Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 56979 (KAR)
SMT. KAVITHA KISHORE v. N K SHIVAPRASAD
MFA/1001/2013 · 2025-09-19
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 56979 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 56979 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#$! !! %&' () !! %&' !! (
)
!"##$! % & '
'
(
'
' )
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
!"##$! '
'
* $
' ##
!"## % & ' '
+ '
#$#! *(
$&(
'
) * !$# ' #
)
*
(
)
!"##$! & '
'
(
- 3 -
'
' )
' !"##$! '
'
*
$ ' ##
!"##
& ' '
+ '
#$#! *(
$&(
'
)*!$# ' #
) *
(
)
'
*
"
- 4 -
$! & '
'
(
'
' )
'
$! '
'
* $
' ##
& ' '
+ '
##$#! *(
$&(
'
)*!$# ' #
) *
- 5 -
)* ' ,
, -)
$
./ 0123456 7588/9 5 :;<<;4 5=509 14 ';8;>#;>#549;># ;4!#$#
./ ?1:@1<8 14 @./ 5::19/4@ ;::300/9 ;4 ###5@52;3@#!7<5@566/8.756A5<5140;59 4/50 238 8@;7 50/ @./ 7/@1@1;4/08 14 @./ 8519 ' <5@@/08 66 @./ @.0// 7/@1@1;4/08 838@514/9 14B301/8 549 @./A >16/9 :651< 7/@1@1;48 :651<14C :;<7/485@1;4 ;> 8######
./ 0123456 :;4819/014C @./ /4@10/ /?19/4:/ ;4 0/:;09 C054@/9 8#"#" 14 '; ;> #+ 8"### 14 '; ;> # 549 8$### 14 '; ;> # =1@. 14@/0/8@ 5@
"D 7/0 5443< CC01/?/9 2A @./ 8519 B39C</4@ 549
- 6 -
5=509 @./ 7/@1@1;4/08 50/ 2/>;0/ @.18 ;30@ ;
### ;> #18 >16/9 5C5148@ @./ B39C</4@ 549 5=509 14 '; ;> #+ ; ;> # 18 >16/9 5C5148@@./B39C</4@5495=50914';;># 549 ;## ;> # 18 >16/9 5C5148@ @./ B39C</4@ 5495=50914';;>#+
4 ;### ;> # &'; ;> #( 1@ 18 :;4@/49/9 @.5@ 7/@1@1;4/0 838@514/9 C01/?;38 14B301/8 549 =58 .;871@561E/9 >0;< ### @; ###549./.58838@514/9@./>;66;=14C14B301/8,
!
C514 @./ 7/@1@1;4/0 =58 59<1@@/9 ;4 ### 549 349/0=/4@ 9/2019/</4@ 349/0 549 49/08 451614C 9;4/ >;0 >05:@30/ 8@52161E5@1;4 549 0@/0156 /776/054C1; &01C.@( 6;=/0 61<2 9;4/ C514 ;4 ## ./ =58 59<1@@/9 @; .;871@56 >;0 0/<;?56 ;> 1<7654@8 549 918:.50C/9 ;4 ### / .58 568;
- 7 -
70;93:/9 5 :;7A ;> @./ *;349 /0@1>1:5@/ 5@ F /4C56303=.1:.918:6;8/8@./>;66;=14C14B301/8,
!"# $ %
" %
&"' ()& %
*"# %
+,
" /504/9 :;348/6 >;0 @./ 577/6654@ :;4@/49/9 @.5@@./577/6654@=5883>>/014C>0;<7/0<54/4@7.A81:56 91852161@A @; @./ /F@/4@ ;> #D @; @./ 01C.@ 6;=/0 61<2 549#D@;@./=.;6/2;9A589/7;8/92A@./9;:@;0*
" =.; @0/5@/9 .1< ./ 0123456 .58 /00/9 14 5=50914C ;46A8#### 349/0@././59;>6;88;>14:;</93014C @0/5@</4@ 7/01;9549.58 /00/9 145=50914C </5C/083< 349/0 @./ ./59 ;> 6;88 ;> 5</41@1/8 549 @;=5098 :;4?/A54:/5@@/4954@:.50C/84;3018.</4@54991/@/@:
- 8 -
./0/>;0/./0/G3/8@/9>;0/4.54:/</4@;>:;<7/485@1;4 349/091>>/0/4@./598
$ ./7/@1@1;4/0=5858@39/4@5C/9$A/508 / .58 /F5<14/9 .1<8/6> 58 * 549 .58 70;93:/9 918:.50C/83<<50A5@F=.1:.918:6;8/8@.5@./=58 59<1@@/9 ;4 ### 549 918:.50C/9 ;4 ### & 95A8( 549 54;@./0 918:.50C/ 83<<50A 5@ F =.1:.918:6;8/8 @.5@ ./ =58 59<1@@/9;4 ##549 918:.50C/9;4### /.58568;70;93:/9F" 7.;@;C057.8549* !.5870;93:/91475@1/4@0/:;09 5@ F * .58 9/7;8/9 @.5@ ./ .58 87/4@ 8!#### @;=5098 </91:56 /F7/48/8 549 14 @.18 0/C509./.5870;93:/9</91:5621668587/0F$@;@./ /F@/4@ ;> 8 1883/9 2A @./ .;871@56 14 =.1:. @./ 7/@1@1;4/0 =58 @0/5@/9 549 F 50/ @./ 70/8:017@1;48 ./ 0123456 .58 C054@/9 5 83< ;> 8### @; @./ 7/@1@1;4/0 349/0 @.18 ./59 =.1:. 4//984;14@/0>/0/4:/2A@.18;30@
- 9 -
.38 14 566 5=509 ;> :;<7/485@1;4 7588/9 2A @./012345618<;91>1/958349/0,
/4:/ @./ :;<7/485@1;4 18 /4.54:/9 @; *
"
"( 58 5C5148@ 8$### 56;4C =1@. 14@/0/8@5@"D7/05443<>0;<@./95@/;>7/@1@1;4@166@./ 95@/ ;> 9/7;81@ 549 @./ 483054:/ ;<754A/87;49/4@ ; 18 910/:@/9 @; 9/7;81@ 8!### 56;4C =1@. 14@/0/8@ 5@ "D 7/0 5443< =1@.14 ;4/ <;4@.
>0;< @.18 ;09/0 50@1:36508 <;34@ 148 51454983>>/014C !#### ;88 ;> 14:;</ 93014C @0/5@</4@7/01;9 !### /91:56F7/48/8 ### </41@1/8 !### ;4?/A54:/ 5@@/4954@ :.50C/84;3018.</4@549 91/@/@: #### +,-
"
"
- 10 -
# ./7/@1@1;4/0=585C/9$A/5085@@./@1</;> 5::19/4@ 14 # 549 2A @.18 @1</ ./ .58 5@@514/9 <5B;01@A 549 @./0/>;0/ ./ 18 7/0<1@@/9 @; =1@.905= @./ 5<;34@56;4C=1@.14@/0/8@5::03/9
4 ; ;> # &'; ;> #( 1@ 18 :;4@/49/9 @.5@ 7/@1@1;4/0 838@514/9 C01/?;38 14B301/8 549 @;;H @0/5@</4@ 58 54 1475@1/4@ >0;< ###@;#"## /.58838@514/9@./>;66;=14C 14B301/8, (
, ,% *
%
& -,%
! . ()& ()&
,
/@1@1;4/0 /F5<14/9 .1<8/6> 58 * 549 .58 70;93:/9 F" *;349 /0@1>1:5@/ =.1:. 918:6;8/8 @./ >;66;=14C14B301/8,
- 11 -
( / " ! ()& , %
"
,
, %
*
" ,%
& . ()& ()& %
! +,00
/504/9 :;348/6 >;0 @./ 577/6654@ 832<1@@/9 @.5@@./577/6654@=585C/952;3@#A/5085@@./@1</;> 5::19/4@549=58/50414C8!#### @;##### 7/0 <;4@.2A9;14C23814/88;>;30854905?/68549./.58 70;93:/9 0/@3048@;8377;0@.18:651<
./ ;:@;0 =.; =58 /F5<14/9 58 * " .58 588/88/9 @./ 91852161@A ;> "D @; 01C.@ 6;=/0 61<2 549 D@;@./=.;6/2;9A549$D@;6/>@377/061<2549 D @; @./ =.;6/ 2;9A ./ 9;:@;0 .58 9/7;8/9 @.5@ >05:@30/ ;> @1215 8.;=8 <56 341;4 549 750@156 341;4 =1@. 1<7654@8 14 81@3+ >05:@30/ ;> >12365 8.;=8 <56 341;4 549
- 12 -
>05:@30/;>C0/5@/0@32/0;81@A;>6/>@.3</03818341@/9=1@. 1<7654@8 14 81@3 ;4819/014C @./ /?19/4:/ ;> * " @./ 0123456 .58 588/88/9 @./ 91852161@A ;> @./ 577/6654@ 5@ !D@;@./=.;6/2;9A54957761/9<36@1761/0;>-!-23@ =.16/ :56:365@14C @./ 0123456 .58 @5H/4 @./ 91852161@A 5@ D=.1:.4//98@;2/14@/0>/0/9=1@.2A@.18;30@549 91852161@A;>#D18@5H/42A@.18;30@;4819/014C@./ 14:;</70;;>>30418./92A@./577/6654@@./0123456.58 588/88/9 @./ <;4@.6A 14:;</ ;> @./ 577/6654@ 58 8$ 7/0 <;4@. =.1:. 4//98 4; 14@/0>/0/4:/ 2A @.18;30@./0/>;0/>3@30/6;88;>14:;</=;0H8;3@58 &8$ I I ! I #D( J 8# ./ 5<;34@ 5=509/9 349/0 7514 549 83>>/014C 6;88 ;> 5</41@1/8 549 :;4?/A54:/ 5@@/4954@ :.50C/8 4;3018.</4@54991/@/@:0/G310/8@;2/14@/0>/0/9=1@. 2A@.18;30@5491@185::;0914C6A/4.54:/9
! .38 14 566 5=509 ;> :;<7/485@1;4 7588/9 2A @./012345618<;91>1/958349/0,
- 13 -
" /4:/ @./ :;<7/485@1;4 18 /4.54:/9 @; *"
"./( 58 5C5148@ 8#"#" 56;4C =1@. 14@/0/8@5@"D7/05443<>0;<@./95@/;>7/@1@1;4@166@./ 95@/ ;> 9/7;81@ 549 @./ 483054:/ ;<754A/87;49/4@ ; 18 910/:@/9 @; 9/7;81@ 8!$" 56;4C =1@. 14@/0/8@ 5@ "D 7/0 5443< =1@.14 ;4/ <;4@.
>0;< @.18 ;09/0
50@1:36508 <;34@ 148 51454983>>/014C $!### ;88;>14:;</93014C6519 37 7/01;9 &8$I <;4@.8( # /91:56F7/48/8 !!" ;88;>>3@30//50414C # ;88;>5</41@1/8 !### ;4?/A54:/ 5@@/4954@ :.50C/84;3018.</4@549 91/@/@: #### 3@30/</91:5@1;4 #### +,-
"
"./
- 14 -
$ 4 ;## ;> # &'; ;> #( 1@ 18 :;4@/49/9 @.5@ 7/@1@1;4/0 838@514/9 C01/?;38 14B301/8 549 @;;H @0/5@</4@ 58 54 1475@1/4@ >0;< ### @; ## ./ .58 838@514/9 @./ >;66;=14C14B301/8,
( 1 ()& %
* 2 %
& ,%
! 3 ,
/@1@1;4/0 /F5<14/9 .1<8/6> 58 * 549 .58 70;93:/9 F! *;349 /0@1>1:5@/ =.1:. 918:6;8/8 @./ >;66;=14C14B301/8,
( 1 ()&
%
*
- 15 -
* 05<5:.54905 =.; @0/5@/9 * .58588/88/9@./91852161@A;>#D@;@./6;=/061<2549 #D@;@./=.;6/2;9A23@=.16/:56:365@14C@./0123456 .58@5H/4@./91852161@A5@D;4819/014C@.//?19/4:/ ;> * 1> 09 ;> #D @; @./ 6;=/0 61<2 18 @5H/4 1@ :;</8 @; D 91852161@A ;4819/014C @./ 5C/ ;> @./ 7/@1@1;4/0 5@ @./ @1</ ;> @./ 5::19/4@ @./ 0123456 .58 57761/9 <36@1761/0 ;> -!- =.1:. 18 4;@ 14 91873@/ ./0/>;0/ >3@30/ 6;88 ;> 14:;</ :;</8 @; 8"###II!IDJ8$##
# ./ 5<;34@8 5=509/9 349/0 6;88 ;> 14:;</ 93014C @0/5@</4@ 7/01;9 6;88 ;> 5</41@1/8 :;4?/A54:/ 4;3018.</4@54991/@/@:0/G310/8@;2/14@/0>/0/9=1@. 2A@.18;30@5491@185::;0914C6A/4.54:/9
.38 14 566 5=509 ;> :;<7/485@1;4 7588/9 2A @./012345618<;91>1/958349/0,
- 16 -
/4:/ @./ :;<7/485@1;4 18 /4.54:/9 @;
*/""/( 58 5C5148@ 8"### 56;4C =1@. 14@/0/8@5@"D7/05443<>0;<@./95@/;>7/@1@1;4@166@./ 95@/ ;> 9/7;81@ 549 @./ 483054:/ ;<754A/87;49/4@ ; 18 910/:@/9 @; 9/7;81@ 8""## 56;4C =1@. 14@/0/8@ 5@ "D 7/0 5443< =1@.14 ;4/ <;4@. >0;< @.18 ;09/0
50@1:36508 <;34@ 148 51454983>>/014C #### ;88 ;> 14:;</ 93014C @0/5@</4@ &8"###I <;4@.8( ### /91:56F7/48/8 ## ;88;>>3@30/14:;</ $## ;88;>5</41@1/8 !### ;4?/A54:/ 5@@/4954@ :.50C/84;3018.</4@549 91/@/@: #### 3@30/</91:5@1;4 #### +,- /""/
- 17 -
4@/0<8;>@./52;?/@./577/56850/9187;8/9 ;>
*0( %!' $
18@;,6;,