- 1 - !! !"# $ % !&& '( ) ! " #$ % ! & $ ' ( )*$ ) (!+,-' " #$! . ! '% Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *#% $ + ! +$ ! /()/ $ ! + ) ) 0 ! %! #) 0 ! % 1234556472389:1686;6<2=24>263862;?4??>26@6A89 :16BCA?D6;:4;AE>A6>A4:6A/54336A2; E/( E; :16 <276 E< :16 AA2:2E;47 23:>2=: 4;A 6332E;3!CA?6 4748C>4?2F16>62;4<:6>>6<6>>6A:E43:16 G556774:6 EC>:H <E> 8>6@2:9I 89 J12=1 :16 556774:6 EC>: J1276 54>:79 477EJ2;? :16 455647 143 DEA2<26A :16 BCA?D6;: 4;A 4J4>A A4:6A */ 54336A 2; E(' E; :16 <276 E< 6;2E> 2@27 !CA?6 74;A F16>62;4<:6> >6<6>>6A :E 43 :16 G6<6>6;=6 EC>:H <E> 8>6@2:9I6;14;=2;?:16=ED56;34:2E;4DEC;:2;>6356=:E< :16 4=KC2>6A A>9 74;A <>ED 3 L ( 56> 4=>6 :E 3* ' '/(56>4=>6 - 3 - C8B6=:D4::6>E<:164=KC232:2E;23:1674;A2; 9 E'L((* D643C>2;? ?C;:43 32:C4:6A 4: !4J472 @2774?6 E< 74;A :47CM 4748C>4?2 A23:>2=: J12=1 J43 4=KC2>6A <E> :16 5C>5E36 E< D4>B4 >EB6=: 2; :6>D3 E< ;E:2<2=4:2E;A4:6AN233C6AC;A6>6=:2E;*#%E< :164;A=KC232:2E;=: N*F16>62;4<:6>>6<6>>6A:E43 :16G=: N*G<E>8>6@2:9I1656=2474;A=KC232:2E; <<2=6>14A54336A:164J4>AA4:6A<2O2;?:16 D4>M6:@47C6E<:165>E56>:94:3* (56>4=>64;A E; >6<6>6;=6 C;A6> 6=:2E; E< :16 =: N* :16 6<6>6;=6EC>:6;14;=6A:16D4>M6:@47C6E<:1674;A:E 3 L ( 56> 4=>6 @2A6 E>A6> A4:6A */ 2; E(';<C>:16>455647 :16556774:6EC>: 89:162D5C?;6AE>A6>A4:6A/54336A2; E/( 6;14;=6A :16 D4>M6: @47C6 E< :16 74;A :E 3* ' '/(56>4=>6 ' EC;367 <E> :16 4556774;:3 >6792;? C5E; :16 BCA?D6;: A4:6A L* 54336A 2; 2; :16 =436 E< - 4 - 3C8D2:3 :14: :16 5>636;: =436 23 =E@6>6A 89 :16 342A E>A6> 2; J12=1 :123 EC>: 143 >6AC=6A :16 >4:6 E< =ED56;34:2E; <>ED 3* ' '/( :E 3* N ( 2; @26J E< :16 BCA?D6;: 54336A2;:16=436E< ! "#$ % & ' ( "#! )' *+ , *- ,. J16>62; :16 4=KC232:2E; J43 C;A6> :16 E:2<2=4:2E; A4:6A *<E>:1632D274>5C>5E36332:C4:6A2;:1632D274> @2774?663C8D2:3:14:32;=6:16>6J43A2<<6>6;=6E<E;6 964> 86:J66; :16 E:2<2=4:2E; 3C8B6=: D4::6> =436 E< ! 4;A E:2<2=4:2E; 3C8B6=: D4::6> E< 342A 455647 P A663=474:2E; J43 ?>4;:6A :16>689 >6AC=2;? :16 =ED56;34:2E;542A4348E@6 * 63C8D2:3:14::16556774:6EC>: 2;3:64AE< :4M2;?PA663=474:2E; 14A:4M6;E;79'PA663=474:2E; 4;A:14:2<=ED56;34:2E;4J4>A6A89:16556774:6EC>: 23>6AC=6A89:4M2;?PA663=474:2E; 5C>5E36E<<272;?E< :16 455647 JEC7A 86 36>@6A 6 <C>:16> 3C8D2:3 :14: :16 - 5 - =ED56;34:2E; 4J4>A6A 2; E(* 143 47>64A9 866; 542A 4;A 34:23<26A 4;A 34D6 143 4::42;6A <2;472:9 EC;367 <E> :16 >635E;A6;:(=742D4;: AE63 ;E: A235C:6 :16 4<E>6342A <4=:C47 4356=: E< :16 D4::6> 2;=6 :16E>A6>2; E(*2354336A2;>6356=:E< :16@6>934D6 E:2<2=4:2E;A4:6ALN2;>6356=:E< :1674;AJ12=12332:C4:6A2;!4J472@2774?6 74;A47CM 4748C>4?2 23:>2=: :123 EC>: AE ;E: 366 4;9 >643E; :E A2<<6> <>ED :16 >4:6 E< =ED56;34:2E; 4J4>A6A 2; E(* / ==E>A2;?79 :16<E77EJ2;?. ! ! #% 5564723&###/ #% 16=ED56;34:2E;4DEC;:4J4>A6A89:16 556774:6EC>:2;43CDE<3* ' '/( 56> 4=>6 J2:1 477 3:4:C:E>9 86;6<2: 23 >6AC=6A:E3* N (56>4=>6 - 6 - #'% :23D4A6=764>:14:2<:16>6234;9A67492; =742D4;:3 <272;? :16 455647 86<E>6 :16 556774:6EC>: :16342AA67496A56>2EA86 6O=7CA6A J1276 =47=C74:2;? 2;:6>63: E; :16 =ED56;34:2E; *+ '( %! + 23: E)7 E)'N )