IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANPHRA PRADESH :: AMARAV (Special Original Jurisdiction) TUESDAY,THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF JUNE TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYQTHIRMAI PRATAPA WRIT PETITION NO: 2156 OF 2018 Between: I K. Dilli Kumgri W/g. Munisubrgmgnyam, aged about 36 years, Occp; Teacher, Resident of H.No. 17/35, Sgrdarpet Street, PanggaJ, Srikalghasthi, Chittoor District - SI 7640. 2 P.S. Thulosi Padmg W/o. A. Yuvgrgj, aged about 45 years, Occp; Teacher, Resident of H.No. Maruthi Nggar, Near SV Medical Collage Allipri Road, Tirupoti Chittoor District - 51 7501 5-11-235, 3 C. Vasonthamma W/o. Nggaroju, aged about 44 Resident years, of H.No. 6-12-248, Tirupati Chitfoor District - Cccp: Teacher, Kanakabhushan Layout, 517501. L 4 N. Sujatha W/o. P. Venkatesh, Occp; Teacher, Resident of H.No. 3-4-115, Qiddangi Street Prasonthi Nogor, KT Road, Tirupati Chittoor District -517501. 5 N. Sudha Rani W/o .K. Venkata Prasad, aged about 41 years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of H.Np.l8-1 -46/C-l4, 2'^=' Floor, Prasathi Nagar, KT Road, Tirupoti Chittoor District- 517501. 6 C. Hemovothi W/o. V. Regmesh, Resident Govindhanggor, Mangalgm Road, Tirupati District-51 7501. G. Gopi Kiran W/o. G. Nethaji, aged about 38 Occp; Teacher, Resident of Flat No. 304, Swgrnamrutha Apartment, SD Lay Cut, 517501. M. Rojasekhar S/o. M. Munivelu, , aged about 38 yegrs, Occp: Teacher, Puron (P & V) Nagalapuram Mandal, 517589. aged about 39 yegrs. aged about 33 yegrs, of H.Ng. 4^3/A, Chittoor Occp: Teacher, 7 years. Tirupati, Chittoor District - 8 Resident of Door No. 2-118, Krishna Chittoor District - .4^ ^ 9 V. Raje^wari D/o. V. Rajamma, aged about 38 years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. 6-19-58-599, K.B. Lay V Out, Tirupa^i Chittoor District - 517501. 10 P, Kusuma W/o. Govardhana Reddy, aged about 37 ' years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. 12-3-265, isuka ’ Street, Tirupati Chittoor District - 51 7501. 11 M. Prasuna W/o. B. Sri Hari Naidu, aged about 41 years, Occp; Teacher, Resident of D.No. 4-45/1, 14"^ Cross, Sri Krishna Nagar, MR Palli, Tirupati, Chittoor District - 517501. 12 C. Swaroopa W/o. N. Mohan Kumar, aged about 37 years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. 15/105, Padmavathi Nagar, Tirupati Chittoor District - 517501. 13 S. Sujatha W/o. Sivaiah, aged about 35 years, Occp; Teacher, Resident of D.No. 5-5-345 (A), Near Sneha Hospital, SD Lay Out, Tirupati Chittoor District - 517501. 14 T. Latha, W/o. G. Chandra Sekhar, aged about 39 years, 4/128-2, Nagari, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. Vasudevapuram, Nathem Kandriga (V), Chittoor District - 51 7591. 15 R. Swarna Latha W/o. R. Gangulaiah, aged about 38 years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. 7-222, Shanthi Nagar, S.V. University Post Tirupati Chittoor District - 517501. 16 M. Jagadeeswari W/o. M Nageswara Reddy, aged about 32 years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. 1- 93/A, TR Kandriga Post, Tirumqndvam village, Chittoor District-51 7591 17 J. Sridevi W/o. L. Reddappa, aged about 39 years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No. 17-34-51-45, Poola Street, Tirupati Chittoor District - 517501. 18 P. Hemandha S/o. P. Tatamunaiah, aged about 38 years, Occp; Teacher, Resident of Edalacheruvu Palli, Egavuru Post, Bhakarapet, Chinnagottigallu Mandal, Chittoor District. 19 Y. Kumari W/o. K Ravi Chandra, aged about 34 years, Occp; Teacher, Resident of D.No. 19-10-3/18, New Indira Nagar, AIR Bypass Road, Tirupati Chittoor District - 517501. 20 M.V. Padmavathi W/o. K. Janardhana, aged about 39 14th years, Occp: Teacher, Resident of D.No.4-45/1, Cross, Sri Krishna Nagar, MR Palli, Tirupati, Chittoor District S 2' N. Lalith years, V)5wa I X^mari, w/o c Occp; Teach a fCnshn ^ecfdy, aged about 4] of_ O.No.Flat No. 101 ^ PQdmavafhi r- ^ ^ ' Ch.f(oorDisWcf-5,7502 a ©h Resident '^es/dency, ^irupati Sal 22 P. Sangeetha years, ^ Nagn D/o. p, T Occp; Teach, vandal, Chitto ■ Paramdh ©r, Resident ^^out ■-•QrO/sfnct-5i759T^"^-n. f V 23 0. Sunifha VV/o. m Occp; Teach iXrupoti Manohar, Resident of Chiffoor Oisfrict dged abouf 37 O.No. 4-4-572, er. years, Nehru Nagar, ~ 5] 7501. Niadhav) p/o r p veprs, Occp: Teacher '^onCCcr, hoc/opo DpMcT ‘ 24 C. ©Qec/ about 37 Bazar street. D-No. 7/5, 25 8^ ehcvaneswari W/o s Obout 41 years, OccD- r ' ' Noroyanr'^- ^"■UPat/ Chitto Naresh Xamar Resident ^Xptithopu Reddy, r of D.No. 2-262, Road, oged Venture or District-517501. Main 26 B.V.s. Parimaip^ O/o. 3 Occp; Teach Chittoor District 33 Oeva Chetty Resident years, P^Ogari, ' oged about ■ N26/I2, er. of D.No. -517590. 27 T ■ RoshpoiofOo years. W/o. G. Gop/lcrish Resident of Tirupati Chtttoo rn, ^®°ch ^©'ony, kt Road, na. oged about O-No. 6-8-IQ92, r District-517501.' ^ W °'50ut 50 Ch/ ®"' D.No. ■ Ch.floor0/s«cf-5,7so, er. 29 NGO 28 P. Nagaven/, ^ Occp: Teochet Prasonthi Lavanya D/o Occp; Teach ^'^ekanad -517501. D/o. Subbar Assistant, Nogar, Tirupati years, iB-7-40, 29 A A.M. , a Nr. Resident gar, Korlagunta, Bhaskar, oged about 30 ' of D.No. tirupati. er years, 13-7-443/0, Chittoor District 30 K. Bharathi, w/p. g. Occp; Teacher A ■ ^'5/A/3A,Subha,hNa'°"'' D/str/ct - 5 j 75q j _ ©9Qr, Korlagunta, B1 K. Sujath Occp; Nggaroth Nethatcuppam’ Chittoor District. 3agannath, ©ged about 33 Of D.No. 'tirupati, Chitto years, 20-1- or o W/o. Teach nom. Chokka Roo, Assistant, D.No. ^9ed about Resident er 31 years. of post. i ^ 32 N. Sarala D/o. N. Munirathnam Naidu, aged about 42 er Assistant, Resident of D.No 1-102 village, Bop-paraju Ramachandrapuram, Chittoor District years, Occp: Teach Anumpalli pOalli post. “ OccoT°y”^°' °bout 3. veers Occp Teocher Assistant. Resident of D.No 2-t-72/A Ko o Street, Tirupati, Chittoor District -.517501, ‘ 34 P. Saritha W/o. Shoban Babu, Occp; Teacher Assistant, Resident of ost & Village, Nagari Mandal, 35 G. Hokavitha W/o. G. Occp: Teacher Assistant, Salivahana Nagar, LIC 517501. aged about 33 years, Damarapakam Chittoor District - 51 7591. Munisekhar, aged about 32 Resident of D.No. years, 1-34-494/9/4, Road, Tirupati, Chittoor District '' Ver'cccrDL"'" oboe, 42 years, Occp. Librarian, Resident of D No Thummalagento, Tirupati Rurat. Chittoor District. 37 P. Venkoto Suhasini w/o. T. Guroppo, years, Occp; Teacher Assista Sekhar 1-89/3 B, aged about 33 nt. Resident of D.No. 22-8- Enclaves 85/5 B/1/202, Venkatarama Apartment, r.- Layout, Grand World Rood Chittoor District - 5l 7501 MLA Tirupati, Occo- w'a"” dfout 48 yeors Occp. Warden, Resident of D No 4 2 29<? r' ■ ^ Tirupati, Chittoor District - 51 7501 ' ' 39 D. Ch. Adi Lakshmi W/o. years, Occp; Warden, Venkata Rama Mohan, aged about 47 Resident of D.No. 1-48/17/l6, Sri Colony, Vasundara - District. Padmavathi Tiruchanoor, Tirupati, Chittoor Nagar, 40 M. Munikumari W/o. M. Venkatesh, years, Occp: Warden, Residenl Reservoir Road, aged about 46 4-4-650-A, of D.No. Tirupati, Chittoor District -517501. 41 N. Kanaka Durga, W/o. Paramesh Occp; Warden, aged about 38 years. Housing Complex. Tirlp1sT'ch°!toorD°stricit^5y^^^^^^^ Occn°w ' '='"'^°‘7u. aged aboul 35 years Occp. Warden, Resident of D.No. 9-99/n a 4i_- Nagar, Neor Vijoya Krishna Junior College,' Thirnmha'idu' polem, Tirupati, Chittoor District. a • "iirnminaidu / jM: s "" yeo^^n *=--0^ Stresf °==P’ Resident of D.No. - Chittoor District - 51 750] ag^d obout 34 10-12-435, K,K, 4<f K. Sunqnada W/p. r. Kespypchri Occp; Warden, dged about 48 Gandhi Colony, SathN^ry! ^ D.No. 13-243, Rajpov Chittoor District- 517501. Purom post, Tirupati, ygars. 45 S. Padmojo W/o. Muni Krishna Occp; Warden, Resident of Sathyanarayono Puram 517501. 46 U Sola Subramanyam, 34 years, Vijoyopurom 517586. 47 D. Portha Sprodhi S/n n n Occ.A,,endef"o.r.;y. Post, Nagolapuram, Chittoor District-51 7589 ■’ cro"“-oc:rr;c“~ » oged about 30 Rajeev Gpndhi years. Colony, post, Tirupati, Chittoor District - S/o. Late U. Mohan Occp; Attender, D.No. mandalam, Jombala dged about J-36, illothuru, post Chittoor District- years, uram Village and Chittoor OccToic7:' 7 29 Assistant, Resident of Pudipatia osh Tirupathi Rural Chittoor District. °9ed dbouf 43 Ayah, Resident pfD No in 117 a,.- ^bnarirupofi.ChiffoofDisi'fc, ■ years, 'tillage and years, Occp; Nogar, Jeevp S' ^ Rovothi, w/o. Late Eswaraiah, Occp. Ayah, Resident Kovonoor aged about 35 , of D.No. 2-52, Sri Ramapuram mandal, Chittoor District. years, 1 post village, Nindra 52 A Varalokshmi, w/p. Eswor Aygh, Resident of d.No. ^ Nogor Panchayothi 53 M. Devoki w/o. Late M. Muroli AoroH "-'9en, Agrohatonn, Sritalashsthi, Chittoor District yeorro""' 5®bror,sanayam, years, Qccp; Office Ayah Mogarala Reddy Vari District. dged about 35 years, Occp; J-95, Lingeswar Nagar Sai '• Avilalo, Tirupati, Chittoor District. aged about 37 of D.No. years. 15-105, BP aged about 39 Resident of Mogarala '^alli, Pakala Mandalam, post, Chittoor Petitioners V AND V«' The State of A.P., Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Endowments Department, Secretariat, Velagapudi Village, Amaravathi Mandal, Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh State. 1. 1 2. The Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams, Tirumala, Tirupati, Chittoor District, , rep. by its Executive Officer. c.— 3. The S.V.Sravanam Project Society, D.No.7.6.294, Mitia Street, Tirupathi, Chittoor Respondents. Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, direction, order or orders more particularly one in District, Rep by its President. 'T the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the inaction of the second respondent in absorbing the petitioners as per their eligibility, in the service of ‘S.V. Institute of Hearing Impairment (Sravanam) Executive Officer on 25.03.2013 contrary to the decision taken by the then as as illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory and consequently direct the second resporident to absorb the petitioners in the service of ‘S.V. Institute of Hearing Impairment (Sravanam)’ and pass such other order or orders as Court may deems fit and proper in the the Honhle circumstances of the case. lA NO: 1 OF 2018 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the second respondent to pay the minimum time scale of pay attached to the post held by the petitioners from the date of their appointment forthwith, pending disposal of the writ petition. AND 1. The State of A.PRep. by its Principal Secretory, Endowments Department, Secretariat, Velogapudi village, Amaravathi Mandal, Guntur District, Andhro Pradesh Stqte. 2. The Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams, Tirumdla, Tirupati, Chittoor District, , rep. by its Executive Officer. 3. The S.V.Sravanam Project Society, p.No.7.6.294, Mitia District, Rep by its President. Street, Tirypathi, Chittopr Respondents. Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a writ, direction, order or orders more particularly one in f the nature of writ of the inaction of the second respondent in absoTbiTg'the’‘petTtioners eligibility, i (Sravanam) Executive Officer as per their f Hearing Impairment I decision t^en by the then on 25.03.20137*" illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory and consequently direct the second respondent to absorb the petitioners in the service of ‘S.V. Institute of Hearing Impairment (Sravanam)’ and pass such other order pr orders the HonTple as as Court circumstances of the case. may deems fit and proper in the lA NO: 1 OF 2018 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the second respondent to pay the minimum time scale of pay attached to the post held by the petitioners from the date of their appointment forthwith, pending disposal of the writ petition. lA NO: 2 OF 2020 Between: K.V Sudha W/o.T.A.P Kasturi Rangan, Aged- 55 years, Occ- Junior Assistant, The S.V Sravanam Project Society, D.No.7-6-294, Mitla Street, Tirupathi, Chittoor District. R/o. Flat No.401, SAl NIKHATA RESIDENCY; Khadi Colony, Shanthinagar, behind Municipal park, Tirupathi- 517 501 ...Petitioner AND 1. K.Dili Kumari W/o. Muni Subramanyam, aged about 36 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.H.No. 17/35, Sardharpet Street, Panagal, Sri Kalahasthi, Chittoor District. 2. P.S Tulasi Padma W/o. A.Yuvaraj, aged about 45 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.H.No. 6-11-235, Maruthinagar, Near S.V Medical College, Allipiri Road, Tirupathi, 3. C.Vasanthamma W/o! Nagaraju, age- 44 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.H.No. 6-12-248, Kanakbushan Layout, Tirupathi. 4. N.Sujatha W/o. P.Venkatesh, aged about 39 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. H.No.3-4-115, Giddangi Street, Prashanthi Nagar, K.T Raod, Tirupathi 5. N.Sudha Rani W/o.K.Venkata Prasad, aged about-41 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.H.No.l8-l-46/C-14, 2'^^ Floor, Prashanthi Nagar, K.T Raod, Tirupathi 6. C.Hemavathi W/o.V.Rearnesh, aged about 38 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. H.No.4-3/A, Govindanagar, Mangalam Road, Tirupathi. 7. G.Gopi Kiran S/o.G.Nethaji, aged about 38 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. Flat No.304, Swarnamutrtha Apartments, S.D Layout, Tirupathi. 8 M.Rajashekar S/o. M.Munivelu, aged about-38 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. H.No.2-118, Krishna Puran [P&V) Nagalapuram Mandal, Chittoor District. 9. V.Rajeshwari D/o. V.Rajamma, aged about-38 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. D.No.6-19-58-599, K.B Lay out, Tirupathi. I 21 -JiT- 10. P.Kusuma W/o. Goverdhan Reddy, aged about 37 years, R/o. 12-3-26S Isuka Street, Tirupathi. 11. M.Prasuna W/o.B.Sri Hari Naidu, age- 41years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.4-45/1,14^'' Cross, Sri Krishna Nagar, MR Palli, Tirupathi. 12 C Swarupa W/o. N.Mohan Kumar, aged about-37 years, ’ Occ-Teacher, R/o. 15/105, Padmavathinagar, Tirupathi. 13. S.Sujatha W/o.Sivaiah, aged about-35 years, Occ-Teacher R/o.5-5-345 (A) near Sneha Hospital, S D Layout, Tirupa 14. T.Latha W/o. G.Chandrashekar, aged about aged about-39 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. D.No.4/128-2, Vasudevapuram, Nathem, Kandriga Village, Nagari, Chittoor District. 15. R.Swarnalatha W/o. R.Gangulaiah, aged ^bou>:-38 years Occ-Teacher, R/o.7-222, Shanthi Nagar, S.V University Post, Tirupathi. 16 M Jagadishwari W/o. M.Nageshwar Reddy, aged about-32 years, ■ Occ-Teacher, R/o. D.No.l-93/A,TR Kandriga Post, Tirumandavam Village, Chittoor District. 17 I Sridevi W/o. L.Reddappa, aged about 39 yeni'S, ^ Occ- Teacher, R/o.D.No.17-34-51-45, Poola Street, Tirupathi. Hemandha S/o.P.Tatamunaiah, aged about 38 years, Occ-Teacher R/o.Edalacheruvu Palli, Egavui u Post, Brakarapeta, Chinnagottlkallu Mandal, Clkt.oo,- D.atr.c,. 18. P i W/o.K.Ravi Chandra, aged about-34 years, ^ .No.19-10-3/18, New Indira Nagai, 19. Y.Kumari Occ-Teacher, R/o. D Road, Tirupathi. AIRbuspass 20 MVPadmavathiW/o.K.lanardhan, aged about 39 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.D.No.4-45/1. 14e> Cross, Sri Krishna Nagar, M.R Palh, Tii upathi. 21, C. Lalkha Kumari W/a C Krishna rdrcrp"--«ihta,.de„s,Pena.na,,apa,h, Tirupathi. -andhama Reddy, aged about-39 years. Village, Nagari Mandal 22 P Sangeetha D/o. P.Pai ' Occ-Teacher, R/o. Desuruagarm Chittoor District. 1 Vi... fo> 22 24. C.Madhavai D/o.C.Rainasubbanna, aged about- 37 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. D.No.7/5, Bazar Street, Nandalur, Kadapa District. 25. B.Bhuvaneshwari W/o.S.Naresh Kumar Reddy, aged about-41 years, R/o. 2-262, Laksminarayana Venture, Thatithopu Main Road, Tirupathi. 26. B.V.S Parimala W/o. B.Vasudeva Chetti, aged about 33 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o.D.No. 1-26/12, Nagari, Chittoor District. 27. T.Pushpalatha W/o. G.Gopi Krishna, aged about- 29 years, Occ-Teacher, R/o. D.No.6-8-1092, NGO Colony, K.T Road, Tirupathi. 28. P.Nagaveni D/o. Subbarayudu, aged about-50 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. D.No.l8-7-40,Prashanthi Nagar, Tirupathi. 29. A.Lavanya D/o. A.M Bhaskar, aged about- 30 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. D.No.l3-7-443/B, Vivekanada Nagar, Kariagunta, Tirupathi. 30. K.Bharathi W/o. B.Jagannath,, aged about-38 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. 20-1-415/A/3A, Subhash Nagar, Korlagunta, Tirupathi. 31. K.Sujatha W/o. Chokka Rao, aged about- 31 years, Occ- TeacherAssistant, R/o. D.No.5-10,Mittavakuppam, Nethakuppam Post, Ramachandrapuram Post, Chittoor District. 32. N.Sarala D/o. N.Muniratnam Naidu, aged abo'dt-42 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. D.No. 1-102, Anumpalli Village, Baparaju palli Post, Ramachandrapuram, Chittoor District. 33. N. Jamuna W/o. late Bhaskar, aged about-31 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. D.No. 2-1-72/A, Kola Street, Tirupathi, 34. p.Saritha W/o. Shobhanbabu, aged about-33 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. Dainarapakam post and vill, Nagari Mandal, Chittoor Distiict. 35. G. Hokavitha W/o. G. Munishekar, aged about- 32 years, Occ-Teacher Assistant, R/o. D.No.1-34-494/9/4, Salivahana nagar, L.I.C. Road, Tirupathi. P.Vijaya Lakshmi W/o. A.Tharakaram, aged about 42 years, Occ- Librarian, R/o.D.No.l89/3 B, Thummalgunta, Tirupathi Road, Chittoor District. 36. 23 ■ 4 -II' 37, P.Venkata Suhasini W/o. T.Gurappa, aged about 33 years, Occ- Teacher Assistant, R/o. 22-8-85/5, B/1/202, Shekar Enclave Apartment, MLA Venkataramana Layout, Grand World Road, Tirupathi. -^7 38. D. Adilakshmi W/o. Rama Rao, aged abut-48 years, Occ - Warden, R/o. D.No.4-2-229, Gajuveedhi, Tirupathi. 39. D.Ch.Adilakasmi W/o. Rama Mohan, aged about 47 years, Occ-Warden, R/o. D.No.1-48/17/16, Sri Venkata Padmavathi Colony, Vasundaranagar, Tiruchanoor, Tirupathi. 40. M. Munikumari W/o. M.Venkatesh, aged about- 46 years Occ- Warden, R/o. D.No.4-4-650-A, Resevoir Road, Tirupathi. 41. N.Kanakadurga W/o. Paramesh, aged about- 38 years, Occ- Warden, R/o. D.No.1-58/1, Srinivasa Housing Complex, Tirupathi. 42. A. Chandi prlya W/o. Giri babu, aged about- .55 years, Occ- Warden, R/o. D.No. 9-99/3A, Padmavathi nagai-. Near Vijayakrishna Junior College, Timminaidu palem, Tirupathi.. 43. Ragha Sudha W/o. Naveen Kumar-, aged about-34 year's, Occ-Warden,R/o. D.No. 10-12-435, K.K Sti eet, Tirupathi. 44 K Sunandha W/o. R.Keshava Char-i, aged about-48 years, Occ-Warden, R/o. D.No. 13-243, Rajeev Ganclht Colony, Post, Tir-upathi Chittopr Distr-rct. Satyanarayanapui-am 45. S. Padmaja W/o. Muni Krishna, apd about-30 years, Occ- Warden, R/o. Rajeev Gandhi Colony, Post, Tir-upathi Chittoor Distr-rct- Satyanar-ayanapurar-n u. BalasLibramanyam S/o. late Mohan, aged abom-34 year's, " Occ- Attendee, R/o. 1-36, lllaturu, Vijayapur-am Mandal, Jambala Post, Chittoor District. 47 D.Pai-dhasaradhi S/o. Das, aged about- 39 years, Occ- Attendee, R/o. D.No.2/72, B.Krishnapuram Vill and Post, Nagalapui-am, Chittoor. 48 M Surendra Babu S/o. M.Doraswamy, aged about-30 years, ' Occ-Attender, R/o. 3-46, Brahmanapattu (P) K.H Wada Village, Tirupathi Rural and Mandal, Chittoor District. 46. U. 49 S. Pavani W/o. G.Hari Prasad, aged about-29 years. Occ- Office assistant, R/o. Pudipatla Village and Post, Tirupathi Road, Chittoor District. I 24 -I&- 50. T. Jayanthi W/o. T.Murali, aged about-43 years, Occ-Ayah, R/o. 10-117, Kranthinagar, Jeevakona, Tirupathi. 51. E.Revathi W/o. late Eshwaraiah, aged about-36 years, Occ-Ayah, aged about-2-52, Sri Ramapuram Post, Kavanoor Village, Nindra Mandal, Chittoor District. 52. A.Varalakshmi W/o. Eshwar, aged about- 35 years, Occ-Ayah, R/o. D.No.3-36, Lingeshwar Nagar, Sainagar Panchayati, Avilala, Tirupathi. 53. M.Devaki W/o. M.Murali, aged about- 37 years, Occ- office ayah, R/o. D.No.15-105, BP Agraharam, Sri Kalahasthi, Chittoor District. 54. V. Sumathi D/o. P.Subramanyam, aged about-39 years, Occ- Office ayaiah, R/o. Mogarala Post, Mogarala Reddy vari Palli, Pakala Mandalam, Chittoor District. ...Respondents 1 to 54 are Petitioners in the WP 55. The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep. by its Principle Secretary, Endowments Department, Secretariat, Velagapudi Village, Amaravathi Mandal, Guntur District. 56. The Tirumala Tirupati Devastanai^s, Tirumala, Tirupathi, Chittoor District, Rep.by its Executive Officer. 57. The S.V Sravanam Project Society, D.No.7-6-294, Mitla Street, Tirupathi, Chittoor District, Rep.by its Presedent. (R-3 impleaded suo-m^ the court 55 (-q 57 are Respondent No.l to 3 in WP otu as per order of li. Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High Court may be pleased to pay the Petitioner minimum time scale of pay attached to her post along with other writ petitioners in the writ petiiton WP No.2156 of 2018 as tho directd by the HONBLE Court in I.A petitioner is similarly situated person No.1 of 2018 dated 22-03-2018. as Counsel for the Petitioner(s);M/s BOBBA VIJAYALAKSHMl Counsel for the Petitioner(s):SRI. Dr MAJJI SURI BABU Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR ENDOWMENTS Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI V DYUMANI (SC FOR TTD) Counsel for the Respondent No.3: — The Court made the following: ORDER 1 APHC010048532018 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI (Special Original Jurisdiction) [3396] TUESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF JUNE TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA WRIT PETITION NO: 2156/2018 Between: ...PETITIONER(S) K. Dilli Kumari and Others AND ...RESPONDENT(S) The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others Counsel for the Petitioner(S): 1. BOBBA VIJAYALAKSHMl 2.Dr MAJJI SURl BABU Counsel for the Respondent(S): 1 .GP FOR ENDOWMENTS (AP) 2.V.DYUMAN1 (SC for TTD) The Court made the following: ORDER: This Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of Constitution of India with the following prayer: “ to issue a writ direction order or orders more particulariy one in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the inaction of the second respondent in absorbing the petitioners as per their eligibility in the service of S.V.Institute of Hearing Impairment Sravanam as contrary to the decision taken by the then Executive Officer on 25.03.2013 as illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory and consequently direct the second respondent to absorb the petitioners in the service of S.V. Institute of Hearing Impairment 2 $ravanam and pass 2. Heard Ms.Majji Venkata Surya Rachana, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Sri Majji Suri Babu, learned counsel for the petitioners and Smt. V. Dyumani, learned Standing Counsel for TTD, appearing for the respondents. 3. When the matter is taken up for hearing, learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that the matter is squarely covered by a common order passed by this Court in W.P.Nps. 29403 and 38488 of 2018, dated 03.04.2025, and hence, requests this Court to pass similar order in this petition also. The operative portion of the said common order is as follows:- In that view, it is apposite to dispose of these Writ Petitions, without touching the merits of the same by remanding the matter to the Respondents-Authorities with the foliowing directions. 9. (i) Petitioners shall submit a comprehensive representation covering their pleadings supported by the relevant documents and the judicial precedents to the Executive Officer of Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanamp within a period of two weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this Order. (ii) The Executive Officer, in turn, shall place the same before the Eoard of Trustees as expeditiously as possible. (Hi) The Board of Trustees shall take a decision over the matter according to governing Rules and law within a period of three months from the date of receipt of representation of the Petitioners. (iv) Depending on the decision to be taken, the Board shall forward the proposal to the Government forthwith for getting necessary approval. 3 (v) Respondent No.1 / Government is directed to consider the said proposal and take appropriate decision according to governing Rules and Law, within a period of three months therefrom. ” 4. Learned Standing Counsel for TTD would submit that Court may pass similar order. Considering the submissions made, this Writ Petition is also disposed of in terms of the common order passed in W.P.Nos.29403 and 38488 of 2018, dated 03.04.2025. There shall be no order as to costs. 5. The Registry is directed to attach a copy of the common order passed in W.P.Nos.29403 and 38488 of 2018, dated 03.04.2025, to this order. 6. As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed. Sd/- K. SRINIVASA RAJU ASSISTANT REGISTRAR / //TRUE COPY// SECTION OFFICER To, 1. The Principal Secretary, State of Andhra Pradesh Endowments Department, Secretariat, Velagapudi Village, Amaravathi Mandal, Guntur District, Andhra Pradesh State. 2. The Executive Officer, Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams, Tirumala, Tirupati, Chittor District, 3. The President, S.V.Sravanam Project Society, D.No.7-6-294, Mitia Street, Tirupathi, Chittoor District. 4. One CC to M/s. BOBBA VIJAYALAKSHMI Advocate [OPUC] 5. One CC to SRI. Dr MAJJI SURI BABU Advocate [OPUC] 6. TwoCCsto GP FOR ENDOWMENTS, High Court Of Andhra Pradesh. [OUT] 7. One CC to SRI. V. DYUMANI (SC FOR TTD) Advocate [OPUC] 8. Three C.D.Copies nm HIGH COURT DATED: 17/06/2025 ORDER WP.No.2156 of 2018 DISPOSING OF THE WP WITHOUT COSTS IN THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH PRESENT THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAl VMT PETiTION Nos.29403 AND 3R488 OF 2Qia PRATAPA gPIVlIVlQN ORDFR- Writ Petiti&n No. 29403 of 2018 is filed under Article 226 of Constitution of India with the following prayer for; “ a of Mandamus declanng the action of the mspondents • mmners as fh^rZ f Devasthanama Tiwpathi from the ihejr initial appointment i necessary posts of in the available sanctioned posts or by creating illegal Arbitrary and unconstitutional and ^ regularize the services of the T/wma/a Tirupathi Devasthanams, Tirupathi tZrL^ of their initial appointment and with all ccnsequ^ntial benefits including payment of arrears of salary from the said date ” Writ Petition No.38488 of 2018 is filed under Article 226 of Gonstitution of India with the following prayer for: m^innh^Z Mandamus declaring the action of ttm 3^ and 4^ respondents m issuing the Proceedma<f ^T.21 09.2018 rejecting Um^mquest of of of sen./ces in the cadm ot unvers in ihe existing vacancies by taking their tong lenam of service 'mthtS^'rf^'T '’^Ohanded, without power and ttSiZecanct-^ Oepadmentin in 2. Heard Sri Y.V.Ravi Prasad, learned senior counsel assisted by Sri Y.V.Anil Kumar, learned Rao, learned Senior Counsel Counsel for Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams counsel for the Petitioners and Sri V.Venugopala assisted by Ms.V.Dyumani, learned Standing 2 Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners would submit that, initially the Petitioners filed W.P.No.29403 of 2018 seeking to direct the Respondents to regularize their services as Drivers in Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanams, TIrupathi from the (jiate of their initial appointment with all consequential benefits including payment of arrears of salary. During pendency of the said writ petition, an interim order has been passed by this Court vide Order dated 21.08.2018 in I.A.No.1 of 2018 directing the Respondents to consider the representations of the Petitioners, dated 04.06.2018 and 17.07.2018, pending dispose of the main writ petition. Learned Senior Counsel brought it to the notice of this Court that, despite the said Order passed by this Court, the Executive Officer of T.T.D had taken a decision over the issue and passed the impugned Order rejecting the claim of the Petitioners and the said Order is U' assailed in W.P.No.38488 of 2018. Learned Senior Counsel would further submit that the impugned order which was passed by the Executive Officer of T.T.D, without placing the matter before the Board of Trustees per se illegal and is against the Statute. 3. Learned Senior Counsel for Respondents/T.T.D would submit that the Impugned Order was passed in pursuance to the interim order passed in W.P.No.29403 of 2018. Learned Senior Counsel would further subrhit that, the cause title In the said petition would show the description of the Respondents as “Board of Trustees, Tirumala Tirupathi Devasthanams, Rep. 4. by its Executive Officer, Tirupathi". Learned Senior Counsel would further submit that, the Petilioners in the said case sought a direction to the 3 Respondents to consider their representations and the Court had also directed m the Respondents to pass orders. It is submitted that, the Executive Officer might have passed the Order since he Is representing T.T.D. Learned Senior Counsel would submit that Tirumald Tirupati Devasthanams is not ehown as an independent Respondent in the taid matter and that made the Executive Officer to pass Order on his own, without placing the matter before the Board of Trustees. 5. At this juncture, learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners brought the notice of this Court that, for giving laddu card, medical card, increments etc., the matter was placed before the Board of Trustees and the Board had taken a decision over the very small issues. Learned Senior Counsel would further submit that, in the case of erhployees pertaining to Forest Department, who are similarly situated like the Petitioners herein, the very same Executive OfRcer had plated the matter before the Board and the Board, in turn, had aa^pted and sent the proposal to the Government and the Government have accepted the said proposal vide Order dated 30.09.2022 and the not done in the present cases. 6. Learned Senior Counsel for Respondents / T.T.D would submit to same was that, such being the case, the Court may pass appropriate orders. 7, Considering the submissions made and a fair look at the material placed on record, in the light of Section 97 of the A.P.Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutfons and Endowments Act, regarding the policy matters. Board of Trustees has every authority to take a decision and the same has not •.s 4 been done in the present case. For ready references, Section 97 of the said Act is extracted hereunder: “97, Powers and functions of the Board- The Board shall in addition to the powers conferred and functions entrusted to it by . this Act, exercise such other powers and perform such other functions as may be prescribed in regard to matters of policy and general superintendence and review in relation to the Administration of Tirumala Tirupathi Oevasthanams having due regard to public interest and the services and amenities to be provided to and welfare safety measures to be undertaken for, the pilgrims, devotees and worshippers resorting to Tirumala Tirupathi Oevasthanams." Coming to the present case, the Executive Officer has taken a decision and rejected the claim of the Petitioners, which is nonest under law and the 8 same has to be set aside. In that view, it is apposite to dispose of these Writ Petitions, without touching the merits of the same by remanding the matter to the Respondents- Authorities with the following directions. Pefitiohers shall submit a comprehensive representation covering their pleadings supported by the relevant documents and the judicia! precedents to the Executive Officer of Tirumala Tirupati Oevasthanams within a period of 9. (r) two weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this Order. The Executive Officer, in turn, shall,place the same before the Board of Trustees as expeditiously as possible, (iii) The Board of Trustees shall take a decision over the matter according to governing Rules and law within a period of three months from the date of receipt of representation of the Petitioners. (ii) ■ 5 (iv) Depending on the deelsion to be taken, the Board shall forward the * -i- , proposal to the Government forthwith for getting necessary approval, (v) Respondent No.1 / Government is directed to consider the said propose! and take appropriate deoislon according to governing Rules and Law, within a period of three months therefrom. As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed.