- 1 - !! "" "# ! $! %&'%' "(( )(* !+ " ! "# $%#&' ( &'' ( ( &"#'& ( ( ( ")#''* ( ( ( + #*'*#'& &"#'& ( '&'"#'&, ")#''* ( ! ( ! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - - &"% ./0123456102789:6;;265/0</52:=>?.26;;25569?$ :2<29:69? ;16>/93 ?8 02?@60/:2 ?.2 A4:3B29? 69: :27122 :6?2: #*'*#'& ;6002: /9 8&"#'& => ?.2 526192:29/81/C/54:3269:(6?9:/D.212/9?.2 A4:3B29? 69: :27122 :6?2: '&'"#'&, ;6002: /9 8")#''*=>?.2526192:/C/54:3269:(9:/ .60=2296<</1B2: '# 261:?.2526192:7849025<81?.26;;25569? ', .2 120;89:29? $ ;56/9?/<< .60 </52: ?.2 04/? 636/90? ?.2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? /9 8")#''* <81 ?.2125/2<8<0;27/</7;21<81B69728<065263122B29?:6?2: #'#'' .2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? 06/: ?8 .6C2 2E274?2: ?.2 06/: 0652 63122B29? 63122/93 ?8 0255 ./0 ;18;21?> =261/93 >8&& B26041/93 '" 67120 '& 349?6 .2 0652 7890/:216?/89 63122: => ?.2 ;61?/20 /0 0,'''''@ 69: 6? ?.2 ?/B2 8< 0652 63122B29? ?.2 - 3 - 120;89:29? $ ;56/9?/<< .60 ;6/: 0#%'''@ 69: 63122: ?8;6>=6569728<0#'''@89?.2:6?28<123/0?16?/89 8<0652:22:0?.26;;25569?$:2<29:69?;80?;892:?.2 2E274?/89 8< 0652 :22: ?.2 120;89:29? $ ;56/9?/<< 38? /0042: 52365 98?/72 89 &*'&#''* 7655/93 4;89 ?.2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? ?8 2E274?2 ?.2 0652 :22: => 1272/C/93 ?.2 =656972 7890/:216?/89 6B849? 4? ?.2 6;;25569?$:2<29:69?98?12;5/2:?8?.206/:5236598?/72 .212<812?.2120;89:29?$;56/9?/<<.60</52:04/?<81?.2 125/2< 8< 0;27/</7 ;21<81B6972 636/90? ?.2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69?9?.206/:04/??.26;;25569?$:2<29:69??6F29 ?.2789?29?/89?.6??.2;56/9?/<<D60B892>569:212.60 6C6/52:?.2.69:@58698<0''''@69:<81?.202741/?> 8< ?.2 06/: 6B849? =8118D2: .2 .60 2E274?2: ?.2 123/0?212: :874B29? /9 <6C841 8< ?.2 120;89:29? $ ;56/9?/<< 2 D60 98? 6D612 ?.6? ?.2 06/: :874B29? 2E274?2: D60 ?.2 0652 63122B29? 2 789?29:2: ?.6? .2 6C6/52: 6B849? 895> 0''''@ 60 .69:@5869 <18B ?.2 120;89:29?$;56/9?/<< - 4 - '" 9 ?.2 =60/0 8< ?.2 6=8C2 06/: ;526:/930 ?.2 1/65841?.60<16B2:?.2<8558D/93/00420@ !" !" # $ $ % $ $ ' .2;56/9?/<<2E6B/92:./B025<60!&69:38? B61F2: E& ?8 E, 69: 38? 2E6B/92: ?D8 6??20?/93 D/?920020?8?.263122B29?8<065260!#69:!,.2 :2<29:69?.6098?52:69>2C/:2972.21/65841?6<?21 6;;127/6?/93?.22C/:29728912781:.60690D212:00420 8& , 69: " /9 ?.2 6<</1B6?/C2 69: 0042 8# /9 ?.2 9236?/C269::27122:?.204/? - 5 - ' 331/2C2: => ?.2 06/: A4:3B29? 69: :271228< ?.2 1/65 841? ?.2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? .60 </52: 8&"#'&89?.2</528<?.229/81/C/54:3269: ( 9:/ .2 (/10? ;;2556?2 841? 6<?21 .261/93 ?.2 6134B29?0 8< =8?. 0/:20 .60 :/0B/002: ?.2 6;;265 89 B21/?06<</1B/93?.2A4:3B29?69::27122;6002:=>?.2 1/65841? '% 26192: 7849025 <81 ?.2 6;;25569? @ :2<29:69? D845: 789?29: ?.6? ?.2 0652 63122B29? .60 =229 38? 2E274?2: /9 ?.2 34/02 8< 02741/?> 8< .69:@5869 8< 0''''@.21/65841?69:?.2(/10?;;2556?2841? .6C298?6;;127/6?2:?.22C/:29728912781:;18;215>69: 2112:/9;600/93?.2/B;4392:A4:3B29? ') 6C/93 .261: ?.2 526192: 7849025 <81 ?.2 6;;25569? @ :2<29:69? ?./0 841? .60 ;21402: ?.2 /B;4392: A4:3B29? 69: :27122 69: ?.2 1/65 841? 12781:0 - 6 - '* .2 0652 63122B29? :6?2: #'#'' /0 6? E#69:/?/0123/0?212::874B29?E&/0?.212781: 8<1/3.?8<?.204/?;18;21?>69:/?/00?69:/93/9?.296B2 8< ?.2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? E, /0 ?.2 78;> 8< ?.2 5236598?/7238?/0042:=>?.2120;89:29?$;56/9?/<<?8?.2 6;;25569?$:2<29:69?7655/934;89./B?82E274?2?.20652 63122B29?=>1272/C/93?.2=6569727890/:216?/896B849? C296<?21021C/728<06/:98?/72?.26;;25569?$:2<29:69? .6098?=22912;5/2:?.206/:5236598?/72 &' .2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? 789?29:2: ?.6? .2 .60?6F29.69:@58698<0''''@<18B?.2120;89:29?$ ;56/9?/<<69:<81?.202741/?>;41;8028<?.206/:6B849? .2 .60 2E274?2: ?.2 123/0?212: :874B29? 2 .60 98? F98D9?.206/:123/0?212::874B29?/0065263122B29? && !# 69: !, 612 ?.2 6??20?/93 D/?920020 ?8 ?.2 0652 63122B29? $ E# !# 69: !, 0;27/</7655> :2;802:12361:/93?.22E274?/898<065263122B29?=>?.2 6;;25569?$:2<29:69?/9<6C8418<120;89:29?$;56/9?/<<=> 1272/C/93 69 6:C6972 6B849? 8< 0#%'''@ /9 ?.2/1 - 7 - ;1202972 69: ?.2> .6: 6<</E2: ?.2 0/396?412 89 /? 60 D/?920020.206/:2C/:29728<!#69:!,D/5538?8 20?6=5/0. ?.6? 60 ;21 E# ?.2 63122B29? 8< 0652 .60 =229 2E274?2: => ?.2 6;;25569? $ :2<29:69? /9 <6C841 8< ?.2 120;89:29? @ ;56/9?/<< .212 /0 98 B6?21/65 ?8 0.8D ?.6??.26;;25569?$:2<29:69?.60=8118D2:.69:@58698< 0''''@ 69: <81 ?.2 02741/?> 8< ?.2 06B2 .2 .60 2E274?2: ?.2 123/0?212: :874B29? /9 <6C841 8< ?.2 120;89:29? $ ;56/9?/<< 9 81:21 ?8 20?6=5/0. ./0 :2<2972 ?.2 6;;25569? @ :2<29:69? .60 98? 29?212: /9?8 D/?9200 =8E &# <?.2;61?>/9 81:21 ?8;18C2 ./0 :2<2972 .60 98? 29?212: /9?8 D/?9200 =8E ?.2 ;1204B;?/89 D/55 61/02 ?.6??.2760202?4;=>?.206/:;21089/098?781127?.2 89G=524;12B2841?/9?.27602 &69:/9?.276028< #.60.25:6049:21@ 1 &'((()*'+,' &'((()*',,' - 8 - - # # # # . &, 890/:21/93 ?.2 6=8C2 60;27? ?.2 1/65 841? 69: ?.2 (/10? ;;2556?2 841? 1/3.?5> 6;;127/6?2: ?.2 2C/:2972 89 12781: 69: 1/3.?5> :27122: ?.2 04/? 8< ?.2 ;56/9?/<< .212 612 98 31849:0 B6:2 84? ?8 6:B/? ?.2 123456102789:6;;265804=0?69?/65H420?/898<56DD/55 61/02<817890/:216?/892972?.26;;265/0 ,- )'%'* &" /0?8&58&) ?IF