- 1 - !!" !!#!$ % $&"$"$ '$( ! ! "# $ % ##!&' ' #' %##!&( ( ) ** * * %##!&! * !+ '( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * '', ''" * * * ) - % !,!!'&'' ("'&!" * * * * ) - %* !$!&'&' !'&'( * - !( * * * . ! . /01 2304 56404078 01 90:6; <= ;6968;>84 7' 08 7("'&!# <608? >??306@6; <= 4/6 73;63 ;>46; !,!!'&'' 5>116; 08 0@0: 01A6::>867B1 7("'&!" 78 4/6 90:6 79 4/6 ;;: 0@0: B;?6 >8; * >:><B3>?0 9731/734C4/630>:7B34D 2/0A/01A78903E6;<=4/673;63 ;>46;!$!&'&'5>116;087!'&'(784/690:679 - 3 - 4/6308A05>:680730@0:B;?6>:><B3>?09731/734C4/6 *0314556::>467B34D ' /6 ><7@6 1B04 08 7("'&!# 01 90:6; <= 5:>084099%/0@>3>7 2/7 01 361578;684 7 ! 08 4/01 2304 56404078 >?>0814 FF2>: 7B108? 7%7563>40@6 7A064= ;6968;>84 7! 5640407863 /63608 ;6968;>84 7' >8; 4/6 0GB0;>473 FF2>: 7B108? 7%7563>40@6 7A064= ;6968;>847( 166H08?36:06979156A090A563973E>8A608 36156A4 79 5:74 <6>308? 7"# 08 B3@6= 7$ 79 >F>5B3 0::>?6G>8;014>:><B3>?0/6;6968;>84108A:B;08? 5640407863 /63608 2636 5:>A6; 6I%5>346 8 6I%5>346 FB;?E684 >8; ;6A366 A>E6 47 <6 5>116; 78 &$&!'&!" 640407863/636082/701;6968;>847'90:6;E01A6::>867B1 56404078 B8;63 3;63 - B:6 !( 08 0@0: 01A7("'&!" <697364/630>:7B342/0A/A>E647<636F6A46;>?>0814 2/0A/ 4/6 5640407863 53696336; > E01A6::>867B1 >556>: 08 7!'&'( B8;63 3;63 ( B:6 !; 79 <69736 4/6*0314556::>467B342/0A/>:17A>E647<636F6A46; 608?>??306@6;4/6564040786301<697364/017B34 - 4 - ( = 3;63;>46;!!&"'&'#4/017B34B5784/6 36GB614 E>;6 <= 4/6 :6>386; A7B816: 973 4/6 5>34061 3696336;4/6E>4463476;0>407868436>:><B3>?068A/ 365734 79 4/6 E6;0>4078 01 537;BA6; 2/0A/ 36>;1 >1 B8;63+ )*+,"),,-).)/, 0")123' (4/5$)564,6/1, 9463B8;6314>8;08?4/65B3571679E6;0>4078>8;4/6 1644:6E684 4/37B?/ E6;0>4078 <74/ 4/6 5>34061 />@6 >?366; 47 1644:6 4/603 ;015B46 >E0A><:= <69736 4/6 E6;0>473784/697::7208?463E1>8;A78;040781 ! /6 361578;684 87! /63608 />; 90:6; 7 ("'&!# 973 156A090A 563973E>8A6 >8; ;6A6:63>4078 4/>4 1>:6 ;66; ;>46; !"&('&!# <6>308? 87 !#""'&!%!#6I6AB46;<=;6968;>8487!089>@7B3 79 ;6968;>84 87' 01 8B:: >8; @70; /6 430>: A7B34 ;6A366; 4/6 1>0; 1B04 78 &$&!'&!" /7:;08? 4/>4 5B31B>84 47 4/6 >::74E684 A634090A>46 ;>46; !&&$!$!;6968;>8487(01;036A46;476I6AB464/6 1>:6 ;66; 08 9>@7B3 79 5:>084099361578;684 87! >8; ;6A:>36; 4/>4 1>:6 ;66; ;>46; !"&('&!# >8; <6>308?87!#""'&!%!#018B::>8;@70;/61B04 5375634=015:7487"#08=7$79>F>5B3@0::>?6 G J 014 >:><B3>?0 /6 5640407863 01 ;6968;>84 87' 08 4/6 1B04 /6 1B04 2>1 ;6A366; 6I%5>346 /63697365640407863 />190:6;0@0:01A7 ("'&!" 973164408?>10;64/66I%5>346;6A366/61>0;01A 56404078 2>1 ;01E0116; 78 !,!!'&''??306@6; <= 4/6 1>E6 5640407863 />1 90:6; 7 !'&'( /6 1>0; >:17 A>E6 47 <6 ;01E0116; 78 !$!&'&' /6 5640407863 />1 90:6; ><7@6 304 6404078 A/>::68?08? 4/6 <74/ 4/6 73;631 8 E6>82/0:6 08 6I6AB4078 56404078 1>:6 ;66; />1 <668 6I6AB46; 08 - 5 - 9>@7B3 79 361578;684 87!5:>84099 78 '!&('&'( 08 36156A4791B045375634=4/37B?/A7B34A7EE01107863 ' />4 4/6 <74/ 4/6 5>34061 />@6 >556>36; <69736 4/6 E6;0>4078 >8; 1644:6; 4/6 E>4463 >E0A><:= 78 4/6 97::7208?463E1>8;A78;040781 />45:>084099361578;68487!/63608/>1>?366;47 204/;3>24/61B04 ("'&!#90:6;<=/0E08041 6840364=>8;/620::90:6165>3>46>55:0A>4078B8;63 73;63 '( B:6 ! 08 @062 79 1644:6E684 <6426685>34061 /6 5:>084099361578;684 87! 01 >;E04408? 4/6 728631/05795640407863;6968;>8487!<=@034B679 1>:6 ;66; ;>46; !"&('&!# <6>308? 87 !#""'&!%!# 6I6AB46; <= ;6968;>84 87' >8; A7816GB684:= 01 36>;= 47 A>8A6: 4/6 1>:6 ;66; <6>308? 87 '('''%'( ;>46; '!&('&'( 6I6AB46; 08 /01 9>@7B3 4/37B?/ A7B34 A7EE01107863 8 @062 79 1644:6E684 <642668 4/6 5>34061 5640407863;6968;>84 87' />1 >?366; 47 5>= 1 '#&&&&&% 2684= *0@6 >H/ 78:= 47 5:>084099361578;684 87! 4/37B?/ 6E>8; 3>94 6>308?7&('9731"&&&&&%7&(! 973 1 $&&&&&% 7 &(& 79 1 $&&&&&% ;>46; '#!!'&'# 79 8;0>8 @6316>1 >8H >;65B33>8A/>:><B3>?0 />45:>084099361578;68487!/>1>?366;4/>44/6 5640407863;6968;>8487'/>1<6A7E64/6><17:B46 72863794/61B045375634=015:7487"#08=7 $79>F>5B3@0::>?6GJ014>:><B3>?0>8;874 47 E>H6 >8= H08; 79 0846396368A6 08 9B4B36 0847 56>A69B: 728631/05 >8; 68F7=E684 79 5711611078 79 4/6 5:74 2/0A/ 01 4/6 1B<F6A4 E>4463 79 4/01 A7E537E016 /6 5:>084099361578;684 87! 73 /01 :6?>: /6031 1BAA61173120::874A:>0E>8=30?/4728631/057@63 - 6 - 4/6 1B04 5375634= >8; >?366; 874 47 755716 973 6846308? 4/6 8>E6 79 5640407863 08 4/6 H/>4> >8; 74/6336:6@>84;7ABE6841 />4 5:>084099361578;684 87! /636<= B8;634>H61 47 E>H6 1B36 4/>4 /6 >8; /01 :6?>: /6031 365361684>40@61>?684164A1/>::874>A4>?>08144/6 15030479A7E537E016>8;1644:6E68408@06279/01 >AA654>8A6 79 1 '# :>H/1 B5661 2684= *0@6 >H/178:= /6A7846841794/011644:6E684/>@6<66836>; 7@63>8;6I5:>086;47<74/4/65>3406108>88>;> :>8?B>?6 >8; >9463 B8;6314>8;08? 4/6 1>E6 4/6= />@6 10?86; 4/01 1644:6E684 78 4/01 ;>= '#!!'&'# <69736 4/6 6;0>473 >8; 36156A40@6 A7B816:19734/65640407863>8;361578;6841 8 9B34/63>8A6 47 4/6 1>0; A7E537E016 4/6 5640407863 2/7 01 4/6 ;6968;>84 7' />1 6@68 537AB36; 4/6 6E>8; 3>94 973 1'#&&&&&% >1 E6840786; 08 5>3>?3>5/7'000 794/6>97361>0;365734 # 8>GB63=<=4/017B34<74/4/65640407863>1 26:: >1 5:>084099%/0@>3>7 2/7 >36 563178>::= 5361684 <69736 4/01 7B34 3653616846; <= 4/603 A7B816: 6I536116; 4/603 B8;6314>8;08? >8; 1>4019>A4078 47 4/6 463E1 79 1644:6E684 8>1EBA/ >1 1B<14>840>: 30?/41 79 4/6 5>34061 >36 08@7:@6; 08 4/>4 4/6 ;66; 79 1>:6 6I6AB46; 4/37B?/ - 7 - 7B34 08 9>@7B3 79 5:>084099361578;684 7! /63608 01 36GB036; 47 <6 A>8A6::6; >8; 4/6 ;66; 79 1>:6 2/0A/ 01 7<4>086; <= ;6968;>84 7'5640407863 /63608 36GB0361 47 <6 A78903E6; 78 5>=E684 79 A714 79 1'#&&&&&% >1 8746; ><7@6 :6>386; A7B816: 973 4/6 5640407863 >8; 361578;684 7! 78 08143BA4078 166H >::7208? 79 4/01 56404078 >8; 36963308? 4/6 E>4463 47 4/6 30>: 7B34 47 36A73;4/6463E1794/6A7E537E016 , /6 1>0; 1B<E011078 01 4>H68 78 36A73; 08A6 4/6 5>34061 />@6 EB4B>::= 3617:@6; 4/6 E>4463 >1 8746; ><7@64/697::7208?+ ! > /65640407801>::726; < /6 73;63 ;>46; !,!!'&'' 5>116; 08 0@0: 01A6::>867B17("'&!"784/690:6794/6 ;;: 0@0: B;?6 >8; * >:><B3>?0 >8; 4/6 73;63 ;>46; !$!&'&' 5>116; 08 7!'&'( 78 4/6 90:6 79 4/6 308A05>: 680730@0:B;?6>:><B3>?0>36/636<=164 >10;6 - 8 - A 55:0A>4078 90:6; B8;63 3;63 - B:6 !( 01 >::726; /6 1B04 08 7("'&!# 01 3614736; 47 4/6 90:6 0@0: B;?6 38 >:><B3>?0 ; >34061>36;036A46;47>556>3<697364/630>: 7B34 78 !#!''&'# 204/7B4 >8= 9B34/63 8740A6 >8; 4/6= >36 >4 :0<634= 47 90:6 4/6 A7E537E01656404078>8;7<4>081BA/73;63>1 563E0110<:6B8;63:>2 "50 '$"$( &! 0147!:7#