- 1 - ! "# $! % &!$! % &!"&# " ! !$$ '#( ) ! " # $%$&! ' ! ( )!$) $%$""& ** + % !& )%,"!* Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $%$&! " ( ( ,! $%$""& *** - )&&&&! ' &&!&$ !. " #* (* * * !,"! * !%% * ( &)!&" * ( (* ),)&! * ( - ( - ( ( - 3 - & - ( ! /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 !,"! <= <;<9 4/0:541 :; !%% /494072=;49 94=49948 ;< 21 >;/4 :;? /21 @447 =0548 @A ;/4 :520B27; :/25547C07C ;/4 D68CB47; 82;48 &)!&" 321148 @A 885 470<9 0E05 (68C4 278 (* 278 082907<),)&! *2:;1 C0E07C 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507C <= ;/4 233425 @904=5A 1;2;48 294 ;/2; <7 !&&! 2; 2@<6; && 3B F/47 ;/4 :520B27; 25<7C F0;/ /01 =904781 :2B4 =9<B 278/0 2C2978027 05 4;9<5 6B3 278F/054 321107C ;/49<28 @A @0G4 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7 <# " )$! 2; ;/2; ;0B4 29 @42907C 94C01;92;0<7 <# "% $)%% @407C 890E47 @A 0;1 890E49 2; 2 /0C/ 13448 278 07 2 921/ 278 74C50C47; B27749 821/48 ;< ;/4 E4/0:54 <= ;/4 :520B27; 1 2 94165; <= ;/4 2=<941208 2::0847; ;/4 :520B27; 161;20748C904E<6107D69041278F21/<130;250H48 - 4 - " /4:520B27;=0548234;0;0<7678494:;0<7!))<=;/4 :;144G07C:<B34712;0<7;F213542848;/2;/41347; 10C70=0:27;2B<67;;<F2981B480:254I347141:<7E4A27:4 :/29C41 278 <;/49 9452;48 :<1;1 ; F21 =69;/49 3542848 ;/2; ;/4 2::0847; <::69948 1<545A <7 2::<67; <= 921/ 278 74C50C47;890E07C<=;/4<==47807CE4/0:54@A0;1890E49 3<7 149E0:4 <= 7<;0:4 ;/4 9413<7847; < 278 23342948;/9<6C/;/409:<67145278=0548143292;4F90;;47 1;2;4B47; 847A07C ;/4 2E49B47;1 B284 07 ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 /4 9413<7847; <! 278 " 84130;4 149E0:4 <= 7<;0:48087<;233429@4=<94;/490@6725278F21352:48 4I 329;4 $ 7 ;/4 @2101 <= ;/4 3542807C1 <= ;/4 329;041 ;/4 520B190@6725=92B48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/4 4E0847:4 /4 90@6725 @A 0B36C748 D68CB47; 278 2F298/21329;5A255<F48;/4:520B34;0;0<7278/458;/2; ;/4:520B27;0147;0;548;<2:<B34712;0<7<= 1%"$) 25<7CF0;/07;4941;2;;/492;4<=)J322788094:;48;/4 - 5 - 9413<7847; <1 278 294 843<10; ;/4 :<B34712;0<7 2B<67;25<7CF0;/07;4941; 407C2CC904E48;/4394147; 233425/21@447=0548 ) /4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 :520B27; /21 920148 ;/4 =<55<F07C:<7;47;0<71 2 *091;5A ;/4 :520B27; 21149;1 ;/2; /4 F21 429707C 1!$&&& 349B<7;/@AF<9G07C2154:;90:0272788<07C 60;0<7 <F4E49 ;/4 90@6725 /21 49948 07 ;2G07C ;/4 07:<B421B4945A21 1!!&&& 349B<7;/ 4:<785A ;/4 :520B27; /21 4I2B0748 ;/4 8<:;<9 21 /490@672567849E25648;/4:520B27;-1F/<54 @<8A 8012@050;A2;"J:<7;9280:;07C;/44E0847:4<=;/48<:;<9 ;/2; ;/4 :520B27; 16==4948 ,&J 8012@050;A ;< 329;0:6529 50B@64;<;/48012@050;A;/4:520B27;017<;0723<10;0<7 ;<801:/29C4/0194C6529F<9G278;/494015<11<=07:<B4 /494 01 =67:;0<725 8012@050;A 278 :520B27; 01 47;0;548 =<9 =6;694 39<134:;1 6; ;/4 90@6725 /21 =20548 ;< :<710849 =6;694 39<134:;1 7 1633<9; <= /01 :<7;47;0<7 /4 /21 - 6 - 94504863<7;/484:010<7<=;/434I<69;07;/4:214<= 27807 ;/4 :214 <= ! "# $$$ : /0985A 864 ;< ;/4 2::0847; ;/4 :520B27; /21 161;20748C904E<6107D690414F21;942;48210732;047;=<9 23490<8<="82A1E472=;49801:/29C4=9<B;/4/<130;25 /4F217<;0723<10;0<7;<801:/29C4/0194C6529F<9G4 /2116==49485<;<=320786907C;942;B47;<71084907C;/4 12B4;/4<E49255:<B34712;0<72F29848@A;/490@672501 <7;/45<F491084 8 21;5A :<7;47848 ;/2; 2; ;/4 ;0B4 <= ;/4 2::0847; ;/4 :520B27; F21 2@<6; ! A4291 /4 90@6725 /21 7<; C927;4827A:<B34712;0<7=<9B29902C439<134:;12787< :<B34712;0<7 01 2F29848 =<9 =6;694 B480:25 4I347141 47:4/41<6C/;=<947/27:4B47;<=:<B34712;0<7 - 7 - 0;/ ;/4 2@<E4 :<7;47;0<71 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 1<6C/;;<255<F;/4233425 , 7 ;/4 <;/49 /278 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 9413<7847; <1 278 716927:4 <B327A /21 920148 ;/4=<55<F07C:<67;49 :<7;47;0<71 2 *091;5A;/421149;0<7<=:520B27;;/2;/4F21429707C 1!!&&& 349 B<7;/ 94B2071 6716@1;27;02;48 864 ;< 52:G<=8<:6B47;29A4E0847:47;/42@147:4<=39<<=<= 07:<B4 ;/4 90@6725 /21 21141148 ;/4 07:<B4 <= ;/4 :520B27;7<;0<7255A @ 4:<785A ;/4 90@6725 :<71084907C ;/4 07D69041 161;20748@A;/4:520B27;2784E0847:4<=;/48<:;<9/21 90C/;5A 21141148 ;/4 F/<54 @<8A 8012@050;A 2; "J /4 1208 8012@050;A 8<41 7<; 2==4:; =6;694 429707C1 =<9 ;/4 :520B27; 278 ;/494=<94 /4 01 7<; 47;0;548 =<9 27A =6;694 39<134:;1 : 21;5A:<7;47848;/2;4E47;/<6C/54=;54C@45<F;/4 G744<= ;/4 :520B27; /21@4472B36;2;48 /4 :520B27; - 8 - /21 4I2B0748 ;/4 8<:;<9 4 /21 7<; 13<G47 2@<6; 27A =6;694 B480:25 4I347141 /494=<94 90@6725 /21 90C/;5A 7<;C927;4827A:<B34712;0<767849;/4/428 0;/ ;/4 2@<E4 :<7;47;0<71 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 1<6C/;;<801B011;/4233425 % 4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 329;041 278 3496148;/494:<981 ; 01 7<; 07 80136;4 ;/2; ;/4 :520B27; /21 161;20748 07D6904107;/49<28;92==0:2::0847;<::69948<7!&&! 864;<921/27874C50C47;890E07C<=;/4<==47807CE4/0:54 @A0;1890E49 !& /4:520B27;:520B1;/2;/4F21429707C 1!$&&& 349 B<7;/ 6; /4 /21 7<; 39<86:48 27A 8<:6B47;1 ;< 16@1;27;02;4/01:520B/494=<9407;/42@147:4<=39<<= <=07:<B47<;0<72507:<B4/21;<@421141148::<9807C ;< ;/4 C608450741 011648 @A ;/4 #2972;2G2 ;2;4 4C25 - 9 - 49E0:41 6;/<90;A =<9 2::0847;1 <::69948 07 ;/4 A429 &!7<;0<72507:<B41/255@4;2G472; 1!$& 3B !! 1349F<678:49;0=0:2;4;/4:520B27;/21161;20748 ,&J8012@050;A;<54=;5<F4954C0154=;54C@45<F;/4G744 /21 @447 2B36;2;48 <71084907C ;/4 B35<A441? <B34712;0<7 :; 21 349 ;/4 :/48654 ;4B <& =<9 2B36;2;0<7 @45<F ;/4 G744 ;/4 8012@050;A /21 ;< @4 21141148 $&J /4 :520B27; /21 161;20748 C904E<61 07D69041 /4 1208 8012@050;A /21 2==4:;48 /01 429707C1 278 ;/494015<11<=07:<B4278/47:4/40147;0;548=<9=6;694 39<134:;1 07:4 ;/494 01 =67:;0<725 8012@050;A 07 E04F <= ;/452F52088<F7@A;/4<7?@5434I<69;07;/4:214<= *" $" '+,-./( /01 $$$ "# '+,-./(2;/4:520B27;0147;0;548;<=6;69439<134:;17 E04F<=;/452F52088<F7@A;/4<7?@5434I<69;07;/4 :214<= % % & ''& 2880;0<7 <= &J <= ;/4 07:<B4 <= ;/4 :520B27; ;<F2981 =6;694 - 10 - 39<134:;1 /21 ;< @4 :<71084948 47:4 ;/4 B<7;/5A 07:<B4 <= ;/4 :520B27; 01 21141148 2; 1!$& 1!$&K&J/4:520B27;012C482@<6;!A42912; ;/4;0B4<=;/42::0847;278B65;03504923350:2@54;</01 2C4 C9<63 01 >!%? /61 ;/4 :520B27; 01 47;0;548 =<9 :<B34712;0<7 <=+ 34 1!$&L!L!%L$&J <72::<67;<=-5<11<==6;69407:<B4- ! /4 72;694 <= 07D69041 0780:2;41 ;/2; ;/4 :520B27; B61; /2E4 @447 67849 941; 278 ;942;B47; =<9 ) B<7;/1 <714M647;5A;/4:520B27;0147;0;548=<9:<B34712;0<7<= +54 1!$&L)B<7;/167849;/4/428>5<11 <=07:<B486907C5208633490<8? !" E47;/<6C/8<:;<9/21843<148;/2;54=;54C@45<F ;/4G744/21@4472B36;2;48;/494017<4E0847:4<=;/4 8<:;<9 94C29807C 2B36;2;0<7 6107C <= 29;0=0:025 54C <71084907C;/407D69A16==4948@A;/4:520B27;F4294<= ;/4 <3070<7 ;/2; =<9 =6;694 B480:25 4I347141 - 11 - +4 /21 ;< @4 2F29848 0; F055 7<; :299A 27A 07;4941; ! 64 ;< ;/4 2::0847; ;/4 :520B27; /21 16==4948 C904E<6107D69041278251<67849C<74169C49A<71084907C ;/4 39<5<7C48 3207 86907C ;942;B47; 21 F455 21 ;/4 349B2747; 8012@050;A :49;0=048 @A ;/4 8<:;<9 F4 294 07:50748 ;< 47/27:4 ;/4 :<B34712;0<7 2F29848 @A ;/4 90@6725 67849 ;/4 /428 <= -3207 278 16==4907C1- =9<B 1$&&&& ;<+ 4278 67849 ;/4 /428 <=-5<11 <=2B470;041-=9<B 1"&&&& ;<+ 4 !$ 07:4 ;/4 :520B27; F21 2C48 2@<6; ! A4291 2; ;/4 ;0B4<=;/42::0847;278/0154=;54C/21@4472B36;2;48 ; F055 2==4:; /01 B29902C4 39<134:;1 /494=<94 +4012F29848=<9B29902C439<134:;1 !) <71084907C;/472;694<=07D69041;/4:<B34712;0<7 2F29848 @A ;/4 90@6725 67849 <;/49 /4281 01 D61; 278 9421<72@54 - 12 - !, /61 ;/4 :520B27; 01 47;0;548 ;< ;/4 =<55<F07C :<B34712;0<7 6-70+/890,017. 197.7087/1+ +/:/.171 ;<8=7 .9;,0/> '+( +/:/.171 ;<8=9+ ,.8 '+( <11<==6;69407:<B4 $)%& !$)&& 20727816==4907C $&&&& ,$&&& 480:254I347141 !,,! !,,! <11<=07:<B486907C 5208 633490<8 &&& %$$&& 29902C439<134:;1 !&&&&& *<<82787<6901/B47; :<7E4A27:4.2;;47827; :/29C41 !&&&& !&&&& <11<==6;6942B470;041 "&&&& ,$&&& *6;694B480:254I347141 !&&&&& 8/> 53 !% 7;/494165;;/4=<55<F07C<984901321148 2 /423342501/>>:7190-/.8 @ /4D68CB47;<=;/4520B190@672501B<80=048 : /4 :520B27; 01 47;0;548 ;< 2 ;<;25 :<B34712;0<7 <= + 4 - 13 - 8 /4 9413<7847; < 278 294 8094:;48 ;< 843<10; ;/4 :<B34712;0<7 2B<67; 2; ;/4 92;4 <= $&J 42:/ 25<7CF0;/07;4941;N)J3492776B=9<B;/482;4 <= =0507C <= ;/4 :520B 34;0;0<7 ;055 ;/4 82;4 <= 94250H2;0<7 F0;/07 2 3490<8 <= 10I F44G1 =9<B ;/4 82;4<=94:403;<=:<3A<=;/01D68CB47; 4 /4843<10;2789454214<=2B<67;1/255@4B28407 ;49B1<=;/42F298<=;/490@6725 !14 '$!( & !14 '"&# "( & 01;<!5<$,