- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $%&$' ()*$(( + ! " # $ % &' " # $ % (#$ % ) (' '' ) % Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ' % % ) *) #! # *)$ +, -..,//-012 3,405 -6672,8 92 -08 40 ,224902 -2, 9(' '' 90 1+, :4/, 9: 1+, /,-;0,8 8841490-/ 421;461 -08 ,224902 )785, -/-37;-54 #:9; 2+9;1 <;4-/ 97;1=$ -;, 4>.750405 1+, ?785>,01 9: 690@4614908-1,8'('-089;8,;9:2,01,06,8-1,8 ''(' 690@461405 1+,> :9; 1+, 9::,06, .7042+-3/, 708,; ,61490 (A -08 ;,-8 B41+ ,61490 ( 9: 084-0 ,0-/ 98, C' #:9; 2+9;1 <=$ -08 2,01,06405 -6672,892-0819708,;5924>./,4>.;4290>,01:9; C >901+2 :9; 1+, 9::,06, .7042+-3/, 708,; ,61490 (A ;,-8 B41+ ,61490 ( 9: D 2,01,06405 -6672,8 9 19 .-E :40, 9: 2''' & :9; 1+, 9::,06, .7042+-3/, 708,; ,614909:B41+8,:-7/12,01,06,2 - 3 - %-6129:1+,6-2,403;4,:-;,1+-11+,40:9;>-01 /985,81+,:4;2140:9;>-1490B41+->-/-.7;.9/46,21-1490 -/-37;-54 -5-4021 -6672,8 92 19 90 '' -//,5405 1+-1 2+, >-;;4,8 -6672,8 9 90 ''' -08 21-;1,8 ;,248405 40 1+, >-1;4>904-/ +972, -/905 B41+ -6672,892196672,893,4051+,:-1+,;&40&/-B -08 -6672,8 9 3,405 1+, >91+,;&40&/-B 9: 1+, 40:9;>-01-;,-/2921-E405B41+1+,>+,-6672,872,8 194//&1;,-1+,;,@,01+975+2+,B-2B9;F405-2-1,-6+,; +, B-2 -2F,8 19 +-089@,; 1+, 2-/-;E 19 -6672,8 9 -08 19 89 -// 1+, +972,+9/8 B9;F2 +, 40:9;>-01 +-8 3,5911,0 +,; :4;21 6+4/8 87;405 ' -08 2,6908 6+4/8 87;405'7;4051+42.,;498-6672,872,8191;,-1+,; B41+ 6;7,/1E +,E +-@, -/29 -372,8 -22-7/1,8 -08 6;4>40-//E 4014>48-1,8 +,; 406, 2+, 697/8 091 19/,;-1, 1+,4//&1;,-1>,0154@,03E1+,-6672,82+,;,17;0,819+,; .-;,01-/ +972, -:1,; +,; 2,6908 8,/4@,;E 71 1+,;, B-2 -09;8,;:9;;,2141714909:690?75-/;45+12-08+,06,2+, ;,17;0,8 19 1+, >-1;4>904-/ +972, 90 'A' -08 40 - 4 - 2.41, 9: 1+-1 1+, -6672,8 +-@, 1;,-1,8 +,; B41+ 6;7,/1E ,06,2+,21-;1,8;,2484052,.-;-1,/E40-.9;14909:1+, >-1;4>904-/ +972, +, 40:9;>-01 21-1,8 1+-1 90 '' -1 C'' -> B+,0 2+, B-2 89405 +,; 8-4/E B9;F 1+, -6672,8 +-@, .46F,8 7. G7-;;,/ B41+ +,; -08 -6672,89-372,8+,;40:4/1+E/-057-5,-082>-2+,8 +,;:-6,-5-40211+,B-// ,1;4,81921;-057/-1,+,;0,6F B41+-0401,01490196-72,8,-1++,B-2-/296;4>40-//E 4014>48-1,8 091 19 :4/, -0E 69>./-401 406, 1+, -6672,8 +-@, 1;4,8 19 21;-057/-1, +,; 0,6F B41+ -0 401,01490 19 6-72, +,; 8,-1+ 2+, +-2 2721-40,8 40?7;4,2 90 +,; 0,6F -082+,B,01191+,+92.41-/90''-08:4/,81+, 69>./-401 90 '' ,8469 ,5-/ -2, 6->, 19 3,;,5421,;,8 01+,3-2429:1+,2->,40@,2145-1490B-2 708,;1-F,0 -08 6+-;5, 2+,,1 6->, 19 3, :4/,8 -5-4021 -6672,8 92 19 :9; 1+, 9::,06,2 .7042+-3/, 708,; ,614902 ( ( (A ' '( 'C ;,-8 B41+,61490(9: - 5 - +, ;4-/ 97;1 199F 69504H-06, :9; 1+, -39@, 2-48 9::,06,2 -08 27>>90,8 1+, -6672,8 +, -6672,8 +-@, -..,-;,8 3,:9;, 1+, ;4-/ 97;1 ./,-8,8 091 574/1E -086/-4>,8193,1;4,8 9 .;9@, 1+, 574/1 9: 1+, -6672,8 1+, .;92,671490 ,I->40,8 19 ( 591 >-;F,8I219-0848,014:4,8 4027..9;19:412 6901,01490+,-6672,8+-@,8,04,8-//1+,406;4>40-1405 >-1,;4-/2 -@-4/-3/, 90 ;,69;8 +, -6672,8 +-@, 091 /,8 -0E ,@48,06, 371 591 >-;F,8 I2 -08 87;405 1+, 6;922&,I->40-14909:1+,.;92,671490B410,22,2 ( +, ;4-/ 97;1 -:1,; 1-F405 4019 690248,;-1490 -// 1+,2, >-1,;4-/2 90 ;,69;8 .-22,8 1+, 4>.750,8 ?785>,019:690@461490690@4614051+,-..,//-012-221-1,8 -39@,,405-55;4,@,83E1+,2->,-6672,892-08 -;,3,:9;,1+4297;1 ,-;8 ;4 @40-2+ ./9-0F-; /,-;0,8 69702,/:9;1+,-..,//-012-08;49.-/F;42+0--8-@ /,-;0,8 45+97;19@,;0>,01/,-8,;:9;1+,;,2.908,01 - 6 - J 1-1, ,;72,8 1+, >-1,;4-/2 406/78405 1+, ;4-/ 97;1 ;,69;82 C 0 @4,B 9: 1+, ;4@-/ 6901,014902 7;5,8 3E /,-;0,869702,/:9;391+1+,.-;14,21+,.94011+-1B97/8 -;42,:9;>E690248,;-149042 E-02B,;191+,-39@,.940142401+, :9;1+,:9//9B405 1 42 1+, 6901,01490 9: 1+, 40:9;>-01 1+-1 2+, >-;;4,8 -6672,8 9 90 ''' -08 1+,;, B-2 >-1;4>904-/ 842.71, 3,1B,,0 1+, +723-08 -08 B4:, -08 -/29 -6672,8 92 -08 B+9 -;, +,; 40&/-B2 +, 40:9;>-01 +-8 3,5911,0 1B9 6+4/8;,0 40 1+, B,8/96F -08 2+, 21-;1,8 ;,248405 2,.-;-1,/E -2 2+, B-2 B9;F405 -2 - - 7 - 1,-6+,; 1 B-2 3;975+1 19 1+, 09146, 9: 1+, 97;1 1+-1 -6672,89+-8:4/,89 ' 3,:9;,1+,%->4/E 97;1 -1 -/-37;-54 2,,F405 ;,214171490 9: 690?75-/ ;45+12 -08 1+, 2-48 .,141490 6->, 19 3, -//9B,8 .-22405 1+, 8,6;,, :9; ;,214171490 90 ' ' 7;27-01 19 1+, 2->,1+,40:9;>-01;,17;0,819+,;>-1;4>904-/+972,90 'A' // 1+,2, :-612 -;, -8>411,8 1 42 1+, 6901,01490 9: 1+, -..,//-012 1+-1 -6672,8 9 +-8 :4/,8 9 '' 3,:9;, 1+, %->4/E 97;1 -1 -/-37;-54 2,,F40584@9;6,+,2->,B-2842>422,890'' 84;,614051+,.-;14,219B-41:9;1+;,,E,-;2:9;;,70490-08 4:091:4/,.,141490:9;84@9;6,901+,5;97089:8,2,;1490 1421+,6901,014909:1+,.;92,6714901+-11+, 40:9;>-01 +-8 ;,17;0,8 19 1+, >-1;4>904-/ +972, 90 'A' -08 2+, B-2 1;,-1,8 B41+ 6;7,/1E 3E -// 1+, -6672,8 -08 90 '' -6672,8 9 .46F,8 7. G7-;;,/B41++,;-081;4,81921;-057/-1,+,;0,6FB41+-0 401,01490196-72,+,;8,-1++,:4;2140:9;>-14906->, 19 3, /985,8 90 '' I 42 1+, B9708 - 8 - 6,;14:46-1, 4227,8 3E 1+, 421;461 92.41-/ -/-37;-54 -669;8405 19 B+46+ 1+, 40?7;,8 B-2 -8>411,8 19 1+, +92.41-/ 90 '' -08 B-2 8426+-;5,8 90 ' +, 6->, 19 1+, +92.41-/ -669>.-04,8 3E +,; :-1+,; B41+ 1+, +4219;E 9: -22-7/1 90 '' -1 ('.> +,;, B-2 .-40 -081,08,;0,22 9@,;1+,/,:1 248,9:1+,0,6F-081+,40?7;EB-224>./,400-17;, A 1 42 .,;140,01 19 091, 1+-1 I 42 1+, 6,;14:46-1, 591 >-;F,8 1+, 1+;975+ 1+, .;92,671490 B410,22 +42 6,;14:46-1, B-2 4227,8 3E 1+, 421;461 92.41-/ -/-37;-54 90 '' 669;8405 19 B+46+ 1+, 40:9;>-01 +-8 69>, 19 1+, +92.41-/ 90 '' B41+ 1+, +4219;E 1+-1 +,; +723-08 +-8 .;,22,8 +,; 0,6F 90 1+, 2->, 8-E 2 .,; I -08 I 1+, 40648,01 +-8 9667;;,8 90 '' 371 -669;8405 19 1+, 40:9;>-011+,2-4840648,01+-89667;;,890'' 0I1+,40:9;>-0121-1,21+-12+,+-2091:4/,8-0E 69>./-401 -1 1+, :4;21 4021-06, 371 90 '' 2+, ,I.,;4,06,8 2,@,;, .-40 40 +,; 0,6F -08 1+,;,:9;, 2+, - 9 - B,01191+,421;461 92.41-/-08401+,>,-014>,1+,;, B-2 8,/-E 40 /985405 1+, :4;21 40:9;>-1490 40 +,; ,@48,06,21-1,81+-190''2+,+-8590,191+, .9/46,21-1490:9;1+,.7;.92,9:/9854051+,69>./-401371 1+, .9/46, +-@, 2755,21,8 +,; 19 59 19 1+, 9@,;0>,01 92.41-/ 669;8405/E 2+, B,01 19 1+, +92.41-/ -08 591 -8>411,8 ' 142.,;140,0119091,1+-11+,.;92,671490+-2 48,014:4,8 1+, 2/,,.,; 19 2755,21 1+-1 -6672,89 +-2-22-7/1,81+,40:9;>-01B41+1+,2->,B+46+42-/29 G741,6901;-;E191+,+4219;E54@,040I1+-1-6672,8 9+-21;4,819.;,22+,;0,6F711+,;,4209;,:,;,06, 9: -22-7/1 B41+ %;9> -// 1+,2, :-612 -08 64;67>21-06,2 41 42 6/,-; 1+-1 B-2 B-01,8 19 ,I-55,;-1, 1+, 40648,01 1+-1 >45+1 +-@, 9667;;,8 90 ''-081+-142B+E2+,+-2;9.,840391+-6672,8 92-083,405+,;40&/-B2142.,;140,0119091,1+-1 1+,40:9;>-0142091-;72146@4//-5,;8>411,8/E2+,B-2 B9;F405-21,-6+,;40-26+99/+,;,-;,406902421,064,2 - 10 - 40 +,; 21-1,>,01 40 1+, :4;21 40:9;>-1490 -08 40 1+, ,@48,06,/,83,:9;,1+,97;1I -08I3,4051+, >,846-/;,69;82-;,-/29406902421,01B41+90,-091+,; 0690248,;-14909: >-1,;4-/2 90 ;,69;8 -> 9: 1+, 9.40490 1+-1 1+, 40:9;>-01 B-01,8 19 40@9F,,61490' 9:-5-40211+,-6672,8-081+-142 B+E 2+, B-2 -8>411,8 19 9@,;0>,01 92.41-/ 90 '' -08 591 8426+-;5,8 90 ' ,@,0 1+975+ 1+,;, B,;, 09 ,I1,;0-/ 40?7;4,2 ,I6,.1 .-40 -08 1,08,;0,229@,;1+,/,:1248,9:1+,0,6F-2.,;I2+, +-809127::,;,8-0E40?7;4,2142-/29.,;140,0119091, 1+-1 I B,;,1+, .+9195;-.+29: 1+, 40:9;>-01B+46+ B,;, 2-48 19 +-@, 3,,0 1-F,0 90 '' 1 42 -/29 09146,81+-14>>,84-1,/E-:1,;1+,296-//,840648,018-1,8 ''1+,40:9;>-01+-81-F,0.+9195;-.+2-2.,; I2-08 .,0&8;4@,-2 .,; IA42 .;9876,8 71 +-2 0911-F,06-;,19@42411+,+92.41-/-08195,11;,-1>,01 %;9>-//1+,2,>-1,;4-/290;,69;82,;497289731-;42,240 1+,>4089:1+,97;1-39711+,40648,011+-1+-89667;;,8 - 11 - 90''+,3,0,:419:276+89731B4//+-@,193, ,I1,08,8191+,-6672,8 ,06,->9:1+,9.404901+-1 1+,-..,//-012-;,,0141/,8:9;-6G7411-/ +-@,590,1+;975+1+,4>.750,8?785>,019: 690@461490-089;8,;9:2,01,06,.-22,83E1+,;4-/97;1 +, ;4-/ 97;1 +-2 .;96,,8,8 19 690@461 1+, -..,//-012 B41+971091464052,;4972406902421,064,2401+,6-2,9:1+, .;92,671490+,;,:9;,->9:1+,9.404901+-11+,2-48 ?785>,01 9: 690@461490 -08 9;8,; 9: 2,01,06, 42 /4-3/, 19 3,2,1-248,669;8405/E-02B,;1+,-39@,.9401401+, -08.;96,,819.-221+,:9//9B405 #4$ +,;4>40-/..,-/42 #44$ +, 4>.750,8 ?785>,01 9: 690@461490 8-1,8 '(' -08 9;8,; 9: ,01,06, 8-1,8 ''(' .-22,8 40 ,22490 -2, 9(' '' 90 1+, :4/, 9: /,-;0,8 8841490-/ 421;461 -08 ,224902 )785, -/-37;-54-;,+,;,3E2,1-248, - 12 - #444$ 902,G7,01/E -..,//-012 -6672,8 92 -08 -;, -6G7411,8 9: 1+, 9::,06,2 .7042+-3/,708,;,614902(A;,-8B41+ ,61490(9: #4@$ -4/ 3908 9: -6672,8 92 -08 -..,//-012 4: -0E -08 1+-1 9: 1+,4; 27;,14,2 2+-//21-086-06,//,8 #@$ %40, ->9701 4: -0E 8,.9241,8 3E -6672,8 92 -08 -..,//-012 42 9;8,;,8 19 3,;,:708,8191+,>-:1,;-..,-/.,;498429@,; ,5421;E 19 2,083-6F 1+, ;4-/97;1 ,69;82 -/905 B41+69.E9:1+42?785>,01:9;40:9;>-1490-08:9;0,,8:7/ -61490 ,) $!!( # 4219/9 1.F