- 1 - !!"#!$ % "&"'""! ""'' ()* + ! " # $ % &"" ' ( ! " )* " +, &' - " ! " $( ! " Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " % &" '!. ! ! ( ' ' $&(' ( ' "( ' ) *! !! ! ' ' ' " " - " ' " "' /" ' ' 0 0 1" &! 2345 672 3489:2;6< => ?234;25 @=9;<2? >=4 A=67 672 B346C2< ! 7C< 3BB23? C< B42>24425 383C;<6 672 D958:2;6 3;5 3E34553625) *! !!C;= ! B3<<25AF672 =6=4 @@C52;6?3C:<4CA9;3?=-CD3F3B943 72 >3@6< => 672 @3<2 342 6736 =; ! 36 3A=96 * B: =; "3A3?2<7E34 CD3F3B943 =35 949<C553BB3 E3< 8=C;8 =; :=6=4@F@?2 A234C;8 428C<6436C=; = ! *!3667366C:23:3GC@3A@3:2C;343<73;5 - 3 - ;28?C82;6 :3;;24 3;5 53<725 6= 672 :=6=4@F@?2 3;5 @39<25 3@@C52;65926=E7C@772<9<63C;25>363?C;D94C2<3;55C25=; 672<B=6 ) 72@?3C:B26C6C=;E3<>C?25AF672EC>23;5:=6724 => 672 52@23<25 949<C553BB3 373;63BB3 E7= :26 EC67 3; 3@@C52;6 =; ! @?3C:C;8 @=:B2;<36C=; => <$ 72 4CA9;3? @=;<C524C;8 2;6C42 :3624C3? =; 42@=45 843;625 @=:B2;<36C=; => <) EC67 C;6242<6 36 672 4362 => H B24 3;;9: >4=: 5362 => B26C6C=; 6C?? 423?CI36C=; 884C2J25AF672<3C5=452467C<3BB23?C<B42>24425 C; E7C@7 C6 C< @=;62;525 6736 672 3:=9;6 843;625 9;524 672 7235=<<=>=;<=46C9:'9;243?GB2;<2<3;5=<<=><6362 342:238243;5C6C<>946724@=;62;52567363<B24672@C636C=; 42B=4625C;( #*# " A26E22; C6E3<72?5 6736=<<=><6362=<<=>=;<=46C9:3;5'9;243?2GB2;<2< <7=9?5A22;73;@25366724362=> H>=42J24F67422F234< A96 C6 E3< ;=6 @=;<C52425 6 C< >946724 @=;62;525 6736 672 4CA9;3? 843;625 =;?F H C;6242<6 A96 3< B24 672 @C636C=; - 4 - 42B=4625 C; # " ## A26E22; E7C@7<7=9?5A2 2;73;@256=*H 7242 C< ;= 5C<B962 428345C;8 @=:B2;<36C=; 9;524 672 7235 =<< => 2B2;52;@F C2 !** 26C6C=;24 =C<672EC>23;5B26C6C=;24=!C<672:=672472;@223@7 => 672: 342 2;6C6?25 >=4 3; 3:=9;6 => <) 9;524 672 7235 =<< => =;<=46C9: 3;5 'C?C3? =;<=46C9: 3< B24 672 @C636C=; 42B=4625 C; ! " # ! # $ % 3;5 A=67 => 672: 342 2;6C6?25 >=4 < 9;524 672 @=;J2;6C=;3?7235<C2?=<<=>2<63623;5>9;243?2GB2;<2< $ ; 3?? 672 6=63? @=:B2;<36C=; @=:2< 6= , -EC67C;6242<636HB243;;9:>4=:6725362 =>B26C6C=;6C??6725362=>423?CI36C=; 723E345=>@=:B2;<36C=;B3<<25AF6724CA9;3? :=5C>C253<9;5240 1 (2018) 18 SCC 130 - 5 - ./0,123.4,/564 2745 =<<=>2B2;52;@F < !** =<<=><6362 < =<<=>'9;243?GB2;<2< < =<< => <B=9<3? 3;5 >C?C3? @=;<=46C9:&<) G!( < H 2<@3?36C=; >=4 67422 @=:B?2625 F234< =; @=;J2;6C=;3? 7235< K< L L M < , - @@=45C;8?F 672 @=:B2;<36C=; C< 2;73;@25 >4=: <))*6=<) * EC67C;6242<6366724362=>H >4=:6725362=>B26C6C=;6C??423?CI36C=; * ;67242<9?6672>=??=EC;8=4524C<B3<<250 C( 723BB23?C<& CC( 72 @?3C:3;6< 3BB2??3;6< 342 2;6C6?25 >=4 672 6=63? @=:B2;<36C=; => <) * EC67 C;6242<6 36 H B24 3;;9: >4=: 672 5362 => B26C6C=; 6C?? 672 5362=>423?CI36C=; CCC( 2<B=;52;6=!N;<943;@2=:B3;FC<3?4235F 52B=<C625 672 3:=9;6 3E34525 AF 672 4CA9;3?. - 6 - 72;@2 42<B=;52;6 =! C< 5C42@625 6= 52B=<C6 672 2;73;@25 @=:B2;<36C=; => < EC67 C;6242<636HEC67C;=;2:=;67>4=:6725362=> 67C<=4524 CJ( ; <9@7 52B=<C6 672 3BB2??3;6< 342 B24:C6625 6= EC67543E 672 2;6C42 3:=9;6 3< B24 672 3BB=46C=;:2;6=>6724CA9;3? ,0- ('""!* &! C<6=0?=0 0