Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 50833 (KAR)
SHIVAKUMAR S/O NINGAPPA SINDAGI v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
MFA/200369/2020 · 2025-11-24
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50833 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50833 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
% & '
''
(#) *+ '' ! *
+
! !"
##
! "
# # $% " #
#
&
''
('$
#
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
# #
! )*
! !*
+
##
!#&##
! "
! )
! !"
##$% "#
&
'' ! )*
('$! #
#
&
- 3 -
+! &
,-.- /01 233-24. 5-.3-6/78-49 :74-; <9 /,- 6427=2>/ 3-/7/71>-5"2>;/,-787.71>241>/5144-5
5-.31>;->/"2?27>.//,-.2=-@A;?=->/2>;2025;;2/-; '' 32..-; <9 /,- ;;7/71>24 7./576/ 2>;
-..71>. A;?- 2>; -=<-5 )% 7@2923A52 B:15 .,15/C57<A>24DE7>
1('$ ' !57-::26/.1:/,-62.-25-/,2//,-6427=2>/:74-; 26427=3-/7/71><-:15-/,-57<A>24.--F7>?61=3->.2/71> 1: .') /1025;. ;2=2?- /1 /,- =1/156964- <-257>? -? 1)') ,- 57<A>24 2:/-5 61>.7;-57>? /,- ->/75- -87;->6- 1> 5-615; 325/76A42549 G.$ /1 ,2. 2..-..-; /,- 61=3->.2/71> 1:
.%$) 2>; 2025;-; 1>49 H 2=1A>/7>? /1
.I) ,14;7>? H >-?47?->6- 1> /,- 325/ 1: /,- 57;-5 1: /,- =1/156964- 2>; 26615;7>?49 ;75-6/-; /,-
- 4 -
5-.31>;->/ /1 ;-31.7/ 1>49 .I) 07/,7> /,5-- =1>/,.:51=/,-;2/-1:/,-.27;@A;?=->/ % ??57-8-; <9 /,- .27; 2025; /,- 233-442>/) 6427=2>/ ,2. 35-:-55-; #
1'%I'' =27>49 61>/->;7>? /,2/ 57<A>24 02. >1/ @A./7:7-; 7> 2025;7>? .I) 2. 2?27>./ .') 6427=-; <9 /,- 6427=2>//7.24.161>/->;-;/,2//,-57<A>24,2.:7G-; H61>/57<A/159>-?47?->6-1>/,-325/1:/,-57;-51:/,- =1/156964- 2>; 24.1 >1/ ?52>/-; 2>9 7>/-5-./ 2>; /,A.
5-JA-./-; :15 ->,2>6-=->/ 1: /,- 61=3->.2/71> 2=1A>/ 241>?07/,7>/-5-./ ( !-7>? 2??57-8-; <9 /,- .2=- 2025; /,- 787.71>241>/5144-5 B:15.,15/C153152/71>DE ,2.35-:-55-; #
1'(''61>/->;7>?/,2/2//,- /7=-1:2667;->//,-57;-51:/,-=1/156964-02.57;7>?/,- 8-,764- 07/, /01 374471> 57;-5. 7> 2 52., 2>; >-?47?->/ =2>>-507/,,7?,.3--;2.25-.A4/57;-541./61>/51418-5 /,-8-,764-2>;62=-7>61>/26/07/,/,-<A.,->6-/,-5-
7. ?51.. 87142/71> 1: -6/71> ' 1: 6/ / 7. 24.1
- 5 -
61>/->;-;/,2//,-6427=2>/,2.>1/=2;-/,->.A52>6- 1=32>9 1: /,- =1/156964- 2. 325/9 /1 /,- 3516--;7>?. 2>; 2. .A6, /,- 3-/7/71> 7. <2; :15 >1>)@17>;-5 1:
>-6-..259 325/7-. / 7. :A5/,-5 61>/->;-; /,2/ /,- 6427=2>/,2.>1/351;A6-; -?7./52/71>-5/7:762/-#7/>-.. -5/7:762/--5=7/ 2>; 5787>? 76->.- 1:/,-57;-5 1: /,- =1/156964-2>;/,A.5-JA-./-;/1.-/2.7;-/,-7=3A?>-; @A;?=->/2>;2025;32..-;<9/,-57<A>24
-25; 25?A=->/. 1: <1/, /,- 325/7-. 2>; 3-5A.-;/,-=2/-5724.282742<4-1>5-615;
-25>-;61A>.-4 :15/,-153152/71> 61>/->;-; /,2//,-2A/,151:G.$/1'02.>1/-G2=7>-;<-:15- /,-57<A>24&',2.>125;2>;,-7.>1/23513-5 .7?>2/159/1.292<1A/G.$/1'/,-5-:15-5-JA-./-; /,-1A5//1.-/2.7;-/,-15;-5 $ 4-25>-; 61A>.-4 :15 /,- 6427=2>/ 61>/->;-; /,2/ /,- 2>2?-5 1: /,- &15F.,13 02. -G2=7>-;2.&'-./2/-;/,2/G.$/125->1/
- 6 -
.7?>-;<9&'1>.7;-57>?,7.-87;->6-2>;24.142<1A5 6,25?-. /,- 57<A>24 ,2. ?52>/-; .%$) /1025;. ;2=2?-./1/,-=1/156964-
. 3-5 G K -315/ =1/156964- 02. <2;49;2=2?-;,-57<A>241<.-58-;/,2/7/7.<-//-5/1 3A56,2.-2>-0=1/156964-7>./-2;1:?-//7>?7/5-3275-;
/02.24.11<.-58-;<9/,-57<A>24/,2//,-6427=2>/7. ,287>?61=35-,->.78->.A52>6-14769-25>-;61A>.-4 :15 /,- 6427=2>/ ./2/-; /,2/ /,- 6,25?-).,--/ 7. :74-; 2?27>.//,-;578-51:/,-<A.2./,-2667;->/166A55-;;A- /1 ,7. >-?47?->6- 2>; 2. .A6, /,-9 ,28- >1/ =2;- /,- >.A52>6- 1=32>9 1: /,- =1/156964- 2. 325/9 /1 /,- 6427=3-/7/71> I -25>-;61A>.-4:15/,-153152/71>,2../2/-; /,2//,-5-02./5734-57;7>?2>;/,-90-5->1/,287>?8247;
;16A=->/. 7>64A;7>? 5787>? 76->.- 2>; /,A. /,- 2667;->/166A55-;1>49;A-/1/,->-?47?->6-1:/,-57;-51: /,-=1/156964-
- 7 -
;=7//-;497/7.262.-1:8-,764-;2=2?-,- -87;->6-282742<4-<-:15-/,-57<A>247./,2/1:&'07/, 5-4-82>/ ;16A=->/. ,-5-:15- /,- 57<A>24 ,2.
57?,/49 2..-..-; /,- 2=1A>/ 1: ;2=2?- 2/ .%$) ;=7//-;497/7.262.-1:/5734-57;7>?,-57<A>24,2. 5-47-;A31>/,-67/2/71>5-315/-;7> 1:/,-61)15;7>2/-!->6,1:/,7.1A5/0,-5-7>7/,2.,-4; /,2/ 7> 62.- 1: /5734-57;7>? 52., 2>;>-?47?->6-7. /1 <- -JA2449 2//57<A/-; 1> <1/, /,- 8-,764-. 7>8148-; 7> /,- 2667;->/>/,-7>./2>/62.-/,-57;-51:/,-=1/156964- ,2. >1 -?7./52/71> -5/7:762/- #7/>-.. -5/7:762/- 2>; 5787>? 76->.- 2>; =15-18-5 ,- 02. 57;7>? /,- =1/156964-07/,/01374471>57;-5.,-5-:15-/,-57<A>24 ,2. 57?,/49 2..-..-; H 1: >-?47?->6- 1> <1/, /,- 8-,764-. 2>; ;75-6/-; /,- 153152/71> /1 ;-31.7/ H 1:
.%$) 0,76, 61=-. /1 .I) 2>; >1/
.I) #A5/,-5 /,7. 1A5/ :7>;. 7/ 5-2.1>2<4- /1 2025;7>/-5-./2//,-52/-1:H3-52>>A= >87-01:/,-2<18-/,-:144107>? - 8 -
7" ,- #
1'%I''7.24410-;7>325/2>; /,- #
1'(''7.;7.=7..-; 77" ,-787.71>241>/5144-5 7.;75-6/-;/1 ;-31.7/ .I) 241>? 07/, 7>/-5-./ 2/ H 3-5 2>>A= :51= /,- ;2/- 1: 3-/7/71> /744 5-247L2/71> 07/,7> 1>- =1>/, :51= /,- ;2/- 1: /,7.@A;?=->/ 777" > .A6, ;-31.7/ /,- 6427=2>/ 7. 3-5=7//-; /1 07/,;520/,-->/75-2=1A>/241>?07/,7>/-5-./ 2665A-;1>7/
1A>.-4 :15 5-.31>;->/ 7. ;75-6/-; /1 :74- 2F242/ 7> #
1'%I''
,-* (' ) &
! 7./
14
1