- 1 - !" # $%# $% %! ## &!' ( ! " "#$% & ' ( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $% ) "#$% & ' * ) " ) + ( ) ) , '( ) " %%,% - " . " % ) "* ) ) " - " - "" - 3 - % ' - "( /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 , '( <= <;<9 4/0:541 :; ! '/494072=;49 94=49948 ;< 21 >;/4 :;?( /21 @447 =0548 @A ;/4 :520B27;1 :/25547C07C ;/4 D68CB47; 82;48 %%,%321148@A;/4907:0325470<90E05"68C4278 . 0D2A236907 <% )2:;1 C0E07C 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507C <= ;/4 233425 @904=5A 1;2;48294;/2;<7%%2;2@<6;!%%F/47;/4 84:42148 2550G29D67 F21 39<:44807C <7 2 B<;<9:A:54 @42907C 4C<.. 21 2 30550<7 90849 <7 B<;<9:A:54 25<7C F0;/ /01 =90478 212E292D F/47 ;/4A :2B474296C25G/<82;/<7<523699<28 0D2A23692; ;/2; ;0B4 2 5<99A @42907C 94C01;92;0<7 <.$. :2B4 =9<B @2:G 1084 @407C 890E47 @A 0;1 890E49 07 /0C/ 13448 27807921/ 278 74C50C47; B27749821/48 2C2071; ;/4B<;<9:A:54 <= ;/484:42148 278 :26148;/42::0847; 1294165;<=;/42=<9412082::0847;@<;/9084927830550<7 - 4 - 90849.2550G29D67 161;20748 C904E<61 07D69041 278 16::6B@48;<;/407D69041 /4 :520B27;1 =0548 2 34;0;0<7 67849 4:;0<7 $$ <= ;/4 :; 144G07C :<B34712;0<7 =<9 ;/4 842;/ <= ;/4 84:4214825<7CF0;/07;4941; 3<7 149E0:4 <= 7<;0:4 9413<7847; < /21 23342948 ;/9<6C/ :<67145 278 =0548 F90;;47 1;2;4B47; 847A07C ;/4 2E49B47;1 B284 07 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 413<7847;<84130;4149E0:4<=7<;0:48087<;233429 @4=<94;/490@6725278F21352:484H.329;4 7 ;/4 @2101 <= ;/4 3542807C1 <= ;/4 329;041 ;/4 520B190@6725=92B48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/4 4E0847:4 /4 90@6725 @A ;/4 0B36C748 D68CB47; 2782F298/21801B01148;/4:520B34;0;0<7F0;/:<1;1 $ /45429748:<67145=<9;/4:520B27;1/21920148;/4 =<55<F07C:<7;47;0<71 2 )091;5A ;/4 :520B27;1 :<7;47848 ;/2; 84:42148 8048 07;/49<28;92==0:2::0847;07E<5E07C;/4<==47807CE4/0:54 - 5 - 278 ;/4A /2E4 251< B47;0<748 ;/4 134:0=0: 94C01;92;0<7 76B@49<=;/4<==47807CE4/0:54278;/4A/2E45<8C48;/4 :<B35207;2C2071;;/4890E49<=;/4<==47807CE4/0:54/4A /2E4 251< 39<86:48 ;/4 8<:6B47;1 011648 @A ;/4 ==0:427848;<1/<F;/2;;/41208E4/0:54F2194C01;4948 F0;/ ;/4 <==0:4 27848 7 130;4 <= ;/2; ;/4 23345527;1 /2E4 7<; ;92:48 ;/4 E4/0:54 278 =0548 ;/4 >? 943<9; )0507C<= >? 943<9; F0557<; @4=2;25 ;< ;/4 :214<= ;/4 :520B27;1 = ;/4 :520B27;1 /2E4 41;2@501/48 ;/2; 07D69A <9 842;/ :26148 864 ;< ;/4 07E<5E4B47; <= ;/4 <==47807CE4/0:54;/490@6725/21;<84:084;/412B4<7 ;/4 4E0847:4 <= ;/4 329;041 278 B2;49025 2E2052@54 <7 94:<98 /<F4E49 ;/4 90@6725 801B01148 ;/4 34;0;0<7 <75A <7;/4@2101<==0507C<=>?943<9; @ 4 =69;/49 :<7;47848 ;/2; <7 27 4295049 <::210<7 10B0529 D68CB47; /21 @447 321148 @A ;/4 90@6725 @A D68CB47; 82;48 %$% 278 ;/4 12B4 /21 @447 14; 21084@A;/01<69;7130;4<=;/2;10B0529<9849/21@447 321148@A;/490@6725 - 6 - , 429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 0716927:4 :<B327A /21 :<7;47848 ;/2; ;/4 94C01;92;0<7 76B@49 <= ;/4 <==47807C E4/0:54 B47;0<748 @A ;/4 :520B27;1 F21 7<; ;92:42@54 /4 3<50:4 /2E4 =0548 ;/4 >? 943<9; ;/2; /21 7<; @447 :/25547C48 @A ;/4 :520B27;1 278 ;/4A /2E4 7<; 2886:48 27A2880;0<7254E0847:421349;/48094:;0<71<=;/01<69; /494=<94 ;/4 90@6725 /21 90C/;5A 801B01148 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 329;041 496148 ;/4D68CB47;2782F298<=;/490@6725 ! /4:214<= ;/4:520B27;1 01 ;/2;<7 %% 2; 2@<6; !%% F/47 84:42148 2550G29D67 092829 F21 39<:44807C <7 2 B<;<9:A:54 @42907C 4C<.. 908847@A/01=90478212E292D@A;/454=;1084<=;/4 9<28 F/47 ;/4A :2B4 7429 6C65G/<8 2;/ <7 <52369 <28 0D2A236922;;/2;;0B42;2@<6;!%%25<99A @42907C4C<.$ :2B4=9<B;/4@2:G1084278 821/48;<;/4B<;<9:A:5464;<0B32:;2550G29D67=455 8<F727816==494807D6904127816::6B@48;<;/407D69041 - 7 - BB4802;45A 2=;49 ;/4 2::0847; .212E292D 5<8C48 2 :<B35207; 2C2071; ;/4 890E49 <= ;/4 <==47807C E4/0:54 B47;0<707C;/494C01;92;0<776B@49<=;/4E4/0:54 /21251<C0E47134:0=0:4E0847:41;2;07C;/2;890E49<=;/4 5<99A @42907C 4C<.$. 01 74C50C47; 07 :26107C ;/4 2::0847; 4 /21 251< =69701/48 ;/4 9454E27; 94:<981 =9<B ;/4 <==0:4 2; 27848 1;2;07C ;/2; ;/4 94C01;92;0<776B@49<=;/4E4/0:54B47;0<74807;/4)01 94C01;4948F0;/;/4 27848/490@6725<75A<7;/4 @2101 <= >? 943<9; =0548 @A ;/4 3<50:4 /21 801B01148 ;/4 :520B34;0;0<7 % 7 27 4295049 <::210<7 ;/4 D68CB47; 278 2F298 82;48 %$% 321148 @A ;/4 90@6725 /21 @447 :/25547C48 @4=<94 ;/01 <69; 07 ) <%$,$% /01 <69; E084 D68CB47; 82;48 %$%%% /21 255<F48 ;/4233425F0;/;/4=<55<F07C<@149E2;0<7 - 8 - !! " # # $ "% &$"! '() # # * !!+ ( "% * ** ,-./01./ 23 # / * ( * * 45 6" 7 -4 * 45# * # * -8( 45 * "% /$ $ - 9 - "% # # * # $ * # # # # * ** * # * * . # 9 7):&) # # 0!+ -84 ,!!1!! - -4 # # - 10 - 6 # ( *# * (/!1! **5 7 130;4 <= ;/01 ;/4 90@6725 2C207 801B01148 ;/4 :520B34;0;0<71<545A<7;/4C9<678;/2;;/43<50:4/28=0548 2 >? =0725 943<9; 278 F494 7<; 07 2 3<10;0<7 ;< ;92:4 ;/4 <==47807CE4/0:54<90;1890E49/4<F749<=;/4<==47807C E4/0:548087<;2334295;/<6C/;/490@672580136;48;/2; /01E4/0:54F2107E<5E4807;/42::0847;;/4:520B27;1/28 39<86:48 ;/4 94C01;92;0<7 76B@49 <= ;/4 E4/0:54 21 B47;0<74807;/4) E47;/4=0507C<=2>?943<9;017<; =2;25;<;/4=0507C<=2:520B34;0;0<70=;/4:520B27;39<E41 ;/2; ;/4 <==47807C E4/0:54 F21 07E<5E48 07 ;/4 2::0847; /4 90@6725 F0;/<6; :<71084907C 255 ;/414 2134:;1 /21 <7:4 2C207 801B01148 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 7 E04F <= ;/4 2@<E4;/423342584149E41;<@4255<F48@A14;;07C21084 - 11 - ;/4 0B36C748 D68CB47; 278 2F298 47:4 F4 3211 ;/4 =<55<F07C 0 /423342501255<F48/40B36C748D68CB47; 278 2F298 82;48 %%,% 321148 @A ;/4 907:0325470<90E05"68C42784B@49. 0D2A236907 <%0114;21084 00 /4 B2;;49 01 94B0;;48 ;< ;/4 90@6725 =<9 =941/ :<7108492;0<7 07 2::<9827:4 F0;/ ;/4 52F 2=;49 C0E07C<33<9;670;A;<@<;/;/4329;041;<2886:4 2880;0<725 4E0847:4 <9 39<86:4 2880;0<725 8<:6B47;10=27A=0548@A;/4329;041 000 /4 329;041 294 8094:;48 ;< 233429 @4=<94 ;/4 90@6725 <7 ,% F0;/<6; 27A =69;/49 7<;0:4 0E /490@6725018094:;48;<8013<14<=;/434;0;0<7 F0;/07 2 3490<8 <= 10H B<7;/1 =9<B ;/4 82;4 <= 23342927:4<=;/4329;041 - 12 - E ==0:4 01 8094:;48 ;< 94;697 ;/4 94:<981 ;< ;/4 :<7:4974890@6725 )* &#' % )* & %! ' % 01;<5<