- 1 - ! "# $ ## # % &%'() *&% (( + ! ! "#$#%# ! &$' ! ' # # ! !! '%% %'( '# ! ' ! ! ) !" # # Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! * * +, -,././01,2 3,/14 56678,9 0 /8 3,:02, .+/8 072.8,,;/144251.0:35/<719,2,6./01&$'0:+525./=5 5452/; 725;8+5 51+/.5 ' :02 8+02. > ') 2/?, 0# # 0: 725< 0</6, .5./01 /952 /1 2</860'#' # -,19/14 01 .+, :/<, 0: .+, <,521,9 2/16/-5</8.2/6.519,88/018794,/9522,4/8.,2,9:02 .+, 0::,16, -71/8+53<, 719,2 ,6./018 '%% %'( 2 @ '# 0: ' 01 .+, 358/8 0: .+, :/28. /1:02?5./01 <094,93=.+,/1:02?51."5<=51250 ,529 2/ 5A,8+ 0995?51/ <,521,9 60718,< :02 .+,-,././01,25192/ 5?5952 +5+53799/1 <,521,9 /4+072.0B,21?,1.<,59,2:02.+,2,8-019,1.".5., ,278,9.+,?5.,2/5<8012,6029 - 3 - ' 1 B/,@ 0: .+, 2/B5< 601.,1./018 724,9 3= .+, <,521,960718,<:0230.+.+,-52./,8.+,-0/1..+5.@07<9 52/8,:02?=6018/9,25./01/8 & = 518@,2 .0 .+, 530B, -0/1. /8 /1 .+, >::/2?5./B,):02.+,:0<<0@/14 # +, /1:02?51. <094,9 .+, :/28. /1:02?5./01 545/18.56678,908%5195190.+,271;10@1-,28018 :02 +5B/14 60??/..,9 0::,16,8 58 8.5.,9 530B, . /8 .+, 601.,1./01 0: .+, 60?-<5/151. .+5. +, @58 @02;/14 /1 5 ,.20<7?-1,52=58-722088 1((#5.5307. %%' 5? .+2,, -,28018 65?, 01 5 ?0.026=6<, 519 58;,9+/?.0:/<<-,.20<+,2,@58515<.,265./013,.@,,1 .+, .@0 0: .+,? :.,2 :/<</14 .+, -,.20< .+, /1:02?51. 9,?519,9.+,3/<<5?071.0:8%# "519.+,-,28018 @+0 65?, 01 .+, ?0.026=6<, -/6;,9 7- C7522,< @/.+ +/? - 4 - 3= 8.5./14 .+5. .+,= 52, +5B/14 01<= 8# " = C7522,</14 @/.+ .+, /1:02?51. .+,= @,1. 5@5= 1 .+, 85?,95=5.'-?B,2=85?,-,280165?,356;01 .+,?0.026=6<, @/.+.@00.+,2 -,28018 519 58857<.,9 .+, /1:02?51. @/.+ +5198 519 ;/915--,9 +/? 01 .+, ?0.026=6<, 2033,9 8'%D( " 3= 8+0@/14 5 ;1/:, 519 <5.,2 +, @58 920--,91,52 .+,6/26<, +,2,5:.,2 +,:/<,9 .+,/1:02?5./012,C7,8./14.+,-0</6,.02,4/8.,2.+,658, 519.0/1/./5.,.+,<,45<56./01545/18..+,?+,!65?, .0 3, 2,4/8.,2,9 519 .+, -,././01,2 @58 5--2,+,19,9 972/14/1B,8./45./01@+0/85225=,95856678,9058-,2 .+,2,?5192,-02. E . /8 .+, 601.,1./01 0: .+, -208,67./01 .+5. 5 87?0:8DD "@582,60B,2,9:20?56678,908%519 A0/1.<=+,6+524,8+,,./810.=,.:/<,90@,B,2/./8 8,,1.+5.10.,8./9,1./:/65./01-5259,@58601976.,9,B,1 .+074+ .+, ! 65?, .0 3, 2,4/8.,2,9 545/18. 56678,9 08% 519 519 71;10@1-,28018. /8 8.5.,9 .+5. .+, -,././01,2 /8 10. +5B/14 51= 62/?/15< 51.,6,9,1.8 - 5 - +,2,:02,.+,9,.,1./010:.+,-,././01,2/1678.09=@07<9 5?071. .0 /1:2/14,?,1. 0: +/8 2/4+. .0 </:, 519 </3,2.= ,16,5?0:.+,0-/1/01.+5..+,-,././01,2/8,1./.<,9 .0 3, ,1<524,9 01 35/< 873A,6. .0 6019/./018 @+/6+ @/<< .5;, 652, 0: .+, 5--2,+,18/01 ,F-2,88,9 3= .+, <,521,9 /4+ 072. 0B,21?,1. <,59,2 .+5. .+, -,././01,2 ?5= 5386019 02 ?5= .5?-,2 02 .+2,5.,1 .+, -208,67./01 @/.1,88,8 ( 66029/14<= 518@,2 .+, 530B, -0/1. /1 .+, 5::/2?5./B,519-206,,9.0-588.+,:0<<0@/14 +,-,././01/8 +, -,././01,2 /8 029,2,9 .0 3, ,1<524,9 01 35/< /1 2/?, 0# # 0: 725< 0</6, .5./01 /952 01 03.5/1/14.+,3019/1587?0:8 "7-,,8@0 5;+8 01<= @/.+ .@0 872,./,8 :02 .+, </;,87? .0 .+, 85./8:56./01 0: .+, A72/89/6./015< 072. 873A,6. .0 .+, :0<<0@/146019/./018 - 6 - 5 +, -,././01,2 8+5<< 10. 60??/. 8/?/<52 0::,16,8 3 +, -,././01,2 8+5<< 10. .+2,5.,1 02 .5?-,2@/.+.+,-208,67./01@/.1,88,8 6 +, -,././01,2 8+5<< 5--,52 3,:02, .+, 072.58519@+,12,C7/2,9 9 : /1 658, .+, -,././01,2 B/0<5.,8 51= 0: .+, 6019/./018 58 8.5.,9 530B, .+, -208,67./01@/<<3,5.</3,2.=.0?0B,.+, 2/5<072.8,,;/146516,<<5./010:35/< 1 :721/8+/14 .+, 872,./,8 3= .+, -,././01,2.+,2/5<072./85.</3,2.=.09/2,6. .+, 1B,8./45./14 ::/6,2 .0 B,2/:= .+, 6022,6.1,88 0: .+, 5992,88 519 57.+,1./6/.= 0: .+, 9067?,1.8 :721/8+,9 3= .+, -,././01,2 519 .+, 872,./,8 519 5 2,-02. ?5= 3, 65<<,9 :02 /1 .+5. 2,4529 @+/6+ /8 .0 3, 873?/..,9 3= .+, 1B,8./45./14 ::/6,2 @/.+/1 # 95=8 +, 2/5< - 7 - 072. 01 85./8:56./01 ?5= -206,,9 .0 566,-. .+, 872,./,8 :02 .+, -72-08, 0: 2,<,58/14 .+, -,././01,20135/< ,) %##( $ /8.0%<0%D