Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 50784 (KAR)
SYED KALEEM ASHRAF AND ORS v. THE ADMINISTRATOR/CHAIRMAN AND ORS
CRP/200003/2024 · 2025-03-21
Anant Ramanath Hegde
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50784 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50784 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#
$#%!#
&&! '
!"
#
"
#$#$%#
&
!"
'
'(
#$#$%#
&
!"
#
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#$#$((
&
!" )*
*
+
, &
(""#
# -+ , &
(""#
' , & !"
,
!" )
*
&
+
'. + +
+ + *
!' / , * ("#"#'*
,
+
"!#"#
, ,
+
"!#"#
, , &
- 3 -
+ + * ,
0
*
0
1234 561 7123814 9:;8<17 2==123>8? @:3 561 =15>5>:813< 2< A177 2< 7123814 9:;8<17 2==123>8? @:3 561 31<=:84185<
# 6>< =15>5>:8 >< @>714 9627718?>8? 561 :3413 42514 ("#"#' >8 :!#"# :8 561 @>71 :@ 238252B2 ,2B@ 3>C;827 272C;32?> >D><>:8 272C;32?> @:3 <6:35 E561 3>C;827F 8 513G< :@ 561 >G=;?814 :3413 561 3>C;82762<4><G><<14561<;>5@:3A285:@92;<1:@295>:8 2842<C23314;8413195>:8<(284!!:@,2B@ 95/ @:3<6:35E561 95/. ' 61 31<=:84185
,2B@ :234 32><14 2 9:85185>:8 C1@:31 561 3>C;827 9:85184>8? 5625 561 <;>5 @>714CH561=72>85>@@<><C233142<5614><=;51><8:532><14
- 4 -
A>56>8:81H123@3:G5614251:@=;C7>925>:8:@8:5>@>925>:8 284 561 <;>5 >< 41@195>D1 @:3 A285 :@ =3:=13 8:5>91 ;8413 195>:8!/:@561 95//
123814 9:;8<17 @:3 561 =15>5>:813< A:;74 9:85184 5625 561 3>C;827 G><9:8<53;14 >5<17@ >8 3124>8? 561 8:5>91 ><<;14 CH 561 =72>85>@@< A6>96 G15 561 31I;>31G185:@195>:8!/:@561 95//5><@;35613 9:85185>:8 5625 561 =13>:4 :@ :81 H123 9:851G=72514 >8 195>:8(:@561 95//62<C118>8513=315145:<2H5625 561 7>G>525>:8 <5235< @3:G 561 4251 :@ 8:5>@>925>:8 2@513 6:74>8? 8191<<23H 18I;>3H >891 8: 18I;>3H >< 6174 561 <;>5><>85>G1><5619:85185>:8
123814 9:;8<17 2==123>8? @:356131<=:84185< A:;74 9:85184 5625 561 8:5>91 >< 8:5 >8 299:342891 A>56 195>:8!/:@561 95//284561<;>5><@>714G:315628 :81H1232@513><<;2891:@8:5>@>925>:8;8413195>:8(:@ 561 95//
- 5 -
( 6><9:;3562<9:8<>413145619:85185>:8<32><14 25561C23284=13;<14561319:34<. % 6:;?6195>:8(:@561 95//9:851G=7251< <;>55:C1@>714A>56>8:81H123@3:G5614251:@8:5>@>925>:8 ;8413 195>:8 ( >8 D>1A :@ 561 >8513=31525>:8 5625 561 8:5>@>925>:8 <6:;74 C1 2@513 9:G=7H>8? 8191<<23H =3:914;31 561 3>C;827 >< 31I;>314 5: 9:8<>413 A615613 8191<<23H =3:914;31 >< 9:G=7>14 :3 8:5 2@513 2@@:34>8? C:56=235>1<5:71241D>41891:856><=:>852<561=72>85>@@ 9:85184< 5625 8191<<23H =3:914;31 >< 8:5 9:G=7>14 A6>71 ><<;>8?8:5>@>925>:8;8413195>:8(:@561 95//61 I;1<5>:832><14C1@:315613>C;82731725>8?5:7>G>525>:8>< 2 G>J14 I;1<5>:8:@72A284 @295 284 61891 561 3>C;827 9:;74 8:5 62D14><G><<14 561 <;>5 25 561 5631<6:74C2<14 :85619:85185>:8<32><14>8561A3>5518<5251G1852<561 2D13G185 G241 >8 561 =72>85 4:1< 8:5 >84>9251 5625 561 <;>5><5>G1C23314
! < @23 2< 31I;>31G185 :@ 8:5>@>925>:8 ;8413 195>:8!/:@561 95//><9:8913814>5><31I;>3145:
- 6 -
C18:5>914@3:G5618:5>91A6>96><2881J145:561=72>85 561=72>85>@@<62D1971237H4><97:<142<5:A625><561317>1@ 561H 231 972>G>8? 284 561 92;<1 :@ 295>:8 >< 27<: G241 61 3>C;827 @177 >8 133:3 >8 :C<13D>8?
5625 561 185>31 9:85185< :@ 561 =72>85 231 8:5 4><97:<14 >8 561 92;<1 :@ 295>:8 625 >< 8:5 561 31I;>31G185 :@ 195>:8 !/ :@ 561 95 // 61 ?><5 :@ 561 317>1@ =72>85>@@< 972>G 284 561 92;<1 :@ 295>:8 :@ <;>5 5: C1 4><97:<14 :5>91 >< 56;< @;7@>77< 561 31I;>31G185 8413 561<1 9>39;G<52891< 561 >G=;?814:3413><;8<;<52>82C711891561@:77:A>8? > 61=15>5>:8><277:A14 >> 61 >G=;?814 :3413 42514 ("#"#' =2<<14 CH 561 238252B2 ,2B@ 3>C;827 272C;32?> >D><>:8272C;32?>><<152<>41 >>> 61G25513><31G>55145:5613>C;827@:3@31<6 24K;4>925>:8>8299:342891A>5672A
- 7 -
>D 61=235>1<<62772==123C1@:315613>C;827:8 #"#"# 5 >< G241 97123 5625 1J91=5 561 @>84>8? 31725>8? 5:
D27>4>5H :@ 561 8:5>91 277 :5613 9:85185>:8< >897;4>8? 7>G>525>:8231B1=5:=18
!()
*# + %
><5:7:'