- 1 - !" #$ %$!&&! !!'' (&) * ! "#$ % & $ ' #$ ( ) !*#"$ $ $$ +,$ % & - # ' #.&#' ) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !+"(+" )+$$ $$+/) $$ $$* *"# ) $ ) 0$) $ 123345675689:6;45<25:2=2>::2<4:!$"($"?2@@4: AB ::3$ 457C> 7D73 )9:64 25: 4;A4> +/ 782B2?9>2 &EC> @1C>< 0>7A95230' 75 5C$* *"# <17@ 2??4237@E734:$ $ >7 2562526C9:2 7>2:2> 342>54: FC95@43 @9A;7<<4: 2??423 =2@ AB F327;25< EC> 45125F4;45< CE FC;?45@2<7C5$ < =2@ @9A;7<<4: C5 "$"($"# 2< 2AC9< ##$" 1C9>@ =145 F327;25< =2@ <>2D43756 75 A9@ A42>756 >467@<>2<7C5 5C$ +!++(# C5 782B2?9> 75:267 C2::>7D4>CECC:@4;?CA42>756>467@<>2<7C55C$ +!++ #" " :>CD4 7< 75 >2@1 25: 54637645< ;2554> 25: :2@14: 26275@< A9@F29@7567589>74@<CF327;25<$4=2@<2G45 <C 25844D757C@?7<23782B2?9>2EC><>42<;45<$4@?7<4<2G756 <>42<;45< 14 FC93: 5C< >4FCD4> E933B- 17@ >761< 2>; 2ACD4 - 3 - 43AC==2@2;?9<2<4:342:756<C?4>;2545<:7@2A737<B25:3C@@ CE 42>5756 F2?2F7<B$ 14>4EC>4 14 E734: F327; ?4<7<7C5 26275@< C=54>25:75@9>4>CECC:@4;?C$ $ 5FC5<4@<=14>47575@9>4>C??C@4:F327;?4<7<7C5 C52336>C95:@<>7A9523E>2;4:7@@94@25:>4FC>:4:4D7:45F4$ 327;25< 4H2;754: 17;@43E 25: >$14;2526C9:2 7>2:2> 2@ @#25:$H17A7<@$#<C$#=4>46C<;2>G4:$5C<14> 125: 75@9>4> 4H2;754: 7<@ CEE7F723 2@ $# 25: 6C< ;2>G4: H17A7<@#25:$$ ($ 5 FC5@7:4>2<7C5 <>7A9523 143: 2FF7:45< CFF9>>4: :94 <C >2@1 25: 54637645< :>7D756 CE 75@9>4: D417F34 AB 7<@ :>7D4> CEE45:756 D417F34 =2@ :93B 75@9>4: 2@ C5 :2<4 CE 2FF7:45<25:F327;25<=2@45<7<34:EC>EC33C=756FC;?45@2<7C5 E>C;75@9>4> !+ ,-./0,12-341 /513412 & ?4F7232;264@' # H?45@4:>432<756<C 2'C<>42<;45<1C@?7<237I2<7C5 ;4:7F754@<>25@?C><2<7C5$ @$"."""+"" A'5C9>7@1756ECC:25:;7@F433254C9@ 4H?45:7<9>4 @$"""""+"" C@@CE42>5756@=17F1<147589>4: =C93:12D4;2:412:@145C<A445 - 4 - 7589>4:FC;?>7@756 2'C@@CE42>5756@:9>756?4>7C:CE <>42<;45< A'C@@CEE9<9>442>5756@C52FFC95<CE ?4>;2545<:7@2A737<B$ @$. """+"" '# ! """+"" '# ! (,1,6-+ -/-7,2) ( 2;264@EC>?275@9EE4>75625:<>29;2 2@2FC5@4J945F4CE<147589>74@ @$" """"+"" C@@CE2;457<74@&25:C>3C@@CE ?>C@?4F<@CE;2>>7264@' @$"""""+"" * C@@CE4H?4F<2<7C5CE37E4 &@1C><45756CE5C>;233C564D7<B' + 3-+ 2" $ C<@2<7@E74:=7<1@2;4F327;25<=2@752??423$< =2@ @9A;7<<4: F327;25< 12: @?4F7E7F233B @<2<4: <12< 14 =2@ 264: " B42>@ =C>G756 2@ :>7D4> 25: 42>5756 @$ """+ ?4> ;C5<1 A9< <>7A9523 FC5@7:4>4: ;C5<13B 75FC;4 2< @$#"""+ =17F1 =2@ 5C< 89@<7E74:$ < =2@ @9A;7<<4: :94 <C 2FF7:45<23 7589>B 17@ >761< 2>; 2ACD4 43AC= 34D43 =2@ 2;?9<2<4:$ +:CF<C> =1C 4H2;754: F327;25< 2@@4@@4: :7@2A737<B2<*"K<C=1C34AC:B$C=4D4><>7A95232@@4@@4:7< 2<"K@2;4>4J97>4@45125F4;45<$ *$ <=2@E9><14>@9A;7<<4:<12<75D74=CE:4F7@7C5CE C5LA34 9?>4;4 C9><75F2@4CE >4?C><4:75 !" ##$<14>412@<CA4 - 5 - 2::7<7C5 CE E9<9>4 ?>C@?4F<@ <C 75FC;4 CE F327;25< 4D45 75 ?4>@C5237589>BF327;@$<=2@@9A;7<<4:<>7A952323@C2=2>:4: 3C=4> FC;?45@2<7C5 <C=2>:@ ?275 25: @9EE4>756 3C@@ CE 2;457<74@25:3C@@CE75FC;4:9>756327:9??4>7C:25:@C961< 45125F4;45<$ .$ >7 9A12@1 2332?9> 342>54: FC95@43 EC> >4@?C5:45<5C$+75@9>4>C??C@4:2??423$ !$ 42>: 342>54: FC95@43$ 4>9@4: 89:6;45< 25: 2=2>:$ ,$ >C;2ACD47<7@@44575@9>4>12@2FF4?<4:2=2>: 25: C53B F327;25< 7@ 75 2??423 EC> 45125F4;45<$ 14>4EC>4 ?C75<<12<=C93:2>7@4EC>FC5@7:4>2<7C57@ M14<14>F327;25<7@45<7<34:EC>45125F4;45< CEFC;?45@2<7C52@@C961<EC>NO #"$ 2;47@25@=4>4:?2><3B752EE7>;2<7D4EC>EC33C=756 >42@C5@$ ##$ FF9>>45F4 CE 2FF7:45< 75DC3D756 75@9>4: D417F34 342:756 <C F327;25< @9@<275756 7589>B 25: 2;?9<2<7C5 CE >761< - 6 - 2>; 2ACD4 43AC= >4@93<756 3C@@ CE 42>5756 F2?2F7<B 25: F327;25<A475645<7<34:EC>FC;?45@2<7C52>45C<75:7@?9<4$@ CA@4>D4: AB <>7A9523 F327;25< 12: @<2<4: 14 =2@ =C>G756 2@ :>7D4>25:42>5756@$ """+?4>;C5<1$9<@2;4=2@5C< @9A@<25<72<4: =7<1 @?4F7E7F 4D7:45F4$ 5 2A@45F4 <>7A9523 2@@4@@4:75FC;45C<7C5233B$C<7C52375FC;4EC>B42>"#=2@ @$#( "+ @2;4 12@ <C A4 FC5@7:4>4:$ @ 5C<4: F327;25< @9EE4>4: 2;?9<2<7C5 CE >761< 2>; 2ACD4 43AC=$ 2@@4@@4: 37;A :7@2A737<B 2< *"K$ 1C961 :94 <C 2;?9<2<7C5 F327;25< =C93: A4 952A34 <C FC5<7594 2@ :>7D4> ?C@@7A737<B CE 42>5756 75FC;4E>C;23<4>52<7D42DCF2<7C5F255C<A4>934:C9<$2G756 5C<4CEE2F<@25:F7>F9;@<25F4@2@@4@@;45<CE3C@@CE42>5756 F2?2F7<B 2< "K =C93: A4 =1C33B 752:4J92<4 7< =C93: A4 2??>C?>72<4<C2@@4@@3C@@CE42>5756F2?2F7<B2<."K$ #$ @ ?4> :4F7@7C5 75 82 F2@4 &@9?>2' E9<9>4 ?>C@?4F<@ 12@ <C A4 2::4: <C ;C5<13B 75FC;4$ 75F4 F327;25< =2@ 264: " B42>@ 25: @43E+4;?3CB4: E9<9>4 ?>C@?4F<@2<("K12@<CA42::4:$19@3C@@CEE9<9>475FC;4 7@>4FC;?9<4:2@EC33C=@ @$#( "+9("K:#:."K:#.P2 ; - 7 - #$ >7A9523 12@ 2=2>:4: 2< ; <C=2>:@ ;4:7F234H?45@4@<2G7565C<4CEA733@?>C:9F4:$ 75F4<14>47@ FC;?34<4 >47;A9>@4;45< <14>4 7@ 5C @FC?4 EC> 45125F4;45<$ >7A9523 12@ 23@C 2=2>:4: 2 ; <C=2>:@ 75F7:45<23 4H?45@4@$ 2G756 75<C 2FFC95< ?4>7C: CE . :2B@ 2@ 75?2<745< @2;4=C93:A489@<7E74:$ #($ 5F2@4CE2;?9<2<7C52<342@<(;C5<1@12@<CA4 FC5@7:4>4:2@32BCEE$14>4EC>4F327;25<=C93:A445<7<34:EC> @9;CE2<;2@FC;?45@2<7C5<C=2>:@3C@@CE75FC;4 :9>756 327: 9? ?4>7C:$ >7A9523 12@ 2=2>:4: @$""""+ <C=2>:@?27525:@9EE4>756$ C5@7:4>756E2F<<12<F327;25<12: @9@<2754:2;?9<2<7C5CE>761<2>;2ACD443AC=@2;4=C93:A4 6>C@@3B 752:4J92<4 7< =C93: A4 2??>C?>72<4 <C 45125F4 7< 2< 2; # $ 7G4=7@4<2G7565C<4CE>2<7C327::C=5ABC5LA34 9?>4;4 C9><75%&'%(&')>4?C><4: 75 **" * !$! 2=2>: CE @$""""+ <C=2>:@ 3C@@ CE 2;457<74@ =C93: A4 752:4J92<4$ < =C93: A4 2??>C?>72<4 <C 45125F4;45< 7< <C 2;$ 19@ <C<23 FC;?45@2<7C5 ?2B2A34=C93:A42@EC33C=@ - 8 - !+ ,-./0,12-341 /513412 # C@@CEE9<9>475FC;4 @$!(!!*"+"" C<>42<;45<1C@?7<237I2<7C5 ;4:7F754@<>25@?C><2<7C5$ @$."""+"" 5C9>7@1756ECC:25:;7@F433254C9@ 4H?45:7<9>4 @$""""+"" ( ?275@9EE4>75625:<>29;22@2 FC5@4J945F4CE<147589>74@ @$# """"+"" C@@CE42>5756:9>756?4>7C:CE <>42<;45< @$ ."""+"" * C@@CE2;457<74@&25:C>3C@@CE ?>C@?4F<@CE;2>>7264@' @$# """"+"" 3-+ 2 " #*$ C5@4J945<3BEC33C=756 7' ??4237@?2><3B233C=4:$ 77' )9:6;45<25:2=2>::2<4:!$"($"?2@@4:AB ::3$ 457C> 7D73 )9:64 25: 4;A4> +/ 782B2?9>2 75 5C$* *"# 7@ ;C:7E74: 25: F327;25< 7@ 143: 45<7<34: EC> <C<23 FC;?45@2<7C5 CE @$,!!*"+ 2@ 26275@< @$!,!"""+ 2=2>:4: AB <>7A9523 =7<1 75<4>4@< 2< *K ?4> 2559; E>C; :2<4CE?4<7<7C5<733:4?C@7<$ 777' 4@?C5:45<5C$+75@9>4>7@:7>4F<4:<C:4?C@7<@27: 2;C95<=7<175@7H=44G@E>C;:2<4CE<17@C>:4>$ 7D' 5:4?C@7<C9<CE45125F4:FC;?45@2<7C52;C95< . K7@C>:4>4:<CA4G4?<75 7H4::4?C@7<75 25B - 9 - 52<7C5237I4: A25G C> C@< CEE7F4 :4?C@7< E4<F1756 17614>>2<4CE75<4>4@<EC>2?4>7C:CEE7D4B42>@25: >4342@4>4;275756 K75E2DC9>CEF327;25<$ !.; (&&!) $ @6Q 7@<C$# 3C$* <-G