- 1 - ! " #$ % % "" &%' ( ! "# # $ %% & '()(*+ % ,, ,, '()(% ! # , %- # %%% &$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , , *+!$ , # . " , & , " & %% #" # *%%% , ," , , " & # / "# # $ 01230 4056 78897: 56 :5649; <1= 7;>56651? @540 409 A1?69?41<:97=?9;A12?69:<1=B14065;96545647C9?28<1= <5?7:;568167: 95?3 733=59D9; BE 409 F2;3>9?4 7?; 7@7=; ;749; %% 87669; 5? # 1*%%% BE 409 ;;: 9?51= 5D5: "2;39 G 7:7B2=735 !09=95?7<49= =9<9==9; 41 76 H409 =5B2?7:I <1= 601=4$ 409 7889::7?4 - 3 - A:75>7?4 56 B9<1=9 4056 12=4 699C5?3 9?07?A9>9?4 1< A1>89?67451? % =59<<7A46:97;5?341<5:5?31<A:75>8945451?7=9 4074 1? %(+%% 74 7B124 7> @09? 409 A:75>7?4056@5<91?907?C7=12;77?;0569>8:1E996 @9=9 8=1A99;5?3 41 4095= :7?; 5? 7 B2::1ACA7=4 ?97= 99=7?7::5A=1661?9;7>7:7B2=735=17;74407445>9 409;=5D9=1<77=245@5<4# 7=B97=5?31++ %%%A7>9<=1>B7AC65;9@54005306899;5?7=7607?; ?93:539?4>7??9=7?;;7609;41409675;B2::1ACA7=47?; A7269;4097AA5;9?4 2941@05A0409A:75>7?4626475?9; 3=59D1265?F2=596095?F2=59607D9=962:49;5?89=>7?9?4 87=457:;567B5:54E7?;67>90767<<9A49;056<242=997=?5?3 A787A54E 09 A:75>7?4 411C 4=974>9?4 5? 07?D7?407=5 0168547:7:7B2=73509A:75>7?4<5:9;409A:75>8945451? 09 =5B2?7: 076 7669669; 409 A1>89?67451? 7?; 87669; 4095>823?9;7@7=;14B95?367456<59;@5404097@7=; 7>12?4 409 7889::7?4A:75>7?4 076 <5:9; 409 8=969?4 78897: - 4 - + 97=; :97=?9; A12?69: <1= 409 7889::7?4 A:75>7?4 7?; :97=?9; A12?69: <1= =9681?;9?4 1% ?62=7?A91>87?E 97=?9; A12?69: <1= 409 7889::7?4A:75>7?4 @12:; A1?49?; 4074 409 7889::7?4A:75>7?4 @76 73=5A2:42=5647?;09626475?9;<=7A42=91<>9;57:>7::91:26 7?;<=7A42=91<:749=7:>7::91:267?;:1@9=607<41<<5B2:7 7?;09@767;>5449;5?0168547:<1=65J;7E609 1A41= @019J7>5?9;05>59&%56629;;567B5:54EA9=45<5A749' J* 076 64749; 4074 409 A:75>7?4 076 +K 89=>7?9?4 ;567B5:54E7?;A1?65;9=5?340967>9409=5B2?7:0769==9; 5?47C5?3;567B5:54E74K@05A0561?409:1@9=65;99 <2=409= 62B>546 4074 409 A1>89?67451? 7@7=;9; 41@7=;6 875? 7?; 62<<9=5?3- 7449?;7?4 A07=396- <242=9 >9;5A7: 9J89?696-:1661<5?A1>9;2=5?34=974>9?489=51;-:1661< 7>9?545967=91?:1@9=65;9@05A0?99;641B99?07?A9; 9?A9 699C6 <1= 9?07?A9>9?4 1< A1>89?67451? BE 7::1@5?340978897: - 5 - ( :97=?9; A12?69: <1= 409 =9681?;9?4 1%?62=7?A9 1>87?E @12:; A1?49?; 4074 409 A1>89?67451? 7@7=;9; BE 409 =5B2?7: 56 7;9L2749 A1?65;9=5?34097395?A1>97?;7D1A7451?1<409A:75>7?4 7?; 409=9 56 ?1 ?99; <1= 7?E 5?49=<9=9?A9 BE 4056 12=4 9?A98=7E6<1=;56>5667:1<78897: 7D5?3 097=; :97=?9; A12?69:6 4056 12=4 89=269; 409 5>823?9; F2;3>9?4 7?; 1409= >749=57:6 8:7A9;1?=9A1=; * 09 ;749 1< 409 7AA5;9?4 739 1< 409 A:75>7?4 7?;:57B5:54E1?409?62=7?A91>87?E7=9?145?;568249 ) 09 7AA5;9?4 076 47C9? 8:7A9 1? %(+%% 7?;761?409;7491<7AA5;9?4409;=5D9=1<4091<<9?;5?3 D905A:9@76?1401:;5?3D7:5;7?;9<<9A45D9;=5D5?3:5A9?A9 09=9<1=9 409 =5B2?7: 076 =5304:E 09:; 4074 =9681?;9?4 1%B95?34095?62=9=1<4091<<9?;5?3D905A:956:57B:941 87EA1>89?67451?7>12?47?;409=97<49=5407641=9A1D9= 40967>9<=1>4091@?9=1<409D905A:9 - 6 - M 09 7889::7?4A:75>7?4 @01 @76 73=5A2:42=564 076626475?9;<=7A42=91<>9;57:>7::91:267?;<=7A42=91< :749=7:>7::91:267?;:1@9=607<41<<5B2:709 1A41=@01 9J7>5?9; 05> 59 &% 076 56629; ;567B5:54E A9=45<5A749 J*64745?34074;567B5:54E41409@01:9B1;E5674+K 1?65;9=5?3 409 <=7A42=96 7D1A7451? 1< 409 A:75>7?4 409 ;567B5:54E 47C9? BE 409 =5B2?7: 74 K 56 ?14 8=189= 54 6012:; B9 47C9? 76 (K 24 409 =5B2?7: 076 =5304:E 47C9? 5?A1>9 1< 409 7889::7?4 7?; =5304:E 788:59; 409 >2:458:59= 09=9<1=9 409 :166 1< <242=9 97=?5?3 @12:; B9 A7:A2:749;762?;9= 6%(J%JJ(KN)*+ 09 7889::7?4 @76 7;>5449; 5? 0168547: <1= 65J ;7E6 1?65;9=5?3 409 <7A4 4074 409 7>12?4 7@7=;9; 41@7=;6875?7?;62<<9=5?35?762>1< 6%561? 409 :1@9= 65;9 @05A0 ?99;6 41 B9 9?07?A9; 41 )+- 7?; 7 62> 1< )+ 56 7@7=;9; 41@7=;6:1661<7>9?54596767375?64 6%7@7=;9; BE409=5B2?7: - 7 - 09 =5B2?7: 076 =5304:E 7@7=;9; 7 62> 1< ),+41@7=;6>9;5A7:9J89?696 % 09 A:75>7?4 @76 7;>5449; 5? 0168547: <1= 65J ;7E6 7?; 7;D569; <1= =964 1?65;9=5?3 409 67>9 09 56 9?454:9;<1=7449?;7?4A07=396<11;GA1?D9E7?A9A07=396 5? 7 62> 1< )+ 7375?64 6( 7@7=;9; BE 409=5B2?7: + 1?65;9=5?3 409 5?F2=596 626475?9; BE 409 A:75>7?47?;89=51;1<4=974>9?45?0168547:09569?454:9; <1= :166 1< 5?A1>9 ;2=5?3 :75; 28 89=51; <1= 7 89=51; 1< 40=99>1?4065?762>1<) -+! 6%(J+$ 767375?64 6(7@7=;9;BE409=5B2?7: ? 89=267: 1< 409 ;567B5:54E A9=45<5A749 &% 1A41= 076 ;98169; 4074 409 8945451?9= 56 5? ?99; 1< 1?9 >1=962=39=E<1==9>1D7:1<5>8:7?467?;9J89?696@5::B9 6 11C5?3 41 409 ?742=9 1< 5?F2=596 626475?9; BE 409 A:75>7?4 7?; 9D5;9?A9 1< &% 7 62> 1< - 8 - )+567@7=;9;41@7=;6<242=9>9;5A7:9J89?696 767375?64 6%7@7=;9;BE409=5B2?7: ( 026 409 A:75>7?4 56 9?454:9; <1= <1::1@5?3 7>12?41<A1>89?67451? . /01) 2345 06071/1895:/ 7;8340. 2345 06071/189 5:;)375 75?7?;62<<9=5?3 6% 6( % 449?;7?4A07=3967?; A1?D9E7?A9A07=396 6( 6 + 1661<<242=95?A1>9 6%+M 6+(M 9;5A7:9J89?696 6) 6) ( ,242=9>9;5A7: 9J89?696 6% 6+ 1661<5?A1>9;2=5?3 :75;2889=51; 6( 6%*( * 1661<7>9?54596 6% 6( 50. )- + ),+ 4:04</2/45 ) , + ?409=962:440978897:;969=D9641B97::1@9; 5?87=49?A9409<1::1@5?3 !5$ 0978897:567::1@9;5?87=4 !55$ 09 7889::7?4A:75>7?4 56 9?454:9; 41 4147: A1>89?67451? 1< ),+ 7375?64 - 9 - 6++* 76 7@7=;9; BE 409 =5B2?7: 7:1?3 @540 5?49=964 74 409=749 1<K 87 <=1>409;7491<8945451?45::546=97:5O7451? !555$ 09=9681?;9?41%?62=7?A9A1>87?E56 ;5=9A49; 41 ;981654 409 A1>89?67451? 7>12?4 @5405? 7 89=51; 1< 95304 @99C6 <=1> 4056 ;7E <75:5?3 @05A0 54 607:: 87E 5?49=96474409=7491<MK8745::87E>9?4 7?;409=97<49=41=9A1D9=4097>12?4<=1> 409 =9681?;9?41@?9= 1< 409 1<<9?;5?3 D905A:9 !5D$ 099?45=97>12?41<A1>89?67451?607::B9 =9:9769; 5? <7D12= 1< 409 7889::7?4 A:75>7?4 7<49= ;29 5;9?45<5A7451? D9=5<5A7451? 1+ & % %' $ %) -#