Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 55324 (PNJ)
GURCHARAN SINGH v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
CWP/19118/2011 · 2025-01-20
Sudeepti Sharma, Sureshwar Thakur
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 55324 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 55324 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!"#$%&'( !$%$)%*#$%&'
& +, -- -. +,- -- -
! "#$% ! &'( )) * ++++ - -. /
, - $
.)
!"#$ %&'( ) *% + ,
"- !#,." !/#,//" !#
" !-#
%&$ %
$
((
((
$
%&$
$
,
"0""
((
, ((
$ $&
( %& $ (
"0""
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
((
((
$
$& %&$
(
1 -2$ ( 0*1)020*34!$)%# / -
$)) (01,,,21/ $ 3 !) (! 0204,212-
$
)" 5
" 6 $ $
()! )! ($
)
) %-
$
(( ) ! $
7 -
) )() ($% (
)
$
) ! ( )
! 4 -
(! (
)
8 $ % 9 :)
! ) )(:- )
)
- $ (
! 0,01/0,,- ! . 34444 (
,%
%&%& $
,
(
%& $ ,
( ,
%&% %
%
%&(&
, 4 %
% 2%
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
, (&%
, &$5
%& $
$
,
& $$ ( ( %
% 6 $&*, % , $0 # $
$
$$(
,
5
&
",
(
,
&5
*
$
( %& $
--,$
4 ,(
7
( $ 8, " (
5
&(&9* $ %# $
7'
:
&
(& $
$
;,
,
, % &
5
(
$
(&
7 * ,
$
%( %& $
- ( ( $ 8", (
5
& ,
&
"
(
&7+7$ ( ,
(&(<
&,""0"",
:
8 +
#
( #(&:
"/0*
%
$
/0", $
4 0
$,(
8" (
,5
,
(&(<
&""0
""
(
%&
:
8 + , $
&
%
%&
% ,&$
,! %
4 ,%
(
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
() %
&$,($
,
$
&,
5
& * ,
($
( %
,$$&
%
%&
$
,%
$&%
($
& %
,
,
( %
$$
% $&
,
(
% 7 (
%&:8+
#
( # #: . .#(&: ,"/07* , $ 0
, (
(
$ & $, (
!
3* %& %
$
%
%
%&
%&= #
>?.".".@"= (% 9 *,,
%
5
&
,
4 %&
&
(
% % %
%
%&(&
A (
,
$
%& )( $
$ , (&
$(& : . .# # #: . .# # #,( $ %
%
( &
,
%
: . .# # #A
(( 8 +,
%
:
. .# # #A ,
( ,
$
% %5 :
8 + $
$
%&&
4( , ( (
:
8
+
$ $
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$ ()8;)! $
% ,$
%
(&: . .# # #(&: . .# # #,
%
%&%
$ %
%
%&
,
,$%%& $
&( %
%&
$ ,,
, $ *
, $$ ( $$ $ $ , %
"", $
&(& - %
( $
&(%
,
%
, ,
$
% $5
$,
,
,( $, (
4( ,
$
(
& -" $
($&
(
( $8"", 6
$
( (
( (&
! "
#$ %
"$$& $&
'$& ()
**+
$&$" (&
++ $,$ () )$ ** -$ + %$ % -$
$&
-$ && $
' - $ $ & -(
($"+ . ()
' $
$&$" &$& +/+ $
$ ' $ $ '(
$!$( ($" -
-$ ,,
0
&! -$ $"((, ) !(( 1 $ - (( &-
$ & $&
!& 0!)+ 2&'&()
'& $( & $
&! & )
$& & $" ($() '
$& $ $ 3)
'( & & $
&)&+
4, 5(( &
' $
-
-$ ($ &
(- '& $( $,)
$
- &&
" 0!) '!
(
-$ !'$ + KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
*
$
,
& -$"
- 3 $(& $"' '$&
$ $& $&$" ' '
' - $ $( $ '(
"$$
- $
- $&
-$ '$
"&
0!) !(,
$) &$() $& $",
($ &
(- '& $( $,) 678 '$+
$
& (& $
-$ -
!'$
-
-$ & $,& !& 5!(
... " -
"!()
! !$
- $! & $, !, &$)
$ ," ! $(() $! $",
"
," $) - $! + *
, ,
$$ %& $
, $ &
,
$
%
&%&$
(
44449 1 :)
!(
)
$
; - $
! ,<09/0,9 ( ( )$ $
= ! #
$
56
(
)- ! . #
&
! , (
$ % (%
$
$
(
% , ( $0 9$( : ;$ :$'$<
, $ %
;
$
%
%! &$
$ %
,% &
(
6 KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
/
&$$
, $ $
$
&
< (
> 5 ! )6&9,,,/0,1.- >
(
?@) (! /,07/0/7 $ (
( ( - !56 . 344444 .0 *
%
,
( %
$
,$
$ %& ./ * $$
$
$
(
$ %
9 2
) $
)
#
((
-)567 7$% $81920!%#*$)% 28$!19:1717$%! ,0 -))
(
() ) % $ )))! )
)$)! ! ! $ ) %
)! )
)
? (
! . ) 0#0%-9390;01<! ) %7$%$8%#70
-(--)! ! . KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
;
$$
&
&,
$
%
%&$ $
:
%8!%* $8197 $)!1 ,, ! ) $
( $ )$))!?$! )
) ( !)$ (
! $ ! (
) $( $ )) $ (
! %
,/ # ( $)(
8
! (( . !
$ (! ! ( )
! . $>)) (
(
$ !) $
3
(
(
(
9, $ ) (
)
$ % (
) !! :(
(
(( ,0 ! ,2;7
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$)( )! )(
! ) ) ,7 -
(")
) (! )(
) (
)
,4 - $ ! )(
$
(
) )( ( ( ( 56 ,9
. )=
.&$ $&
>+ +2+'$ $ : $( 4$"
2$(
?+ @ (
)! $ ( . ( ..) )$ 3: .-0"
;
#: ,
" %
(
0" ( B! 9
;
#: ,"C # .-,
%! #
%! #, %! $
&% % ,( &B! 3 #*
? (
%&,
$
: =%
,;' #.." 0"# $$% ,%
%& $
B
($&
$ %&
( ($
& $ %
:
=% : , #? (
,
$
: =% , 0"#
$$% ,
(
&%& ( (&$ ( &$ ( KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
, (&%
$
0"B
? (
,
(
& %& ( (& $ ( & $ (
%
($ &
& ,(&%
$
%! # 0"
%5
? (
! #%
4( %& $$$ ( &
%
$$(
$$(
? (
%&
( &? (
D %# (
$ 3D # 0",
%! #, %! % % ,( &BC 3 #;
%5
$
%! # .-,
? (
$
($ &
& , (
$ %
&$
(
(
(
( ,
( %
(,
%5 ((
( $
$ (
( (4(
( 6 & $
$ (
(9 * ( ( %
$ %
;' # .."
,
%
( %& & A 8 (
( % > ! E )#
"
(B! 6+ .
($& $
&
A!$(),
"
)$
,$
!& 5!(
:
5!( / $((
$( $(
$
$ 9"'
"$ ,
."$(&
$ ! $) &()
'$( ') !& 5!( + 2 &,() ."$(&
$
$
B
'(!'
$"$, '(!' - "
' $( !0
$ ''!'
!$& ! '' $& '$3'!'
($1 -)
" !$& ! '' $((
$)$(
$ 9"'
"$ -
!& 5!(
:
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
5!( /
"
'(, $ A!$(),
"
)$+8 F$
,
(
&
%
%& $ (
: .-0"
;
# : , ",
% $$
%
* $
$ 8)))
!(A ,1 ! (.)
)$!)
6 $ ! BB! !( ! ! /0 $ =
)
) )
! ) 56 ( ! ) ()
( ()
(
! ))
(
() 8)
! )) $
(
) $
! )
! )(
8
8)
! ( ) (! )(
)
($ () ) ( () 8)
! (" )
(
$") ("() ! 6 :(
)
)
! ))8 )
)$ KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
)
( $(
! )
)
( ) ! ,; # (
)
$
( ! )
)
$
( ) ! ,< -
) (
) $ )
()
)! %
) (?$! ! ( (
)!$ ( 8 (8
)! ( C) ( %
- ! ! $ (
( C) ( $ ( ) . ) ! ( )
)! !(-! ! )(
8) ! )! ) )
( ( )
$.(
%
)
)
KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
,2 ?$! ) ! $.)
)$ ! (. ) =
.&$ $&
>+ +2+'$ !$
) !)
! (
( /0 - .) )$(
! 56 (" .)
.
(
@
G, )) ( ) )8 !)
))$$
( ))) .)
! ))) )
$)) $ )
"$
)
/, -(" ) ))
.) )$
! 56 ! BB! )( )
$
) $ ))(
(- $
8
!) $ ())
) ,08)
! !)
)) (
56 ) . 56 8 ( )
8)
! ! )( ! ) $) .() .)
! ! ) KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
$ ( )
8
// ! $ )
)
%7$%$8%#700%# ! < $('= > -0%#: .)60! 0%# %$19! "
)!B$
8
! $( ! ). ( ) $ $3 ! 040,/0,2-)! ! . 0 $
&
$ $ (
4 !0,
% (
4
,
$
, (6
4 $
,& (6
,!!, $$
F
,
$ $
!! $$
%
% (
,% %&*
(( (
( %
4 !0,% ( $ &
(
! %
: & ( (%
(
% ! &
%
4 !0 *
,
4 !0, ( ( ,
(6
,
,% & %
& 4 %
%5 ,%
%
6 +
"
( $(( $()
2'& C ( - -@$
"
$ + + +
$
( - -
"$(&& ! '
"
+ + -((
&+8 / '&
%
$
$ ,6
($&( %
(
! KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
% &
, $
% ( (&,
$,
$ $(
7%02 !#!$8197 $)!1 /7 (
(
$
$ ! ! ( )))$ ( )! (5. B26 $
)! )(
8
$
( !) 3! ?$! )
)
) /4 -!. ($
(( /9
(
) ))
)
56 )56
- -. - - '
"! 919! :037%4?!0 $%# & ?$ 919!!:$!1052 & ?$ KAVNEET SINGH 2025.01.21 16:19 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document