Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 50728 (KAR)
RAMA SHETTY v. SURESH AND ANR
MFA/202075/2023 · 2025-09-16
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50728 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50728 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #
$% & & ##
'&( )
! "#$#!%#
&
''' (
"#$#!%&
'&)
&$%&%&*! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' '
!+*! ' (
'
' !%*&%&* #$ &%&! ' '
,
' '
-
% ./01. 2.34 566758 34 834279 :/; 59<3443/= >32. 2.7 ?/=47=2/:875;=79?/0=478:/;@/2.43974323425A7=06:/; :3=589346/458
73=1 511;37B79 @C 2.7 D091<7=2 5=9 5>5;9 95279 !%*&%&* 654479 3= /#$ &%&! @C 2.7 E998 7=3/; 3B38 0917 F 585@0;513 .7;73=5:27;
- 3 -
;7:7;;79 2/ 54 G2.7 ;3@0=58H :/; 4./;2 2.7 5667885=2E ?853<5=2 34 @7:/;7 2.34 /0;2 477A3=1 7=.5=?7<7=2 /: ?/<67=4523/=
& ;37::5?2487593=12/:383=1/:?853<672323/=5;7 2.52 /= !+%&&%&! 52 5@/02 !&%% 6< >.7= 2.7 ?853<5=258/=1>32..344/=>546;/?7793=1@C>58A:;/< /==5@52255=952/.7=125B388517=75;>527;25=A/= .7=125 ;/59 2.7 ;397; /: /=95 </2/;?C?87 @75;3=1 /E*& E*+!# ?5<7 :;/< @5?A 4397 >32. .31. 46779 3= 5 ;54. 5=9 =718317=2 <5==7; 5=9 954.79 2/ 2.7 ?853<5=2 5=9 ?50479 2.7 5??397=2 07 2/ >.3?. 2.7 ?853<5=2 404253=79 1;37B/04 3=D0;374 .7 3=D0;374 .5B7 ;7408279 3= 67;<5=7=2 65;2358 9345@3832C 5=9 45<7 .54 5::7?279 .34 :020;7 75;=3=1 ?565?32C .7 ?853<5=2 ?/=27=979 2.52 .7 .5B3=1 40::7;79 2.7 3=D0;374 34 7=232879 :/;?/<67=4523/=:;/<2.7;746/=97=24
- 4 -
* 75;9 875;=79 ?/0=478 :/; 2.7 5667885=2E ?853<5=2 5=9 875;=79 ?/0=478 :/; ;746/=97=2 /&E =40;5=?7/<65=C
75;=79 ?/0=478 :/; 2.7 5667885=2E?853<5=2 >/089?/=27=92.522.7?853<5=2>545179#C75;454/= 2.7 9527 /: 2.7 5??397=2 5=9 .7 >54 9/3=1 51;3?0820;58 >/;A 5=9 907 2/ 2.7 5??397=2 2.7 1;752 2/7 /: 2.7 ?853<5=2 .54 @77= 5<6025279 5=9 2.7 /?2/;E& .54 425279 2.7 9345@3832C 52 *#I 2/ 2.7 >./87 @/9C 5=9 2.7 ;3@0=58 .54 7;;79 3= 25A3=1 2.7 9345@3832C 52 !&I 7 :0;2.7; 40@<324 2.52 2.7 ?/<67=4523/= 5>5;979 0=97; /2.7; .7594 37 653= 5=9 40::7;3=1) 5227=95=2 5=9 ?/=B7C5=?7?.5;174)8/44/:3=?/<790;3=12.72;752<7=2 67;3/9) 8/44 /: 5<7=32374 5;7 /= 2.7 8/>7; 4397 >.3?. =7794 2/ @7 7=.5=?79 7=?7 477A4 :/; 7=.5=?7<7=2/: ?/<67=4523/=@C588/>3=12.7566758
#
875;=79 ?/0=478 :/; 2.7 ;746/=97=2 /&E=40;5=?7 /<65=C ?/=27=979 2.52 2.7
- 5 -
?/<67=4523/= 5>5;979 @C 2.7 ;3@0=58 34 597J0527 ?/=4397;3=12.75173=?/<75=95B/?523/=/:2.7?853<5=2 5=9 2.7;7 34 =/ =779 :/; 5=C 3=27;:7;7=?7 @C 2.34 /0;2 7=?76;5C4:/;934<34458/:566758
5B3=1 .75;9 875;=79 ?/0=4784 2.34 /0;2 67;0479 2.7 3<601=79 D091<7=2 5=9 /2.7; <527;3584 685?79/=;7?/;9
+ .7 9527 /: 2.7 5??397=2 517 /: 2.7 ?853<5=2 5=9835@3832C/=2.7=40;5=?7/<65=C5;7=/23=9346027
$ .7 5??397=2 .54 25A7= 685?7 /= !+%&&%&! .79/?2/;>./.543440799345@3832C?7;23:3?527EKL.54 @77= 7K5<3=79 54 & & .54 425279 2.52 2.7 9345@3832C 34 *#I2/ 2.7 >./87@/9C5=92.7;3@0=58 .54 25A7= 9345@3832C 52 !&I 54 & 34 =/2 5 2;75279 9/?2/; .7 5667885=2 .54 404253=79 ?;04.
3=D0;374 5=9 907 2/ >.3?..341;7522/7.54@77=5<6025279/=4397;3=1588 2.52 2.7 ;3@0=58 .54 ;31.28C 5>5;979 5 40< /:
- 6 -
*
+ ;/0=979 /:: 2/ *
+ 2/>5;94 8/44/::020;73=?/<75=92.7;734=/=779:/;3=27;:7;7=?7
L .7 5667885=2 >54 59<32279 3= ./463258 :/; & 95C4 /=4397;3=1 2.7 :5?2 2.52 2.7 5</0=2 5>5;979 2/>5;94653=5=940::7;3=13=540</:4&%%%% E34/= 2.7 8/>7; 4397 >.3?. =7794 2/ @7 7=.5=?79 2/ *+)5=9540</:*+2/>5;948/44/: 5<7=32374545153=424!%%%% E5>5;979@C2.7;3@0=58
!% .7 ;3@0=58 .54 ;31.28C 5>5;979 5 40< /:
*! +2/>5;94<793?587K67=474
!! .7 ?853<5=2 >54 59<32279 3= ./463258 :/; & 95C4 5=9 59B3479 :/; ;742 /=4397;3=1 2.7 45<7 .7 34 7=232879:/;5227=95=2?.5;174://9F?/=B7C5=?7?.5;174 3=540</:* +5153=424!%%%% E5>5;979@C 2.7;3@0=58
!& /=4397;3=1 2.7 3=D0;374 404253=79 @C 2.7 ?853<5=25=967;3/9/:2;752<7=23=./463258.7347=232879
- 7 -
:/; 8/44 /: 3=?/<7 90;3=1 8539 06 67;3/9 :/; 5 67;3/9 /: 2.;77</=2.43=540</:* +4!&#% EK*
!* .04 2.7 ?853<5=2 34 7=232879 :/; :/88/>3=1 5</0=2/:?/<67=4523/= ,
-./* 0123 .4.5/-/6738- 59612., 0123 .4.5/-/67 389*153 ! 53=5=940::7;3=1 4&%%%% E 4#%%%% E & 227=95=2?.5;1745=9 ?/=B7C5=?7?.5;174 4!%%%% E 4&%%% E * /44/::020;73=?/<7 4&&#+%% E 4&&#+%% E
793?587K67=474 4!%&+%% E 4!%&+%% E # /44/:3=?/<790;3=1 85390667;3/9 4!#%%% E 4&+#% E
/44/:5<7=32374 4!%%%% E 4#%%%% E 3., *:
+ *
;!+ 28.2<-0-23 *!!!+
! =2.7;740822.75667589747;B742/@7588/>79 3=E65;27=?72.7:/88/>3=1
3 .756675834588/>793=E65;2
33 .7 5667885=2E?853<5=2 34 7=232879 2/ 2/258 ?/<67=4523/= /: *
;!+ 5153=42 4*$*%% E545>5;979@C2.7;3@0=58
- 8 -
58/=1 >32. 3=27;742 52 2.7;527 /:I 65 :;/<2.79527/:672323/=2388324;7583M523/=
333 .7;746/=97=2/&E=40;5=?7?/<65=C34 93;7?279 2/ 976/432 2.7 ?/<67=4523/= 5</0=2 >32.3= 5 67;3/9 /: 731.2 >77A4 :;/< 2.34 95C :5383=1 >.3?. 32 4.588 65C 3=27;742522.7;527/:LI65238865C<7=2
3B .77=23;75</0=2/:?/<67=4523/=4.588@7 ;7875479 3= :5B/0; /: 2.7 5667885=2E ?853<5=2 5:27; 907 397=23:3?523/=
B7;3:3?523/=
/+ ' & &( %
!&# 2)BA