Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 54349 (KAR)

MANAGING DIRECTOR v. SRI SRINATHA RAO

MFA/3725/2022 · 2025-07-22

T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ %#! !!!&& '( ) *+ !!# '( ) * + !" #$$ % &$ !!#$' %( """ ) %" ' &* !% Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & !% + & & !% & $ ###$ #&#& ' ) %"+, & & $ ' " " & ' " #$$ % " "%& * & $ " " " * ' " "- % ." "* .% - 3 - * + &* !% & #% & * % ' "" & !% & $ %"", & #! ' - 4 - " " ! & ' " #$$ " " * "% * $ % " * & %& "* .% " "" %* / / 0 * " # " 1& 23 42567 89 :;6 <==655<>: 1?=1?<:21>@<552>A2>BC63:21>DC7AE6>:<>776@?667<:67 $ =<3367 89 :;6 772:21><5 23:?2@: <>7 63321>3 *C7A6 ;2F<E1AA< 32::2>A <: ;<7?<F<:;2 <>7 772:21><5 ' 41? 3;1?: G:;6 ?28C><5(' 2> 1 & 31 4<? <3 52<8252:9 <>7 BC<>:CE 23 @1>@6?>67 " ?181& 23 42567 89 :;6 @5<2E<>:3&?63=1>76>:3 366H2>A 41? 6>;<>@6E6>: 14 @1E=6>3<:21> ;6 7<:6 14 <@@276>: 2>F15F6E6>: 14 F6;2@56 76<:; 14 ?<DI<5 <A67 # 96<?3 <?6 >1: 2> 723=C:6, :;6 - 5 - 723=C:6 2> ?63=6@: 14 <==6<5 42567 89 :;6 <==655<>:J 1?=1?<:21> ?6A<?72>A :;6 52<8252:9 :1 =<9 :;6 @1E=6>3<:21> 1> :;6 A?1C>7 :;<: :;6 ?276? 14 :;6 E1:1? @9@56 ?272>A I2:;1C: <>9 7?2F2>A 52@6>36 <>7 <531 >1: I6<?2>A ;65E6: 2> :6?E3 14 6@:21> # 14 :;6 @: I;2@;3;1I3@1>:?28C:1?9>6A52A6>@6 ;6 @<36 14 :;6 @5<2E<>:3 2> 23@ ?18 1& 23 :;<: :;6 <@@276>: ;<7 1@@C??67 1> # <>7 <3 =6? :;6 2>@1E6 42K67 89 :;6 6A<5 6?F2@6C:;1?2:92>?63=6@:14C>3H255675<81C?41?:;696<? 23 3!& =6? E1>:; 8C: :;6 ?28C><5 ;<3 @1>3276?67:;62>@1E6<::;6?<:6143=6?E1>:; ;6 76@6<367 I<3 <A67 # 96<?3 <: :;6 :2E6 14 76<:; ;6>@6 !L :1 86 <7767 :1I<?73 :;6 4C:C?6 =?13=6@:C3 8C::;6?28C><5;<3>1:A?<>:67<>9@1E=6>3<:21>C>76? :;6;6<7144252<5@1>31?:2CE2>F26I14:;65<I5<2771I> 89 :;6 1>0856 =6K 1C?: 2> :;6 @<36 14 - 6 - <>7 3<E6 ?6BC2?63 ?6@1>3276?<:21> 89 E172492>A:;6<I<?7<>76>;<>@2>A:;6@1E=6>3<:21> ! 6<?7 ?2 " <8<52 56<?>67 @1C>365 <==6<?2>A41?:;6<==655<>:J 1?=1?<:21><>7?21=<5 56<?>67@1C>365<==6<?2>A41??63=1>76>:13<>7<>7 @?13318D6@:1? >"1&?2"<8<5256<?>67 @1C>365 <==6<?2>A 41? :;6 <==655<>: I2:; <55 F6;6E6>: 3C8E2:3 :;<: :;6 76@6<367 I<3 ?272>A E1:1? @9@56 89 1F6?:<H2>A <>1:;6? F6;2@56 A12>A <;6<7 @<E6 1> :;6 I?1>A327614:;6?1<7>6A52A6>:59I2:;1C:I6<?2>A;65E6: <>7I2:;1C:;<F2>A7?2F2>A52@6>36<>77<3;67:1:;64?1>: =1?:21>14:;68C326:;68CE=6?<>7;6<752A;:?2A;:3276 14 :;6 8C3 ;1CA; :;6 7?2F6? 14 :;6 8C3 ;<7 42567 @1E=5<2>:<3=6? K:;6=152@6;<7E6@;<>2@<55942567 @;<?A63;66:<A<2>3::;67?2F6?14:;68C33=6? K :;6 ?<:21> @<?7 233C67 1> !# :;6 76@6<367 <A6 ;<7866>3;1I><3E2>1?<33C@;;6I<3<E2>1?<31> 1 - 7 - :;6 7<:6 14 <@@276>: 1 7?2F2>A 52@6>36 ;<3 866> =?17C@67 89 :;6 @5<2E<>:3 8641?6 :;6 ?28C><5 :1 3;1I :;<: :;6 ?276? 14 :;6 E1:1? @9@56 ;<F2>A <> 6446@:2F6 <>7 F<527 7?2F2>A 52@6>36 :1?276 :;6E1:1? @9@56 ;<: <=<?: ;6 ;<3 4C?:;6? @1>:6>767 :;<: :;6?6 23 < F215<:21> 14 6@:21> # 14 @: <>7 :;6 3=1: 3H6:@; E<?H67 <: K3;1I3:;<::;6?623<>6A52A6>@61>:;6=<?:14:;6 ?276?14:;6E1:1?@9@566;<34C?:;6?3C8E2::67:;<:2> :;6 <836>@6 14 <>9 2>@1E6 =?114 :;6 ?28C><5 ;<3 @1EE2::6736?21C36??1?2>:<H2>A2>@1E614:;676@6<367 <: :;6 ?<:6 14 3 =6? E1>:; 2> :;6 =?636>@6 14 <7E23321> 89 2> :;6 @?133 6K<E2><:21> :;<: :;6 76@6<367 I<3 6<?>2>A 3!& :1 3& =6? E1>:; 2:; :;23 ;6 31CA;: :1 <551I :;6 <==6<5 89 :;6 1?=1?<:21><>736:<3276:;6DC7AE6>:<>7<I<?7=<3367 89:;6?28C><5 64C:2>A:;63C8E23321>314:;656<?>67@1C>365 41?:;6<==655<>::;656<?>67@1C>36541?:;6?63=1>76>:3 2>"1&I2:;<55F6;6E6>@63C8E2::67:;<: - 8 - :;6 3=1: 3H6:@; @56<?59 3;1I3 :;6 7<E<A63 3C3:<2>67 :1 :;68C33;1I3:;6?<3;<>7>6A52A6>:7?2F2>A14:;67?2F6? 31<531:;6=;1:1A?<=;314:;63=1:E<?H67<: K3<>7 !;6@<36I<3?6A23:6?67<A<2>3::;67?2F6?14:;68C3 <>7=152@6;<F642567@;<?A63;66:<A<2>3::;67?2F6?14:;6 8C3 ;6 @;<?A63;66: I<3 >1: @;<556>A67 89 :;6 1?=1?<:21> <>7 ;<F2>A <7E2::67 :;6 @;<?A63;66: :;6 1?=1?<:21> >1I @<>>1: 86 =6?E2::67 :1 <==?18<:6 <>7 ?6=?18<:6:;64<@::;<::;6?623>1>6A52A6>@61>:;6=<?: 14 :;6 7?2F6? 14 :;6 C3 6 ;<3 4C?:;6? 3C8E2::67 :;6 ?28C><5 ;<3 >1: =?1=6?59 @1>3276?67 :;6 2>@1E6 14 :;6 76@6<367 8C: :<H6> :;6 2>@1E6 <: 3& =6? E1>:; <>7 <@@1?72>A59 31CA;: :1 723E233 :;6 <==6<5 <>7 <551I :;6@?13318D6@:21> <F2>A ;6<?7 :;6 56<?>67 @1C>365 41? :;6 =<?:263 =6?C367 :;6 6>:2?6 <==6<5 <>7 @?133 18D6@:21> =<=6?3 <>7 31 <531 :;6 ?2<5 1C?: 6@1?73 ;6 =12>:3 :;<:I1C57<?23641?@1>3276?<:21><?6/ - 9 - 2' ;6:;6? :;6 <==655<>: J 1?=1?<:21> ;<3 E<76 1C: < @<36 1> :;6 @1>:?28C:1?9 >6A52A6>@6 1>:;6 =<?:14 76@6<367 M4 2: 2331<:I;<:=6?@6>:<A6M 22' ;6:;6?:;6@1E=6>3<:21><I<?76789:;6 ?28C><58642:I2:;2>:;66K=?63321>14DC3: @1E=6>3<:21> 24 <>3I6? 23 1:;6?I236 I;6:;6?<>92>:6?46?6>@623?6BC2?67<::;6 ;<>73 14 :;23 @1C?: :1 6>;<>@6 :;6 @1E=6>3<:21>M $ 9<>3I6?:1:;6<81F6=12>:314@1>3276?<:21> 23G>6A<:2F6(41?:;6=12>:1<>7G=<?:592><442?E<:2F6( 41?=12>:141?:;641551I2>A?6<31>3/ 7E2::6759:;6"2342567<A<2>3::;67?2F6?14:;6 8C3 <>7 :;6 =152@6 <4:6? 2>F63:2A<:21> ;<F6 42567 :;6 @;<?A63;66:<A<2>3::;67?2F6?14:;68C3;64252>A14:;6 @;<?A63;66: <A<2>3: :;6 7?2F6? 14 :;6 8C3 ;<3 >1: 866> @;<556>A67 89 :;6 ?63=1>76>: 1?=1?<:21> ;6 =;1:1A?<=;3 :<H6> 1> :;6 3=1: @56<?59 3=6<H3 <81C: :;6 ?<3; <>7 >6A52A6>: 7?2F2>A 14 :;6 8C3 89 :;67?2F6? 3 =6?:;63=1:3H6:@;:;66>:2?6E6<3C?6E6>:14?1<723 466:4?1E:;6<@@276>:3=1:<>7?1<71>:;6564:3276I<3 466:I;2@;@56<?593;1I3:;<::;68C3I<3862>A7?2F6> - 10 - 89 2:3 7?2F6? 1> :;6 I?1>A 3276 <>7 :;6 =;1:1A?<=;3 =?17C@67 <: K3 <>7 ! 3;1I3 :;6 3=667 14 :;6 8C3 ;6 @1>D12>: =6?C3<5 14 =;1:1A?<=;3 26 K3 <>7 ! <>7 :;6 3=1: 3H6:@; @56<?59 3;1I3 :;<: :;6 7?2F6? 14 :;6 8C3I;1I<37?2F2>A:;68C3I<31>:;66K:?6E6?2A;:3276 <>78691>7:;6=6?E2332856C3<A614?1<7 # C3862>A<;6<F9=<336>A6?F6;2@56:;67?2F6? 1CA;: :1 ;<F6 :<H6> <55 =?6@<C:21>3 I;256 7?2F2>A I2:;2> :;652E2:14C3<A614?1<7;63=1:3H6:@;@56<?59?6F6<53 :;<::;68C3I<31>I?1>A3276@?1332>AE1?6:;<>;<5414 =6?E2332856 ?1<7 C3<A6 4 :;6 7?2F6? 3;1C57 ;<F6 866> E1?6=?C76>:<>7@2?@CE3=6@:I;2567?2F2>A:;68C3@1C57 ;<F6<F12767:;6C>41?:C><:6<@@276>:I;2@;;<7@5<2E67 <91C>A5246>76?:;636@2?@CE3:<>@63:;63C8E23321>3 14 :;6 56<?>67 @1C>365 41? :;6 <==655<>: :;<: :;6?6 I<3 >6A52A6>@6 1> :;6 =<?: 14 :;6 ?276? @<>>1: 86 @1C>:6><>@67 @@1?72>A59 =12>: 1 23 <>3I6?67 <A<2>3::;6 1?=1?<:21> - 11 - 1 4<? <3 BC<>:CE 23 @1>@6?>67 :;6 2>@1E6 42K67 89 :;6 6A<5 6?F2@63 C:;1?2:9 2> ?63=6@: 14 C>3H25567 5<81C? 41? :;6 96<? 23 3!& =6? E1>:; :;6 ?28C><5 ;<3 :<H6> :;6 2>@1E6 <: 3& =6?E1>:;;6<@@276>:1@@C??672>:;696<?;6 ?28C><5 @1EE2::67 <> 6??1? 89 :<H2>A :;6 2>@1E6 14 :;6 76@6<367 <: < 51I6? ?<:6 :;<> :;6 2>@1E6 42K67 89 :;6 6A<5 6?F2@63 C:;1?2:9 ;6 76@6<367 I<3 <A67 # 96<?3<::;6:2E614<@@276>:;6>@6!L23?6BC2?67:186 <7767:1I<?73:;6G133144C:C?6=?13=6@:C3(2>:6?E314 :;65<I5<2771I>89:;61>(856=6K 1C?:2>:;6@<3614 !" # $ #%&' #() *+ #, "*"!)- % .' # , )!/" #- !/)'%?6=1?:672>01223;6 @5<2E<>:3 <?6 <531 6>:2:56 41? G133 14 4252<5 @1>31?:2CE( <: :;6?<:6143!&6<@;2>:6?E314:;65<I5<2771I> 89:;61>(856=6K 1C?:2> 4* )#)' $#%&' #() "*"!)- >F26I14:;62>@1E63:<:673C=?< <>7 1> ?676:6?E2><:21> G133 14 6=6>76>@9( I1?H3 1C: :1 , $ $* ',$ - .) / / / * >F26I145<I5<2771I>89:;61>(856=6K 1C?: - 12 - 2> .' , )!/" <>7 %*"! "%5 $ #- !/)'% % "6"%" # $ # 4)' !" # $ #%&' #() *+ #,"*"!)- #- # !/)'?6=1?:67 2>012:;6?63;<5586L63@<5<:21> 1>@1E=6>3<:21>41?6<@;:;?6696<?3<I<?767C>76? :;6@1>F6>:21><5;6<734?1E<3:;6<@@276>:23 14:;696<?:;6<==655<>:3<?66>:2:56741?L 2>@?6<367 1> @1>F6>:21><5 ;6<73 @@1?72>A59 =12>: 123<>3I6?672>4<F1C?14@5<2E<>:@?13318D6@:1?<>7 <A<2>3::;6@1?=1?<:21> > 3CEE<?9 :;6 :1:<5 @1E=6>3<:21> ?6 76:6?E2>67 89 :;23 1C?: C>76? F<?21C3 ;6<73 23 <3 41551I3/ 012,34506,1786 4967 133146=6>76>@9 3 #!& 13314 3:<:6 3 & 13314"C>6?<5 K=6>363 3 & 13314"252<5 1>31?:2CE 3!K' 3 $& - 13 - L 63@<5<:21> 1> @1>F6>:21><5;6<73 & , $$* @@1?72>A59 :;23 @1C?: =?1@6673 :1 =<33 :;6 41551I2>A1?76?/ 2' ==6<5 42567 89 :;6 1?=1?<:21> 2> " 1&@<552>A2>BC63:21>:;6DC7AE6>: <>7 76@?66 =<3367 89 :;6 ?28C><5 23 -"%*"%%)- 22' ;6<E1C>:2>76=132:89:;6@1?=1?<:21>3;<55 86 :?<>3E2::67 41?:;I2:; :1 :;6 @1>@6?>67 ?28C><541?7238C?36E6>:8<5<>@68676=132:67 <51>A I2:; <@@?C67 2>:6?63: I2:;2> < =6?217 14 32K I66H3 4?1E :;6 7<:6 14 ?6@62=: 14 @1=9 14 :;231?76? 222' ;6 " ?18 1& 42567 89 :;6 @5<2E<>:&@?133 18D6@:1? 23 $$ 5)- "# + '! ;6 <==655<>:@5<2E<>: 23 6>:2:567 41? <> <772:21><5 @1E=6>3<:21> 14 ,$:$ * - 14 - ', $$ ; ,$$ ) <51>A I2:; 2>:6?63: <: L =6? <>>CE 4?1E :;6 7<:6 14 4252>A14=6:2:21>:255?6<52N<:21> 2F' ;6 @1E=6>3<:21> <I<?767 89 :;6 ?28C><5 23 6>;<>@67 4?1E 3#& :1 3!& F' ;6 6>:2?6 @1E=6>3<:21> <I<?767 2> @?133 18D6@:21><3I655<3:;6<E1C>:<I<?76789:;6 ?28C><5 3;<55 86 76=132:67 89 :;6 <==655<>: J 1?=1?<:21>I2:;<>2>:6?63:<::;6?<:614L =6?<>>CE4?1E:;67<:6144252>A14=6:2:21>:255 ?6<52N<:21>8641?6:;6@1>@6?>67?28C><5I2:;2> <=6?2171432KI66H34?1E:;67<:614?6@62=:14 @1=914:;231?76? F2' ;6 <==1?:21>E6>: <>7 7238C?36E6>: <3 =6? :;61?76?14:;6?28C><5 F22' 11?76?<3:1@13: !2* ' ) # &23:1/51/!