- 1 - ! "!# ! $ #%!!! $ #%!# &!' !"# $ % & # %& ' !"# ( ) ##""## ' ' '' ##""## $ % *& Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ((+ ((, ' ' ' #,"""" #("( "!",("(! -) '* ' ' . * . * ' % . * & /01234/5/016/27896:/5;8134/</3=3=86/17896:/5 06205:834/7896:/50<</01=6>;8134/1/:<862/63: ( 4=:?1=3</3=3=86=:;=5/20>0=6:334/812/1203/2 "!",("(! =6 8#,"""" #("( <0::/2 @A /63105 2B=6=:3103=C/ 1=@9605 06>0581/ /674 /6>05919 %;81 :4813DE&1/F/73=868;34/750=BB02/@A34/</3=3=86/1 ;81 34/ 78B<0::=8603/ 0<<8=63B/63 4=5/ 1/F/73=6> 34/ 0<<5=703=86 34/ 78B/: 38 34/ 786759:=86 3403 78B<0::=8603/ 0<<8=63B/63 =: 683 0 C/:3/2 1=>43 ?4=74 - 3 - 706 @/ /G/17=:/2 03 06A 3=B/ =6 ;9391/ 8B<0::=8603/ /B<58AB/63706683@/750=B/2818;;/1/20;3/1050<:/8; 3=B/0620;3/134/71=:=:=:8C/14/:0B/=:/G31073/2=6 <010>10<48,( 6C=/?34/<1=67=<5/:50=228?6=634/F92>B/63 8; C: 34/ ?4=5/ 786:=2/1=6> 34/ 70:/ 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 =6 <010>10<4 8, 30H/6 683/ 8; <18C=:=86 ;81 >1063 8; 78B<0::=8603//B<58AB/63=:38/60@5/34/;0B=5A8;34/ 2/7/0:/2 /B<58A// 38 3=2/ 8C/1 34/ :922/6 71=:=: 29/ 38 34/2/0348;34/@1/02/016/1?4=7440:5/;334/;0B=5A=6 </691A062 ?=3489306A B/06:8; 5=C/5=4882 938;<91/ 49B06=301=06 786:=2/103=86 06240C=6>1/>012 38 34/ ;073 3403 965/:: :8B/ :8917/ 8; 5=C/5=4882 =: <18C=2/2 34/ ;0B=5A ?8952 683 @/ =6 0 <8:=3=86 38 B0H/ @834 34//62: B//3 0 <18C=:=86 =: B02/ ;81 >=C=6> >0=6;95 0<<8=63B/63 38 86/ 8; 34/ 2/</62063: 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 ?48 B0A @/ /5=>=@5/ ;81 :974 0<<8=63B/63 0C=6> 1/>012 38 :974 06 8@F/73 =3 ?8952 @/ 8; 68 0C0=5 38 >1063 78B<0::=8603/ - 4 - 0<<8=63B/633834/2/</62063:8;34/2/7/0:/2/B<58A// 0;3/1 34/ 71=:=: ?4=74 018:/ 86 0778963 8; 34/2/034 8; 0 @1/02)?=66/140:@//68C/178B/ ! 3 =: 8@:/1C/2 3403 349: 34/1/ =: 05:8 0 78B</55=6> 6//2 38 073 ?=34 0 :/6:/ 8; =BB/2=07A =6 B033/1: 7867/16=6> 78B<0::=8603/ 0<<8=63B/63 @/709:/ 86 ;0=591/ 38 28 :8 34/ 8@F/73 8; 34/ :74/B/ 8; 78B<0::=8603/?8952@/;19:3103/24/1/0586>50<:/8; 3=B/40:877911/2:=67/34/203/8;2/0348;34/2/7/0:/2 /B<58A// 34/ :/6:/ 8; =BB/2=07A ;81 ://H=6> 78B<0::=8603/0<<8=63B/63?89527/0:/38/G=:3062349: 58:/ =3: :=>6=;=7067/ 062 34=: ?8952 @/ 0 1/5/C063 7=179B:3067/ ?4=74 B9:3 ?/=>4 ?=34 34/ 093481=3=/: =6 2/3/1B=6=6> 0: 38 ?4/34/1 0 70:/ ;81 34/ >1063 8; 78B<0::=8603/ 0<<8=63B/63 40: @//6 B02/ 893 ;81 786:=2/103=86 4/ :78</ =: 05:8 2=:79::/2 =6 <010>10<4 8, 8?/C/1 =6 <010>10<4 8,! 78B/: 38 34/ - 5 - 786759:=86340334/:=6/I90686;81686)/63/130=6=6>34/ 750=B;8178B<0::=8603/0<<8=63B/63=:340334/;0B=5A8; 34/2/7/0:/2/B<58A//?8952@/960@5/38B0H/3?8/62: B//3 ?=34893 86/ 8; 34/ 2/;/62063: 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 /B<58A//@/=6>/B<58A/28678B<0::=8603/>18962:4/ ;=6067=05 7862=3=86 8; 34/ ;0B=5A 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 03 34/ 3=B/ 8; 34/ 2/034 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 =: 34/ <1=B01A 786:=2/103=86340389>4338>9=2/34/E093481=3=/:2/7=:=86 =634/B033/1 + 0H=6> 683/ 8; 34/ :0B/ 2=:B=::/2 34/ 0<<5=703=86 =6 78B=6> 38 34/ 786759:=86 3403 1/F/73=86 8; 34/ 750=B B02/ @A 34/ 0<<5=7063 706683 @/ ;0953/2 ?=34 4/:0=2812/1=:74055/6>/2@/;81/34=:8913@A;=5=6>34=: </3=3=86 , 4/ B0=67863/63=8691>/2 =634=:?1=3 </3=3=86 =: 34/ 786759:=86 8; 34/ 3403 34/ 2/7/0:/2 6062 9B01?482=/2=64016/::40:68B=603/234/B834/18; - 6 - 34/ </3=3=86/1 062 683 68B=603/2 34/ 0<<5=7063 062 34/ =B<9>6/2812/1=:/1186/89: 3 =: 05:8 7863/62/2 3403 40: 683 786:=2/1/2 3403 34/ 2/7/0:/2 6062 9B01 ?0: 683 B011=/2 062 5=C=6> =6 0 F8=63 ;0B=5A 8; </3=3=86/1 062 4=: @1834/1 9:/2 38 588H 0;3/1 34/ B834/1 8; </3=3=86/1 062 9:/238588H0;3/16/7/::01A?81H:8;34/F8=63;0B=5A062 ?0: 2/</62/63 86 34/ =678B/ 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 6062 9B01 /67/ 34/ C/1A 1/F/73=86 =: 683 7811/73 062 </3=3=86/1=:/63=35/2;8178B<0::=8603/0<<8=63B/63 J 4/ 40: 78BB=33/2 06 /1181 =6 683 786:=2/1=6>34/<1=B01A8@F/738;:9740:74/B/=:38:0C/ 34/@/1/0C/2;0B=5A;18B:922/6;=6067=0571=:=:877911=6> 29/ 38 34/ 2/034 8; :85/ @1/02 /016/1 4/ 834/1 1/0:86 ?0:>=C/6786:=2/1=6>34/5/33/1203/2#+##("((340334/ @1834/18;34/60629B01=:0>/2B81/3406( A/01: /67/34/:0B/706683@/786:=2/1/2=:05:86833/60@5/ 1/0:86 - 7 - #" 4/ 7896:/5 05:8 ?8952 C/4/B/635A 7863/62 3403?4/634/;0B=5A=:962/134/;=6067=0571=:=:89>43683 38 40C/ 1/F/73/2 34/ :0B/ 062 34/ 89>43 38 40C/ 786:=2/1/2 34/ C/1A 8@F/73 062 <18C=2=6> 34/ 78B<0::=8603/0<<8=63B/63 ## 34/ 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 34/ 1/:<862/63:;=5/20:303/B/638;8@F/73=86:@/;81/34/ C=2/ 66/G91/) 38 34/ ?1=3 </3=3=86 062 @189>43 38 683=7/ 8; 34=: 8913 03 <010>10<4 8+ 3403 865A B3=2A0?03=?0:68B=603/20:6/G38;H=6@A1=6062 9B01 ?4/6 4/ ?0: 05=C/ 062 B3=2A0?03= 402 :9@B=33/2 06 0<<5=703=86 38 2/5/3/ 4/1 60B/ ;18B 34/ :/1C=7/1/7812:8;503/60629B0106202234/60B/:8; 4/1834/1:86:4/?0:1/<5=/2340334/2/5/3=86022=3=86 8; 60B/ =6 34/ :/1C=7/ 1/7812: 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 =: 683 ;/0:=@5/0;3/134/2/0348;34//B<58A// - 8 - #( =3=:7863/62/234030:</7=;=7>18962=:91>/2=6 34/1/<5A:303/B/63?4=5/;=5=6>34/:303/B/638;8@F/73=86 0624/67/34/1=>435A1/F/73/234/:0B/ # 0C=6> 4/012 34/ </3=3=86/1E: 7896:/5 062 05:8 34/ 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 34/ 1/:<862/63: 062 05:8 786:=2/1=6> 34/ >18962: ?4=74 40C/ @//6 91>/2 =6 34/ </3=3=8634/<8=633403?895201=:/;81786:=2/103=868;34=: 7891301/ K4/34/134/78BB=33/206/1181=6 1/F/73=6>34/0<<5=703=86;=5/2@A34/</3=3=86/1 062 ?4/34/1 =3 1/I9=1/: =63/1;/1/67/ 8; 34=: 8913LM #! 0C=6> 786:=2/1/2 34/ >18962: ?4=74 40C/ @//691>/2=634/?1=3</3=3=860:?/550:34/:303/B/638; 8@F/73=86: ;=5/2 @/;81/ 34/ 03 66/G91/) 062 =6 <010>10<48(8;34/=18?68@F/73=86:303/B/63:74/B/ 05:8 /G31073/2 ?4/1/=6 =3 =: C/1A 75/01 3403 :74/B/ 8; /B<58AB/630::=:3067/?=34962/1=62=>/637=179B:3067/: =: 0<<5=70@5/ 38 0 2/</62/63 ;0B=5A B/B@/1 8; 34/ 8C/16B/63 :/1C063 ?48 2=/: ?4=5/ =6 :/1C=7/ 81 1/3=1/2 - 9 - 86 B/2=705 >18962: : </1 <85=7A =6 C8>9/ 34/ /5=>=@5/ B/B@/1B/06:8;34/;8558?=6>=67592=6>34/:<89:/:86 209>43/1 @1834/1 81 :=:3/1 =6 70:/ 8; 96B011=/2 8C/16B/63 :/1C063 ?48 ?0: ?4855A 2/</62/63 86 8C/16B/63:/1C0630334/3=B/8;4=:2/034=64016/::81 1/3=1/B/6386B/2=705>18962:0:34/70:/B0A@/ # 0C=6> 786:=2/1/2 34/ :74/B/ =3 =: C/1A 75/01 340334/:74/B/=67592/:34/@1834/1?48=:0696B011=/2 @1834/18;34/8C/16B/63:/1C063062?4/6:974@/=6> 34/70:/34/@1834/105:878B/:?=34=634/:74/B/8;34/ 1/:<862/63?48=:05:80696B011=/22B=33/25A34/1/=: 68 2/6=05 3403 2/7/0:/2 =: 96B011=/2 062 05:8 68 289@3 865A 34/ 60B/ 8; 34/ B834/1 ?0: B/63=86/2 0: 34/ 68B=6// =6 34/ :/1C=7/ 1/7812: 34/ :0B/ 706683 @/ 0 >18962 38 1/F/73 34/ 750=B 8; 34/ @1834/1 ?48 =: 06 96B011=/2 4/ 834/1 1/0:86 0::=>6/2 =: 3403 </1:86 :48952 683 @/ 0>/2 B81/ 3406 ( A/01: 4/ 7896:/5 0<</01=6>;8134/1/:<862/63:683<507/206A1/7812?=34 1/>0123834/@0134034/:48952683@/B81/34060>/8; - 10 - ( A/01:06234/:0=2@01=:865A=61/:</738;</6:=86=: 7867/16/2062683=61/:</738;34//B<58AB/638834/1 ;0B=5A B/B@/1 /016=6> =6 34/ ;0B=5A 062 ;0B=5A =: 962/1 ;=6067=052=:31/::4/6:974@/=6>34/70:/89>4338 40C/ 30H/6 683/ 8; 34/ :0=2 195/ 0: ?/55 0: 34/ ;0B=5A =: 962/12=:31/::8607789638;2/0348;34/</1:86?48=: 962/1 8C/16B/63 :/1C=7/ 062 34/ ;073 3403 ?4/6 34/ 750=B =: B02/ @A 34/ @1834/1 ?48 =: 06 96B011=/2 @1834/1 89>43 38 40C/ @//6 786:=2/1/2 062 34/ C/1A 8@F/738;34/C/1A:74/B/40:683@//6<18</15A1/02@A 34/?4=5/786:=2/1=6>34/750=BB02/@A34/750=B063 4/2/50A=:6830331=@930@5/3834/</1:86?48=:750=B=6> 34/ 78B<0::=8603/ /B<58AB/63 062 34/ /6281:/B/63 =::9/2 =: 961/0:860@5/ 86/ 062 34/ :0B/ =: 683 =6 077812067/?=3450? #+ 4/6 :974 @/=6> 34/ 70:/ 34/ 89>43 38 40C/ 30H/6 683/ 8; 34/ 2/50A =: 86 0778963 8; 06 961/0:860@5//6281:/B/63=::9/2@A34/1/:<862/63:062 34/ :0B/ 40: 683 @//6 786:=2/1/2 @A 34/ <18</15A - 11 - /67/ =3 1/I9=1/: =63/1;/1/67/ 8; 34=: 8913 0: 34/ 78BB=33/2 06 /1181 =6 2=:B=::=6> 34/ 750=B B02/ @A 34/ 0<<5=7063 4/1/;81/ ?/ 06:?/1/2 34/ <8=63 0: 0;;=1B03=C/ #, 6C=/?8;34/2=:79::=86:B02/0@8C/?/<0:: 34/;8558?=6> =& 1=3</3=3=86=:0558?/2 ==& 4/ =B<9>6/2 812/1 203/2 "!",("(! =6 8#,"""" #("(! <0::/2 @A 34/ /63105 2B=6=:3103=C/ 1=@9605 06>0581/ /674 /6>05919 =: 4/1/@A I90:4/2 86:/I9/635A34/0<<5=703=86=:0558?/2 ===& 4//6281:/B/63203/2# "J("((=::9/2 @A1/:<862/638#06234/78BB96=703=86 203/2 #+##("(( =::9/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8(01/4/1/@AI90:4/2 =C& 2=1/73=86 =: =::9/2 =6 34/ 60391/ 8; B0620B9: 2=1/73=6> 34/ 1/:<862/63: 38 34/ 0<<5=703=86 062 38 >=C/ 78B<0::=8603/ 0<<8=63B/63 38 34/ </3=3=86/1 ?=34=6 0 - 12 - </1=82 8; 86/ B8634 ;18B 34/ 203/ 8; 1/7/=<38;34/78<A8;34=:812/1 !() &!!' % !() &#' % =:38#58 +