- 1 - ! " #$% " &!%'"" &!%'"#'$!!# (") ! " # $%&&&# ' Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (')' $%&&&# $%&&&# ) !" & $%&&&* % !" + $%&&& ! " '' ''* + ##&#'&') , - '&'*'&' + '&'*'&' . + /- 0. 0. . - 3 - ! ! 0. " # 123 4526 7862629: 23 ;2<8= >? 618 7862629:85 @1A<<8:B2:B 618 95=85 =A68= ##&#'&') 7A338= >? 618 A5:A6ACA6A68 =D2:2365A62E852>F:A<A<A>F5AB2!;95 31956 /618 52>F:A<-" 2: 77<2@A629: 9'&'*'&' A6 ::8GF58 41858>? 618 A77<2@A629: ;2<8= >? 618 A77<2@A:6!7862629:8518582:"1A3>88:7A56<?A<<948=A:= 618 75A?85 388C2:B ;95 HFA312:B 618 :962;2@A629: =A68= ''&''&'A6 ::8GF58 *1A3>88:58I8@68= ' 528; ;A@63 9; 618 @A38 18 7862629:85A77<2@A:6 23 495C2:B A3 A 9<2@8 :378@695 2: A5:A6ACA 6A68 :=F3652A< 8@F526? 95@8 !;95 31956 /-" @@95=2:B 69 618 7862629:85 61858 A58 ') 79363 58385E8= 2: 618 6A68 9; A5:A6ACA 2: 618 @A=58 9; 33236A:6 9DDA:=A:6 3785 562@<8*#.9;6189:3626F629:9; :=2A A:= A3 785 618 :962;2@A629: =A68= 'J&#'&#) ! ::8GF58 #"K9;618793631AE869>858385E8=;95 - 4 - 6A688E8<9@A<A=58A:=*%K9;618793631AE869>8 58385E8=;958B29:A<9@A<A=58 @@95=2:B<?9F69;') 793639:879361A369>858385E8=;956A688E8<9@A< A=58 A:= ) 79363 1AE8 69 >8 58385E8= ;95 8B29:A< 9@A< A=58 F56185 @A38 9;6187862629:852361A6 F<8 !'" 9; 618 A5:A6ACA F><2@ D7<9?D8:6 !8385EA629: A:= 7792:6D8:6 ;95 ?=85A>A=A5:A6ACA 8B29:" ! 5BA:2LA629:9;9@A<A=58 <<96D8:6A:=5A:3;859; 8539:3" F<83 '&# !;95 31956 /618 F<83 '&#-" 759E2=83;95D85B2:B9;6A688E8<9@A<A=584261618 8B29:A< 9@A< A=58 69 @9:3626F68 A 32:B<8 6A68 2=8 9@A<A=588:@86189:87936F:=856186A688E8< 9@A< A=58 1A3 69 >8 D85B8= 4261 618 ) 79363 F:=85 8B29:A<9@A<@A=58A:=A@@95=2:B<?9F69;')79363% 793631AE869>858385E8=;956189@A<A=58F6A3 785 618 962;2@A629: =A68= ''&''&' A6 ::8GF58 * 9:<? ) 79363 1AE8 >88: 58385E8= 82:B ABB528E8= >? 618 3AD8 618 7862629:85 A7759A@18= 618 52>F:A< >? ;2<2:B 77<2@A629: 9'&'*'&'1852>F:A<>?95=85 - 5 - =A68= ##&#'&') 1A3 7A56<? A<<948= 618 A77<2@A629: A:= 58I8@68= 618 75A?85 9; 618 7862629:85A77<2@A:6 388C2:B ;95 HFA312:B 618 :962;2@A629: =A68= ''&''&' A6 ::8GF58 * 82:B ABB528E8= >? 618 3A2= 95=85 9; 61852>F:A<6187862629:8523>8;9586123@9F56 8A5:8= @9F:38< A778A52:B ;95 618 7862629:85 1A3 3F>D2668=61A62:61838:29526?<2367587A58=;956187936 9;:378@6956187862629:85238<2B2><869>8759D968=;95 618 :8G6 @A=58 28 69 618 7936 9; 33236A:6 9DDA:=A:6;%793639; 33236A:69DDA:=A:61AE8 >88: 58385E8= ;95 ?=85A>A=A5:A6ACA 8B29: 618 7862629:8549F<= >8 8<2B2><8 ;95 759D9629: 2619F6 A:? 58A39: 9:8 7936 1A3 >88: 58=F@8= >? 412@1 618 759D9629: 9; 618 7862629:85 69 618 7936 9; 33236A:6 9DDA:=A:6 1A3 >88: A;;8@68= 1858;958 18 39FB16 ;95A<<942:B61845267862629: ) 8A5:8= A778A52:B ;95 618 58379:=8:636A68 1A3 @9:68:68= 61A6 9F6 9; ') 79363 9; 33236A:6 - 6 - 9DDA:=A:6 2: 79363 A58 58385E8= ;95 6A68 8E8< A=58 A:= # 79363 A58 58385E8= ;95 ?=85A>A= A5:A6ACA8B29:A=58F561859F69;793639;6A68 8E8<A=589:879362358385E8=;956A688E8<9@A< A=58M A:= 9F6 9; # 79363 9; ?=85A>A=A5:A6ACA 8B29: A=58 ) 79363 A58 58385E8= ;95 8B29:A< 9@A< A=58 <<)793636961879369; 33236A:69DDA:=A:6 1AE8>88:;2<<8=F76159FB1759D9629:;59D618@A=589; :378@695 1858 23 :9 7936 AEA2<A><8 ;95 B2E2:B 759D9629: 69 618 7862629:85 8:@8 18 39FB16 ;95 =23D233A<9;61845267862629: % 8A5= 618 <8A5:8= @9F:38< ;95 618 7862629:85 A:= <8A5:8= ;9561858379:=8:63 6 23 :96 2: =237F68 61A6 69 618 @A=58 9; 33236A:6 9DDA:=A:6 2: ') 79363 1AE8 >88: 58385E8= F:=856A68<8E8< F69;')7936379363A5858385E8= ;95 6A68 8E8< A=58 A:= # 79363 A58 58385E8= ;95 ?=85A>A=A5:A6ACA 8B29: A=58 : E284 9; 618 - 7 - F<83 '&# 233F8= F:=85 562@<8 *#. 9; 618 9:3626F629:K9;618793631AE869>858385E8=F:=85 6186A688E8<9@A<A=58A:=*%K9;618793631AE8 69>858385E8=F:=858B29:A<9@A<A=58 * 95 >86685 F:=8536A:=2:B F<8 !'" 9; 618 A5:A6ACA F><2@ D7<9?D8:6 !8385EA629: A:= 7792:6D8:6 ;95 ?=85A>A=A5:A6ACA 8B29:" ! 5BA:2LA629:9;9@A<A=58 <<96D8:6A:=5A:3;859; 8539:3"F<83'&#238G65A@68=18582:>8<94 ! ! " # ! "$ ! % " % ! & $ " " '( )* % ) % % + , + - . - 8 - *% + % ! / 01 !)2 ) % ! 3 451 + , - 061 + 051 + . % * + % ! $ % # . " $7" " # % " )* " ) ! *% 2 "# * " * + % ! 8 F<8 !'"!@" 9; 618 F<83 '&# 759E2=83 ;95 D85B85 9; 6A68 8E8< 9@A< A=58 A:= 618 8B29:A< 9@A<A=58 J F53FA:66961A6:962;2@A629:=A68=&##'&#1A3 >88:233F8=418582:)793637<F3#7936696A<<?%79363 1AE8 >88: 58385E8= ;95 8B29:A< 9@A< A=58 F6 >? - 9 - 2D7FB:8= :962;2@A629: =A68= ''&''&' A6 ::8GF58 * 9:<? ) 79363 9; 33236A:6 9DDA:=A:6 2: 1AE8>88:58385E8=18:962;2@A629:A6 ::8GF58 *23 233F8= @9:65A5? 69 618 F<83 '&# 1858;958 618 :962;2@A629:A6 ::8GF58 *2358HF258=69>8HFA318= #& @@95=2:B<?618;9<<942:B95=85237A338= A" 5267862629:23*++,-. >" 18 95=85 =A68= ##&#'&') 7A338= >? 618 A5:A6ACA 6A68 =D2:2365A62E8 52>F:A< A<A>F5AB2 2: 77<2@A629: 9'&'*'&' A6 ::8GF5823386A32=8 @" 962;2@A629: =A68= ''&''&' A6 ::8GF58 *231858>?HFA318= =" 18 58379:=8:63 A58 =258@68= 69 58@9:32=85 618 2=8:62;2@A629: 9; 618 79363 69 618 @A=58 9; 33236A:6 9DDA:=A:6 2: 2: 685D3 9; 618 25@F<A5 =A68= '#&'&# 42612: 618 78529= 9; - 10 - D9:613 ;59D 618 =A68 9; 58@8276 9; @97? 9; 6123 95=851858379:=8:6331A<<:962;?6183AD8A;685 @A<<2:B;953FBB83629:959>I8@629:;59D618A;;8@68= 7A56283 8" 1858A;68558379:=8:63A58A6<2>856?696AC8 3F>38HF8:6 A@629: ;95 B2E2:B 759D9629: 69 618 8<2B2><8@A:=2=A6832:?=85A>A=A5:A6ACA58B29: "./ (") ' "./ (#'$!!#) ' 236 9#< 9*