- 1 - !" #!$!! ! % & &' (%)*&(( + ! " # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % & % $ ! ' ( )$'&* * ! + ,++ + )$'$*! , )*- , , "! ,# , *' * " " * , + - 3 - ) , ,, "&" "" "$) *) ,- & $ ! , * " . "/ " 01 , , *$ , , # 2 $! 2 34 5678.916: ; # 56 <= 1/4 8" * 86:3475=487:34=41.64>>>5:5861=4//586/ ?>@4 16> ,1/: .1AB <4A51= 8?.: ; 5C1D1<?.1 5/ 59<?@656@ :34 C?>@946: >1:4> *' * " 1AE?5::56@ 1AA?/4> 8/ :8 * 87 :34 87746A4/ <?65/31F=4 ?6>4. 4A:586/ "&" "" "$ 16> * 87 6>516 461= 8>4 G78./38.:HIJ?6>4.4A:586/&$16>!87.8:4A:586 8735=>.467.894K?1= 7746A4/A:G78./38.:H IJ 16> ?6>4. 4A:586/ ". "/ 16> " 01 87 A34>?=4> 1/:4/ 16> A34>?=4> .5F4/ .4046:586 87 - 4 - :.8A5:54/ 946>946: A: *$ G78. /38.: H A:IJ ,1A:/87:34A1/456F.5471.4:31::341<<4==16: 34.456 1/ 5678.916: 75=4> :34 75./: 5678.91:586 86 *!*( * 1@156/: :34 1AA?/4> 1==4@56@ :31: 1AA?/4> 8 31> B5>61<<4> 35/ 9568. >1?@3:4. 1@4> & D41./ 16>:34.4FDA8995::4>:341F804946:5864>87746A4/ 6 :34 F1/5/ 87:34 75./: 5678.91:586, L1/.4@5/:4.4> 16> :34 5604/:5@1:586 L1/ ?6>4.:1B46 7:4. 5604/:5@1:586 A31.@4)/344:A194:8F475=4>1@156/:1AA?/4>8/:8* 78.:341F804/15>87746A4/ " 34 1AA?/4> 3104 1<<41.4> F478.4 :34 .51= 8?.: 16> <=41>4> 68:@?5=:D 34 <.8/4A?:5864K19564> #/ :8 L5:64//4/ @8: 91.B4> K/ :8 '! 16> 5>46:5754> 8:8(56/?<<8.:875:/A86:46:58634 1AA?/4> 3104 >4654> 1== :34 56A.59561:56@ 91:4.51=/ 1015=1F=486.4A8.>56:345./:1:4946:?6>4.4A:586""87 . ?: 3104 68: A38/46 :8 =41> 16D 405>46A4 56 - 5 - /?<<8.:87:345.>4746A434.51=8?.:17:4.:1B56@56:8 A86/5>4.1:586 1== :34/4 91:4.51=/ 86 .4A8.> A194 :8 :34 A86A=?/586 :31: :34 <.8/4A?:586 5/ 68: /?AA4//7?= 56 <.8056@ :34 @?5=: 87 :34 1AA?/4> 78. 16D 87 :34 87746A4/ AA8.>56@=D:3459<?@64>C?>@946:871AE?5::1=A194:8 F4 <1//4> 456@ 1@@.5404> FD :34 /194 5678.916: ; # 5/F478.4:35/8?.:FD75=56@:341<<41= 41.>9:15/36105 16@164=41.64>A8?6/4= 78.:341<<4==16:/.53501616>1::161/34::5=41.64> A8?6/4= 78. .4/<86>46: 8/ :8 * 16> .5 191>1. 3131F?>>56=41.64>5@38?.:804.6946:=41>4.78. .4/<86>46:8):1:44.?/4>:3491:4.51=/56A=?>56@ :34.51=8?.:.4A8.>/ $ 6 054L 87 :34 .501= A86:46:586/ ?.@4> FD =41.64>A8?6/4=/78.F8:3:34<1.:54/:34<856::31:L8?=> 1.5/478.9DA86/5>4.1:5865/ - 6 - D16/L4.:8:341F804<856:5/56:3478. :3478==8L56@ & : 5/ :34 /<4A575A A86:46:586 87 :34 5678.916: F478.4 :34 .51= 8?.: :31: 1AA?/4> 8 31> B5>61<<4> :3405A:59@5.=1@4>&D41./16>A8995::4>:3487746A4 <?65/31F=4 ?6>4. 4A:586 "&" 87 AA?/4> 8 L.86@7?==D A867564> :34 05A:59 @5.= 78. 98.4 :316 :3.44 >1D/16>A8995::4>:3487746A4?6>4.4A:586""87 4 ?/4> A.59561= 78.A4 :8 >5/.8F4 :34 L574 87 :34 5678.916:31:A34>A.59561=A86/<5.1ADL5:31AA?/4>8/ :8 ( :8 A8995: :34 87746A4 AA?/4> 8 A8995::4> 1@@.101:4> <464:.1:504 /4K?1= 1//1?=: 86 :34 05A:59 @5.= .4<41:4>=D16>34L1/31056@<8.68@.1<35A91:4.51=L5:3 16 56:46:586 :8 /31.4 8. :.16/95: A35=> <8.68@.1<3D B68L56@ 7?==D L4== :31: :34 05A:59 @5.= F4=86@/ :8 /A34>?=4> A1/:4 16> A8995::4> :34 87746A4 L5:3 16 - 7 - 56:46:586 :8 3?95=51:4 34. 4 1F?/4> :34 05A:59 @5.= 56 75=:3D =16@?1@4 L5:356 :34 <?F=5A 054L 16> 56:46:5861==D 56/?=:4> 34. AA?/4> 8/ :8 ( 3104 1F4::4> 1AA?/4> 856A8995//58687:3487746A416>:34.4FD:34D3104 A8995::4>87746A41//:1:4>1F804 ! 8 <.804 5:/ A86:46:586 <.8/4A?:586 4K19564> # ; 05A:59 34./4=7 046 :38?@3 :35/ L5:64// /:1:4> :31:/34L1/1@4>&D41./1::31::5948756A5>46:/34 /<4A575A1==D /:1:4/ :31: /34 L1/ 56 =804 L5:3 :34 1AA?/4> 16>/34L16:4>:891..D3594.<1.46:/L4.41@156/: /?A3 91..51@4 16> :34D L4.4 68: L5==56@ :8 1..16@4 34. 91..51@4L5:3:341AA?/4>34.478.4/3434./4=756/5/:4> :341AA?/4>:8@88?:87:3438?/416>:88B:341AA?/4> L5:334.#5:64//1>95:/:31:1AA?/4>831>1>05/4> 34.68::856>?=@456 =80417715.F?:56/<5:487:31:/34 L1/34==F46:5691..D56@359341>95:/:31:34.71:34. 31> @5046 1 71=/4 A89<=156: 3?/ # 31/ A89<=4:4=D :?.64>38/:5=4:8:34A1/487:34<.8/4A?:586 - 8 - ' # 5/ :34 A89<=15616: ) :34 71:34. 87 :34 05A:59@5.=046:38?@3:8/8944K:46:34/?<<8.:4>:34 A1/4 87 :34 <.8/4A?:586 >?.56@ A.8//)4K19561:586 /:1:4> :31: 68 56A5>46: 31> 8AA?..4> 1/ 1==4@4> 8L404. 34 >4654>:34 /?@@4/:586 :31:# L1/ L5==56@:8 91..D :34 1AA?/4>16>/3434./4=756/5/:4>359:891..D ( #/" :8 1.4 :34 9131M1. L5:64//4/ :8 01.58?/9131M1./#/ "$:8!'( &16> ! 1.4 :34 645@3F8?./ 864 87 :34/4L5:64//4/ 1.4 :34 4D4L5:64//4/?::345.405>46A4>5/A=8/4/:31::34DL4.4 >4<8/56@86:34F1/5/87:34/1D87:3405A:59@5.= * #5/:3498:34.87:3405A:59@5.=341=/8 >4<8/4>86:34F1/5/87:34/1D87:3405A:59@5.=# *5/ :34A=1//91:487:3405A:5916># 5/:34/5/:4.87:34 05A:59#/ 16> "1.4:34F.8:34./871AA?/4>8 # 5//15>:831041AA89<1654>1AA?/4>816>:34 05A:59@5.= 56 :34A1. :31: L1/>.5046FD # $ # '5/ /15>:83104@5046/34=:4.:81AA?/4>816>:3405A:59 - 9 - @5.=F?:686487:34/4L5:64//4/3104/?<<8.:4>:34A1/4 87:34<.8/4A?:586 #3466891:4.51=L5:64//4/3104/?<<8.:4>:34 A1/4 87 :34 <.8/4A?:586 /59<=D 86 :34 F1/5/ 87 :34 75./: 5678.91:586 =8>@4> FD # :34 1AA?/4> A1668: F4 A8605A:4> 046 :38?@3 /4.58?/ 1==4@1:586/ 1.4 91>4 1@156/:1AA?/4> 856<1.:5A?=1. 16> :34 8:34. 1AA?/4> 56@464.1=>868:756>16D/?<<8.:56@91:4.51=/:838=> :31: :34 <.8/4A?:586 5/ /?AA4//7?= 56 <.8056@ :34 @?5=: 87 :34 1AA?/4> F4D86> .41/861F=4 >8?F: 6>4. /?A3 A5.A?9/:16A4/:341AA?/4>1.446:5:=4>78.1AE?5::1= 3104@864:3.8?@3:3459<?@64>C?>@946:87 1AE?5::1= <1//4> FD :34 .51= 8?.: 34 .51= 8?.: 31/ A86/5>4.4> :34 8.1= 16> >8A?946:1.D 405>46A4 <=1A4> F478.45:16>1..504>1::34.5@3:A86A=?/586>868:756> 16D.41/86:856:4.74.4L5:3:34/194 " 6054L87:341F80416/L4.:341F804<856: 56:34 16><.8A44>:8<1//:3478==8L56@ - 10 - 34.59561=<<41=5/ 34 744/ 87 :34 =41.64> 95A?/ ?.514 5/ 75K4> 1: /****) 34 4@5/:.1. 5/ >5.4A:4> :8 <1D :34 744/ 87 :34 =41.64>95A?/?.514 4@5/:.D:8/46>F1AB:341=86@L5:3A8<D87:35/ C?>@946:78.5678.91:58616>78.644>7?=1A:586 ,% &!!( $ 5/:8=8 ! :<B