Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 5696 (PNJ)

BALWANT SINGH NOW DECEASED THROUGH LRS v. STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS

CWP/37308/2025 · 2026-03-23

Harkesh Manuja

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

CWP No.37308 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CWP No.37308 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CWP No.37308 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CWP No.37308 of 20 (" '' +. - " 0(!+"(%!%$ ' !-(!:/ $% " "&  $(!+. %)"4%0 ' $  - )!- ' "("(%! J.+!-% *)-:0 !"+  F" G# - 4( +8+ %.. # C#< 8+ +''.  A# +''. %) +8+ ("& / 2  C# (! +'' +''. '(!4 (0')  4" +(( C#< 0+(! 2025 (O&M)    ' $  - +" "&  (!"+!4  %$ %$0+2 "3+.) ' "+(!(!:"%"&  "&(%)",("8+0% +''%'(+ %0  %$ )4& +'' +. +"&  "&+! -   4"(%! D %$ "&  -%8! # . 3+!"'++:+'&% F"+4" -&  )!-  # !"& 4+ %$"& +'' ..+!",8& 4(- -,/+ -%!+8+-(! % 8+- 8   ' !-(!: (! +'' +. / $ %.. 4"%'%4 - -"%4%!(- "& ( #<#<<<#&  +$" ,$ &+''.(4+" C#<#<<;/+ -%!"& *)-:0 !"%$ +"&(+''.(4+"(%!"&+"8+& .-"% ''.(4+"(%!# A# &%):& "&   ( !% 9)+ . 8 ''.(4+"(%! ( 0+(!"+(!+/. , (! "&  (! %)" %0("" - "% "+2  !%"  %$ "&  $+4 8+-8  ' !-(!:8& !"&  4"(% "& ' 4(+.+!--("(!4"(3 $+4")+.'% 2 '"(!0(!-"&+" 4"(%!D(+/ C# &  4"(%!D+''.(4+"(%!-+ ! %#B+!-;%$;DB8 '' +. "&  $%0 8   ' !-(!:# & ''.(4+"(%! ' !-(!: "(.. "&  +'' +. (!4('. ,"& (:&%)"(4% 4"+! 0'):! - *)-:0 !" "&+" "&   4+!!% 4"(%!D(!3( 8%$ +- '1)0 ((!: $% 4%!(- +"(%! &  # % - C#<#<<; $%  $(F+"(%! (! .(:&" %$ +(!"+(!+/. #%8 3 ,(!4 "& %. %$ "&  %"&  .+!-%8!  9)+ " +0 +49)(("(%!'%4 -(!:8 '(+" $% '%!- !"%#"%8+(" ! +-*)-(4+"(!: )'%! "&  +''.(4+"(  4" +" "&  (!"+!4  %$ " %#"%C%$"& +$% 0 !"(%! ,8& !"& ( 4"(%!D+''.(4+"(%!8 %#B+!-;%$;DB,"& 3 7+0 / $%  "&  (:& %)"# %8 3 , " (+''.(4+"(%!+!-- 4(- -"& +0  (4+"(%!)!-  4"(%!D8+$(. - "%$"& (:&%)"-+" -B#<B#<<;# "%/ !%"0+(!"+(!+/. ,/ (!:+ 4% . 8("& "&  '(!4('.  "&+" %!.7 + (!:  (!"+!" 4+ , )!$%")!+" .7, "&  (  $+4" "&+" "&  +'' +. %! "&   .( - 4"(%!D+''.(4+"(%!8+- 4(- -#& .'%("(%!(!"& (!"+!"4+ #"0)"+ +/ ! $(4(+.'%3((%!# !-+" -B##;;/+ -%!"& +8+ B8+- 4(- -%!#<#<<<8& !"  &  %.. 4"% %):&" "% &+3  2 '" " +. 8   - 4(- - %! B#<B#<<;# 4"+!-*)"($( -(!"& 3( 8"+2 !(!" +!!%" /  )44 (3  +''.(4+"(%! )!- )0+(5)'+6#)""&+"(!%""& '% % -%)/", "&   4%!- +''.(4+"(%! -+" " %$ "&  +'' ..+"  4%)" *)-:0 !" ( ! %.. 4"%(+.%+"$+)."(!- 4(-(!:" 4  "&  8   ("$% +"(%!  "&  (%! - %!8+ 7+0  , "&  0 %! . -%! <<;#"  4%!- (!:.   (:& ( - %! #&+" "+.% 8+- !"&  '" "&  ;# ! (!"&   )!-  '%(!"  -+" -  ( !%" !:"&  MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.25 17:13 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CWP No.37308 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CWP No.37308 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment