- 1 - !"# $! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$ '#( ) ! "# # $! % ! & ## ## ' ## ( ) * Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ) + + # $! ( ! ,!&* % ) !$ ## # " '# () $!%% # ) %* ## ,(* ) !!# * ) &% %%% ## ) + + - * ## + $,%%# ) &% %%% ) + + - # .%$&/ .,&&%/ ## + ) 0+ # 0+ + ) - 3 - & (# 0+ # * 12. 344536 7895: 5;<2=8 ,(* => <15 =<=: )512;65. ;< !!(15:5283><5::5>5::59<=3.?<15 ;<@>=: .1=:<* 13. A558 >2659 AB <15 ;632C38<. ;136658D28D <15 E79DC58< 389 3F3:9 93<59 $,%% 43..59 AB <15 #:6582=:2G26+79D5389+389 996 293: 28)=&% %%% % 3;<. D2G28D :2.5 <= <15 >2628D => <15 344536 A:25>6B .<3<59 3:5 <13< =8%%% 3<3A=7< !4C F158 <15 95;53.59 F3. :5<7:828D 3><5: ;=C465<2=8 => 12. A7.285..=8<15293:H128;1=62:=39853:39F39A:29D5 3 ;3: A53:28D :5D2.<:3<2=8 = ! ,!& 344:=3;159 >:=C A51289 28 3 :3.1 389 85D62D58< C3885: 389 12< <15 95;53.59 . 3 :5.76< => <15 3>=:5.329 3;;2958< <15 95;53.59 .7.<32859 D:25G=7. 28E7:25. 389 .7;;7CA59 <= <1528E7:25. - 4 - 15 ;632C38<. >2659 3 45<2<2=8 7895: 5;<2=8 && => <15 ;< .55I28D ;=C458.3<2=8 >=: <15 953<1 => <15 95;53.5936=8DF2<128<5:5.< 4=8 .5:G2;5 => 8=<2;5 <15 :5.4=8958< =. 389 % 34453:59 <1:=7D1 <152: ;=78.56 389 >2659 <15 F:2<<58 .<3<5C58< $ 8 <15 A3.2. => <15 4653928D. => <15 43:<25. <15 632C.:2A7836>:3C59<152..75.389<15:53><5::5;=:959 <15 5G2958;5 15 :2A7836 AB 2C47D859 E79DC58< 389 3F3:913.43:<6B366=F59<15;632C45<2<2=83891569<13< <15 ;632C38< 2. 58<2<659 <= 3 ;=C458.3<2=8 => .%$36=8DF2<128<5:5.<3<<15:3<5=> /43 389 92:5;<59 <15 8.7:38;5 =C438B <= 954=.2< <15 ;=C458.3<2=8 3C=78< 36=8D F2<1 28<5:5.< 528D 3DD:25G59<154:5.58<34453613.A558>2659 & 15653:859;=78.56>=:<15;632C38<.13.:32.59<15 >=66=F28D;=8<58<2=8. - 5 - 3* 2:.<6B <15 ;632C38<. 3..5:< <13< <15 95;53.59 F3. 3D593A=7<$B53:.3<<15<2C5=><153;;2958<3891393 C=8<16B 28;=C5 => . AB F=:I28D 3. 3 >:72< G5895: =F5G5: <15 3..5..C58< => C=8<16B 28;=C5 => <1595;53.593<.,$AB<15:2A78362.78E7.<2>259 3895::=85=7. A* 5;=896B 3. 45: <15 E79DC58< => <15 =8@A65 74:5C5 =7:< 28 <15 ;3.5 => ! *# + & , -53;1=><15;632C38<.3:558<2<659<=;=C458.3<2=8 =>.7895:<151539=>?6=..=>6=G53893>>5;<2=8 389;=8.=:<27C@ ;* 3.<6B ;=8.295:28D <15 3D5 389 3G=;3<2=8 => <15 95;53.59 <15 =G5:366 ;=C458.3<2=8 3F3:959 AB <15 :2A78362.28395J73<5389=8<156=F5:.295 2<1 <15 3A=G5 ;=8<58<2=8. <15 653:859 ;=78.56 .=7D1<<=366=F<15344536 - 6 - , 8 <15 =<15: 1389 <15 653:859 ;=78.56 >=: <15 8.7:38;5 =C438B 13. :32.59 <15 >=66=F28D ;=78<5: ;=8<58<2=8. 3* 2:.<6B 36<1=7D1 <15 ;632C38<. ;632C <13< <15 95;53.59 F3. 53:828D . 45: C=8<1 <15B 13G5 >32659 <= .7A.<38<23<5 <152: ;632C F2<1 .744=:<28D 9=;7C58<. =8.5J758<6B <15 :2A7836 13. ;=::5;<6B 3..5..59<1528;=C5=><1595;53.598=<2=8366B A* 5;=896B =8 344:5;23<2=8 => =:36 389 9=;7C58<3:B 5G2958;5 389 ;=8.295:28D <15 3D5 389 3G=;3<2=8 => <15 95;53.59 <15 =G5:366 ;=C458.3<2=8 3F3:959 AB <15 :2A78362.E7.<389:53.=83A65 ! 53:9 <15 653:859 ;=78.56 >=: <15 43:<25. 389 45:7.59<15E79DC58<3893F3:9=><15:2A7836 < 2. 8=< 28 92.47<5 <13< =13CC39 76<382 9259 28 <15 :=39 <:3>>2; 3;;2958< =;;7::59 =8 %%% 975 <= :3.1 38985D62D58< 9:2G28D => <15 =>>58928D G512;65 AB 2<. 9:2G5: - 7 - 15 ;632C38<. ;632C <13< 95;53.59 F3. 53:828D . 45: C=8<1 >:=C >:72< G58928D A7.285.. A7< >32659 <= 4:=97;5 .744=:<28D 9=;7C58<. <= .7A.<38<23<5 <152:;632C15:2A783613.:2D1<6B3..5..59<158=<2=836 28;=C53<<15:3<5=>.,$389:2D1<6B39959%$/ =><1528;=C5<=F3:9.>7<7:54:=.45;<.17.<15C=8<16B 28;=C5 ;=C5. <= .!! 28;5 <15:5 3:5 >=7: 95458958<.2<2.344:=4:23<5<=9597;<<1=><1528;=C5 =><1595;53.59<=F3:9.45:.=8365K458.5.389:5C32828D 3C=78<13.<=A5<3I583.12.;=8<:2A7<2=8<=<15>3C26B 1595;53.59F3.3D593A=7<$B53:.3<<15<2C5=><15 3;;2958<389C76<24625:34462;3A65<=12.3D5D:=742.?@ 17. <15 ;632C38<. 3:5 58<2<659 <= ;=C458.3<2=8 => . / /0 (.!!L%LL* =8 3;;=78< => ?6=..=>95458958;B@ 8 3992<2=8 <15 ;632C38<. 3:5 58<2<659 <= ;=C458.3<2=8=>.&$=83;;=78<=>?6=..=>5.<3<5@ 389 ;=C458.3<2=8 => .&$ =8 3;;=78< => ?>785:36 5K458.5.@ - 8 - % 8G25F=><1563F63299=F8AB<1574:5C5=7:<28 <15 ;3.5 => (.74:3* ;632C38<=2.<15F2>5=>95;53.59389;632C38<=.% <= 3:5 937D1<5:. => <15 95;53.59 3:5 58<2<659 >=: ;=C458.3<2=8=>.53;17895:<151539=>06=.. =>43:58<36;=8.=:<27C0 17. <15 ;632C38<. 3:5 58<2<659 <= <15 >=66=F28D ;=C458.3<2=8 1234.56748493: 973:346359. 184674 '.( =..=>95458958;B %%!! 785:365K458.5. &$ =..=>5.<3<5 &$ =..=>.4=7.36;=8.=:<27C =..=>#3:58<36;=8.=:<27C % 65; / 0 8<15:5.76<<15>=66=F28D=:95:2.43..59 3* 153445362.5;;<397425:6 A* 15E79DC58<=><15632C.:2A78362.C=92>259 - 9 - ;* 15 ;632C38<. 3:5 58<2<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=C458.3<2=8 => .%$%!! 3. 3D328.< .%$3F3:959AB<15:2A7836 9* 15 8.7:38;5 =C438B 2. 92:5;<59 <= 954=.2< <15;=C458.3<2=83C=78<36=8DF2<128<5:5.<3< &/ 43 >:=C <15 93<5 => >2628D => <15 ;632C 45<2<2=8 <266 <15 93<5 => :5362M3<2=8 F2<128 3 45:2=9=>.2KF55I.>:=C<1593<5=>:5;524<=>3 ;=4B=><12.E79DC58< 5* 15 344=:<2=8C58< 954=.2< 389 :5653.5 => 3C=78< .1366 A5 C395 28 3;;=:938;5 F2<1 <15 <5:C.=><153F3:9=><15:2A7836 !90 '$!( & !90 '"&# "( & 2.<=6=&%