- 1 - ! "!#$ %#&!!!# # '#!( ! " # $ $% & $ ' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (&( ! " '# ) $ ) ( * $ & ( + ,, - " # " ,# ) . . + - /01 23404056 01 70839 :11:0806; 4/3 5<93< 9:439 ( 2:1139 06 23=0:8 :13 5 $ & 5613>?3648@ : A:69:A?1 01 15?;/4 :;:0614 4/3 <3125693641 45 <34<:6173< 4/3 234040563< 06 /01 5<0;06:8 28:=357=567063A3646:A38@:4364<:8<0156 36;:8?<? /3 234040563< =5643691 4/:4 /01 4<:6173< 7<5A 36;:8?<? 364<:8 <0156 45 :8:B?<:;0 364<:8 <0156 01 C058:40C3 57 4/3 2<06=02831 57 6:4?<:8 D?140=3 4/3<3B@ 067<06;06; /01 7?69:A364:8 <0;/41 ?693< <40=83 57 4/3 561404?4056 57 690: 3 1?BA041 4/:4 /3 /:1 B336 06 D?90=0:8=?1459@106=3$ &06 5 ' &:69 - 3 - /:1 A:064:0639 ;559 =569?=4 06 :==5<9:6=3 E04/ 2<0156 <?831 401/01;<03C:6=34/:4064/3:B136=357=5;3645< D?14070:B83 <3:1561 75< 1?=/ 4<:6173< /3 01 13<05?18@ 2<3D?90=39 :1 4/3 0A2?;639 4<:6173< :773=41 /01 <0;/4 45 :==311/019C5=:43:14/3=:1301B306;:9D?90=:439064/3 5?<485=:43906 36;:8?<? & 3:<639 =5?6138 75< 4/3 234040563< <3043<:406; 4/3:B5C31?BA0110561/:128:=39<380:6=3564/393=01056 57 4/3 55<906:43 36=/ 06 ") 5 &('( '# 3 1?BA041 4/:4 4/3 7:=41 :69 =0<=?A14:6=31 06 4/3 2<31364 =:13 :<3 1?B14:640:88@ 093640=:8 45 4/513 06 4/3 1:09 93=01056 :69 4/3<375<3 4/3 <:405 8:09 95E6 4/3<306 1>?:<38@:228031454/3234040563<F1=:13 ' 3< =564<: 83:<639 0;/ 5?<4 5C3<6A364 83:93</:115?;/445D?1407@4/34<:6173<=56436906;4/:4 4/3 234040563< /:1 65 C31439 <0;/4 45 061014 ?256 06=:<=3<:405606:2:<40=?8:<2<0156 4011?BA044394/:44/3 - 4 - 4<:6173<7<5A 36;:8?<?45:8:B?<:;0 364<:8 <0156 E:1 63=31104:439 2?<38@ 56 13=?<04@ =561093<:40561 :69 E:1 3773=439 2?<1?:64 45 4/3 <3>?0104056 A:93 B@ 4/3 /037 ?23<064369364364<:8<0156 36;:8?<? /:C3/3:<94/383:<639=5?6138:223:<06;56 B54/ 10931 :69 23<?139 4/3 A:43<0:8 56 <3=5<9 06=8?906; 4/35<93<0A2?;639 $ /3234040563<:6?693<4<0:82<01563<859;39:4 36;:8?<? 364<:8 <0156 /:1 65E B336 4<:6173<<39 45 :8:B?<:;0364<:8<01562?<1?:6445:65<93<2:1139B@ 4/383:<6393110561-?9;3 /35<93<<3C3:814/:41?=/ 4<:6173< E:1 2<5A2439 B@ : <3>?0104056 1?BA04439 B@ 4/3 /037?23<06436936457364<:8<0156 36;:8?<?E/506 4?<6:=439?256:<325<4574/3?23<06436936457580=3 <:6=/ 770=3 36;:8?<? :69 4/3 =5AA?60=:4056 57 4/30<3=45<363<:857<01561:695<<3=4056:83<C0=31 =0406;G13=?<04@<3:1561 H64/:4B:1014/3234040563<E:1 1/074397<5A 36;:8?<?45:8:B?<:;0364<:8<0156 - 5 - /3 55<906:43 36=/ 06 4/3 D?9;A364 <38039 ?256 B@ 4/3 234040563< E/083 =561093<06; /:1=:43;5<0=:88@/3894/:44/31/07406;57:2<01563< 016304/3<:A3<3:9A06014<:40C365<:A060143<0:8:=4 /3 56FB83 23I 5?<4 /:1 8:09 95E6 4/:4 E/363C3< 1?=/ 1/07406;0115?;/4B@E:@57D?90=0:85<>?:10D?90=0:85<93< 04 B3=5A31 5B80;:45<@?256 4/3=56=3<639 5?<445 :228@ 041A069454/3=0<=?A14:6=312<5D3=43975<1?=/4<:6173< :69 3>?:88@ 45 :775<9 :6 3773=40C3 5225<4?604@ 45 4/3 2<01563< 45 28:=3 /01 5BD3=40561 /01 1:73;?:<9 785E1 90<3=48@7<5A4/3=561404?4056:8;?:<:6433?693<<40=83 4/:4 65 23<156 1/:88 B3 932<0C39 57 /01 80B3<4@ 3I=324 B@ 2<5=39?<3 314:B801/39 B@ 8:E E/0=/ 01 7:0< D?14 :69 <3:156:B83 ( 64/32<31364=:130401654069012?434/:44/3 234040563<E:163C3<13<C39E04/:=52@574/3<3>?0104056 A:93 B@ 4/3 /037 ?23<064369364 57 364<:8 <0156 36;:8?<?65<E:1/3;0C36:65225<4?604@45=5643144/3 - 6 - ;<5?691?<;394/3<306 /3234040563<E:14/?1936039/01 <0;/445B3/3:<9B375<3:65<93<:9C3<138@:773=406;/0A E:12:1139 /015A011056;531454/3<554574/3A:443< :14/35<93<0A2?;639016542<3=3939B@=5A280:6=3E04/ 4/3 2<06=02831 57 6:4?<:8 D?140=3 ?<4/3<A5<3 4/3 5<93< 2:1139B@4/383:<6393110561-?9;3A3<38@<3=5<914/3 2/<:13 G13=?<04@ <3:1561H :1 4/3 ;<5?69 75< 4<:6173< 4 6304/3< 901=85131 4/3 6:4?<3 57 1?=/ 13=?<04@ 4/<3:4 65< 93A5614<:431 :6 :2280=:4056 57 D?90=0:8 A069 45 4/3 A:43<0:8128:=39B@4/32<0156:?4/5<04031 ?=/:=<@240= <3=04:8 7:881 1/5<4 57 4/3 14:69:<91 <3>?0<39 E/36 7?69:A364:8<0;/41?693<<40=83:<3:414:J3 % 6 ?693<4<0:8 2<01563< =56406?31 45 36D5@ :88 =561404?4056:8 2<543=40561 1:C3 4/513 E/0=/ :<3 63=311:<08@ =?<4:0839 B@ 4/3 7:=4 57 8:E7?8 =?1459@ /3 <0;/4 45 8073 :69 23<156:8 80B3<4@ ?693< <40=83 36=5A2:1131 4/3 <0;/4 45 7:0< 2<5=39?<3 /?A:63 4<3:4A364 :69 2<543=4056 :;:0614 :<B04<:<@ 3I3<=013 57 25E3< 7 4/3 4<:6173< 57 :6 ?693<4<0:8 2<01563< 01 45 B3 - 7 - 5<93<39 4/3 5?<4 A?14 B:8:6=3 4/3 13=?<04@ =56=3<61 2<5D3=439 B@ 4/3 :?4/5<04031 E04/ 4/3 83;040A:43 <0;/41 57 4/32<01563<4539?=:4056<3/:B0804:40567:A08@C0104:4056 :69 :==311 45 83;:8 :11014:6=3 6 4/3 0614:64 =:13 4/3 5<93< 0A2?;639 9531 654 <3783=4 :6@ 1?=/ B:8:6=06; 3I3<=013 6143:9 04 2<5=3391 56 : B:<3 :113<4056 57 G13=?<04@ <3:1561H E04/5?4 901=85106; 4/3 7:=4?:8 B:101 75< 1?=/=56=8?1056 /015?<4014/3<375<3574/3=561093<395206056 4/:44/383:<6393110561-?9;3/:17:083945901=/:<;34/3 5B80;:405657:228@06;/01A0697:0<8@:695BD3=40C38@:69 /:1:8159360394/3234040563<:65225<4?604@45B3/3:<9 B375<3 3773=406; /01 4<:6173< /3 0A2?;639 5<93< /:1 4/?1<31?84390613<05?12<3D?90=3454/3234040563<E/5:1 :6?693<4<0:82<01563<<34:061/01<0;/4457:0<2<5=39?<3 ==5<906;8@ 4/3 5<93< 9:439 ( 90<3=406; 4/3 4<:6173<574/3234040563<7<5A 36;:8?<?364<:8<015645 :8:B?<:;0 364<:8 <0156 01 ?61?14:06:B83 06 8:E /3 - 8 - 234040563< 01 36404839 45 B3 <34<:6173<<39 45 36;:8?<? 364<:8<0156 5< 4/3 75<3;506; <3:1561 4/01 5?<4 2<5=3391 452:114/375885E06;. "0#/32340405601!K "00# /3 0A2?;639 5<93< 9:439 ( 2:1139 06 23=0:8 :13 5 $ & 236906; 56 4/3 7083 57 4/3 83:<639,,9904056:804@0C08:693110561 -?9;3 36;:8?<? :4 663I?<3 14:691 >?:1/39K "000# 3125693641 :<3 /3<3B@90<3=439 45 <34<:6173< 234040563< 45 36;:8?<? 364<:8 <015675<4/E04/ !)* '!!# #( & 014 5 .& - 9 - L M " # . + - +!, 743< 901251:8 57 4/3 23404056 4/3 83:<639 =5?6138 :223:<06; 75< 4/3 :4056:8 6C3140;:4056 ;36=@ " # 5<:88@ A5C39 4/3 A:443< =56436906; 4/:4 4/3 2<31364 2340405604138701654A:064:06:B83564E5=5?641.70<148@75< 656D50693< 57 : 63=311:<@ 2:<4@ 6:A38@ 4/3 K :69 13=5698@ 4/:4 4/3 2<523< <3A39@ :C:08:B83 45 4/3 234040563<01B@E:@57:6:223:8?693<3=4056574/3 :4056:8 6C3140;:4056 ;36=@ =4 ( B375<3 4/3 0C01056 36=/ :694/3<375<3 4/3 2<31364 23404056 ?693< 3=4056 ( 57 4/3 /:<:40@: :;:<0J ?<:J1/: :6/04: &01654A:064:06:B83 - 10 - :C06; /3:<9 4/3 83:<639 13605< =5?6138 75< 4/3 234040563<:694/383:<639=5?6138:223:<06;75<4/3 4/31/5<4>?3140564/:4:<013175<=561093<:405601E/34/3< 4/3 01 : 63=311:<@ 2:<4@ 45 4/3 2<5=33906;1 06 4/3 7:=41:69=0<=?A14:6=31574/32<31364=:13 & 401654069012?434/:44/3/037?23<064369364 57 364<:8 <01561 36;:8?<? 1?BA04439 : <3>?0104056 133J06; 4<:6173< 57 =3<4:06 ?693<4<0:8 2<01563<1 45 C:<05?1 =364<:82<01561:=<5114/34:435613=?<04@=561093<:40561 ?<1?:64454/31:09<3>?01040564/383:<63904@0C08:69 3110561 -?9;3 36;:8?<? 2:1139 4/3 0A2?;639 5<93< 90<3=406;4/34<:6173<57:==?139 51 45'454/3364<:8 <0156 38:;:C0K :==?139 51 :69 $ 45 4/3 364<:8 <0156 :8:B?<:;0K :==?139 51 :69 ( 45 4/3 364<:8 <01560D:@:2?<:K:==?139 51 %:69454/3364<:8 <0156 /0C:A5;;:K :69 :==?139 51 :69 45 4/3 364<:8 <0156 @1?<? /3 234040563< /3<306 E/5 01 :<<:@39 :1:==?139 5 '06 4/313110561 =:13 /:1 B336 - 11 - 4<:6173<<39454/3364<:8<0156 38:;:C02?<1?:64454/3 1:095<93< ' 40123<4063644565434/:44/30A2?;6395<93<01 654 563 2:1139 ?693< 4/3 2<5C010561 57 4/3 68:E7?8 =40C04031"<3C364056#=4%$"# 64/3=564<:<@ 4/3 3640<3 2<5=311 3A:6:431 7<5A : <3>?0104056 A5C39 ?693< 4/3 2<5C010561 57 4/3 <01561 =4 (%' :69 4/3 :<6:4:J: <0156 ?831 :99<31106; :9A06014<:40C3 :69 13=?<04@ =56=3<61 /3 83:<639 3110561 -?9;3 B375<3 E/5A4/3=<0A06:82<5=33906;1:<3236906;/:13I3<=0139 D?<0190=4056064/01<3;:<915838@564/3:9A06014<:40C3:69 13=?<04@:123=41:1<3>?010405639B@4/32<0156:?4/5<04031 /3<375<34/3<583574/3 :14/306C3140;:406;:;36=@ ?693<4/39531654<3693<04:63=311:<@5<2<523< 2:<4@ 45 4/3 2<31364 2<5=33906;1 E/0=/ :<013 5?4 57 :6 :9A06014<:40C35<93<?693<4/3<01561=4 /3=564364056 57 656D50693< 57 : 63=311:<@ 2:<4@ 01 4/3<375<3 A01=56=30C39:69?61?14:06:B83 - 12 - ?<4/3<A5<3106=34/30A2?;6395<93<012:1139 ?693<4/32<5C010561574/3<01561=4:69654?693<4/3 =4 5<4/3 4/3 =564364056 4/:4 4/3 234040563<F1 568@<3A39@8031B@E:@57:6:223:8?693<3=405657 4/3 =4B375<34/30C01056 36=/=:6654B3:==32439 /3<3A39@?693<3=405601=5670639455<93<12:1139 B@23=0:85?<415<31105615?<41?693<4/3 =45< 4/3 /35<93<0A2?;639064/32<31364=:13B306; :9A06014<:40C3066:4?<3:692:1139?693<4/3<01561=4 4/3234040563<01E388E04/06/01<0;/44506C5J34/306/3<364 D?<0190=4056 57 4/01 5?<4 ?693< 3=4056 '( 57 4/3 /:<:40@: :;:<0J?<:J1/::6/04:& $ /3<380:6=328:=39B@4/383:<639=5?613875<4/3 56 4/3 D?9;A364 06 "" " #" $ % & & #&'() ( *" # + ,-. 01 A0128:=39 :69 9531 654 :9C:6=3 4/3 =564364056 57 4/3 <312569364 :;36=@ 106=3 4/3 1:09 D?9;A364 23<4:061 45 5<93<1 2:1139 06 4/3 3I3<=013 57 - 13 - 25E3<1 ?693< 4/3 =4 E/3<3:1 4/3 2<31364 =:13 01 75?693956:901406=414:4?45<@7<:A3E5<J:845;34/3< 6 80;/4 57 4/3 75<3;506; 901=?11056 4/01 5?<4 70691 65 A3<04 06 4/3 5<:8 1?BA0110561 :9C:6=39 B@ 4/3 83:<639 =5?6138 75< 4/3 /3 0A2?;639 5<93< /:C06; :8<3:9@B3363I:A0639:69901251395756A3<0414/3<301 65;<5?6945<3=:885<<352364/31:A3 ==5<906;8@4/3 5<:8 <3>?314 A:93 B@ 4/3 14:691 <3D3=439 :69 65 7?<4/3<5<93<1:<3E:<<:6439 !)* '!!# #( & 014 5 .%8 5 .