Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 50767 (KAR)
MALLIKARJUN v. SHIVARAJ AND ANR
MFA/203927/2023 · 2025-12-02
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50767 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50767 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"# ##
$%& '
!"# #$%&'('#
)
# ! '# ! !! #$'*$*%'&
"## # #
*#
## ! + ! $%&'('#
)
##!#
*, ! #('#'*#*(*- '
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'.-' ! -(#(&#*(**
#!# #./*('% ! # ###
#**'((($ 0
#'-*(((($'*0 #
! 1
" 23452 627 89978: ;< :;<67= >3? 8=@;<<;3A B;62 627 C3A<7A6 3> :78?A7= C34A<7: >3? 627 98?6;7< ;6 ;< 68D7A 49 >3?>;A8:=;<93<8:# *# 2;< 89978: ;< >;:7= 858;A<6 627 E4=5@7A6 8A= 8B8?==867=-(#(&#*(**98<<7=FG6277A;3?;H;:4=57 8A===;6;3A8:28:D;;A! 3#./3>*('%# -# 27 C:8;@8A6 857= ' G78?< =3;A5 85?;C4:64?7 8A=8:<3<3C;8:B3?D@76B;628A8CC;=7A63A(#(-#*('. 8A=<4<68;A7=5?;7H34<;AE4?7<8A=27>;:7=8C:8;@976;6;3A
- 3 -
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
- 4 -
# 23452 627 8997::8A6 <6867= 6286 27 B8< 78?A;A5<#-(((($97?@3A622728<A369?3=4C7=8AG ;AC3@7 9?33># 27?7>3?7 8< 97? 627 54;=7:;A7< 3> 627 8?A868D86867758:7?H;C7<4623?;6G8<6278CC;=7A6 ;<3>627G78?*('.2;<A36;3A8:;AC3@7;<63F768D7A86 <#'(*($ 97? @3A62# 7 B8< 857= ' G78?< 8A= 627?7>3?7 627 @4:6;9:;7? B8< ?;526:G 68D7A 8< K''L# 27 8997::8A6 <4<68;A7= >?8C64?7 3> :7>6 <234:=7? 8A= F:4A6 6?84@8 3A 627 ?;526 <;=7 2;9 8< 97? J#&$B34A= C7?6;>;C867# 7 8:<3 7J8@;A7= 627 =3C63? 8< #* 8A= 27 8<<7<<7=627=;<8F;:;6G86&0F46627?;F4A8:;A<678=3> 68D;A5 '-?= 3> &0 8< '0 28< 68D7A 627 =;<8F;:;6G 8< '(0#27?7>3?762;<34?6>;A=<;6?78<3A8F:76368D7627 =;<8F;:;6G8<'0#24<627:3<<3>>464?778?A;A5<B34:= F7 <#'(*(J'*J''J'0M<#*(*/($# .# 27 ?;F4A8: 28< 8B8?=7= 8A 8@34A6 3> <#.((($ 63B8?=< @7=;C8: 7J97A<7< 8A= ;6 A77=< A3 ;A67?>7?7AC7#
- 5 -
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
<4?57?G>3??7@3H8:8A=6277<6;@867=C3<6;<<#*((($# 27?7>3?7 62;< 34?6 >;A=< ;6 ?78<3A8F:7 63 5?8A6 8A 8@34A63><#*((($63B8?=<>464?7@7=;C8:7J97A<7<# ''# 7AC76278997::8A6;<7A6;6:7=>3?627@3=;>;7= C3@97A<86;3A4A=7?=;>>7?7A6278=<8<F7:3B
- 6 -
8;A8A=<4>>7?;A5 <#(((($ 7=;C8:7J97A<7< <#.((($ 464?7@7=;C8:7J97A<7< <#*((($ 3<<3>>464?778?A;A5< <#*(*/($ 3<<3>;AC3@7=4?;A5:8;=4997?;3= <#&'((($ ?8A<93?686;3A 7J6?8 A34?;<2@7A6 8A=8667A=8A6C28?57< <#-(((($ 3<<3>8@7A;6;7< <#*((($ 368: 7<<8B8?=7=FG?;F4A8: A28AC7@7A6 <#&&//($ <#**'((($ (
)$
27 A<4?8AC7 3@98AG 28< 8:?78=G =793<;67= 627 8@34A6 8B8?=7= FG 627 ?;F4A8:# 24< 627 8997::8A6 ;< 7A6;6:7=>3?7A28AC7=C3@97A<86;3A3><#**%/($B;62 ;A67?7<6 86 0 97? 8AA4@ 8A= 627?7>3?7 627 89978: =7<7?H7<63F78::3B7=;A98?6# '*# A627?7<4:6627>3::3B;A53?=7?;<98<<7= ; 9978:;<8::3B7=;A98?6# ;;
27 8997::8A6C:8;@8A6 ;< 7A6;6:7= >3? 627 7A28AC7= C3@97A<86;3A 3> <#**%/($ B;62 ;A67?7<6 86 0 97? 8AA4@ >?3@ 627 =867 3> 976;6;3A 6;:: 627 =867 3> ?78:;<86;3A# 3B7H7? 8<97?6273?=7? =867=('#'*#*(*-
- 7 -
627 8997::8A6 ;< A36 7A6;6:7= >3? ;A67?7<6 >3? 627 =7:8G7= 97?;3=3>&-/=8G<;A>;:;A562789978:# ;;; 7<93A=7A6
3#*$A<4?8AC7 3@98AG ;< =;?7C67= 63 =793<;6 627 8>3?7<8;= C3@97A<86;3A 8@34A6 B;62;A3A7@3A62>?3@627=8673>62;<E4=5@7A6# ;H
A <4C2 =793<;6 627 8997::8A6 ;< 97?@;667= 63 B;62=?8B 627 7A6;?7 8@34A6 8:3A5 B;62 ;A67?7<6 8CC?47= 3A;6#
(*+ $#&
"
;<6 3#': 3#'