Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 50700 (KAR)
MANIMALA AND ORS v. VEERAPPA AND ANR
MFA/201854/2024 · 2025-11-04
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50700 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 50700 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $% #
$% !%"! ##
&"' (
! "
#
"
$ $
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! %
&!#
'
! # ! ( )(*
"("!($$$
#
+ !,$$ %
&! ! -
$. '
.&' # (*(
$
# ! ! " ( ! ! /! #
0! #
0! #
#
- 3 -
% &
0! #
'
123 455647 89:6; 6<=2>9 .&' >? =16 >=>; 612<763<=*&16;6294?=6;;6?6;;6:=>43@=16<=/?>; 31>;='143A669?276:AB=16<742C49=3A629D4DD;26E6:AB =16F8:DC69=49:4G4;::4=6:*54336:AB=16 49:::2=2>947692>;2E27#8:D6474A8;4D229 >$
4<=3D2E29D;236=>=16?2729D>?=16455647A;26?7B 3=4=6: 4;6 =14= >9 * 4= 4A>8= .$ 5C =16 :6<6436: 4:1838:49 6::B G43 5;><66:29D >9 123 C>=>;<B<76 A64;29D ;6D23=;4=2>9 >(" ( 964;
8C54 4=6 >9 49D4954772 => !14H=4C54772 C429 ;>4: ==14==2C647>;;BA64;29D;6D23=;4=2>9>( )(* G4354;H6:29=16C2::76>?=16;>4:G2=1>8=49B54;H29D 72D1=3 54;H29D 32D9473 >; ?69<29D >? 3=>963 574<6: AB 2=3 32:6 3 =16 :6<6436: :2: 9>= 9>=2<6 =16 54;H6: 7>;;B :4316: =16 7>;;B=> 2=3 ;64; 69: 32:6 3 4 ;6387= 16 ?677
- 4 -
:>G9?;>C=16C>=>;<B<76383=4296:D;26E>8329F8;26349: 38<<8CA6:=>=1629F8;263>9=1635>=
16<742C49=3?276:456=2=2>989:6;6<=2>9"" >? =16 <= 366H29D <>C56934=2>9 ?>; =16 :64=1 >? =16 :6<6436:4:1838:496::B47>9DG2=129=6;63=
936;E2<6>?38CC>93;635>9:69=>349:
45564;6: =1;>8D1 =162; ;6356<=2E6 <>89367 635>9:69= > :2: 9>= <1>>36 => ?276 49B 3=4=6C69= >? >AF6<=2>93 635>9:69= > ?276: 123 G;2==69 3=4=6C69= 356<2?2<477B 49:<4=6D>;2<477B:69B29D=16<>9=69=3>?=1656=2=2>96 473> :6926: =16 4D6 29<>C6 49: ><<854=2>9 >? =16 :6<6436:=G43<>9=69:6:=14==16<>9<6;96:5>72<614:
?276: 4 <14;D6 3166= 4D4293= A>=1 =16 :;2E6; >? =16 7>;;B 49: =16 :6<6436: ;2:6; >? =16 C>=>;<B<76 49: =16;6?>;6 =16;6 G43 <>9=;2A8=>;B 96D72D69<6 >9 =16 54;= >? =16 :6<6436:29<48329D=164<<2:69==G43?8;=16;<>9=69:6: =14==16;2:6;>?=16C>=>;<B<76:2:9>=5>336334E472:49:
6??6<=2E6 :;2E29D 72<6936 43 >9 =16 :4=6 >? 4<<2:69= 49:
=1>8D1 =16 >??69:29D 7>;;B G43 2938;6: G2=1 ;635>9:69=
- 5 -
> =16 5>72<B <>9:2=2>93 14: A669 E2>74=6: 69<6 ;635>9:69=>3>8D1=?>;:23C23347>?=1656=2=2>9
$ 9=16A4323>?=165764:29D3>?=1654;=263=16 742C3;2A8947?;4C6:=1623386349:=16;64?=6;;6<>;:6:
=16 6E2:69<6 16 <742C49=3 29 >;:6; => 5;>E6 =16 <436 6I4C296: <742C49= > 43 49: D>= 6I12A2=6:
:><8C69=3 94C67B
I =>
I 9 A6147? >? =16 ;635>9:69=3 ;635>9:69= > 6I4C296: 2=3 >??2<247 43 49:D>=6I12A2=6::><8C69=394C67B
I=>
I
" 16 742C3 ;2A8947 AB =16 2C58D96: F8:DC69=167:=14==164<<2:69==>>H574<6>9 4<<>89=>?=16;43149:96D72D69=4<=3>?A>=1=16:;2E6;>? =16 7>;;B 49: =16 ;2:6; >? =16 C>=>;<B<76 3 4 ;6387= >? G12<1=16:6<6436:383=4296:29F8;26349:38<<8CA6:=> =16 29F8;263 16 ;2A8947 ?8;=16; 167: =14= =16 <742C49=3 4;6 69=2=76: => >97B $J >? =16 =>=47 <>C56934=2>9 >? 3. ( ?;>C ;635>9:69= >3 49: 47>9D G2=1 29=6;63= 4= =16 ;4=6 >? "J 54 49: :2;6<=6: ;635>9:69= >(938;49<6 >C549B => :65>32= >97B $J >? =16
- 6 -
69=2;6<>C56934=2>94C>89=47>9DG2=129=6;63=G2=129* :4B3 ?;>C =16 :4=6 >? 543329D >?
=16 4G4;: !629D 4DD;26E6: AB =16 342: F8:DC69= =16 5;6369= 455647 143 A669?276:
. ;24D;4F 4=27 764;96:<>8936745564;29D?>; =16<742C49=3143;4236:=16?>77>G29D<>9=69=2>93 4' 2;3=7B =16 4<<2:69= ><<8;;6: :86 => =16 96D72D69<6>?=16:;2E6;>?=167>;;BG1>14:54;H6:=16 7>;;B 29 =16 C2::76 >? =16 ;>4: 16 ;2A8947 6;;6: 29 ?43=6929D $J >? =16 724A272=B >9 =16 :6<6436: G12<1 23 <>9=;4;B=>=16C4=6;2474E4274A76>9;6<>;:93855>;=>? 123 <436 16 143 473> ;6726: 85>9 =16 F8:DC69= >? =16 >9/A76 56I >8;= 29 =16 <436 >? A' 6<>9:7B 2= G43 ?8;=16; <>9=69:6: =14= =16 :;2E6;>?=167>;;B14:54;H6:=16E612<7629=16C2::76>? =16 ;>4: 4= 4A>8= .$ 5C :8;29D =16 92D1= G2=1>8= 3G2=<129D >9 49B 29:2<4=>; >; 49B 54;H29D 72D1=3 3 4
- 7 -
;6387==16;2:6;>?=16C>=>;<B<76G43894A76=>9>=2<6=16 54;H6: 7>;;B 29 =16 92D1= 69<6 =16 4<<2:69= ><<8;;6:
3>767B :86 => =16 96D72D69<6 >? =16 :;2E6; >? =16 7>;;B G12<1 ;6387=6: 29 =16 :64=1 >? =16 C>=>;<B<76 ;2:6; 16 ;2A8947 6;;6: 29 1>7:29D =14= =16 :6<6436: 14: <>9=;2A8=6:$J=>=16><<8;;69<6>?=164<<2:69= <' 43=7B29;6356<=>?K849=8C2=G43<>9=69:6:
=14= <>932:6;29D=16 4D6 49: 4E><4=2>9>? =16 :6<6436: =16>E6;477<>C56934=2>94G4;:6:AB=16;2A894723>9=16 7>G6;32:669<6163>8D1=?>;477>G29D=16455647
9 =16 >=16; 149: C= 49D66=4 !14:;4316==B 764;96: <>89367 45564;29D ?>; =16 635>9:69= >(938;49<6 >C549B 143 ;4236: =16 ?>77>G29D<>9=69=2>93 4' 2;3=7B =16 4<<2:69= ><<8;;6: :86 => =16 96D72D69<6>?:6<6436:43G677 43=16:;2E6;>?=167>;;B E69=1>8D1=167>;;B14:A66954;H6:>9=16;>4:=16;6 G43 38??2<269= 354<6 ?>; =16 ;2:6; >? =16 C>=>;<B<76 =>
- 8 -
5433>G6E6;=16;2:6;>?=16C>=>;<B<76G43:;2E29D294 ;43149:96D72D69=C4996;49::4316:4D4293==1654;H6:
7>;;B 16 ;2A8947 4?=6; <>932:6;29D =16 6E2:69<6 >9 ;6<>;:143;2D1=7B493G6;6:3386> 4;=7B??2;C4=2E6 A' 6<>9:7B 29 ;6356<= >? K849=8C >? <>C56934=2>9 316 143 <>9=69:6: =14= <>932:6;29D =16 6E2:69<6>?=1654;=26343G67743=164D649:4E><4=2>9 >?=16:6<6436:=16>E6;477<>C56934=2>94G4;:6:AB=16 ;2A8947 23 F83= 49: ;643>94A76 69<6 3>8D1= ?>; :23C23347>?=16455647
* 64;: =16 764;96: <>89367 ?>; =16 54;=263 6;836:=16F8:DC69=49:4G4;:>?=16;2A8947
16 <436 >? =16 <742C49=3 23 =14= >9 * 4= 4A>8= .$ 5C =16 :6<6436:
4:1838:49 6::B G43 :;2E29D =16 C>=>;<B<76 A64;29D ;6D23=;4=2>9 >(" ( 169 16 ;64<16: 964;
8C54 4=6 >9 =16 49D4954772 => !14H=4C54772 C429 ;>4: 4 7>;;B A64;29D ;6D23=;4=2>9 >( )(* G43
- 9 -
54;H6:29=16C2::76>?=16;>4:G2=1>8=49B54;H29D72D1= 16 :6<6436: 9>= 36629D =16 54;H6: 7>;;B :4316: =16 7>;;B49:?677:>G9?;>C=16C>=>;<B<76383=4296:29F8;263 49:38<<8CA6:=>=1629F8;263
165>72<6;6D23=6;6:4949:4A4=6:<14;D6 3166=4D4293==16:6<6436:49:=16:;2E6;>?=167>;;B3 56;=163H6=<1=16G2:=1>?=16;>4:234A>8=?66=16 7>;;BG4354;H6:4A>8=?66=?;>C=1632:6>?=16;>4:
16;6 G43 38??2<269= 354<6 76?= =>G4;:3 =16 ;2D1= 32:6 >?
=16 7>;;B ?>; =16 E612<763 => 5433 <>C29D ?;>C >55>32=6 :2;6<=2>9 29<6=164<<2:69=><<8;;6:4=4A>8=.$5C 92D1==167>;;BG12<1G4354;H6:29=16C2::76>?=16;>4: G2=1>8=49B54;H29D72D1=49:=16;2:6;>?=16C>=>;<B<76 G43894A76=>3662=7=1>8D1=16;6G4338??2<269=354<6 >9=1676?=32:6=>5433=1;>8D1=16;2:6;G43=;4E6729D4= 12D1 3566: 49: 29 4 ;431 49: 96D72D69= C4996; 49:
:4316: =16 54;H6: 7>;;B >932:6;29D =166E2:69<6 >? =16 54;=263 =16 35>= C414L4; =16 3H6=<1 =16 49: =16
- 10 -
<14;D63166=G64;6>?=16>5292>9=14=A>=1=16:;2E6;>? =167>;;B49:=16;2:6;>?=16C>=>;<B<76G6;696D72D69=29 <48329D =16 4<<2:69= 16 :6<6436: <>9=;2A8=6: J => =164<<2:69=G1276=16:;2E6;>?=167>;;B<>9=;2A8=6:J > =14= 6I=69= =16 F8:DC69= 49: 4G4;: 54336: AB =16 ;2A89474;6C>:2?26: 9;6356<=>?K849=8C23<>9<6;96:<>932:6;29D =164D649:4E><4=2>9>?=16:6<6436:49:=166E2:69<6>? =16>E6;477<>C56934=2>94G4;:6:AB=16;2A894723 F83=49:;643>94A76
<<>;:29D7BG65433=16?>77>G29D>;:6;
2' 1645564723 ! 22' 16 #8:DC69= 49: 4G4;: >? =16 742C3;2A894723C>:2?26: 222' 16 938;49<6 >C549B 23 :2;6<=6:
=> :65>32= >97B J >? =16 =>=47 <>C56934=2>9 >? 3. (
- 11 -
4G4;: G2=1 29=6;63= "J 54 ?;>C =16:4=6>??2729D>?=16<742C56=2=2>9 =277 =16 :4=6 >? ;6472L4=2>9 G2=129 4 56;2>:>?32IG66H3?;>C=16:4=6>? ;6<625=>?<>5B>?=123>;:6; 2E' 16 455>;=2>9C69= :65>32= 49:
;676436 >? 4C>89= 31477 A6 C4:6 29 =6;C3>?=164G4;:>?=16;2A8947
)* &# ' %
)* &!%"!' %
23=>7>"