- 1 - !"# $! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$ '#( ) ! " #$ %%&' !() *&)&(' + Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (&,(!!-!!((' # (-(!(!' (&(!(!) # " !('(, ! # # !'! # !.)) # !(! &)'(!) # # # / / & / ! 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 !'! => =<=: 501;652 ;< !.)) 05:5183><5: :5>5::59 <= 32 ?<05 ;<@ 032 A558 >1659AB<05;631C38<;036658D18D<05E79DC58<3893F3:9 93<59 !(! 432259 AB <05 581=: 1G16 79D5 H 991<1=836323G3I36B38193: 12<:1;<05:5183><5: - 3 - :5>5::59 <= 32 <05 ?:1A7836@ >=: 20=:< 18 =&)'(!) #3;<2 D1G18D :125 <= <05 >1618D => <012 344536 A:15>6B 2<3<59 3:5 <03< =8 (.((!' 3< 3A=7< !( 0:2 <05 ;631C38< 36=8D F1<0 012 :563<1G5 83C56B 3G189:3I7C3: F32 4:=;55918D =8 3 7J7I1 C=<=:;B;65 A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =%%&' <0:=7D0 07A3 =665D5 =39 323G3I36B38 3G189:3I7C3: F32 :1918D <05 C=<=:;B;65 389 <05 ;631C38< F32 4:=;55918D 32 3 41661=8 :195: 058 <05B :53;059 853: <05 ;3:G18D => II3 3D3CC3 3G13<<03<<1C5<0523193G189:3I7C3::=95 <05C=<=:;B;653<301D024559389183:32038985D61D58< C3885: 58938D5:18D 07C38 61>5 6=2< ;=8<:=6 =G5: <05 24559=><05C=<=:;B;65F01;02I1995923:5276<=><05 3>=:52319 3;;1958< <05 ;631C38< 272<31859 D:15G=72 18E7:152389F320=241<361J59 05;631C38<>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8!--=><05 ;< 255I18D ;=C45823<1=8 < F32 4653959 <03< 05 039 - 4 - 2458< 3 07D5 3C=78< <=F3:92 C591;36 5K458252 ;=8G5B38;5 ;03:D52 389 =<05: 18;1958<36 ;=2<2 05 ;631C38<F3203653890536<0B3<<05<1C5=><053;;1958< 5 F32 9=18D 4:1G3<5 65;<:1;36 F=:I 389 F32 53:818D 2-((%45:93B<F32>7:<05:4653959<03<<053;;1958< =;;7::59 47:56B =8 3;;=78< => <05 :320 389 85D61D58< :1918D=><05=>>58918DC=<=:;B;65AB1<2:195: , 8 25:G1;5 => 8=<1;5 <05 :524=8958< =2! 389 34453:59 <0:=7D0 <051: ;=78256 524=8958< =! >1659 3 F:1<<58 2<3<5C58< 958B18D <05 3G5:C58<2 C395 18 <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 389 2<3<59 <03< <05 G501;65 18G=6G59 18 <05 3;;1958< F32 >766B 1827:59 F1<0 :524=8958< = < F32 >7:<05:27AC1<<59<03<1><05=7:<;=C52<=<05;=8;6721=8 <03<<05;631C38<1258<1<659>=:38B2=:<=>;=C45823<1=8 <0523C5C3BA591:5;<59<=A54319AB:524=8958<= 524=8958< = >1659 =AE5;<1=82 <= <05 C318 45<1<1=8 ;=8<58918D<03<<0523193;;1958<9198=<=;;7:975<=<05 :320 389 85D61D58< 3;< => <05 :195: => <05 7J7I1 =<=:;B;6582<5391<039<3I58463;5975<=<05:195:@2 - 5 - :32038985D61D58<C3885:320501C256>9320593D3182< <05A:19D558;5054:3B59<=912C122<0545<1<1=8 & 8 <05 A3212 => <05 4653918D2 => <05 43:<152 <05 631C2:1A7836>:3C59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055G1958;505;631C38<01C256>F325K3C185932! 389 : 3E589:3 =<03:1 F32 5K3C1859 32 % 05 ;631C38< D=< 5K01A1<59 9=;7C58<2 C3:I59 32 K! <= K.& 524=8958< =%827:38;5 =C438B F32 5K3C185932%!3899198=<5K01A1<38B9=;7C58<2 - 05 631C2 :1A7836 AB <05 1C47D859 E79DC58< 0569<03<<053;;1958<<==I463;5=83;;=78<=> :320 389 85D61D58< :1918D => <05 =>>58918D G501;65 AB 1<2 :195:323:5276<=>F01;0<05;631C38<272<3185918E7:152 05:1A7836>7:<05:0569<03<<05;631C38<1258<1<659<=3 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2.,,(% 36=8D F1<0 18<5:52< 3< <05 :3<5 => -L 43 389 91:5;<59 <05 :524=8958< =% 827:38;5 =C438B <= 954=21< <05 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< - 6 - 36=8D F1<0 18<5:52< 518D 3DD:15G59 <05 4:5258< 344536 032A558>1659 ' C< 55G3 01CI=9 653:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=:<05;631C38<032:31259<05>=66=F18D;=8<58<1=82 3 #1:2<6B3<<05<1C5=><053;;1958<<05;631C38<F32 53:818D 2!)(((% 45: C=8<0 7< <05 :1A7836 032 ;=82195:59 <05 8=<1=836 18;=C5 => <05 ;631C38< 32 2.(((%45:C=8<0F01;012=8<056=F5:2195 A 5;=896B 975 <= <05 3;;1958< <05 ;631C38< 032 272<31859D:15G=7218E7:1525F32<:53<59321843<158<>=: 3 45:1=9 => . C=8<02 G58 3><5: 912;03:D5 >:=C <05 0=241<3605F328=<1834=21<1=8<=912;03:D5012:5D763: F=:I 5 032 27>>5:59 6=< => 4318 97:18D <:53<C58< =82195:18D <05 23C5 <05 =G5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3F3:959 AB<05:1A783612=8<056=F5:219505:1A78360328=< D:38<5938B;=C45823<1=8<=F3:92?6=22=>18;=C597:18D <05 6319%74 45:1=9@ 389 ?6=22 => 3C581<152@ 58;5 205 2=7D0<>=:58038;5C58<=><05;=C45823<1=8 - 7 - ) 8 <05 =<05: 0389 C< :55<1 3<16 56I7891 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 827:38;5 =C438B 032 :31259 >=66=F18D;=78<5:;=8<58<1=82 3 #1:2<6B 5G58 <0=7D0 <05 ;631C38< 032 ;631C59 <03< 05 F32 53:818D 2!)(((% 45: C=8<0 05 032 8=< 4:=97;59 38B 9=;7C58<2 <= 27A2<38<13<5 <05 23C5 05:5>=:5 <05 :1A7836 032 :1D0<6B 32252259 <05 8=<1=836 18;=C5=><05;631C38<322.(((%45:C=8<0 A 5;=896B <05 18E7:152 27>>5:59AB <05 ;631C38< 3:5 C18=: 18 83<7:5 =82195:18D <05 5G1958;5 => <05 9=;<=:2389<05C591;36:5;=:92<05=G5:366;=C45823<1=8 3F3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 12 E72< 389 :532=83A65 58;5 2052=7D0<>=:912C12236=><05344536 . 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05E79DC58<3893F3:9=><05:1A7836 !( <128=<1891247<5<03<<05;631C38<27>>5:5918E7:152 18 <05 :=39 <:3>>1; 3;;1958< <03< =;;7::59 =8 (.((!' - 8 - 975 <= <05 :320 389 85D61D58< :1918D => <05 :195: => <05 C=<=:;B;65A53:18D:5D12<:3<1=88=%%&' !! 05;631C38<;631C2<03<05F3253:818D2!)(((% 45: C=8<0 7< 05 032 8=< 4:=97;59 38B 9=;7C58<2 <= 52<3A6120<0523C505:5>=:518<053A258;5=>4:==>=> 18;=C5 8=<1=836 18;=C5 032 <= A5 32252259 2 45: <05 D719561852 122759 AB <05 3:83<3I3 <3<5 5D36 5:G1;52 7<0=:1<B >=: 3;;1958<2 <03< =;;7::59 18 <05 B53: (!' <05 8=<1=836 18;=C5 => <05 ;631C38< 032 <= A5 <3I58 32 2!(&(%4C ! 245:F=789;5:<1>1;3<5<05;631C38<032272<31859 0539 18E7:B 27>>5:59 >1<2 975 <= ;=663<18D => A6==9 18 <05 A:318 3I18D 18<= ;=82195:3<1=8 <05 954=21<1=8 => <05 9=;<=:38918E7:152C58<1=85918<05F=789;5:<1>1;3<5<05 :1A7836 032 :1D0<6B <3I58 <05 F0=65 A=9B 9123A161<B 3< 'L05;631C38<123D593A=7<.B53:23<<05<1C5=> <053;;1958< 389C76<14615: 34461;3A65 <= 012 3D5 D:=7412 ?!'@ 072 <05 ;631C38< 12 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => - 9 - *++ +, 2!(&(M!M!'M'L =8 3;;=78< => /6=22=>>7<7:518;=C5/ ! 75 <= <05 3;;1958< <05 ;631C38< 032 27>>5:59 D:15G=72 18E7:152 389 362= 7895:D=85 27:D5:B 5 F32 1843<158< 18 <05 0=241<36 >=: 3 45:1=9 => 8185 C=8<02 =82195:18D <05 4:=6=8D59 4318 97:18D <:53<C58< 32 F566 32<0545:C3858<9123A161<B;5:<1>159AB<059=;<=:F53:5 18;61859 <= 58038;5 <05 ;=C45823<1=8 3F3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 7895: <05 0539 => /4318 389 27>>5:18D2/ >:=C 2((((% <= *, 389 <05 ;631C38< 12 362= 58<1<659 >=: <05 ;=C45823<1=8 7895: <05 0539 => /6=22 => 3C581<152/*, !, 05 83<7:5 => 18E7:152 1891;3<52 <03< <05 ;631C38< C72<03G5A5587895::52<389<:53<C58<>=:345:1=9=>. C=8<02 =825N758<6B <05 ;631C38< 12 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => *- , 2!(&(M. C=8<02 7895:<050539?6=22=>18;=C597:18D63197445:1=9@ - 10 - !& =82195:18D<0583<7:5=>18E7:152<05;=C45823<1=8 3F3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 7895: =<05: 05392 12 E72< 389 :532=83A65 !- 072 <05 ;631C38< 12 58<1<659 >=: <05 >=66=F18D ;=C45823<1=8 ./01*234151607 6407013026* *2827606 9:3;0 749512< '*( *2827606 9:3;4* 573 '*( 31838927>>5:18D2 (((( )(((( 591;365K458252 ((((( ((((( #==98=7:120C58< ;=8G5B38;5389 3<<58938<;03:D52 !(((( !(((( =22=>18;=C597:18D 63197445:1=9 ( .&( =22=>3C581<152 ( ,(((( =22=>>7<7:518;=C5 -'.( ''-'( #7<7:5591;36K458252 &((( &((( 32< - - - 11 - !' 8<05:5276<<05>=66=F18D=:95:12432259 3 05344536122<<80641/273 A 05 E79DC58< => <05 631C2 :1A7836 12 C=91>159 ; 05;631C38<1258<1<659<=3<=<36;=C45823<1=8 =>* - , 9 05 827:38;5 =C438B 12 91:5;<59 <= 954=21< <05 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< 36=8D F1<0 18<5:52< O -L43 >:=C <05 93<5 => >1618D => <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361J3<1=8 F1<018 3 45:1=9=>21KF55I2>:=C<0593<5=>:5;514<=> ;=4B=><012E79DC58< - 12 - 5 05 954=21< 389 :565325 => 58038;59 ;=C45823<1=8 20366 A5 32 45: <05 =:95: => <05 :1A7836 !6, '$!( & !6, '"&# "( & 12<=!6=&)