#20% 9905, 08 /0.,5:,/ :6 .,:7.1 :;, :.0-4 67.: .,56./8 ?0:; - 56<3 69 :;08 6./,. 96. 0887,-=6/090,/561205:061?-..-1: ,) %$( ! $
08:6 46*