Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 50716 (KAR)
SUDEEP @ SUDI @ SUDEER v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
MFA/200387/2022 · 2025-03-19
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50716 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50716 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#
$
$
%%&
' ( )* %%&
' (
) *
!"#
$ %
&
'
(( !"#
$ %
&
(
( )*%& ( (
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!"! #+
)#*# (
(
) * '
((
(
(( (( '
$ %
&
!"*
$ %
&
(
( )*%& (
)#*#
!"! #+
(
- 3 -
,
$ % , &
-./01234101.5.6700.8578.5970.:;287:6<55<2/
01. 7==.795 78. 07>./ 3= ;28 ;</79 :<5=2579 ?@ A2/5./0 2; ?20101.=780<.5
.</47448<.-.:?@01.B3:46./07/:7C78:</ 2!"! #+ :70.: )#*# ?@ 01. 9.78/.:
::9 ./<28 <-<9 3:4. D
<B7@7=387 %;28 51280E01.8<?3/79F&01.=.0<0<2/.875C.99758.5=2/:./0 ' %;2851280E01.28=2870<2/F&78.?.;28.01<52380 </01.5.7==.795
* (28 01. 57>. 2; A2/-./<./A. 01. =780<.5 78. 8.;.88.:0275=.801.<887/>5?.;28.01.8<?3/79
G
1. ;7A0379 6708<H 2; 01. A75. <5 0170 2/ )# #+ 70 7?230 #G# 76 01. =.0<0<2/.8 C75 01. =<99<2/8<:.82/01.62028A@A9.?.78</42'
! ))*
- 4 -
C1<A1C758<::./?@1<5;701.8</97C1.57<:62028A@A9. C1<9./.420<70</4A38-.C751<0?@01.?352C/.:?@01. 28=2870<2/ ?.78</4 2'
*! (!#! C1<A1 A76. ;826
01. 2==25<0. :<8.A0<2/ 8.5390</4 </ 01. =.0<0<2/.8 ;799</4 :2C/7/:53507</</4;87A038.2;517;02;01.8<410;.63870 =82H<679 *8:7/:2=./0@=.;87A038.2;01.8<4100<?<7 1.=.0<0<2/.8C75<66.:<70.9@51<;0.:0201.125=<0797/: 1.C75</=70<./0;28G:7@597<6</4017001.=.0<0<2/.8 C75 7 A229<. 74.: 7?230 + @.785 70 01. 0<6. 2; 01. 7AA<:./0 523410 7:.I370. A26=./570<2/ ;826
01. 8.5=2/:./028=2870<2/
1. =.0<0<2/ C75 8.5<50.: ?@ 01. 8.5=2/:./0 28=2870<2/ A2/0./:</4 0170 01. A26=./570<2/ A97<6.: <5 1<419@.H28?<07/0<674</78@7/:3/0./7?9.7/:01.8.C75 /2 53A1 /.49<4./A. 2/ 01. =780 2; <05 :8<-.8 ?30 01. /.49<4./A. C75 2/ =780 2; 01. 8<:.8 2; 01. 62028A@A9. <07952:<5=30.:01.74.</A26.7/:2AA3=70<2/ 2; 01. =.0<0<2/.8 7/: 0.86.: 01. A26=./570<2/ 75 1<419@ .H28?<07/0<674</78@7/:3/0./7?9. <07952022>
- 5 -
3= 01. A2/0./0<2/ 0170 01. 2C/.8 7/: </538.8 2; 01. 62028A@A9.C.8.7952/.A.5578@=780<.50201.=.0<0<2/
" ;0.8 ;876</4 2; <553.5 01. =.0<0<2/.8 C75 .H76</.: 75 7/: 01. :2A028 C12 755.55.: 01. :<57?<9<0@ C75 .H76</.: 75 7/: H5 02 C.8. 678>.:1.:8<-.82;01.?35C75.H76</.:75
) ;0.8 1.78</4 ?201 01. 5<:.5 01. 8<?3/79 175 7C78:.:7A26=./570<2/2; 5G### 0201.=.0<0<2/.8 3/:.8;2992C</41.7:5 9 2 .7:5 26=./570<2/</ % 5&
7</7/:53;;.8</45 ####
.:<A79.H=./5.5</A388.:7/: ;3038.6.:<A79.H=./5.5 00./:7/02/-.@7/A. 238<51</4;22:7/:201.8 </A<:./079.H=./5.5
!G###
* 2552;</A26.:38</497<:3= =.8<2: G##
G 2552;;3038.</A26.2/ 7AA23/028=.867/./0:<57?<9<0@ +GG##
2552;76./<0<.59<;.A26;2805 7/:.H=.A07/A@2;9<;. ####
+,- ./)
! .</4 7448<.-.: ?@ 01. 576. 01. =.0<0<2/.8 <5 ?.;28. 01<5 2380 5..></4 ./17/A.6./0 2; A26=./570<2/
- 6 -
7/: 01. 8.5=2/:./028=2870<2/ <5 ?.;28. 01<5 2380 A2/0./:</4017001.8.C75A2/08<?3028@/.49<4./A.2/01. =7802;01.8<:.82;01.62028A@A9.7/:01.576.175/20 ?../=82=.89@7==8.A<70.:?@01.8<?3/79
+ .78:78436./052;?2015<:.5
#
1. 9.78/.: A23/5.9 7==.78</4 ;28
01. 8.5=2/:./028=2870<2/ C12 <5 7==.997/0 </ ( 2#)* # C239: 53?6<0 0170 01. 28=2870<2/ 17:
07>./3=01.A2/0./0<2/017001.2C/.87/:</538.82;01. 62028A@A9.78.7952/.A.5578@=780<.57/:017001.8.C75 A2/08<?3028@ /.49<4./A. 2/ 01. =780 2; 01. 8<:.8 2; 01. 62028A@A9. . 53?6<05 0170 01. 57<: 75=.A0 C75 /20 A2/5<:.8.:?@01.8<?3/79</7=82=.867//.8.:.;./:5
01. <6=34/.: B3:46./0 8.478:</4 01.
I37/036 2; A26=./570<2/<5A2/A.8/.:.-./012341;..?9.700.6=0<5 67:.0257@017001.A26=./570<2/<52/01.1<41.85<:. 9.78/.: A23/5.9 ;28 01. =.0<0<2/.8 C239: 53?6<0 0170 01. =.0<0<2/.8 C75 7 A229<. 7/: 01. - 7 -
8<?3/79175/20=82=.89@755.55.:01.;3/A0<2/79:<57?<9<0@ 2; 01. =.0<0<2/.8 . A2/0./:5 0170 175 5070.: 01. :<57?<9<0@ 2; * J 7/: 01. 8<?3/79755.55.: 70 +JC1<A1 175 /2 A288.970<2/ C<01 .7A1 201.8 . 7952 53?6<05 0170
01. A26=./570<2/ 7C78:.: 3/:.8 01. 8.67</</4 1.7:5 <5 7952 2/ 01. 92C.8 5<:. 7/: 01. 576. /..:5 02 ?. 8.755.55.:?@01<52380
A78.;39 =.83579 2; 01. 8.A28:5 C239: 8.-.79 0170 ;28 01. =.0<0<2/.8 <0 C75 7 A75. 2; A26=25<0. /.49<4./A. ?30 /20 7 A2/08<?3028@ /.49<4./A. -<:./09@
01. =.0<0<2/.8 17: /2 829. 02 =97@ </ A2/08<?30</4 7/@ /.49<4./A. </ 01. 7AA<:./0 75 1. C75 8<:</4 =<99<2/ 1. 28=2870<2/012341A2/0./:.:017001.2C/.87/:</538.8 2; 01. 62028A@A9. 78. /.A.5578@ =780<.5 :<: /20 2=0 02 </-2>. 01.=82-<5<2/5 2; 8:.8 39. # 2; ; 70 799 28=2870<2/ C75 7448<.-.: ?@ /2/<6=9.7:6./0 2; 01. 2C/.87/:</538.82;01.62028A@A9./201</4=8.-./0.:<0 02;<9.7/7==9<A70<2/3/:.88:.8 39.#2;
- 8 -
* 2 ;78 75 7 =.0<0<2/.8 <5 A2/A.8/.: <0 C75 7 A75. 2; A26=25<0. /.49<4./A. ;28 1<6 7/: 1. A239: 17-. =82A..:.: C<01 7/@2/. 2; 01. 0280;.75285 C1<A1 1. A1225.502?.=82=.81.8.;28.<0A7//20?.57<:017001. =.0<0<2/ 53;;.8.: ;826 /2/B2</:.8 2; /.A.5578@ =780@ 52 ;787501.=.0<0<2/.8<5A2/A.8/.:
G 1.B3:46./02;01.;399?./A12;01<52380</ 01.A75.2;
C1<A1 A76. 02 ?. 8.<0.870.:?@ 01<5 2380 </ 7/201.8 ;399 ?./A1:.A<5<2/ </ 01. A75.2; !"# $ %
01. 97C A2/A.8/</4 01. A75. 2; A26=25<0. /.49<4./A.97@5:2C/01.A2/A.=02;A26=25<0./.49<4./A.
0<5/.A.5578@022?5.8-.0170?20101.5.:.A<5<2/52;01. ;399?./A12;01<52380C.8.7;;<86.:?@01. =.H2380</
01. A75. 2; !% & '% ( )
1.8.;28. 01. 7==.79 ;<9.: ?@ 01. ' 28=2870<2/ <5 ?.8.;02;7/@6.8<0552;787501<5A2/0./0<2/<5A2/A.8/.:
1 ++!/9</.'78"#* 2 ##*/9</.'78) 3 %# &+)*
- 9 -
26</4 02 01. I37/036 2; 01. A26=./570<2/ 7623/0<0<58.9.-7/002/20.017001.=.0<0<2/.853;;.8.: ;87A038.2;517;02;8<410;.63870=82H<679 *8:7/:2=./ 0@=.2;;87A038.2;01.8<4100<?<7.C752=.870.:2/ )# #+ 7/: :<5A1784.: 2/ ##"#+ 5070.:
017001.8.<57=1@5<A79:<57?<9<0@2;* J
" 1.=1@5<A79:<57?<9<0@5070.:?@17502?. ?28/.</6</:C1<9.755.55</401.;3/A0<2/79:<57?<9<0@1. 8<?3/79 A2/5<:.85 ;3/A0<2/79 :<57?<9<0@ 70 +J C1<A1 7==.78502?.2/01.92C.85<:./01.A2/5<:.8.:2=</<2/ 2; 01<5 2380 01. ;3/A0<2/79 :<57?<9<0@ 2; 01. =.0<0<2/.8 <5 1.9:70*J
) 0<5=.80</./002/20.017001.=.0<0<2/.8C757 A229<. 74.: 7?230 + @.785 1. 74. 7/: 2AA3=70<2/ 2;
01.=.0<0<2/.875.-<:./A.:;82601.8.A28:57-7<97?9.78. /20</:<5=30.?30C170<5</:<5=30.<52/9@01.</A26.2; 01.=.0<0<2/.8 ! 1. 43<:.9</.5 <553.: ?@ 01. '
;28 01. =38=25. 2; 5.009.6./0 2; :<5=30.5 ?.;28.
01.2>
:79701
- 10 -
=8.5A8<?.: /20<2/79 </A26. 2; 5* # ;28 01. @.78 #+ / 36=0../ /36?.85 2; B3:46./05 01<5 2380 175 1.9: 0170 01. 43<:.9</.5 <553.: ?@ 01. '
</ 4./.879 A2/;286<0@ C<01 01. C74.5 ;<H.: 3/:.8 01. </<636 74.5
A01.8.;28.01.</A26.2;01.=.0<0<2/.8</01. 7?5./A.2;7/@201.8A24./0.-<:./A.17502?.A2/5083.: 70 5* # =.8 62/01 1.8.;28. 01. 9255 2; ;3038. </A26.<5A79A3970.:750/) % 5* # H H!H*J&
+ 2/5.I3./09@ 129:</4 0170 01. =.0<0<2/.8 C75 3/7?9. 02 8.536. 1<5 C28> 70 9.750 ;28 7 =.8<2: 2; * 62/015 7 536 2; 0!) % 5* # H *& <5 7C78:.:0201.=.0<0<2/.8
# 1.8<?3/791757C78:.:75362; 5####
02C78:501.=7</7/:53;;.8</40201.;7A0017001.8.C.8. 0C2;87A038.5<0C239:?.B3507/:=82=.8027C78:7536 2;0.) 3/:.801<51.7:
- 11 -
1. =.0<0<2/.8 C75 </=70<./0 ;28 G :7@5 7/: 01.8.;28.75362;0) <57C78:.:021<63/:.8
01. 1.7: 2; 700./:7/0 A2/-.@7/A. ;22: D /238<516./0 .0A
22></4 02 01. /7038. 2; </B38<.5 53;;.8.: 01. A26=./570<2/ 2; 5#### 7C78:.: 3/:.8 01. 1.7: 2; 92552;76./<0<.5<5./17/A.:020)
*
1. A26=./570<2/ 7C78:.: 3/:.8 01. 1.7: 2; 6.:<A79.H=./5.5:2.5/208.I3<8.7/@./17/A.6./0 G 135 01. =.0<0<2/.8 <5 ./0.8.: ;28 7 02079 A26=./570<2/3/:.8;2992C</41.7:5 9 2 .7:5 26=./570<2/</ % 5&
7</7/:53;;.8</45 G####
.:<A79.H=./5.5 !G###
* 2552;</A26.:38</497<:3= =.8<2: *+) #
G 2552;;3038.</A26.2/ 7AA23/028=.867/./0:<57?<9<0@ 5*)#"#
2552;76./<0<.5 *####
" 2C78:5;22:/238<516./0 A2/-.@7/A..0AA1784.5 ###
+,- /)
100,234+,5,671789+:1 6;834,- ./)
4:,4<1214+ /)
- 12 -
/
01. 8.5390
01. 7==.79 ;<9.: ?@
01. 28=2870<2/ <59<7?9. 02?.:<56<55.: 7/:01. 7==.79 ;<9.:
?@ 01. =.0<0<2/.8 :.5.8-.5 02 ?. 7992C.: </=780 7/: 1./A.01.;2992C</4
%<& 1.7==.79;<9.:?@01.28=2870<2/</( 2#)* #<5:<56<55.:K
%<<& 1.7==.79;<9.:?@01.7==.997/0A97<67/0 </(
2##*!) #<57992C.:</=780K
%<<<& 1. 7==.997/0 =.0<0<2/.8 <5 ./0<09.: ;28 7 536 2; 5"!# </ 7::<0<2/ 02 01. A26=./570<2/ 7C78:.: ?@ 01. 8<?3/79 792/4 C<01 </0.8.50 70 "J =7 ;826 01. :70.2;=.0<0<2/0<99<05:.=25<0K
%<-& 1. 8.5=2/:./0' <5 :<8.A0.: 02 :.=25<001.A26=./570<2/7623/0C<01</7 =.8<2: 2; 5<H C..>5 ;826 01. :70. 2; 01<5 28:.8K
- 13 -
%-& .50 2; 01. 28:.8 2; 01. 8<?3/79 507/:5 3/790.8.:K %-<& 1. 7623/0 </ :.=25<0 <; 7/@ ?. 087/56<00.: 02 01. A2/A.8/.: 8<?3/79 ;2801C<01
:
&
$ ( $
G+ '