Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 50838 (KAR)

THE MANAGING DIRECTOR v. NAGANATH AND ORS

MFA/200571/2021 · 2025-03-21

K Natarajan, Vijaykumar A Patil

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ $ #$ %$!" ""&% ' () ""&% ' ( ) ! " # $"% & ' ( () Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ** ( ( ** ( $+% ' * *) # $"%, '* -"--"!) & ' ( (*. ( %"%" ) * * ! ') * ( * "%%% / ( 0 1 ( (! % * * ( ) ** ( ( ** ( & ' ( () - 3 - % " " # & ' ( () * * !')*( , ( * # * "%%% / ( 0 1( (! % 1* * ( - 4 - 2 2 ( $ '2 ) 34546789::49;59<4=>;4?@A?4< 4B6>8A!')8= 868< (43>B;45 B6 '=8< 538<6 34<4>A9=64< <4=4<<4? 68 95 C634 B6/) 9A? 634 59D4 9<4 9<>5>AE 8@6 8= 634 F@?ED4A6 9A? 979<? ?964? "%%% :9554? >A (8! % GH634??>6>8A9; 4A>8<>I>; @?E49A?4DG4<- 1(>F9H:@< % 38@E363>5D9664<>5;>564?=8<9?D>55>8A7>63 634B8A54A68=;49<A4?B8@A54;=8<G863:9<6>45>6>569J4A @:=8<=>A9;?>5:859; % 9<6>45 9<4 <4=4<<4? 68 95 :4< 634>< <9AJ>AE G4=8<4634<>G@A9; %" 4>AE 9EE<>4I4? GH 634 F@?ED4A6 9A? 979<? :9554? GH 634 <>G@A9; 634 :46>6>8A4<5 39I4 =>;4? 634 9::49; >A * 8% % 544J>AE 4A39AB4D4A6 8= B8D:4A596>8A 9A? 634 <45:8A?4A6-8<:8<96>8A 395 =>;4? - 5 - 6349::49;>A*8%%! %544J>AE68<4?@B4634 B8D:4A596>8A 95 74;; 95 634 ;>9G>;>6H 8= !K 8A 634 <45:8A?4A6-8<:8<96>8A % 34B9548=634B;9>D9A65>56396634H39I4=>;4? B;9>D :46>6>8A @A?4< 4B6>8A ++ 8= ( B6 =8< B;9>D>AE B8D:4A596>8A=8<634?49638=634?4B4954?>A<89?6<9==>B 9BB>?4A6 6 >5 9;;4E4? 6396 8A %%,%! 634 ?4B4954? D8;9A?8634<574<4:<8B44?>AE>A9<@>54< 44:G49<>AE <4E>56<96>8A 8-" -"! 34A 634H <49B34? A49< >;9E><8558A@G;>-(>F9H:@<<89?634?<>I4<8=63459>? B<@>54<F44:795?<>I>AE63459D4>A95;879A?B9@6>8@5 D9AA4<9663966>D4634 @5G49<>AE<4E>56<96>8A 8- *- G4>AE ?<>I4A GH >65 ?<>I4< 7>63 3>E3 5:44?>A9<9539A?A4E;>E4A6D9AA4<;856B8A6<8;8I4<>6 9A??9534?68 B<@>54< @4 68 349? 8A B8;;>5>8A 58D48= 634:4<58A574<4>AF@<4?589;58?>4?9A?D8;9;58?>4? >A63459>?9BB>?4A69A?634HB;9>D4?634B8D:4A596>8A8A I9<>8@5 349?5 95 634H G4>AE 634 ;4E9; 34><5 8= 634 ?4B4954? - 6 - %+ 34<45:8A?4A68$87A4<8=634 G@5 G49<>AE 4E8--*- 395 9::49<4? 63<8@E3 >65 B8@A54; 9A? =>;4? 634 7<>664A 56964D4A6 GH ?4AH>AE 634 <9539A?A4E;>E4A68A634:9<68=634?<>I4<8=634 G@5 6 >5 B8A64A?4? 6396 634 9BB>?4A6 >5 8BB@<<4? :@<4;H ?@468634<9539A?A4E;>E4A68A634:9<68=?<>I4<8=634 B<@>54< F44: 34<4=8<4 634 ;>9G>;>6H 539;; G4 =>L4? 8A 634 87A4<8=634B<@>54<F44:6>5?4A>4?6349E48BB@:96>8A 9A?>AB8D48=634?4B4954?4AB4:<9H4?=8<?>5D>559; 8=6349::49; %! 34 <45:8A?4A6 8 $ 87A4< 8= 634 B<@>54< F44: G49<>AE 4E8-"--"! 9::49<4? 63<8@E3 3>5 B8@A54; 9A? =>;4? 634 7<>664A 56964D4A6 ?4AH>AE 634 <953 9A?A4E;>E4A6?<>I>AE8=634?<>I4<8=634B<@>54<F44:9A? B8A64A?4?63966349BB>?4A67958BB@<<4??@468634<953 9A?A4E;>E4A6?<>I>AE8=634?<>I4<8=634 G@56>5 =@<634<B8A64A?4?63966349G964D4A6B39<E4-53446>5=>;4? 9E9>A56 634 ?<>I4< 8= 634 B<@>54< 4AB4 >= 9AH ;>9G>;>6H 539;;G4=>L4?8A634 G@5 - 7 - % 954? @:8A 634 9G8I4 :;49?>AE5 634 <>G@A9; 395=<9D4?634=8;;87>AE>55@45- !"#$%#!#$& ' "( )* +, -./01' ( 0!.#%#2#&& - + 3 4 34 - 54 3 3 %, 34 B;9>D9A6 8 795 4L9D>A4? 95 ! 9A? ?8B@D4A65 D9<J4? 68E4634< 7>63 8634< B;9>D9A65 95 L 68 , A 634 8634< 39A? 634 <45:8A?4A65 4L9D>A4?9A?6348==>B>9;7>6A4554L9D>A4?95 9A?E86D9<J4?L9A?L - 8 - % =64< 349<>AE 634 9<E@D4A65 634 <>G@A9; 9;;874? 634 B;9>D :46>6>8A >A (8! % >A :9<6 979<?>AE634B8D:4A596>8A95@A?4<- ; 8 49?5 8D:4A596>8A 79<?4? 8558=>AB8D4?@468 ?4:4A?4ABH 5%+ - 879<?5;8I49A?9==4B6>8A 5%%%% - 879<?5;8558=456964 5%%%% - " 879<?5;8558=B8A58<6>@D 5"%%%% - 879<?5=@A4<9;4L:4A545 5%%% - 869; 5%+ - 34 <>G@A9; 395 =>L4? 634 ;>9G>;>6H 96 !K 8A 634 G@59A?K8A63487A4<8=634B<@>54<F44: 9;8AE7>63634>A64<45696634<9648=+K:4<9AA@D=<8D 634?9648=:46>6>8A6>;;634?9648=<49;>M96>8A *44;>AE 9EE<>4I4? GH 634 59D4 634 B;9>D9A65 39I4 =>;4? 634 9::49; =8< 4A39AB4D4A6 8= B8D:4A596>8A 9A? 634 395 9;58 :<4=4<<4? 634 9::49; =8< N@456>8A>AE634N@9A6@D8=B8D:4A596>8A9A?;>9G>;>6H - 9 - 34 ;49<A4? B8@A54; =8< 634 9::4;;9A65 - B;9>D9A65 B8A64A?4? 6396 634 <>G@A9; 395 69J4A 634 >AB8D4 8= 634 ?4B4954? - D8; 96 5%%% - :4< D8A63 =8< 634 9BB>?4A6 8=634 H49< %! 73>B3 >5 D49E4< 6>5 B8A64A?4? 6396 4I4A 95 :4< 634 8J-?9;963 39<6 634 A86>8A9; >AB8D4 96 5%% - 795 B8A5>?4<4? GH 634 8@<6 =8< 634 9BB>?4A6 8= 634 H49< %! 6 >5 =@<634< B8A64A?4?6396634=@6@<4:<85:4B6596"%K8=634>AB8D4 395 A86 G44A 69J4A >A68 B8A5>?4<96>8A 34 <>G@A9; 395 A86 :<8:4<;H 979<?4? 634 B8D:4A596>8A 6879<?5 ;855 8= B8A58<6>@D 95 :4< 634 F@?ED4A6 8= 634 8A/G;4 @:<4D4 8@<6>A634B9548= !"##! 6>59;58B8A64A?4?6396 >A $ %& ' 63>58@<63959;<49?HB8A5>?4<4?634 ;>9G>;>6H 73>B3 795 9;<49?H @:34;? GH 63>5 8@<6 9A? 9669>A4?=>A9;>6H>A<45:4B68=!K8A634 G@59A? K ;>9G>;>6H =>L4? 8A 634 87A4< 8= 634 B<@>54< 4AB4 :<9H4?=8<9;;87>AE6349::49; 1 67/& - 10 - " 34 ;49<A4? B8@A54; =8< 634 <45:8A?4A6 8 - 395 54<>8@5;H 8GF4B64? 634 9::49; 9A? B8A64A?4? 6396638@E3979<?8=B8D:4A596>8A795<>E36;HB8A5>?4<4? GH 634 <>G@A9; G@6 =>L>AE 634 ;>9G>;>6H 96 !K >5 4L8<G>69A6 6 395 68 G4 <4?@B4? 96 ;4956 %K 4AB4 :<9H4?=8<9;;87>AE>659::49; 9I>AE 349<? 634 9<E@D4A65 9A? :4<@54? 634 <4B8<?5 634 :8>A65 639678@;? 9<>54 =8< 8@< B8A5>?4<96>8A 9<495@A?4<- 1 ( + 4 4 8 ( ,./01%9%9 4 + -- 4 4 - 4 , 4 (, 3 4 4 3 4 83 - 11 - !() ( - + A :4<@59; 8= 634 <4B8<?5 73>B3 <4I49;5 6396 6349BB>?4A67958BB@<<4?8A%%,%!?@468634<953 9A?A4E;>E4A6?<>I>AE8=634G863634I43>B;45>4?@468 349?-8AB8;;>5>8A8=<@>54< 44:G49<>AE4E8-"-- "! 9A? G49<>AE 4E8--*- >5 A86 >A ?>5:@6434:8;>B439I4=>;4?634B39<E4-534469E9>A56634 ?<>I4<5 8= 634 G@5 9A? 9G964? B39<E4O53446 >5 =>;4? 9E9>A56 634 ?<>I4< 8= 634 F44: 738 9;58 ?>4? >A 634 59>? 9BB>?4A634L$9A?B39<E4-53446>5=>;4?GH634 :8;>B473>B3B;49<;H<4I49;563966349BB>?4A68BB@<<4??@4 68634<9539A?A4E;>E4A68A634:9<68=G863634?<>I4<5 ! 34 88<?>A964 4AB3 8= 63>5 8@<6 >A $ %& ' 39?=>L4?634;>9G>;>6H96634<96>88=!K8A 634 G@59A?K8A63487A4<8=634F44:73>B3 9669>A4? 634 =>A9;>6H @B3 G4>AE 634 B954 =>L>AE 634 ;>9G>;>6H96!K8A634 G@59A?K8A63487A4< 8= 634 44: 74 9<4 8= 634 8:>A>8A 6396 >6 >5 9669>A4? =>A9;>6H34<4=8<4634<>G@A9;<>E36;H=>L4?634;>9G>;>6H>A - 12 - 634<96>88=!K8A634 G@59A?K8A63487A4< 8= 634 F44: 73>B3 ?8 A86 B9;; =8< 9AH >A64<=4<4AB4 (*+ , ( ( - ( # (( !() ( - >63 <4E9<? 68 634 955455D4A6 8= B8D:4A596>8A634 <>G@A9; 395 B8A5>?4<4?634 >AB8D48= 634?4B4954?965%%% -:4<D8A63A8@<8:>A>8A634 <>G@A9; 395 B8DD>664? 9A 4<<8< >A =>L>AE 634 >AB8D4 96 5%%% - :4< D8A63 95 :4< 634 8J-?9;963 B39<6 634 8@<65 9<4 B8A5>?4<>AE 9 5@D 8= 5%% - :4< D8A63 95634A86>8A9;>AB8D4=8<6349BB>?4A68=634H49<%! , 6 >5 9;58 544A =<8D 634 <4B8<?5 6396 634 <>G@A9; 395 A86 B8A5>?4<4? =@6@<4 :<85:4B65 8= 634 ?4B4954? 95 :4< 634 F@?ED4A6 8= 634 8A/G;4 @:<4D4 8@<6 >A 634 B954 8= ( ,* (( )* .#( # 4AB4 634 B;9>D9A65 9<4 9;58 4A6>6;4? 68 9A 9??>6>8A 8= "%K 8= 634 9554554? >AB8D4 @A?4< 634 349? 8= ;855 8= =@6@<4 :<85:4B65 67:/: - 13 - % 34 9E4 8= 634 ?4B4954? >5 H49<5 634 D@;6>:;>4< >5 ! 34 ?4B4954? 795 D9<<>4? :4<58A 9A? 634<4 9<4 % ?4:4A?4A65 4AB4 634<4 >5 ?4?@B6>8A 8= <?68634>AB8D48=634?4B4954?=5%% -P"%K '5"%% -)'5%% -P5"%%)Q5"% -L L!D>A@5 <?Q5,+%% -4AB4634B;9>D9A65 9<4 4A6>6;4? =8< ! %+ +/0 - # ,* 95 9E9>A56 5%+ - 979<?4? GH 634 <>G@A9; 5 <4E9<?5 68 634 B8A58<6>@D 95 :4< 634 F@?ED4A6 8= 634 8A/G;4 @:<4D4 8@<6 >A 634 B954 8= 6 7 634 ?4B4954? 395 ;4=6 % ?4:4A?4A65 34H 9<4 4A6>6;4? =8< 5"%%%% - 49B3 73>B3 B8D45 68 5"%%%% - L Q ! ++0 - ( 34 <>G@A9; 395 979<?4? 634 B8D:4A596>8A 6879<?5 634 ;8I4 9A? 9==4B6>8A 96 5%%%% - 9A? 6879<?5;8558=456964965%%%% -9A?6879<?5=@A4<9; 4L:4A545 96 5%%% - 34 59D4 >5 546-95>?4 9A? D8?>=>4? 96 ! +0 - 9A? ! +0 -1, - 14 - 34<4=8<4 634 B;9>D9A65 9<4 4A6>6;4? =8< 634 4A39AB4?B8D:4A596>8A95@A?4<- 2(,( 8558=?4:4A?4ABH 0 -%-:;# 8558=B8A58<6>@D '5"%%%% -L) 5%%%% - 8558=56964 5%%% - 879<?5=@A4<9;4L:4A545 5%%% - *+, -.( /+01*2304567+, -88.( 72+7931:;37-+*47 - <.<( 67131 - ( " *8< 634 9G8I4 59>? ?>5B@55>8A , ( - ,* ( # (( BB8<?>AE;H 74 :<8B44?68:955634=8;;87>AE 34 9::49; =>;4? GH 634 >A *8%%! %>5?>5D>554? 34 9::49; =>;4? GH 634 B;9>D9A65 >A *8% %>59;;874?>A:9<6 - 15 - 34F@?ED4A69A?979<??964?"%%%:9554?>A (8! % GH 634 ??>6>8A9; 4A>8< >I>; @?E4 9A? 4DG4< -1 (>F9H9:@< >5 D8?>=>4? ( 34 B;9>D9A65 9<4 4A6>6;4? =8< 9A 4A39AB4? B8D:4A596>8A 8= 5,%% - 8I4< 9A? 9G8I4 634 B8D:4A596>8A 979<?4? GH 634 <>G@A9; 73>B3 539;; B9<<H>A64<45696634<9648=+K:4<9AA@D=<8D634 ?9648=:46>6>8A6>;;634?9648=<49;>M96>8A ( 34<45:8A?4A68$ >5?><4B64?68?4:85>6 !K8=634B8D:4A596>8A9D8@A6>45+!! - 9A? K 8= 634 B8D:4A596>8A 9D8@A6 >4 5"+ -GH63487A4<8=634B<@>54<F44:7>63 >A64<456 G4=8<4 634 <>G@A9; 7>63>A 9 :4<>8? 8= % 744J5 =<8D 634 ?964 8= <4B4>:6 8= B8:H 8= 63>5 F@?ED4A6 ( 34 9::8<6>8AD4A6 D9?4 GH 634 <>G@A9; >5 @A9;64<4? - 16 - ( 349D8@A6>A?4:85>6D9?4GH634 539;;G4 6<9A5D>664?68634<>G@A9;=8<637>63 1( &$' $ 1( &%$!"' $ >568 ;8"