- 1 - !" # $ % %% &' ( !" # $ %& ' ( ) * * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! # $ %& +$ !" # $ %& ), '"# ) ) &) ) * &&'&'' &+'&'& * ) - ) * +'&' ) . ) * - ) / / 0 * )$ 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 4C42=3<<16D>9CB6=<4=94E4?994<69&&'&''543369 :; <16 ?2=@2547 6=2A? 2F27 *>9C6 4=9 ABB2332A=6? 8A? A?GB6=-3 AB56=34<2A= 294? H8A? 31A?< - 3 - . ABB2332A=6?-I2= A+'&'& 366G2=C6=14=@6B6=< A8@AB56=34<2A= ' =6 4;4=4=9 A 14=G6? B6< E2<1 4= 4@@296=< A= 'J&'&'& 4=9 9269 23 E286 4=9 BA<16? 82769 @742B 56<2<2A= :68A?6 <16 ABB2332A=6? @742B2=C @AB56=34<2A= A8 3'K&&&&&# E2<1 2=<6?63< 16 ABB2332A=6? @A=3296?69 <16 6=<2?6 B4<6?2473 A= ?6@A?9 4=9 4E4?969 3K '+ # E2<1 2=<6?63< 4< <16 ?4<6 A8 'L56?4==>B8?ABA=6BA=<148<6?<1694<6A84@@296=< <277<1694<6A82<3?6472M4<2A=CC?26F69:;<1634B6<16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=;23:68A?6<123 A>?< 64?9 4?C>B6=<3 A8 :A<1 <16 54?<263 4=9 56?>369<16B4<6?24734F4274:76A=?6@A?9 % 16B42=@A=<6=<2A=A8<16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 23 <14< 43 56? N' A3< A?<6B 65A?< 233>69 :; <16 4=912 692@47 A776C6 <16 @4>36 A8 964<1 A8 4;4=4=9 E439>6<A164?<9236436E12@1E43=A<9>6<A<163<?633 4=93<?42=84@<A?A8<166B57A;B6=<:><9>6<A<16164?< - 4 - 6=74?C694=984<7496=433>@1<16;4?6=A<724:76<A54; <16 @AB56=34<2A= <A <16 @742B4=< 4=9 ?635A=96=< A 16?68A?6 <16 ABB2332A=6? 23 =A< D>3<28269 2= 349972=C <16724:272<;>5A=<16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 168A77AE2=C3>:3<4=<247O>63<2A=3A874EEA>79 4?2368A?@A=3296?4<2A=/ 16<16? <16 ABB2332A=6? 23 D>3<282692=843<6=2=C<16724:272<;>5A=<16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; E16= <16 164?< 9236436 E43 =A< 9>6 <A 3<?633 4=9 3<?42= 84@<A?:><9>6<A<16164?<6=74?C694=9 84<7496=P ' 16<16? <16 @742B4=< 143 7A9C69 <16 @AB5742=< <A <16 5A72@6 3<4<2=C <14< <16 96@64369 143 @A=3>B69 47@A1A7 4=9 2< 45564?3164?<92364369>6<A@A=3>B5<2A= A847@A1A76F6?;94;P 16<16? <16?6 23 4 @43>47 @A==6@<2A= :6<E66= <16 964<1 4=9 <16 >36 A8 <16 F612@76P - 5 - K =3>55A?<A82<3@A=<6=<2A=764?=69@A>=3678A? <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 143 ?67269 >5A= <16 36F6?47 @2<4<2A=3 =?657;764?=69@A>=3678A?<16@742B4=<3473A 82769@6?<42=@2<4<2A=3 + 3 56? <16 @2<4<2A= 2= <16 @436 A8 !""##2<143167943>=96?/ $ = <16 3429 @2<4<2A= 2< E43 8>?<16? A:36?F69 43 >=96?/ ! "#$% & ' ! "#$%( ) - 6 - J 3 56? <16 @2<4<2A= 2= <16 @436 A8 $!%&' !%!(%) * %*)! %"!%& * ) !+!) !%* '",-./-,2<143167943>=96?/ ! * + * , * - * - ! *) . / 0 - 7 - / - / & 56?>347 A8 <16 ?6@A?93 31AE3 <14< 96@64369 E43 EA?G2=C 43 9?2F6? >=96? ?635A=96=< A 2= 7A??; :64?2=CA#'#$$ 32=@6Q;64?3='$&$'&'& 16 7A4969 <16 5456?3 2= <16 7A??; E6=< <A <16>G4<54772 5456?B2774=94<&&5B16E43@AF6?2=C<164954<?2 43 ?42= E43 @AB2=C 16 <269 <16 ?A56 4=9 4< <14< <2B6 3>996=7; 16 3725569 4=9 8677 9AE= 4=9 3>3<42=69 2=D>?263 4=9<16=16EAG6>54=934<2=<16@4:2=4=99>6<A<16 <6=32A=A8 9672F6?; A8CAA93 1692699>6 <A 164?< 4<<4@G ='J&$'&'&4<&&4B5456?B277AE=6?@4B6=64? <167A??;4=934E<169?2F6?2=<16@4:2=4=9<?269<AE4G6 12B>5:><16929=A<E4G6>562=8A?B69<1634B6<A ?635A=96=< A R AE=6? A8 <16 7A??; 16 :?A<16? A8 - 8 - ?635A=96=< A 4=9 E286 A8 <16 96@64369 E6=< <A ;96?4:49 4=9 34E 123 9649 :A9; 2= <16 @4:2= 4=9 2=8A?B69 >G4<54772 5A72@6 16 >G4<54772 5A72@6 ?6C23<6?69 <16 @436 2= ?2B6 AK%$'&'& 4=@1=4B4 E43 @A=9>@<69 4=9 48<6? 5A3< BA?<6B 6N4B2=4<2A= :A9; E439672F6?69<A<16?674<2F63A84;4=4=9432=CA=<16 A3< A?<6B 65A?< =3>?4=@6 AB54=; @A=<6=969 <14< <16?6 23 =A =6N>3 :6<E66= 964<1 4=9 6B57A;B6=< 43 3>@1<16;4?6=A<724:76<A54;<16@AB56=34<2A=16?6 23 =A 9235><6 ?6C4?92=C 6B57A;6? 4=9 6B57A;66 ?674<2A=3125:6<E66=?635A=96=<A4=94;4=4=96 E43 9?2F2=C <16 7A??; 56?<42=2=C <A ?635A=96=< A A= '$&$'&'& 4=9 E6=< <A >G4<54772 5456? B277 <16?6 16 E43 @AF6?2=C <16 CAA93 2= 4954<?2 43 ?42= E43 @AB2=C 4=9 16 <269 <16 ?A56 4=9 3>996=7; 3725569 4=9 8677 9AE= 4=93>3<42=692=D>?263E127616E43A=9><;4=9<16=16 EAG6>54=934<2=<16@4:2=A8<167A??;4=99>6<A<16 <6=32A=A8 9672F6?; A8CAA93 1692699>6 <A 164?< 4<<4@G 64?=69 @A>=367 8A? <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 3<4<69 <14< - 9 - 164?< 4<<4@G 23 =A< 9>6 <A 3<?633 4?232=C A>< A8 <16 6B57A;B6=<6E434@A=3>B6?A847@A1A733>@1<16 164?<E436=74?C694=9<16?6E4384<7496= AE2<238A?<16 A>?<<A366E16<16?4@@296=< 1434?236=A><A84=92=<16@A>?36A86B57A;B6=< ' 9B2<<697; 16 E43 @4??;2=C CAA93 <A 4 5456? B277 4=9 9>?2=C <16 @A>?36 A8 6B57A;B6=< 16 149 164?< 4<<4@G2=<16@4:2=4=9926916?623=6N>3:6<E66=>36 A8<16F612@764=9<16964<1A89?2F6?16?68A?62<@4=:6 3429 <14< 16 9269 2= <16 @A>?36 A8 6B57A;B6=< = 4 @2<4<2A= ?65A?<69 2= 0 ,1 !"" ,2=<16@436A8 234 "" 2 5 =<163429@4366B57A;6?49B2<<69<14<<16 96@64369E436B57A;694349?2F6?4=916E43A=9><;4< <16<2B6A8123964<116?6E436F6?;?643A=<A433>B6 <14<7A=C356773A89?2F2=CE43B4<6?247@A=<?2:><A?;84@<A? 28=A<<163A76@4>368A?4@@676?4<69<14<4@@676?4<69234= >=6N56@<69964<14<;A>=C6?4C6>@1>=<AE4?94@<2A= - 10 - @A=3296?4:7; 963@?2:69 43 4= 4@@296=< 4<<?2:><4:76 A=7; <1?A>C1<16=4<>?6A86B57A;B6=<4=9<169656=96=<3A8 <1696@643694?66=<2<7698A?@AB56=34<2A=A =3>?4=@6 AB54=;3<4<69<14<16E43@A=3>B2=C47@A1A7?6C>74?7; A 6F296=@6 23 574@69 :68A?6 <16 A>?< <14< 16 E43 4 @1?A=2@ 47@A1A72@ < 23 4?C>69 <14< 16 149 164?< 4<<4@G 4=9 2< 23 84< 7496= = <16 A3< A?<6B 65A?< 2< E43 B6=<2A=69 <14< 96@64369 3>3<42=69 2=D>?263 <16 ?4M69 :?432A= A8 &K N&' @B=A<69AF6? ?2C1<67:AE DA2=< 4=9 :?432A=A8&N& @B=A<69AF6?:4@GA84:9AB6=4=9 <16@4>36A8964<12331AE=43164?<923643616?68A?6 <16 4?C>B6=<3 A8 <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; <14< 96@64369 929=A<C6<164?<4<<4@G9>6<A3<?6332=<166B57A;B6=< @4==A<:64@@65<6916 ABB2332A=6??2C1<7;@A=3296?69 477<16364356@<34=94E4?969@AB56=34<2A=4=992?6@<69 <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; <A 54; <16 @AB56=34<2A= 123 A>?<82=93=A?643A=<A2=<6?86?6E2<1<163429A?96?16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 23 92?6@<69 <A 965A32< <16 @AB56=34<2A=A83K '+ #E2<12=<6?63<4<'L56? - 11 - 4==>B8?ABA=6BA=<148<6?<166N52?;A894<6A84@@296=< <277 <16 94<6 A8 2<3 ?6472M4<2A= E2<12= A=6 BA=<1 8?AB <A94; = 3>@1 965A32< BA<16? A8 <16 96@64369 23 6=<2<769 8A? 3'&&&&&# E2<1 2=<6?63< 4@@?>69 A= 2< 4=9 3162356?B2<<69<AE2<19?4E<166=<2?64BA>=<286A8 <1696@64369236=<2<7698A?<16:474=@64BA>=<47A=CE2<1 2=<6?63<4@@?>69A=2<4=93162356?B2<<69<AE2<19?4E<16 6=<2?64BA>=< % =<16?63>7<<168A77AE2=C/ 2 1645564723923B23369 22 16 2B5>C=69 D>9CB6=< 4=9 4E4?9 23@A=82?B69 9# &% ' $ 23<A/7A/ /*