Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 5416 (KAR)

RAGHAVENDRA S/O SURESHBABU JAMAKHANDIKAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/101253/2019 · 2025-01-08

J M Khazi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#!!#$ # % ! " # $ ! " % %& ! " ' ( ) - 2 - % ! * * # +# ! "%%# ' ( , #) # &$#$& + #$ - ! + #$ &#$ * % - ! #$##$# * - 3 - . / & ( 0 /) 1232345167894:61:66:3;51<:7:==>71< 4724% 9:?1 @3A1< 2937 B1232345 >5<16 71=2345 # 624 C>:79 291 =63D35:A B64=11<35;7 35323:21< :;:3572 291D 35 4+ #$ @46 291 4@@15=17 B>5379:EA1 >5<16 1=23457 & #$ 6 8 1=2345 % 4@ 45 291 @3A1 4@ <<32345:A3?3A><;1:5<>792:;3 # 57>BB4624@291B1232345291B12323451679:?1 =45215<1<29:2<4=>D152BA:=1<4561=46<D:F1732=A1:6 29:2291=4DBA:35:52:BBA31<@46291;6:524@:A4:5>5<16 937 73;5:2>61 @216 291 A4:5 8:7 7:5=23451< 291 152361 :D4>52 8:7 =61<321< 24 291 :==4>52 4@ 291 =4DBA:35:52 19:78329<6:852917:D12964>;9:8329<6:8:A7A3B1 9:7 D:<1 @:A71 :AA1;:23457 35 291 =4DBA:352 24 D:F1 8645;@>A;:3556A 4$G& #$2937450EA14>62 <361=21<291263:A4>6224=4573<16:AA291<4=>D1527:5< 2915 B:77 :BB64B63:21 46<167 H=1B2 61@16635; 24 291 - 4 - <4=>D1527 291 263:A 4>62 9:7 542 2:F15 291D 3524 =4573<16:2345 % A45;8329=4DBA:352617B45<152 4#9:7542 @3A1<:5I:@@3<:?32:5<<4=>D152724794829:2E1@461@3A35; 291=4DBA:352919:71H9:>721<:AA29161D1<317:?:3A:EA1 >5<16 1=23457 "(%) :5< "() 9161@461 291 =4DBA:35237=4526:6I242916:234A:3<<485EI291450EA1 >B61D14>6291263:A4>629:7542:BB61=3:21<29171 :7B1=27 5AI 45 291 E:737 4@ <4=>D1527 83294>2 :BB61=3:235;291<1@15=1B>2@4629EI291B1232345167291 263:A 4>62 9:7 72:21< 29:2 29161 37 D:2163:A 24 B64=11< :;:3572291B123234516 %5291@:3A>614@617B45<152 4#2461B:I291 A4:5 29611 5423=178161 377>1< 35=A><35; 291 @35:A 5423=1 <:21< #$#$% 5 291 @:3A>61 4@ 617B45<152 4# 24 =4DBAI 8329 291 7:D1 :6E326:2345 B64=11<35;7 8161 35323:21<5721:<4@61=13?35;2915423=1:5<B:623=3B:235; 35 32 617B45<152 4# 9:7 61@>71< 24 61=13?1 291 5423=1 4571C>152AI 291 :8:6< =:D1 24 E1 B:771< 45 - 5 - +$%#$%52917:D1<:I328:7@3A1<:5<5423=18:7 :A74 377>1< 24 617B45<152 4# <D3221<AI 91 9:7 542 =9:AA15;1<291:6E326:2345:8:6<:5<35721:<4@2917:D1 919:735?1521<:54?1A8:I2417=:B1@64D291A3:E3A32IEI @3A35;291=4DBA:35294>;9291B123234516B64<>=1<:AA291 <4=>D1527 E1@461 291 35?1723;:235; 4@@3=16 91 9:7 542 2:F15 291D 3524 =4573<16:2345 :5< D1=9:53=:AAI @3A1< 291 =9:6;1 79112 7 B16 291 :6E326:2345 :8:6< :5 1H1=>2345 B123234537@3A1<@4661=4?16I 17B45<152 4# 9:7 :?:3A1< : A4:5 4@ $$$$$$ EI ;3?35; 71=>632I 4@ 29611 321D7 4@ 3DD4?:EA1B64B162IEID37A1:<35;291E:5F481?1635 4 #$$+ 291 B123234516 :5< 937 @:D3AI D1DE167 9:?171=>61<:=4AA>7345<1=61124<1@6:><29136=61<32467 5 291 =4DBA:352 617B45<152 4# 9:7 =A:3D1< 29:2 291 1:6A316 ?193=A1 A4:5 8:7 =A1:61< 35 291 I1:6 #$$ 3271A@ 893=9 37 @:A71 91 ?193=A1 A4:5 8:7 =A1:61< 45 %$%#$I7>BB617735;29171@:=27617B45<152 4# 9:7 D37A1< 291 E:5F 45235>:2345 4@ 291 =63D35:A B64=11<35;7 :;:3572 291 B1232345167 :D4>527 24 :E>71 4@ - 6 - 291 B64=177 4@ 291 4>62 :5< B6:I 24 :AA48 291 B1232345 C>:792917:D1 " 57>BB4624@937:6;>D1527A1:651<=4>571A@46 B12323451679:761A31<>B45291@4AA4835;<1=37345 3) 6:6>5 :6D: :5< 29167 ?7 2:21 4@ :65:2:F: EI *9321 31A< 15;:A>6> :5< 542916) + 1:651< 61B61715235; 617B45<152 4 2:21 :5< A1:651< =4>571A 61B61715235; 617B45<152 4# =4DBA:35:52 7>ED3221< 29:2 <>635; 291 I1:6 #$$$ 617B45<152 4#:?:3A1<?193=A1A4:5:5<B>6=9:71<21DB4 H=1A ;44<7 ?193=A1 E1:635; 61;3726:2345 4J%G %+ @64D 291 >6E:5 =44B16:23?1 E:5F :5>D7:;:6 8329 291 =45<323454@<1B473235;#"$$$ :5<61B:I35;291A4:5 35I1:6AI3572:AD15274@+$$$$ *915617B45<152 4# =4>A< 542 B:I 291 3572:AD1527 45 &$%#$$# 91 8:7 7:5=23451< 61A4:5 4@ %#&$$$ H=1B2 @46 +$$$$ 61B:3< 35 291 7:3< I1:6 23AA #$$ 91 <3< 542 B:I :5I 3572:AD1527 1 - 7 - + 9161@46145G$##$$2917:3<?193=A18:7 713K1<46284I1:67617B45<152 4#<3<542;45124291 E:5F:5<D1122914@@3=3:A7481?16:@216284I1:6791 8:7 7>DD451< 24 291 E:5F :5< 45 291 =45<32345 4@ B64<>=35;B64B162I<4=>D1527291E:5F4@@3=3:A7B64D371< 2461A1:71291?193=A19161@461617B45<152 4#9:5<1< 4?161H26:=27:5<42916<4=>D1527B162:3535;24A:5< 72:5<35;359375:D1229:223D1291E:5F4@@3=3:A7244F 937 73;5:2>61 24 71?16:A EA:5F <4=>D1527 8329 : B64D371 29:2:@216291D11235;9184>A<E13523D:21<4@291@:=24@ 291 7:5=2345 4@ 291 A4:5 481?16 :@216 " <:I7 8915 617B45<152 4#D:<115C>36I918:735@46D1<29:2291 A4:5 8:7 542 7:5=23451< 91I 8152 45 B472B4535; 612>6535; 291 <4=>D1527 481?16 A:216 91 @:3A1< 24 B>67>12917:D1 +# 5 G$#$$G 291 E:5F 9:7 74A< 291 ;44<7 ?193=A1246:5<32>22:6:L:?:34@:<:;17B45<152 4# 8:7 377>1< 5423=17 <:21< $$#$$ $&$#$$ #G$#$$" %$#$$" #$&#$$G $#$%#$$& :5< #$$ >635; #$$ 291 E:5F =A471< 291 ?193=A1 - 8 - A4:5:5<EID37>735;29173;5:2>6174@617B45<152 4# 2:F15 45 EA:5F B:B167 :5< ?4>=9167 291 E:5F 4@@3=3:A7 9:?1 =91:21< 291 617B45<152 4# 8329 :5 352152345 24 F54=F 4@@ 291 B64B162I 72:5<35; 35 291 5:D1 4@ 291 83@1 :5<7454@617B45<152 4# +% 91I 9:?1 :A74 @3A1< : =:71 E1@461 291 4352 1;3726:64@44B16:23?14=312317:5<71=>61<:51HB:621 :8:6< <:21< +$%#$% EI D:5:;35; 29:2 5423=1 37 542 716?1<45617B45<152 4#*915291E:5F71525423=124 713K1291B64B162I72:5<35;352915:D14@83@1:5<7454@ 291 617B45<152 91 =:D1 24 F548 :E4>2 291 :8:6< 5 15C>36I 8329 291 E:5F16 617B45<152 4# 61:A371< 29:2 :@216 =A4735; 291 ?193=A1 A4:5 45 291 E:737 4@ 73;5:2>617 2:F15 24 EA:5F B:B167 291 E:5F 4@@3=3:A 9:?1 =91:21< 617B45<152 4# 17B45<152 4# :BB64:=91< 291 =45=1651< B4A3=1 24 @3A1 : =4DBA:352 :;:3572 291D28:7 542 152162:351< 9161@461 91 @46=1< 24 @3A1 291 B63?:21 =4DBA:352 - 9 - +91A1:651<:;3726:2161@1661<291=4DBA:35224 291=45=1651< B4A3=1 @4635?1723;:2345 @216 =45<>=235; : <12:3A1< 35?1723;:2345 291 =45=1651< B4A3=1 9:?1 @3A1< : =9:6;179112:;:3572291B1232345167916137:D:2163:A24 B64=11< :;:3572 291 B123234516 @216 291 61D:5< 35 6A 4$G& #$291A1:651<:;3726:219:7B:771< 3DB>;51< 46<16 EI 2:F35; 3524 =4573<16:2345 :AA 291 <4=>D1527BA:=1<4561=46<916137 D:2163:A 24B64=11<:;:3572291B1232345167:5<74>;92@46<37D377:A 4@291B1232345 G 57>BB4624@937:6;>D1527A1:651<=4>571A@46 617B45<152 4#9:761A31<>B45291@4AA4835;<1=37345 3) 9:6:DE116 >D:6 35;9 ?7 91 2:21 4@ 9:6F9:5<:5<56( ) 1:6<:6;>D15274@E42973<17:5<B16>71<291 61=46< & 91 >5<37B>21< @:=27 :61 29:2 <>635; 291 I1:6 #$$$ 617B45<152 4# E466481< : ?193=A1 A4:5 :5< 2 - 10 - B>6=9:71<:21DB4 H=1A ;44<7?193=A11 8:761C>361< 24 61B:I 291 7:D1 35 3572:AD1527 4@ +$$$$ B16 I1:6 *91591@:3A1<24=4DBAI832929161B:ID1527=91<>A191 8:7 ;6:521< : 61A4:5 4@ %#&$$$ 45 &$%#$$# 17B3212917:D1617B45<152 4#9:7@:3A1<24F11B>B 8329 291 61B:ID152 7=91<>A1 9161@461 291 E:5F 9:7 713K1< 291 ?193=A1 :216 45 32 8:7 74A< 24 6:5<32 >22:6:L :?:3 @46 ""$$$ :5< 291 7:3< :D4>52 8:7 =61<321< 24 937 A4:5 :==4>52 4 $$$# 481?16723AAE:A:5=18:7<>1 $ 2372917B1=3@3==:714@291B123234516729:235 46<162415:EA1617B45<152 4#2461B:I291:D4>52<>1 :2 937 61C>172 : D462;:;1 A4:5 4@ $$$$$$ 8:7 7:5=23451<:7B16:==4>52 4 %%#917:3<:D4>52 4@ $$$$$$ 8:7 =61<321< 24 291 :==4>52 4@ 617B45<152 4#:5<@64D29161328:726:57@1661<24291 193=A1 A4:5 :==4>52 4 $$$% $# :5< 291 7:3< ?193=A1 A4:5 :==4>52 8:7 =A471< 481?16 617B45<152 4#@:3A1<24B:I291D462;:;1A4:5:5<29161@461:@216 377>35; 71?16:A 5423=17 : =:71 8:7 @3A1< E1@461 291 4352 - 11 - 1;3726:6 4@ 291 46B46:21 4=312I :5< :5 :8:6< 8:7 71=>61< ?15 294>;9 617B45<152 4# 8:7 377>1< 8329 2915423=1352152345:AAI91<3<542=9447124=452172291 7:D1 1 9:7 :A74 542 =9:AA15;1< 291 :8:6< B:771< :;:3572 93D :5< :7 :5 :6D2837235; 2:=23=7 617B45<152 4# 9:7 =94715 24 @3A1 : @:A71 =4DBA:352 :5< 291 =45=1651< B4A3=1 83294>2 1H:D3535; 291 <4=>D1527 D:352:351<8329291E:5F9:?1@3A1<:=9:6;179112 5<37B>21<AI 291 ?193=A1 A4:5 2:F15 EI 617B45<152 4#8:754261B:3<91:==4>5272:21D1524@ 291?193=A1A4:5=A1:6AI35<3=:21729:21?15:@2162917:A14@ 291 ?193=A1 @46 ""$$$ :5< :<L>7235; 291 7:3< :D4>52 248:6<7 291 E:A:5=1 <>1 @64D 617B45<152 4# 723AA : 9>;1 E:A:5=1 8:7 <>1 :5< 35216172 8:7 :==>D>A:235; 17B45<152 4# 9:7 542 D:<1 :5I =A:3D 29:2 91 9:7 61B:3<291?193=A1A4:5:5<542935;8:7<>1 ?15294>;9 617B45<152 4# =A:3D1< 29:2 B64D3735; 24 B:I : D462;:;1 A4:5 937 73;5:2>617 8161 2:F15 24 EA:5F <4=>D1527:5<54A4:58:77:5=23451<2493D919:754 1HBA:5:2345 :7 24 948 45 #$$#$ : 7>D 4@ - 12 - $$$$$$ 8:7 26:57@1661< @64D 937 D462;:;1 A4:5 :==4>52 4 %%# 24 937 :==4>52 4 $$$# 5 291 7:D1 <:I 4>2 4@ $$$$$$ : 7>D 4@ &+%G#" 37 <1E321< :5< 26:57@1661< 24 937 ?193=A1 A4:5 :==4>52 4 $$$% $# 91 7:D1 37 :<L>721< 248:6<7 291 A4:5 <>1 35 : 7>D 4@ %#$+ 248:6<7 B635=3B:A +$GG&+ 248:6<735216172:5<%#% 248:6<742916 =9:6;17:5<291?193=A1A4:5:==4>52=:D124E1=A471< # @216 291 =A47>61 4@ 291 ?193=A1 A4:5 :==4>52 $$$$$$ 2:F15 :7 : D462;:;1 A4:5 8:7 723AA <>1 <D3221<AI617B45<152 4#9:7542B:3<:5I3572:AD1527 248:6<7 291 D462;:;1 A4:5 @ 291 D462;:;1 A4:5 4@ $$$$$$ 37 542 :<L>721< 248:6<7 291 ?193=A1 A4:5 617B45<152 4#375429:?35;:5I1HBA:5:2345:724948 &+%G#" =:D1 24 E1 B:3< 45 %$%#$ <D3221<AI 291 152361 =:71 37 E:71< 45 <4=>D152:6I 1?3<15=1 D:352:351< 8329 291 E:5F 9161@461 291 35?1723;:235; 4@@3=16 8:7 1HB1=21< 24 1H:D351 :AA 29171 <4=>D1527 - 13 - 35=A><35; 291 :==4>52 72:21D152 4@ 617B45<152 4# 8329 291E:5F35C>172345 % 481?16 291 =9:6;1 79112 35<3=:217 29:2 291 35?1723;:235; 4@@3=16 9:7 542 :2 :AA 1H:D351< 291 :==4>52 72:21D15274@291284A4:5:==4>527:5<291:==4>524@ 617B45<152 4# D:352:351< 8329 291 E:5F 4@ 893=9 B1232345167 :61 291 361=2467 *915 617B45<152 4# <1@:>A21<35B:I35;291?193=A1A4:5:5<45%$%#$: 242:A7>D4@&+%G#" =:D124E1=61<321<24291A4:5 :==4>52@64D2917:?35;7E:5F:==4>524@617B45<152 4# 4>24@$$$$$$ 893=98161=61<321<24937:==4>52 45 #$$#$ @64D 937 D462;:;1 A4:5 :==4>52 4%%# 2 ;417 83294>2 7:I35; 29:2 E:71< 45 291 <4=>D1527 1H1=>21< EI 617B45<152 4# : D462;:;1 A4:5 4@ $$$$$$ 8:77:5=23451<24291617B45<152 4#:5< 4>24@2917:D1291?193=A1A4:5:==4>528:77:237@31<:5< =A471< *915617B45<152 4#9:7:A74@:3A1<2461B:I 291 D462;:;1 A4:5 91 9:7 E115 377>1< 8329 5423=17 1 - 14 - 9:7 542 =94715 24 617B45< 24 291 7:D1 EI D:F35; B:ID15246=9:AA15;35;2917:D19161@461B64=11<35;7 8161 35323:21< E1@461 291 4352 1;3726:6 4@ 44B16:23?1 4=312317 1 8:7 :A74 377>1< 5423=1 893=9 :==46<35; 24 291 B1232345167 37 61@>71< EI 617B45<152 54# :5< 29161@461 1HB:621 46<16 =:D1 24 E1 B:771< ;6:5235; :5 :8:6<@4661=4?16I4@#&G$$$ 832935216172:71<45 2917:D1:5:22:=9D1525423=18:7377>1<24617B45<152 4# " 17B321 291 7:D1 617B45<152 54# 9:7 542 =9:AA15;1< 291 7:3< :8:6< E1@461 291 B64B16 @46>D 5721:< 4@ 291 7:D1 91 9:7 =94715 24 @3A1 : B63?:21 =4DBA:352:;:3572291B1232345167763;92AI7>ED3221<EI 291 A1:651< =4>571A @46 291 B1232345167 294>;9 35 291 D11235; <:21< $$##$ 35 :AA 71?15 361=2467 8161 B6171528915291A4:54@617B45<152 4#:5<4291678:7 7:5=23451<@4629161:7457E172F54852493D617B45<152 4#9:7B3=F1<>B291B123234516724:66:3;5:7:==>71< - 15 - + ?15294>;935291=4DBA:352323772:21<29:291 9:< :BB64:=91< 291 =45=1651< B4A3=1 24 @3A1 : =4DBA:352 :5<291I<3<54261=13?12917:D1:<D3221<AI617B45<152 4#9:7542B64<>=1<=4BI4@291=4DBA:3525I948291 35?1723;:235;4@@3=169:7542D:<1:B64B1635?1723;:2345 5 1H:D3535; :AA 291 29611 :==4>52 72:21D1527 4@ 617B45<152 4# 91 84>A< 9:?1 =4D1 24 F548 29:2 291 D462;:;1 A4:5 4@ $$$$$$ 8:7 7:5=23451< 24 617B45<152 4#:5<2917:D19:7E115:<L>721<248:6<7 29161B:ID1524@291?193=A1A4:5<>1:5<3237542:=:71 4@ B1232345167 9:?35; D37:BB64B63:21< 291 A4:5 :D4>52 >23A3K35;73;51<EA:5F<4=>D1527 G 91 ?16I =45<>=2 4@ 617B45<152 4# 35 542 617B45<35; 24 291 5423=17 24 =452172 291 B64=11<35;7 E1@46129143521;3726:64@44B16:23?14=312I:5<:A74 =9:AA15;35; 291 :8:6< B:771< EI 93D 37 =4526:6I 24 291 :AA1;:23457 D:<1 35 291 =4DBA:352 ?15 294>;9 35 6A 4$G& #$291446<35:2115=94@29374>62 <361=21<291263:A4>62241H:D351:AA291<4=>D1527:5< B:7751=177:6I46<16732:BB1:6729:2291263:A4>629:7 - 16 - 542:BBA31<327D35<5AI45291E:7374@72:21D15274@ 832517717 :AA1;1<AI ;3?15 >5<16 1=2345 + 6 291 263:A 4>62 9:7 B64=11<1< 24 94A< 29:2 29161 37 7>@@3=3152 D:2163:A 24 @6:D1 =9:6;17 :;:3572 291 B1232345167 91 =45=A>73457:663?1<:2EI291263:A4>6237=4526:6I24291 <4=>D1527 BA:=1< 45 61=46< :5< :7 7>=9 B16?1671 45235>:2345 4@ 291 B64=11<35;7 :;:3572 291 B1232345167 84>A< =162:35AI :D4>52 24 :E>71 4@ 291 B64=177 4@ 291 4>629161@461291=63D35:AB64=11<35;735C>172345:61 A3:EA124E1C>:791<:5<:==46<35;AI291@4AA4835; :) 1232345 @3A1< EI 291 B1232345167 >5<16 1=2345#4@637:AA481< E) 91 =63D35:A B64=11<35;7 35323:21< :;:3572 291B123234516735 4+ #$45291 @3A1 4@ <<32345:A 3?3A ><;1 :5< >792:;3@462914@@15=17B>5379:EA1>5<16 1=23457&-#$6 81=2345%4@ 379161EIC>:791< - 17 - =) 15<:=4BI4@29146<1624291263:A=4>62 @46298329 '() *!#$+ !