- 1 - ! "" #$ % %$ & $ '(')*+(' ** ! " #$ %$%$ & '% % #$( & $ $ '% % $ () Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ' !) " #$ $ % ' * $% ' & ' + '' , )+ '%- ' . $ $$( ' '' $ +. )+ ) + ' + ' $ . ' /$' ' ' 0$ %- - 3 - # 0$ %-& 12323451678439:66:3;51<:9:==>91<48:9?3@1< 2839 A1232345 >5<16 1=2345 + 4? 281 4<1 4? 3B3@ 64=1<>61 #6& 24 C>:98 281 =4DA@:352 :5< =8:6;1 98112 35 4)+ :5< 46<16 4? 2:E35; =4;53F:5=1 :5< 399>:5=1 4? A64=199 <:21< :5< 152361 A64=11<35;9 :9 :;:3592 83D 35 63D1 4. 4? 4D15 >G:@@3 8:67:<?462814??15=19A>5398:G@1 >5<16 1=23459 +. )+ ) :5< 1=2345 + 4? 67 1=23459:5<+281476H6483G32345=2 . A15<35;45281?3@14?<<32345:@ 3B3@><;1:5<'( 4>62 8:67:< 5 9>AA462 4? 281 A1232345 A123234516 8:9 =45215<1<28:2281=4DA@:352395429>92:35:G@1352811H1 4? @:7 81 46<16 4? 2:E35; =4;53F:5=1 :5< 399>:5=1 4? A64=199:;:3592281A123234516394AA491<24@:7 ?:=29:5< =36=>D92:5=19 4? 281 =:91 81 :@@1;:23459 D:<1 35 281 =4DA@:3529 <:21< :5< GH 619A45<1524:61=4526:<3=246H241:=842816816139 - 4 - 3546<35:21 <1@:H 35 ?3@35; 281 =4DA@:352 :5< 281 9:D1 39 542 1IA@:351< 81 92:21D1529 4? 281 732519919 :61 =45=4=21<?46281A>6A4914?2839=:914DA@:35:5251B16 @1<D:632:@@3?17328:==>91<4 ':@91 :@@1;:23459 :61 D:<1 24 264>G@1 281 A123234516 4DA@:35:52 8:< ;451 24 >J:6:2 24 ?3@1 281 =4DA@:352 :5< 35 619A1=2 4? 281 9:D1 92:21D152 4? 281 732519919 39 542 61=46<1< 8161 :61 54 9A1=3?3= :@@1;:23459:;:3592281A123234516:5<28161:6145@HG:@< :5<4D53G>9:@@1;:234595281@3;824?281<1=393454?281 45/G@1 >A61D1 4>62 35 281 A64=11<35;9 :;:3592 281 A123234516 39 @3:G@1 24 G1 C>:981<:5<A6:H24:@@47281A1232345 1:651< 61A61915235; 619A45<152 4( 2:21 :5< @1:651< =4>591@ 61A61915235; 619A45<1524=4DA@:35:529>GD3221<46:@4GJ1=23459 92:235; 28:2 :==>91< 49 :5< :61 281 A:61529 :5< 1 (2022) 1 SCR 558 - 5 - :==>91< 4+ 39 281 G642816 :5< :==>91< 4) 39 281 939216(35(@:74?A12323451681D:663:;14?=4DA@:35:52 :5< A123234516 7:9 A16?46D1< 45 :2 8:67:< 4DA@:35:52 8:9 @492 816 ?:2816 :5< 7328 ;61:2 <3??3=>@2H 61@:23B19 A16?46D1< 816 D:663:;1 GH 9A15<35; 9 @:E8 2 281 23D1 4? D:663:;1 45 281 <1D:5<D:<1GHA123234516:5<42816:==>91< :9>D 4? 9)@:E87:9A:3<:5<D:663:;17:9A16?46D1<GH 9A15<35; 9 @:E8 ==>91< 4 8:< =45B35=1< 281 =4DA@:35:52:5<816?:D3@HD1DG16928:2A12323451639 8:B35; : 6193<1523:@ 84>91 5 281 35923;:2345 4? 281 :==>91<4924) A1232345167:651<281=4DA@:35:52 28:2281H984>@<5428:B1:5H=83@<615 ==>91< 4) 7:9 542 :@@4735; 281 =4DA@:35:52 24 2:E1 =:61 4? 816 8>9G:5< :5< ?46=3G@H A61B15235; 816 ?64D 2:E35; =:61 4? 83D 81 >91< 24 :99:>@2281=4DA@:35:52B15A123234516>91<24=4D1 84D1 @:21 35 <6>5E15 =45<32345 :5< :99:>@2 816 123234516 7:9 542 A16?46D35; 839 D:632:@ 4G@3;:23459 - 6 - 5:G@1 24 G1:6 281 8:6:99D152 <>635; 281 D4528 4? :6=8 =4DA@:35:52612>651<24281D:263D453:@84D1 815 : A:5=8:H:2 7:9 81@< 281 :==>91< A169459 35=@><35;281A123234516<1D:5<1<:<<32345:@<476H:5< :==>91< 4 :99:>@21< 281 =4DA@:35:52 35 281 A61915=1 4? A:5=8:9 4DA@:35:52 2631< 24 @4<;1 =4DA@:352:;:3592:@@281:==>91<A169459 35=@><35;281 A123234516:2:5<835:;:6 123234516 :==>91< 49+ :5< ) >91< 24 :99:>@2 :5< :G>91 816 >5<16 281 35?@>15=1 4? :@=484@ 81H 7161 <1D:5<35; 28:2 132816 816 A:61529 984>@< ;3B1 :<<32345:@ <476H 46 1@91 981 984>@< A:H 281D @23D:21@H =4DA@:35:52 7:9 <63B15 4>2 4? 281 D:263D453:@ 84D1 5 2839 61;:6< 981 ?3@1< =4DA@:352 45 471B16 <>1 24 281 35216B152345 4? 1@<16@HA169459 35=@><35; 281 :==>91< 49 24 ) 9:3< =4DA@:352 7:9 542 A169>:<1< :5< 981 7:9 2:E15 24 >J:6:2GH281D - 7 - 471B16 :;:35 281H 92:621< <1D:5<35; 28:2 816 A:61529 984>@< A:H :<<32345:@ <476H :9 281H 7:52 24 =45926>=2 : 84>91 :5< 281H <1D:5<1< 9K @:E8 81H >91< 24 :G>91 816 5=1 :;:35 >5:G@1 24 G1:6 281 8:6:99D152 981 =:@@1< 816 G642816 :5< 7328 83D612>651<24816A:6152:@84D145+5 ) :2 AD 51:6 816 84>91 281H <1D:5<1< <476H :5< :G>91< 816 84>;8 281 =45=1651< A4@3=1 :<B391< 281 :==>91< 281H <3< 542 @3921524281D:5<28161?461 :;:3598139?46=1<24?3@1 =4DA@:35245 +$:91< 45 281 =4DA@:352 281 =45=1651< A4@3=18:B161;392161<281=:9135=63D14.?46 281 4??15=19 A>5398:G@1 >5<16 1=23459 +. )+ ) 61:< 7328 1=2345 + 4? :5< 1=23459 :5< + 4? 476H 6483G32345 =2 . :5< 2:E15 >A 35B1923;:2345 ?216 =45=@><35; <12:3@1< 35B1923;:2345 =8:6;1 98112 39 ?3@1< :;:3592 :==>91< 49 24 ) 35=@><35; 281 A123234516 8161 39 9>??3=3152 D:2163:@ 24 - 8 - A64=11< :;:3592 :@@ 281 :==>91< A169459 35=@><35; 281 A123234516:5<A6:H24<39D399281A1232345 + 1:6<:6;>D1529:5<A16>91<28161=46< ) 8>9 A123234516 784 39 :==>91< 4 ! 281 8>9G:5< 4? =4DA@:35:52 39 911E35; C>:9835; 4? 281 =8:6;198112=45215<35;28:2281:@@1;:23459:;:3592:@@ 281 :==>91< A169459 35=@><35; 281 A123234516 :61 4D53G>9 :5< 28161 39 54 1B3<15=1 24 A64=11< :;:3592 83D 8161@:2345983AG127115281A:623193954235 <39A>2181D:663:;14?=4DA@:35:52:5<:==>91<4 7:9 81@< 45 8161 39 9A1=3?3= :@@1;:2345 28:2 :9<1D:5<1<GH281:==>91<A169459 <476H35: 9>D 4? 9) @:E8 35 =:98 24@:9 4? ;4@< 7:9 ;3B15 3D3@:6@H ;4@<465:D152713;835;L24@:97:9;3B15 24281G63<1:5<84>9184@<:623=@197161:@94;3B15:5< D:663:;17:9A16?46D1<GH9A15<35;35:@@ 9@:E8 - 9 - ?216 281 D:663:;1 =4DA@:35:52 92:H1< 7328 281 :==>91<A169459:2:5<835:;:64?>J:6:2 K 81 =4DA@:35:52 =@1:6@H 61?1661< 24 281 8:6:99D152D121<4>2GH:@@281A169459 35=@><35;281 A123234516 2 39 :@@1;1< 28:2 A123234516 >91< 24 =4D1 <6>5E:5<?:3@1<24A16?46D839D:263D453:@4G@3;:23459 @@4?281D>91<248:6:99:5<3@@(261:2816?46;12235; :<<32345:@ <476H 81H 7161 <1D:5<35; :<<32345:@ <476H:5<?35<35;?:>@273288164DA@:35:527:9542 :@@471< 24 9A15< 23D1 7328 A123234516 GH 839 939216(35( @:7==>91<4:5<7161=@:3D35;28:2935=1281H 8:B1 1<>=:21< :==>91< 4 35 ?4613;5 =4>526H 281 <476H A:3< 39 542 9>??3=3152 ==>91< 4 :@94 :99:>@21<81684>;82863=1 9812631<24?3@1=4DA@:352 :2 :5<835:;:6 981 =4>@< 542 ==>91< 4 7:9 <1D:5<35; 816 24 ;12 D451H 24 A>6=8:91 : 84>91 ==>91< 4+ 7:9 :@94 9>AA46235; 281 61D:3535; :==>91<A169459 - 10 - 2:AA1:69 7815281?3692=4DA@:3527:9?3@1< 45 :9122@1D1527:9:663B1<:2:5<7815 2835;9<3<5423DA64B1 281=4DA@:35:528:9=8491524 ?3@1 281 91=45< =4DA@:352 >A45 783=8 : =:91 39 61;392161<:5<>@23D:21@H=8:6;19811239?3@1< . 8161 :61 :@@1;:23459 :;:3592 1:=8 4? 281 :==>91<A169459 35=@><35;281A123234516?216<12:3@1< 35B1923;:2345 =8:6;1 98112 39 ?3@1< 2 D:E19 4>2 : 92645; A63D1 =:91 9 24 :61 =321< :9 1H1732519919 24 281 35=3<152 8191 :@@1;:23459 :61 61C>361< 24 G1 192:G@3981< :2 : ?>@@(?@1<;1< 263:@ 3284>2 A64B3<35; 4AA462>532H 24 281 A6491=>2345 24 A64B1 281 :@@1;:23459 281 <39A>21< ?:=29 =:5542 G1 <1=3<1<35:A1232345>5<16 1=2345+6 4?:6 :9 281 <1=39345 4? 281 45/G@1 >A61D1 4>62 35 39 =45=1651< 35 281 @3;82 4? 281 9A1=3?3= :@@1;:23459 :;:3592 1:=8 4? 281 :==>91< A169459 35=@><35;281A123234516 3239542:AA@3=:G@124281=:91 - 11 - 45 8:5< 5 281 619>@2 281 A1232345 ?:3@9 :5< :==46<35;@H 281?4@@4735; 3& 1232345 ?3@1< GH 281 A123234516:==>91< 4 >5<16 1=2345 + 6 39 8161GH <39D3991< 33& 15< : =4AH 4? 2839 46<16 24 281 263:@ =4>62 ?46287328 ,+ '%$ &* % 3924. @4