- 1 - ! "#! "# #$ !! %$& ' !"!# $ % & ' ( !# )) ## !"# *# & & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ## !+ &## !"!# $ % # + *, !( & + + !%!( + & & & "#"#*"*! #!"!*"! & + + & + & #' & & + #*""""""- & + & & +# & + + & & & . #&## & . ## - 3 - # %& . #&##( !# /01 233425 67849 4:;0<7 !%!( <= <;<9 4/0:541 :; !> %/494072=;49 94=49948 ;< 21 ?;/4 :;@( /21 A447 =0548 AB ;/4 :520C27; :/25547D07D ;/4 E68DC47; 82;48 "#"#*"*! 321148 AB <#' 0E2B23692 07 <#!"!*"!# *# +2:;1 D0F07D 9014 ;< ;/4 =0507D <= ;/4 233425 A904=5B 1;2;48 294 ;/2; <7 ")#!*#*"! G/47 ;/4 :520C27; G21 39<:44807D <7 C<;<9:B:54 A42907D 94D01;92;0<7 <# -*- -) 21230550<790849<70E2B23692- <5/29<287429 282C2;;0:9<112;;/2;;0C40H2782990849<=;/41208 C<;<9:B:549<84;/412C4 2; 2 /0D/ 13448 278 07 2921/ 278 74D50D47; C27749 A407D 672A54 ;< :<7;9<5 ;69;548 8<G7 07 2 80;:/ 278 :26148 2::0847;# 1 2 94165; <= ;/4 2=<941208 2::0847; ;/4 :520C27; 161;20748 D904F<61 07E69041278G21/<130;250I48# - 4 - # /4:520C27;=0548234;0;0<7678494:;0<7! <=;/4 :;144H07D:<C34712;0<7#;G213542848;/2;1/41347; 10D70=0:27;2C<67;;<G2981C480:254J347141:<7F4B27:4 :/29D41 278 <;/49 9452;48 :<1;1# ; G21 =69;/49 3542848 ;/2; ;/4 2::0847; <::69948 1<545B <7 2::<67; <= 921/ 278 74D50D47;890F07D<=;/4<==47807DF4/0:54AB0;1890F49# )# 3<7 149F0:4 <= 7<;0:4 ;/4 9413<7847; <#* 23342948 ;/9<6D/ :<67145 278 =0548 G90;;47 1;2;4C47; 847B07D ;/4 2F49C47;1 C284 07 ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7# /4 9413<7847;<#!84130;4149F0:4<=7<;0:48087<;233429 A4=<94;/490A6725278G21352:484J-329;4# # 7 ;/4 A2101 <= ;/4 3542807D1 <= ;/4 329;041 ;/4 520C190A6725=92C48;/4011641278;/4942=;4994:<9848 ;/4 4F0847:4# /4 90A6725 AB 0C36D748 E68DC47; 278 2G298 /21 801C01148 ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7# 407D 2DD904F48 ;/4394147;233425/21A447=0548# - 5 - # 429748:<67145=<9;/4:520C27;/21:<7;47848;/2; ;/42::0847;<::69948864;<;/474D50D47:4<=;/490849<= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54 A42907D 94D01;92;0<7 <# -*--) # CC4802;45B 2=;49 ;/2; 2::0847; ;/4 :520C27; /21 A447 28C0;;48 ;< 21/<8/292 &<130;25 0E2B23692# 1 349 ;/4 C480:2594:<9810;01:54295BC47;0<748;/2;;/4:520C27; 16==4948 07E69041 07 2 9<28 ;92==0: 2::0847; :214 864 ;< 74D50D47:4 <= ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54 278 1H08<= ;/4 C<;<9:B:5421294165;<=G/0:/;/4:520C27;/2116==4948 07E69041#F47;/43<50:42=;49;/<9<6D/07F41;0D2;0<7/2F4 =0548:/29D41/44;2D2071;;/490849<=;/4C<;<9:B:54# 75B A4:2614 ;/494 01 8452B 07 5<8D07D ;/4 :<C35207; ;/4 90A6725 /21 94E4:;48 ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7# &4 =69;/49 :<7;47;48 ;/2; ;/4 :520C27; G21 28C0;;48 07 ;/4 /<130;25 278 /49 /61A278G21;2H07D :294<= /49# /494=<94;/4B G4947<;2A54;<D0F4:<C35207;0CC4802;45B#=;49)82B1 =9<C ;/4 82;4 <= 2::0847; /49 /61A278 5<8D48 2 :<C35207;#/490A6725G0;/<6;:<71084907D;/012134:;<= - 6 - ;/4 C2;;49 /21 49948 07 801C01107D ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7# &47:4/41<6D/;=<9255<G07D;/4233425# # 429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 716927:4 <C327B /21 :<7;47;48;/2;;/494018452B075<8D07D;/4:<C35207;#7 ;/4:<C35207;;/4B/2F4134:0=0:255B1;2;48;/2;;/490849 <= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54 G21 90807D ;/4 12C4 07 2 921/ 278 74D50D47;C27749278C<;<9:B:54;69748;69;54#7;/4 943<9;;/494017<82C2D4;<;/4C<;<9:B:54278;/490849 /21 7<; 16==4948 27B 07E69041# /494=<94 0; 01 F49B :5429 ;/2;;<C2H42=2514:520C;/4:520C27;/210C350:2;48;/4 C<;<9:B:54#/490A6725/2190D/;5B801C01148;/4:520C 34;0;0<7#&47:4/41<6D/;=<9801C01125<=;/4233425# # &4298 ;/4 5429748 :<67145 =<9 ;/4 329;041 278 3496148;/494:<981# ># /4:214<=;/4:520C27;101;/2;<7")#!*#*"!G/47 ;/4 :520C27; G21 39<:44807D <7 C<;<9:B:54 A42907D 94D01;92;0<7 <# -*--) 21 2 30550<7 90849 <7 0E2B23692- <5/29 <28 7429 282C2;;0 :9<11 2; ;/2; - 7 - ;0C40H2784990849<=;/41208C<;<9:B:549<84;/412C4 2; 2 /0D/ 13448 278 07 2 921/ 278 74D50D47; C27749 672A54 ;< :<7;9<5 ;69;54 8<G7 07 2 80;:/ 278 :26148 2::0847;#64;<1208 0C32:;:520C27;161;2074807E69041# CC4802;45B 2=;49 ;/2; 2::0847; 1/4 /21 A447 1/0=;48 ;< 21/<8/292&<130;250E2B23692# !"# 7;/4C480:2594:<98139<86:48A4=<94;/4:<69;0; 01 C47;0<748 ;/2; 0; 01 2 :214 278 2::0847; /21 <::69948 864 ;< ;/4 74D50D47:4 <= ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54# /4 134:0=0: :214 <= ;/4 :520C27; 01 ;/2; 1/4 /2116==49481490<6107E6904107;/412082::0847;2781/4 G211/0=;48;</<130;2527828C0;;48<7;/412C482B278 801:/29D48<7!#!*#*"!#/494=<941/4:<6587<;5<8D4 ;/4 :<C35207; 0CC4802;45B# < 39<F4 ;/4 :214 ;/4 :520C27;/214J2C0748/49145=21!#/4+/21A447 5<8D48 2D2071; ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54# <50:4 /2F4 =0548 :/294 1/44; 2D2071; ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54# 7 ;/4 G<678 :49;0=0:2;4 0; 01 C47;0<748 21 ?/01;<9B <= =255 =9<C;G<G/44549A0H4278908498087<;=255/42807E69B@# - 8 - /4 90A6725 G0;/<6; :<71084907D 255 ;/414 2134:;1 <75B <7 ;/4 D9<678 ;/2; ;/494 01 2 8452B 07 5<8D07D ;/4 :<C35207; /21 801C01148 ;/4 :520C 34;0;0<7# < 80139<F4 ;/4 :214 <= ;/4 :520C27; ;/4 9413<7847;-716927:4 <C327B /21 7<; 4J2C0748 27B G0;741141 740;/49 ;/4 7F41;0D2;0<7 ==0:49 /21 A447 4J2C0748 7<9 ;/4 90849 <= ;/4 C<;<9:B:54 /21 A447 4J2C0748 278 ;/4B /2F4 7<; 450:0;48 27B G<9;/G/054 07=<9C2;0<7 =9<C ;/4 4F0847:4 <= !07;/4:9<114J2C072;0<7# !!# 7849 ;/414 :09:6C1;27:41 G4 294 <= ;/4 <3070<7 ;/2;07<9849;<D0F4<74C<94<33<9;670;B;<;/4329;041 ;/4C2;;4994K60941;<A494C0;;48A2:H;<;/490A6725=<9 =941/:<7108492;0<7# !*# 7;/494165;=<55<G07D<984901321148 2( 3342501255<G48# A( /4 E68DC47; 278 2G298 321148 AB ;/4 90A67250114;21084# - 9 - :( 2;;490194C0;;48A2:H;<;/490A6725=<9=941/ :<7108492;0<7 94149F07D 50A49;B ;< ;/4 329;041 ;< 2886:4 2880;0<725 4F0847:4 278 39<86:4 2880;0<725 8<:6C47;1# 8( 90A6725 2=;49 /42907D ;/4 329;041 1/255 3211 2339<3902;4 <98491 07 2::<9827:4 G0;/ 52G G0;/<6; A407D 07=5647:48 AB 27B <A149F2;0<7 C284 AB ;/01 <69;07;/01<9849# 4( 4D01;9B 01 8094:;48 ;< 94;697 ;/4 <90D0725 94:<981;<;/490A6725# () %!& # () % #$ & # 01;<#!5<#)>